575 replies to this topic

[Tony Maurice]

You could easily get the glare off you if you would either provide information of substance or roleclaim.  You've done neither.  I have nothing to go on other than your voting record, posts, and your reactions when accused.

 

You've been nothing but cryptic when confronted.  How else should I react but to assume you're scum?  You went defensive and cryptic.  I'm reacting to what I see.  That's is all.  I want to win, and right now we are not.  Help the town win if that's your goal.

I don’t need to get the glare off me, you obviously wan to win by killing me so I welcome you to do so. You are the true master of mafia on how you figured out my alignment through my speech.

[Nadarr]

Hey guys!! I'm completely caught up on the game, but I am at work currently. Will post something meaningful later.

[Finster Baby]

Now lets get back to rooting out scum.

 

This is Lyner's bandwagon: Lyner (4): Lord MK, Brewersalliance, Tony Maurice, lilweirdward

 

MK came up town as he was lynched last night.  Brewers/Nadarr's RC of commuter is plausible, but could easily be a diversion.  Tony seems very scummish to me but seems also to be potentially hiding a power role that could help the town, why I don't know.  likweirdward I don't have a good fix on.   Could be either way.

 

I forgot Kevin was confirmed town by Lyner.  Sorry for the accusation, mate.

 

Wolfpacks has been VERY quiet the whole game.  I'm trying to figure out why.  Don't have a good read either way.

Torres:  I don't believe his RC at all.  Lean scum, especially with his attempt to get someone to give their role away.  (*https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/64644-tw-12-agents-of-shield-mafia-day-3/?p=1008006)

Robert:  Defended me when Tony voted for me.  Lean town

 

So It's either Tony or Torres, at least for me. 

 

So, since the only reason my vote for Tony was OMGUS...

 

UNVOTE

 

But we need to lynch scum tonight.  Otherwise the town is in deep kimchee.

[Nadarr]

Torres:  I don't believe his RC at all.  Lean scum, especially with his attempt to get someone to give their role away.  (*https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/64644-tw-12-agents-of-shield-mafia-day-3/?p=1008006)

 

Even though I just joined this game I have been following the whole time and I honestly don't understand why everyone jumped off Torres and onto Lyner. Torres is def giving off a scum vibe.

 

Vote Torres 

[KevinH]

Welcome Nadarr!

 

Unfortunately, I am transferring my past suspicion on Brewers to you. 

 

1) Brewers did the scummy thing of getting Velocity lynched Day 1.  I know he claimed it was a joke and unvoted a couple hours before deadline but I put all the blame on him.

 

2) He was in on the lynch of Lyner.

 

Vote: Nadarr

 

It's not personal, it's business

[Nadarr]

Welcome Nadarr!

 

Unfortunately, I am transferring my past suspicion on Brewers to you. 

 

1) Brewers did the scummy thing of getting Velocity lynched Day 1.  I know he claimed it was a joke and unvoted a couple hours before deadline but I put all the blame on him.

 

2) He was in on the lynch of Lyner.

 

Vote: Nadarr

 

It's not personal, it's business

 

I understand completely. What he did to Velocity was bullshit and he should have been lynched for it. Joke or not. However, his claim of Yo Yo Rodriguez was true.

[Robert2424]

1st lynch, KevinH, lilweirdward, Torres51, Robert2424, Lord MK

2nd lynch, Lord MK, Brewersalliance Now Nadrr, Tony Maurice, lilweirdward

 

Disecting the list and what I know. Kevin was confirmed by lyner, so we can remove him. I believe what was Brewers Role Claim still as that makes the most sense. Any other claim I'd be pushing hard for a brewers/Nadrr lynch. MK and lilweirdward was apart of both lynches yet both aren't even in discussion. Torres is inactive mainly. So, lets go down the list. 

 

Vote lilweirdward

 

You were on both wagons, and pretty inactive. Compared to MK, I consider you the most scummy.

 

My scum list in order so far. 

 

lilweidrward

MK

Tony Maurice

Torres

[lilweirdward]

Yeah I absolutely believe Brewers/Nadarr's claim now too, and the fact that Nadarr is confident in Torres' scumminess is giving me confidence that my strong early suspicions of him were valid.

 

Vote: Torres (again)

1st lynch, KevinH, lilweirdward, Torres51, Robert2424, Lord MK

2nd lynch, Lord MK, Brewersalliance Now Nadrr, Tony Maurice, lilweirdward

 

Disecting the list and what I know. Kevin was confirmed by lyner, so we can remove him. I believe what was Brewers Role Claim still as that makes the most sense. Any other claim I'd be pushing hard for a brewers/Nadrr lynch. MK and lilweirdward was apart of both lynches yet both aren't even in discussion. Torres is inactive mainly. So, lets go down the list. 

 

Vote lilweirdward

 

You were on both wagons, and pretty inactive. Compared to MK, I consider you the most scummy.

