378 replies to this topic

[Nadarr]

Personally I think it’s STP

Please explain.

[brewersalliance]

Vote Count

lolweirdward 
Nadarr
SealTeamPi 
the Warrior 
Tony Maurice
 

 

Not Voting: LALALALAWILLYWADWEIRD, nadarr, SealTeamPi, The Warrior, Tony Maurice

 

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch

Deadline is 5/26/2020 at 9am CN time

[lilweirdward]

Not Voting: LALALALAWILLYWADWEIRD

The literal worst.

Also is there a deadline vote limit?

[Nadarr]

[quote name="lilweirdward" post="1004718" timestamp="1590102328"][quote name="brewersalliance" post="1004715" timestamp="1590100422"]
Not Voting: LALALALAWILLYWADWEIRD[/quote]

The literal worst.

Also is there a deadline vote limit?[/quote

You get used to it.

[brewersalliance]

[quote name="brewersalliance" post="1004715" timestamp="1590100422"]
Not Voting: LALALALAWILLYWADWEIRD

The literal worst.

Also is there a deadline vote limit?[/quote

You get used to it.

and for that nadarr has been mod killed 

[Nadarr]

[quote name="brewersalliance" post="1004723" timestamp="1590106877"][quote name="Nadarr" post="1004719" timestamp="1590102689"][quote name="lilweirdward" post="1004718" timestamp="1590102328"][quote name="brewersalliance" post="1004715" timestamp="1590100422"]
Not Voting: LALALALAWILLYWADWEIRD[/quote]

The literal worst.

Also is there a deadline vote limit?[/quote

You get used to it.[/quote]and for that nadarr has been mod killed [/quote]

Yay!!! The Velocity treatment!!
Sorry about the weird quotes. My phone doesnt like to quote shit.

[brewersalliance]

You're dead no talking

[Velocity]

The lawyer read from the will of John Roenekie. "Upon my disappearance, I leave everything to Carole Baskin." Disappearance? Thought the lawyer.... what will says disappearance??

Velocity, John Roenike, manager of GW Zoo disappeared N4

It is now Day 5

bAH!

[lilweirdward]

The lawyer read from the will of John Roenekie. "Upon my disappearance, I leave everything to Carole Baskin." Disappearance? Thought the lawyer.... what will says disappearance??

Velocity, John Roenike, manager of GW Zoo disappeared N4

It is now Day 5

bAH!

That's what you get for never voting, scum.

[lilweirdward]

Alright, boys.

We got rid of the policy lynch.

Well, one thing is sure.
Scum is a newbie faction.
No way that they get rid of Nadarr otherwise.

It's either STP, Tony Maurice or Torres.

I mean, you lost your biggest wrecking ball.

And thus,
Vote: STP.

 

MK seems to know something that  else here doesn’t... Care to expand?

 

For now Vote MK. Looks like he is hiding something.

 

Reading back through the thread to try to get any idea of who might be mafia since nothing from recently feels very helpful, and this exchange from the 2nd day seems potentially interesting. Remember, at this time MK was a traitor and should have known who were the mafia, while the mafia should have known that a traitor existed but not known who the traitor was. In this context, the above exchange should mean one of two things:

1. MK wanted to throw people off the trail of the real mafia by chasing down three randos that definitely weren't scum. Torres obviously ended up not being scum, lending credibility to this option. Two people not on this list who are still left (other than me): The Warrior and Jazzy/Nadarr 2.0.
2. MK figured it would be a good idea to explicitly call out people who he knew were mafia, and/or he actually didn't know who the mafia were (would be an irregular rule). This obviously doesn't seem likely, except for two curious points of interest: a) two of the people he called out, STP and Tony, are still left, and both of them got very defensive and have used this exchange as really their only reason why they spent a significant portion of the game trying to get MK lynched during the day.

I still don't really know what to make of this, but it seems like it could be a useful lead.

[Tony Maurice]

That’s why I believe it is STP. I am sure if there was a different joe exotic they would have come out. I’m just a victim of MK too, but I’m sure STP is evil.

[lilweirdward]

That doesn't make any sense bro. Also you were convinced it was TW last time. Are you really convinced that it's not him anymore just because he role claimed as the main character?

[Tony Maurice]

Yep. Why? Because I know no better. 

 

Is Nadarr really dead?

[brewersalliance]

Lol no. Nadarr isn't dead.

[Tony Maurice]

that sucks just like this font

[The Warrior]

 

Alright, boys.

We got rid of the policy lynch.

Well, one thing is sure.
Scum is a newbie faction.
No way that they get rid of Nadarr otherwise.

