300 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

FoS Kevin
For hiding in the middle of the post count

I'll try to rise in the post count rankings.

[Nadarr]

I agree. Why would you vote for someone after a credible RC when it is the only information we have to go on. The likely answer is scum. There have been no other reason to vote Kvrest. And in my opinion, if there isn't a good reason presented by the end of the day then one of yall is probably going to be lynched.

[SeaBeeGipson]

So if we go off the theory of there being 3 scum,

There are two groups I'm specifically looking at.

1) those who jumped on Kverst AFTER we discussed his role claim being creditable. (Rafay and Velocity). The problem isnt really solely you jumped on a credible role claim. You did so without supplying much of any reasoning of your own. Also, there was a very unlikely odd someone was going to be lynched besides Kverst. It was moreso a situation of Kverst v. No lynch by that point.

If the RC was credible, what sense did it make to remove 2 townies (Kverst + night kill) rather than take the L on a no lynch that day.

Even today the responses seem like weak defenses. "It was Kverst or me?"
"We needed to lynch someone"
We usually do prefer a lynch but when the odds are stacked that we likely might be hitting a townie, why would you lynch that?

The second group is Lord MK and Col Med

These two didnt even vote. Had all day to cast a vote and nothing. Either they were scum remaining quiet hoping for a late day lynch, seen the target was a town and decided to let town eat themselves, or they wanted to avoid being on a wagon with a potential town at that point. Funnily enough, they dont seem to be quite enthused today either to get the ball rolling. Hoping for another late day lynch?

My main FoS is Col Med and MK.

The not voting just goes wrong. I know when you two were left it was pointless to vote anything other than Kverst as no one else could've been lynched but you didnt even offer any statements during the last moments. Just sat back and I believe watched town eat itself.

[brewersalliance]

So if we go off the theory of there being 3 scum,

There are two groups I'm specifically looking at.

1) those who jumped on Kverst AFTER we discussed his role claim being creditable. (Rafay and Velocity). The problem isnt really solely you jumped on a credible role claim. You did so without supplying much of any reasoning of your own. Also, there was a very unlikely odd someone was going to be lynched besides Kverst. It was moreso a situation of Kverst v. No lynch by that point.

If the RC was credible, what sense did it make to remove 2 townies (Kverst + night kill) rather than take the L on a no lynch that day.

Even today the responses seem like weak defenses. "It was Kverst or me?"
"We needed to lynch someone"
We usually do prefer a lynch but when the odds are stacked that we likely might be hitting a townie, why would you lynch that?

The second group is Lord MK and Col Med

These two didnt even vote. Had all day to cast a vote and nothing. Either they were scum remaining quiet hoping for a late day lynch, seen the target was a town and decided to let town eat themselves, or they wanted to avoid being on a wagon with a potential town at that point. Funnily enough, they dont seem to be quite enthused today either to get the ball rolling. Hoping for another late day lynch?

My main FoS is Col Med and MK.

The not voting just goes wrong. I know when you two were left it was pointless to vote anything other than Kverst as no one else could've been lynched but you didnt even offer any statements during the last moments. Just sat back and I believe watched town eat itself.

you kind of contradict yourself here.

 

You are saying rafay and velocity shouldnt have voted kverst but then you are calling out MK and CM for not voting and saying they are more suspicious.  idk just doesnt make sense to me to look at it like that.  

[Canik]

Damn. GL Town o7

[SeaBeeGipson]

So if we go off the theory of there being 3 scum,

There are two groups I'm specifically looking at.

1) those who jumped on Kverst AFTER we discussed his role claim being creditable. (Rafay and Velocity). The problem isnt really solely you jumped on a credible role claim. You did so without supplying much of any reasoning of your own. Also, there was a very unlikely odd someone was going to be lynched besides Kverst. It was moreso a situation of Kverst v. No lynch by that point.

If the RC was credible, what sense did it make to remove 2 townies (Kverst + night kill) rather than take the L on a no lynch that day.

Even today the responses seem like weak defenses. "It was Kverst or me?"
"We needed to lynch someone"
We usually do prefer a lynch but when the odds are stacked that we likely might be hitting a townie, why would you lynch that?

The second group is Lord MK and Col Med

These two didnt even vote. Had all day to cast a vote and nothing. Either they were scum remaining quiet hoping for a late day lynch, seen the target was a town and decided to let town eat themselves, or they wanted to avoid being on a wagon with a potential town at that point. Funnily enough, they dont seem to be quite enthused today either to get the ball rolling. Hoping for another late day lynch?

My main FoS is Col Med and MK.

The not voting just goes wrong. I know when you two were left it was pointless to vote anything other than Kverst as no one else could've been lynched but you didnt even offer any statements during the last moments. Just sat back and I believe watched town eat itself.

you kind of contradict yourself here.
 
You are saying rafay and velocity shouldnt have voted kverst but then you are calling out MK and CM for not voting and saying they are more suspicious.  idk just doesnt make sense to me to look at it like that.  

Not so much the voting itself. I'm looking deeper at

The reasoning the first group voted on a person that might've been townie

And

The lack of anything from the 2nd group

Voting or lack thereof is just the result from those two aspects I'm curious about.

Why vote a person that might be townie with a credible role claim?

And

Why not add any substance at the end EVEN if you arent voting so that at least you could help town by helping our power roles, or adding any substance at all. Instead I feel they sat back and watched town eat itself.

[Colonel Medved]

FoS on Colonel Medved for least posts.

 

 

 

 

CM and MK did not vote. Not sure If there is anything to make from that

 

 

As I said previously, I've been pretty sick as of late and have been withdrawn from the forums. The little time i have had I've either tried reading up on the two games, or doing things for the academy. I apologize for my silence as of late, i'm still sick but am hoping it will end soon.