 

My scum list in order so far. 

 

lilweidrward

MK

Tony Maurice

Torres

 

Why is MK still in your list? He was killed last night and confirmed town (the doctor actually). 

[Tony Maurice]

Vote Robert 

[Robert2424]

I was going by the voting. I forgot scum killed him. 

 

 

Vote Robert 

This is a terrible way to play tony. And people are suspecting you cause of it. 

[Tony Maurice]

A vote for Robert means I’m playing bad?

[Robert2424]

Voting without explain why. Unless we are suppose to call that a OMGUS Vote? 

[Tony Maurice]

Call it what you want. A votes, a vote.

[The Warrior]

Vote Count

 

Finster Baby (0):

KevinH (0):

lilweirdward (1): Robert2424

Nadarr Brewersalliance (2): Wolfpacks, KevinH

Robert2424 (1): Tony Maurice

Tony Maurice (0):

Torres51 (2): Nadarr (Brewers), lilweirdward

Wolfpacks (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: Finster Baby, Torres51

 

With 8 alive it take 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 12:00pm CST on Monday, June 29th.

[Torres951]

Can I ask why I seem scummy?

[Robert2424]

Can I ask why I seem scummy?

Your Activity is a huge part of that. Not adding anything to a conversation is also part of it. Even if its Theory's or questions about Roles, ect, is helpful. Though, Everybody seems to just ignored my Earlier theory. Your objective as town is to Find scum. Causing Discussion helps. This is more of a strategic game then anything, and if people dislike your play style, they begin coming after you. Like Velocity. I don't necessarily Hate Velocity play style, but many here do. If your only going to hide in the back, every single game, and not generate discussion, or even try, you paint a target on your back. So he's deemed inactive, cause he's always one of the lowest posters when he just sits there and lurks. Lurking is his thing, and to me its a scum tell. Reading the thread without responding as if taking notes who to target without adding anything to bring down scum. If something is weird to you, I'd recommend asking about it. If you have a theory about the setup, especially if not mentioned, or even unlikely, activity is key. I have to say this is the main problem with you and Velocity. The least active posters are looked down upon because you add nothing and nobody can't get a read, so you'll just be labeled as scummy until people at least see an effort and many just don't see an effort. Especially if your new, you should be asking questions. People like me, TW, or Kevin are very open to answering basic questions about the game in my experience. Not saying that others won't answer them, but if your going to become a better Mafia player, knowledge is key. 

[Torres951]

 

Can I ask why I seem scummy?

Your Activity is a huge part of that. Not adding anything to a conversation is also part of it. Even if its Theory's or questions about Roles, ect, is helpful. Though, Everybody seems to just ignored my Earlier theory. Your objective as town is to Find scum. Causing Discussion helps. This is more of a strategic game then anything, and if people dislike your play style, they begin coming after you. Like Velocity. I don't necessarily Hate Velocity play style, but many here do. If your only going to hide in the back, every single game, and not generate discussion, or even try, you paint a target on your back. So he's deemed inactive, cause he's always one of the lowest posters when he just sits there and lurks. Lurking is his thing, and to me its a scum tell. Reading the thread without responding as if taking notes who to target without adding anything to bring down scum. If something is weird to you, I'd recommend asking about it. If you have a theory about the setup, especially if not mentioned, or even unlikely, activity is key. I have to say this is the main problem with you and Velocity. The least active posters are looked down upon because you add nothing and nobody can't get a read, so you'll just be labeled as scummy until people at least see an effort and many just don't see an effort. Especially if your new, you should be asking questions. People like me, TW, or Kevin are very open to answering basic questions about the game in my experience. Not saying that others won't answer them, but if your going to become a better Mafia player, knowledge is key. 

 

Duly noted! I will try to be more proactive in this thread. I do realize that I do seem scummy by just coasting along with everyone. Thank you Robert!

[Wolfpacks]

UNVOTE, I wanna see how nadarr plays this

[Nadarr]

UNVOTE, I wanna see how nadarr plays this

 

What am I playing? The game in general or something specific?

[lilweirdward]

Can I ask why I seem scummy?

FWIW, you seem scummy to me because...

1) You barely participated D1 except to hop on Velocity's lynch train as soon as it was getting going, which was at the very end with very little time for him to save himself
2) You again didn't say or do much for the first half of D2
3) In the second half once you started getting called out, you seemed to intentionally act scummy. I think it was brewers who said it felt like you were trying to reverse psychology everyone into being so obviously apathetic and joking about the accusations pointed at you that it would make people stop.
4) It's now D4 and this is again the first time you've posted today, and again only after people start putting pressure on you for being scum.

As I said last time I called you out, you could just genuinely not be taking this game seriously, kind of like how Tony is except less rude about it lol. But you keep spiking up once there's some heat but never actually really participating or doing much to help weed out scum, which is a really easy and convenient thing to do if you are in fact scum.