720 replies to this topic

[brewersalliance]

Strongman is typically a scum aligned modifier as well.

Unvote

I'm starting to think we actually have three scum factions and all three were individual serial killers.

Two serial killers plus a mafia team and a neutral player (me) would mean at most there are only 7 Townies. That would not be fair to the town at all.

And the most common town claim for a SK is a vig.
Robert said in the OP that all scum have fake names to claim. And super girl wouldn't kill people. That also feels weird to me.

[Lord MK]

What do you mean by missing your targets?
Who did you target?

[brewersalliance]

And since I'm very sure there is actually only one scum left, I'm gonna vote with town. So LWW, I'm following you with my vote.

[Lord MK]

And a strongman always gets the kill.
Unless your target is a commuter

[brewersalliance]

Yes sir. on Nigh 1, 3, and 4. I must have TERRIBLE aim because I'm always missing my targets

Wait so a town vig that has tried to kill three times?and on night one with NO information?! That 100000% sounds like an sk making that claim and now admitting it just in case one of our players is a tracker

And a strongman always gets the kill.
Unless your target is a commuter

Good point, strongman kills are unblockable.

[lilweirdward]

The missing puzzle piece for me is how I was role blocked last night. Because even if Torres is the last SK, there's almost no chance he's also an RB, and whoever that player is must still be alive since I was blocked last night.

Otherwise I have a really hard time believing Torres' RC. No way you had unlimited strong man shots, used them 3 out of 4 nights, and apparently missed all of them? Legit not possible.

[Lord MK]

Yes sir. on Nigh 1, 3, and 4. I must have TERRIBLE aim because I'm always missing my targets

Wait so a town vig that has tried to kill three times?and on night one with NO information?! That 100000% sounds like an sk making that claim and now admitting it just in case one of our players is a tracker

That's true.
No town role in their right mind tries to kill n1.
You got nothing to go on.
This sounds awfully like a sk trying to cover their tracks.

The missing puzzle piece for me is how I was role blocked last night. Because even if Torres is the last SK, there's almost no chance he's also an RB, and whoever that player is must still be alive since I was blocked last night.

Otherwise I have a really hard time believing Torres' RC. No way you had unlimited strong man shots, used them 3 out of 4 nights, and apparently missed all of them? Legit not possible.

Well, he can be a mafia rb.
In most cases, if mafia is down to the last person, they can use both roles.

[Lyner]

So we need to hit scum today or we lose the game

 

Don't put 2 vote on the same person until we figure out everybody's role

[Lord MK]

So we need to hit scum today or we lose the game

Don't put 2 vote on the same person until we figure out everybody's role

Well, not if there's just one scum left.

If there's just one lone scum left.
Then they need to get the total number to 2.
Mislynch today, and with successful nk, then we are down to 4. So we are still safe.

[Torres951]

Night 1, I tried killing Brewers because it would've been funny to kill him the first night

Night 2, I forgot to confirm the kill, so it never went through

Night 3, I went after TW but I missed

Night 4, I tried to go after TW again because I thought second time's the charm right? He's apparently more elusive than I thought.

[Lord MK]

Really?
That's your justification.
It would be funny to kill one of the most active players.

[lilweirdward]

Yeah, for me I definitely need TW to give his side of things. He's been deathly quiet but now he can basically make or break this game.

Anyway you basically just confirmed my theory, so thanks for that. Now I just need to figure out who the RB is.

[brewersalliance]

Yeah, for me I definitely need TW to give his side of things. He's been deathly quiet but now he can basically make or break this game.

Anyway you basically just confirmed my theory, so thanks for that. Now I just need to figure out who the RB is.

LWW the nights you were blocked who did you target

Perhaps they have an asthetic modifier

Night 1, I tried killing Brewers because it would've been funny to kill him the first night
Night 2, I forgot to confirm the kill, so it never went through
Night 3, I went after TW but I missed
Night 4, I tried to go after TW again because I thought second time's the charm right? He's apparently more elusive than I thought.