 

As for me not voting, i wasn't around for deadline. I was either working or trying to sleep off this bug i have. By the looks of it, my one vote wouldn't have mattered anyway since it seems people were set on Kverst for the lynch. I can tell you that i wouldn't have voted Kverst, so the result would have been the same.

 

 

 

The second group is Lord MK and Col Med 

 

These two didnt even vote. Had all day to cast a vote and nothing. Either they were scum remaining quiet hoping for a late day lynch, seen the target was a town and decided to let town eat themselves, or they wanted to avoid being on a wagon with a potential town at that point. Funnily enough, they dont seem to be quite enthused today either to get the ball rolling. Hoping for another late day lynch? 

 

My main FoS is Col Med and MK. 

 

The not voting just goes wrong. I know when you two were left it was pointless to vote anything other than Kverst as no one else could've been lynched but you didnt even offer any statements during the last moments. Just sat back and I believe watched town eat itself.

 

 

Most of this can be answered to what i said above, but i do want to point out that this day just started late last night. It takes time for some people to post, specifically me since i work during the night and sleep during the day. I was at work when the day opened, and slept until about 1 hour ago. Just for a heads up, i go to work in about 30 minutes. I hope my silence won't be more the reason to FoS me.

[Lord MK]

Okay, the time between brewer's vote, (which was around 1 am) and the deadline (around 11am) was too short and too damn early for me to respond to.

How about you ask Jazzy95 to move the deadline closer to sanity?
Huh? How about that?

[KevinH]

With 6 votes, Kverst, Tartarus (Town Jailor) was lynched D2
 
 
Vote Count:

• 
  
• Kverst: Brewers, Canik, Warrior, Rafay, Velocity
• Rafay: SeeBeeGipson, Nadarr
• Nadarr: KevinH
• Canik: Kverst

Not Voting: Medved, Lord MK

 

 

FoS: Brewers, Warrior, Rafay, Velocity

 

Excuses or not, they lynched a townie.

[Rafay]

So who was I supposed to vote for? The inactives? People with a low post count?

[Jazzy95]

Initial Post has been updated with links and roles.

 

Vote Count:

1. Medved:
2. KevinH:
3. Brewers:
4. The Warrior:
5. Lord MK:
6. Rafay: 
7. Velocity:
8. SeeBeeGipson:
9. Nadarr: 

Not Voting: Medved, Lord MK, KevinH, SeeBeeGipson, Nadarr, Brewers, Warrior, Rafay, Velocity

 

 

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.  Deadline is Thursday, March 14th at 5:00 PM CN.

[Lord MK]

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. Deadline is Thursday, March 14th at 5:00 PM CN.

brewersalliance
I am going to give you an advance notice, in case you forget.
I can't make that time.
If you are going to make a wagon, make it at least 24 hours before deadline.
Or i won't be able to vote.
I warned you, don't come at me on d4, if i happen to make it out of n3 alive.

[brewersalliance]

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. Deadline is Thursday, March 14th at 5:00 PM CN.

brewersalliance
I am going to give you an advance notice, in case you forget.
I can't make that time.
If you are going to make a wagon, make it at least 24 hours before deadline.
Or i won't be able to vote.
I warned you, don't come at me on d4, if i happen to make it out of n3 alive.

I'm not the one saying you're scum for not voting that was SBG lol so not sure why u directed that at me but okay. Hopefully we have something to go on sooner. Right now it's a coinflip between Rafay and Velocity for me. I'll vote probably Thursday morning

[Velocity]

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. Deadline is Thursday, March 14th at 5:00 PM CN.

brewersalliance
I am going to give you an advance notice, in case you forget.
I can't make that time.
If you are going to make a wagon, make it at least 24 hours before deadline.
Or i won't be able to vote.
I warned you, don't come at me on d4, if i happen to make it out of n3 alive.

I'm not the one saying you're scum for not voting that was SBG lol so not sure why u directed that at me but okay. Hopefully we have something to go on sooner. Right now it's a coinflip between Rafay and Velocity for me. I'll vote probably Thursday morning

Can I have heads?

[KevinH]

Heads, it is.

 

Vote: Velocity

[Velocity]

Heads, it is.

Vote: Velocity

My head, I suppose? My head isn’t very useful to a town that wants to win though, although I can’t blame you for voting me at this point

[Lord MK]

Heads, it is.

Vote: Velocity

Lol
You are acting suspicious, dude

[Velocity]

Heads, it is.

Vote: Velocity

Lol
You are acting suspicious, dude

That is exactly what I said, I don’t blame him for voting for me, because I’m not really worried. If you lynch me, good job town you’ve lost another one of us, and mafia gets a kill at night. You don’t, I’m probably gonna be killed by the mafia anyways.

[brewersalliance]

if youre town, you are doing a really crappy job defending yourself.  basically all you are saying is go ahead and do it, I dont blame you.  Thats not the attitude a town player should have.  If you are town, and you did something stupid, ie the vote on Kverst, dont act all salty when we call you out of it.  Dont give up.  If you are town, give us a reason to not vote you. 

[Velocity]

if youre town, you are doing a really crappy job defending yourself. basically all you are saying is go ahead and do it, I dont blame you. Thats not the attitude a town player should have. If you are town, and you did something stupid, ie the vote on Kverst, dont act all salty when we call you out of it. Dont give up. If you are town, give us a reason to not vote you.

Aye, I’m not salty. I haven’t given up. Do you want me to roleclaim? There isn’t much more that I can do to prove that I’m town at this point. My vote on Kverst was a huge mistake and the only excuse I have is that I wasn’t really paying attention when I cast it, and just wanted to get a lynch done.