720 replies to this topic

[Lyner]

Yeah, after nadarr showed up as neither Joker/slade (again) I thought the lore text is not an accurate depiction

 

so I didn't bring that up

[lilweirdward]

Yesterday went too fast with Rafay hammering the wagon

Regarding Joker and Slade, with our SK that means 3 scum factions. We haven't seen much NK in this game, perhaps Joker is actually clown?

Found it. I guess I'll buy Lyner's explanation, but I definitely read it originally as Joker and Slade being the mafia team, and Lyner just knowing there were 3 scum factions.

[brewersalliance]

Well then that would actually mean four scum.

Two sk (velocity and nadarr) and the joker/Slade

And then me as a survivor make it only what? 6 total town? That would be very uneven/slanted for a scum win, unless the town has some OP roles

[Lord MK]

Yesterday went too fast with Rafay hammering the wagon

Regarding Joker and Slade, with our SK that means 3 scum factions. We haven't seen much NK in this game, perhaps Joker is actually clown?

Found it. I guess I'll buy Lyner's explanation, but I definitely read it originally as Joker and Slade being the mafia team, and Lyner just knowing there were 3 scum factions.

Actually Joker and Slade can't be a single team.
Joker always acts alone.
That's one of the key characteristic of Joker.

[brewersalliance]

I think 3 individual serial killers makes the most sense

[lilweirdward]

Yesterday went too fast with Rafay hammering the wagon

Regarding Joker and Slade, with our SK that means 3 scum factions. We haven't seen much NK in this game, perhaps Joker is actually clown?

Found it. I guess I'll buy Lyner's explanation, but I definitely read it originally as Joker and Slade being the mafia team, and Lyner just knowing there were 3 scum factions.

Actually Joker and Slade can't be a single team.
Joker always acts alone.
That's one of the key characteristic of Joker.

If this is another trick to get sometime to sympathize with Joker's character, then I'm all about it lol.

[brewersalliance]

What about Harley Quinn

[Lyner]

Anyhow I'll just RC now

 

I'm Wonder Woman, a backup cop

 

I will be promoted to cop if any cop dies

 

I'll wait until TW post and let lww decide

[Lord MK]

Yesterday went too fast with Rafay hammering the wagon

Regarding Joker and Slade, with our SK that means 3 scum factions. We haven't seen much NK in this game, perhaps Joker is actually clown?

Found it. I guess I'll buy Lyner's explanation, but I definitely read it originally as Joker and Slade being the mafia team, and Lyner just knowing there were 3 scum factions.

Actually Joker and Slade can't be a single team.
Joker always acts alone.
That's one of the key characteristic of Joker.

If this is another trick to get sometime to sympathize with Joker's character, then I'm all about it lol.

No, actually i meant if Joker exists, he is a sk.

[lilweirdward]

Anyhow I'll just RC now

I'm Wonder Woman, a backup cop

I will be promoted to cop if any cop dies

I'll wait until TW post and let lww decide

Honestly I wouldn't believe this if it wasn't Robert's game where he said he wanted to use lesser seen roles lol, because otherwise this is basically impossible to prove or disprove, right? It would be a clever way of having help for town with me as apparently the only cop, although Robert probably didn't expect me to just be kept alive the whole game like this lol.
Oh btw there's still the fact that someone killed Rafay during the day. Would not surprise me if it's a hidden modifier that the RB gained part way through since I can't imagine an SK getting a free day shot too.

[Lord MK]

Lol, i was going to call bull on lyner's rc, as i thought that there was no cop. With there being no cop investigations so far
That's when i remembered about lww and his situation, lol.




So

Oh btw there's still the fact that someone killed Rafay during the day. Would not surprise me if it's a hidden modifier that the RB gained part way through since I can't imagine an SK getting a free day shot too.

That's Nadarr.
Sk with special killing conditions.
Special being day kills

[Lord MK]

What about Harley Quinn

She and the Joker are more or less the same.

[lilweirdward]

That's Nadarr.
Sk with special killing conditions.
Special being day kills

Yeah good catch, that definitely makes sense. So it was a likely a scum action the whole time, just not scum team.

[brewersalliance]

Where is TW?

[Lord MK]

Bloody hell, what happened to this game?
We were all active One sec and then i turn around and boom, dead.

[lilweirdward]

Personally I'm waiting for TW to give his side of things. Even though it definitely seems like we only have one scum left, that's not necessarily the only possibility and I want to be as sure as I can be before placing my vote.

@Torres, do you have anything left to offer now that you've had some time to think? I know it seems like we won't believe you no matter what, but I'm still feeling persuadable. Maybe I missed something in your story that connects the dots?

[Robert2424]

God, I need to throw some context here. 

 

I provide modifiers to each side to try to balance stuff. There is a very common modifier people seem to gloss over that allot of characters have had. 

 

While this is my universe, similarity to cannon DC are going to be common but not bible. If I like something, or find it interesting, its Cannon in Robert-verse. My Story's mostly reflect whats goes on during the night with subtle hints. Though, I won't leave out the possibility things can be misleading, or become clear as Roles are revealed. For instant, the Bombs was a indication of something happening at a later time with Scarecrow. I didn't quite say what kind of bombs they were. Just a theme. Subtle hints happen. I will say not every character I've put into story's is automaticlly in the game. For instance, there no Beast Boy Role, Cyborg, or a player thats Robin. I've also not involved everyone who is, Unless it involves there death. Eventually everyone will. 

 

However, if you want to ask about something about Robert-verse characters. I'm willing to answer them. As its simple lore questions. With multi-verse implications, though the multi-verse has NOT come into play yet. That is why I said, you assuming Joker was Female. I will say currently, Joker exists in Robert-verse, but is a man. Also, some villains can't seem to keep there mouth shut. Indicating if they want to be discovered or play a major role. I will say there is a part of the multiverse, were male characters are Female, and Females are male, but isn't in this story. 

[lilweirdward]

I'm starting to doubt the "three SK" theory. I don't have a better one, but it feels like Robert is heavily implying that there are still two scum left, because Slade surely has to be a real character in game, and he's now confirmed that Joker is as well. I appreciate him confirming that Nadarr (scarecrow) was the source of the bomb day kill though. I can't tell if there are meant to be other hints in his post or not.

I strongly suspect that someone on my side is only pretending to be. I can't figure out if Torres is an SK, mafia, or just a horrible Vig lol, but I'm still hoping that TW holds the key.
@Robert, this may seem obvious lol, but can you confirm that Slade is a real character and not just flavor text? Just so I'm not working off of assumptions.

[Lord MK]

I don't think that Robert can do that.
That would amount to heavy mod interference.
So we might not get a favourable response


My guts says go with Torres.
They aren't always right.
But honestly if lose, cause Torres is town, then it's not our fault, it's Torres

I mean, come on, you and me and even brewers to an extent have wrote so much yesterday that most games take days to do.
So i still say, Torres is the best option

Best case scenario, we catch scum.
Worst case scenario, we lose, but not for lack of trying.

[lilweirdward]

I'd understand if he won't confirm it, but it can't hurt to try. Also I know you want to get this game over with, but I'm kind of competitive lol and I'd prefer to win if I can help it. I'm still leaning towards Torres, but just Robert's text alone has raised doubts in my mind, and I'd like to see the game play out a tiny bit more before committing to anything.