959 replies to this topic

[Finster Baby]

I think we need a vote count please.

[Canik]

 

Role-playing
 

Left Trigger  Use Grenades
Right Trigger Use Weapon
Left Bumper   Use Armor Abilities
Right Bumper  Melee Attack
A Button      Jump
B Button      Switch Grenades
X Button      Action / Reload
 

*accidentally hits you with a sticky grenade* sorry! damn weird Halo controls!

[lilweirdward]

Ha, I'm pretty sure you're the one that, in the past, has spent an entire D1 posting very detailed "fancy statistics" about which strategies are more likely to be beneficial for town than others. You should know as well as anyone that influencing those estimates with your own personal read of recent events is a huge red flag, and I would bet money that you'd be all over him if he had done that.

To me, this seems like a classic case of scum deflecting their own behavior onto other people and calling it scummy, especially the "fancy statistics" accusation by you of all people. Why are you so bothered any time someone implies that there's a chance you might be scum? It's happened a lot in just the short time this game has been open, and it's getting more suspicious to me.

I feel you have a deep resentment towards me and it's affecting the way you're interpreting my words.
I use numbers, that's no secret. Does it somehow make me scummy to say that other people (like KevinH) use numbers too? Am I forbidden to say that I have different view on the numbers KevinH used?
Also I'm not bothered at all, that people might think I'm a scum. Why would I? This is normal part of the game, especially so early when virtually everyone can be a scum. I was talking about something entirely different, but I doubt that explaining it again will help you. I'll just say, that after this day you'll have to recalibrate your "clasic cases of scum behavior".

Maybe I was off, but I read the whole "Kevin and his fancy numbers" comment as a dig at the fact that he was doing the same thing you've done before. I like the whole stats angle so obviously I'm not saying you're suspicious purely because you pointed it out, but your logic didn't make sense to me, and the way you phrased your comments came off the wrong way to me. Maybe I'm wrong - a lot of times I am - but it never hurts to pressure people that seem scummy and see how they respond, as I'm sure you'd agree.

[KevinH]

I assume Brewers is telling the truth and that we have a 50-50 chance of getting scum in the absence of any other information.

I did not think Lord MK's vote on Lyner was anything special; it's what we do in the game of Mafia.

However, the comments since then seem desperate, so now we have some "other information"

I don't know what the vote count is so I won't switch yet, but unless I hear a better argument, I will switch to Lord MK.

[Velocity]

Official Vote Count v5?

 

Tony Maurice (0):

lilwardweird (0):

brewersalliance (0):

Lyner (1): MK

Canik (0):

ABT (2): KevinH, Canik

KevinH (0):

The Warrior (0):

captainjf (0):

Rafay (0):

Torres951 (0):

MK (5): brewersalliance, ABT, Torres, lilwierdward, Rafay

Finster Baby (0):

Ferastical (0):

Robert2424 (0):

Wolfpacks (0):

 

Not Voting (8): Tony Maurice, Lyner, The Warrior, captainjf, Finster Baby, Ferastical, Robert, Wolfpacks 

 

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch or 5 at deadline.

Deadline is 9-29 at 6 PM CN time.

[The Warrior]

MK is at 5 votes now which is already enough to lynch at deadline. I intend on voting for MK barring any new major revelations but we are still 5-6 days away from deadline so I am going to hold my vote until closer to then. Please do not hammer him this early If he gets closer to the 9 vote threshold.

@MK - You claimed that you and Brewers have the same alignment. Can you please elaborate? If you are town it will help clear Brewers on a later day.

[brewersalliance]

@tony please pay attention to the vote count this game, no need to end it early again

Also I'm to the point that if MK is town I'm going to be surprised

[Robert2424]

Yeah, at this point I plan on voting before deadline as well. 

[Tony Maurice]

@tony please pay attention to the vote count this game, no need to end it early again

Also I'm to the point that if MK is town I'm going to be surprised

we'll see about that 

[Wolfpacks]

Im going with brewers claim for no other reason then I've never seen a 50/50 role and want to see how it pans out

Vote MK

*Clears throat*

[Lord MK]

Well apparently, the only way for me to win is to get lynched.
So i don't know.
Lynch me, I guess

That's the puzzle, isn't it?

I blame Velocity.
He's the one who went behind my back to give me unknown modifiers and alignment changes.

Vote: MK

This is the one that did it for me. Playing dumb like the mod is just screwing with your alignment and that's why brewers said what he said is ridiculous. I thought maybe there was a chance that you just panicked and made yourself seem worse in the moment, but this is an obvious scum tell to me.

It's true.
But I don't need your whiny ass to support me.

[Ferastical]

There isn't like a Jester in this game, right?

 

God I hate Jesters...

[Wolfpacks]

Im going with brewers claim for no other reason then I've never seen a 50/50 role and want to see how it pans out

Vote MK

*Clears throat*

Actually im seeing MKs abruptness as more frustration, like he's being chucked under a bus.

UNVOTE

VOTE brewers

I dont believe 50/50 is a thing now

[Lord MK]

There isn't like a Jester in this game, right?

God I hate Jesters...

Jesters would have been better, tbh.
And I'm saying this after i having been one before.

[lilweirdward]

This feels like a gambit to me, but I'm actually gonna lay low a little bit and see how others respond to this.

[brewersalliance]

Im going with brewers claim for no other reason then I've never seen a 50/50 role and want to see how it pans out

Vote MK

*Clears throat*

Actually im seeing MKs abruptness as more frustration, like he's being chucked under a bus.

UNVOTE

VOTE brewers

I dont believe 50/50 is a thing now

You're right I made the whole thing up so I can die come day 3

[Tony Maurice]

You're right I made the whole thing up so I can die come day 3

 

could be an executioner like in ToS 

[brewersalliance]

Also I don't think a Jester would straight up imply they are a jester @lww. Their goal is to get lynched, not convince town to let them live. But even if he's a Jester, which is unlikely, lynching him is worth the risk. Besides, this is a war themed game, so I just don't see how a jester would even fit the theme.

[brewersalliance]

Also if mk was town, wouldn't that in his mind mean ABT is not town based on my claim? So instead of freaking out like he is, he would be confident that ABT isn't town and therefore would be advocating for reasons why we should Lynch ABT instead. But he hasn't done one thing to suggest we should Lynch ABT...

MKs actions are in no way consistent with someone who is town

[The Warrior]

 

 

Im going with brewers claim for no other reason then I've never seen a 50/50 role and want to see how it pans out

Vote MK

*Clears throat*

Actually im seeing MKs abruptness as more frustration, like he's being chucked under a bus.

UNVOTE

VOTE brewers

I dont believe 50/50 is a thing now

 

 

You don't think the frustration could be coming from him maybe being scum multiple games in a row and getting caught super early in this game? That seems more likely to me than Brewers lying about something like this on day 2 of a large game. Do you believe that would be a worthwhile gamble for Brewers to make on day 2?