It's either STP, Tony Maurice or Torres.

I mean, you lost your biggest wrecking ball.

And thus,
Vote: STP.

 

MK seems to know something that  else here doesn’t... Care to expand?

 

For now Vote MK. Looks like he is hiding something.

 

Reading back through the thread to try to get any idea of who might be mafia since nothing from recently feels very helpful, and this exchange from the 2nd day seems potentially interesting. Remember, at this time MK was a traitor and should have known who were the mafia, while the mafia should have known that a traitor existed but not known who the traitor was. In this context, the above exchange should mean one of two things:

1. MK wanted to throw people off the trail of the real mafia by chasing down three randos that definitely weren't scum. Torres obviously ended up not being scum, lending credibility to this option. Two people not on this list who are still left (other than me): The Warrior and Jazzy/Nadarr 2.0.
2. MK figured it would be a good idea to explicitly call out people who he knew were mafia, and/or he actually didn't know who the mafia were (would be an irregular rule). This obviously doesn't seem likely, except for two curious points of interest: a) two of the people he called out, STP and Tony, are still left, and both of them got very defensive and have used this exchange as really their only reason why they spent a significant portion of the game trying to get MK lynched during the day.

I still don't really know what to make of this, but it seems like it could be a useful lead.

 

 

You could be on to something with some of this but it is also possible that MK simply did not know who else was mafia:

 

These are a few of the ways that Traitor has been implemented.

• The Traitor may or may not know who is in the Mafia to begin with. If not, Traitor is basically intended to act like a "bad Townie" - whereas "good Townies" try to find scum, "bad Townies" hinder the Town from finding the scum without necessarily knowing who they are. However, it is considerably more common for the Traitor to know who the scum are.
  • On occasion the Traitor is only told who one of the scum is.

 

It could explain why he acted erratically with his flop-flopping on Tony and generally odd behavior.

 

@Tony - Can you clarify why you believe STP could be scum?

[Nadarr]

that sucks just like this font

What's that supposed to mean?

 

Reading back through the thread to try to get any idea of who might be mafia since nothing from recently feels very helpful, and this exchange from the 2nd day seems potentially interesting. Remember, at this time MK was a traitor and should have known who were the mafia, while the mafia should have known that a traitor existed but not known who the traitor was. In this context, the above exchange should mean one of two things: MK wanted to throw people off the trail of the real mafia by chasing down three randos that definitely weren't scum. Torres obviously ended up not being scum, lending credibility to this option. Two people not on this list who are still left (other than me): The Warrior and Jazzy/Nadarr 2.0. MK figured it would be a good idea to explicitly call out people who he knew were mafia, and/or he actually didn't know who the mafia were (would be an irregular rule). This obviously doesn't seem likely, except for two curious points of interest: a) two of the people he called out, STP and Tony, are still left, and both of them got very defensive and have used this exchange as really their only reason why they spent a significant portion of the game trying to get MK lynched during the day. I still don't really know what to make of this, but it seems like it could be a useful lead. You could be on to something with some of this but it is also possible that MK simply did not know who else was mafia:

 

Is it also possible that a traitor (MK) has a separate win condition than the scum and was trying to kill them off by trying to get wagons started on STP and Tony.

[lilweirdward]

You could be on to something with some of this but it is also possible that MK simply did not know who else was mafia:

It could explain why he acted erratically with his flop-flopping on Tony and generally odd behavior.

I guess it's possible, I mean "normal" games don't have deflectors which is basically the only way Kevin could've come back as a role cop. The fact that he sort of backed off Tony doesn't really make sense though because he shouldn't be told who the mafia is halfway through and they can't talk or anything, right? Tony has been weird but at least pretty consistently weird lol. Idk what would've tipped MK off.

Is it also possible that a traitor (MK) has a separate win condition than the scum and was trying to kill them off by trying to get wagons started on STP and Tony.

This doesn't make any sense to me. The only constant in the traitor role according to mafiascum is that it is mafia aligned and wins if they do. Also his name is bolded in red in the OP indicating that he's scum.

[Tony Maurice]

Isnt supposed to mean anything nadarr.

 

and I just think it is STP of a hunch, after everything that had happened he seems the most sketchy unless someone can disprove TW claim

[SealTeamPi]

Sorry, I've been quiet over the last 24 hours. There has been a family emergency on my end.

To discuss the accusations by Tony. I think he's mad that I've been calling out his erratic behavior during this game as a whole. As to MK, he lumped us together cause we ganged up on him a bit in the beginning before his lynch.

 

I think that Tony has been acting inconsistent at best, and hence.

Vote: Tony