Really dude? That is the dumbest reason to try to kill someone.

Let's kill the most active player and someone who's pretty darn good at mafia for laughs?! Sounds like scum cover to me.

No way u target people that many times for legit no reason if you're town

[lilweirdward]

Frankly it's probably Lyner. He made a comment early on (after Velocity got killed but well before Nadarr did) that there were 3 scum factions, which I thought was a really interesting comment at the time since we only knew of two by that point: Velocity and the assumed presence of a mafia team. I'd have to go back and find it which is hard on mobile but it screamed very informed minority to me.

[Lyner]

Night 1, I tried killing Brewers because it would've been funny to kill him the first night

Night 2, I forgot to confirm the kill, so it never went through

Night 3, I went after TW but I missed

Night 4, I tried to go after TW again because I thought second time's the charm right? He's apparently more elusive than I thought.

 

uhh if u're scum and TW is commuter that does explain why there's no kill last night, and why there's so little kills in the game despite having at least 3 scum factions

 

I need to hear from TW if he's a commuter

[brewersalliance]

And @lww TW, MK and I have all modded games where scum can do a factional kill and a regular ability at the same time. Robert could be doing the same here as well.

So he could be a serial killer who can role block. Serial killers do have abilities sometimes (like a joat or something)

[lilweirdward]

Yeah, for me I definitely need TW to give his side of things. He's been deathly quiet but now he can basically make or break this game.

Anyway you basically just confirmed my theory, so thanks for that. Now I just need to figure out who the RB is.

LWW the nights you were blocked who did you target

Perhaps they have an asthetic modifier

I've been blocked on Nadarr, Kevin, and Lyner. I was not blocked on my first investigation which was Velocity.

[brewersalliance]

Frankly it's probably Lyner. He made a comment early on (after Velocity got killed but well before Nadarr did) that there were 3 scum factions, which I thought was a really interesting comment at the time since we only knew of two by that point: Velocity and the assumed presence of a mafia team. I'd have to go back and find it which is hard on mobile but it screamed very informed minority to me.

I def missed that. If u could find the quote that would be awesome.

But I still think Torres is the better choice. His actions make zero sense for a town vig. And lyner is right about the lack of kills. Even if Torres was having his kills blocked every night, odds are whoever else is scum probably wasn't targeting the same player as Torres each night lol

Yeah, for me I definitely need TW to give his side of things. He's been deathly quiet but now he can basically make or break this game.

Anyway you basically just confirmed my theory, so thanks for that. Now I just need to figure out who the RB is.

LWW the nights you were blocked who did you target

Perhaps they have an asthetic modifier

I've been blocked on Nadarr, Kevin, and Lyner. I was not blocked on my first investigation which was Velocity.

Another possibility: Torres hasn't actually tried to kill anyone and is a RB and is sticking to u, hoping we Lynch town lol

[Lyner]

Frankly it's probably Lyner. He made a comment early on (after Velocity got killed but well before Nadarr did) that there were 3 scum factions, which I thought was a really interesting comment at the time since we only knew of two by that point: Velocity and the assumed presence of a mafia team. I'd have to go back and find it which is hard on mobile but it screamed very informed minority to me.

I got that from Robert's lore text

joker and slade are two different scum faction, Velocity is neither one of them so that's 3

[brewersalliance]

Frankly it's probably Lyner. He made a comment early on (after Velocity got killed but well before Nadarr did) that there were 3 scum factions, which I thought was a really interesting comment at the time since we only knew of two by that point: Velocity and the assumed presence of a mafia team. I'd have to go back and find it which is hard on mobile but it screamed very informed minority to me.

I got that from Robert's lore text
joker and slade are two different scum faction, Velocity is neither one of them so that's 3

I guess that kind of makes sense. Tho nadarr was scarecrow so maybe they aren't actually in the game and are just red Herrings/flavor?
And I think this means LWW was def role blocked


He's the only confirmer town so I still want to follow his vote