1469 replies to this topic

[Firkked]

I view the opinions of someone else as I do with any other type of post:
What information meshes with my own views?
is there a hidden agenda going on?
is there any inconsistency with previous postings?
any unexplained or ill defined reasons? did they slip up and let a bone drop out their mouth?

As to whether I will post a complete and in-depth list of my opinions on each person at any point during this game remains to be seen, at this time I don't see any value or merit in it. I have pointed out the people whom I suspect are scum or town and will probably continue to do so in the future, just not as a grocery list or "weekend reminder note" like CD.

[Kaziocore]

Actually I'm not a fan of giving your opinion who the scum is or who do you think the townie is that much. You'll give ideas who the scum should kill or not.

[Martino]

true. course since i didnt really suspect anyone anyway it doesnt make a difference in my case.

i think i do understand where junk was going with this though. i mean why is it different from having a person on the lynching block per se say who he thinks is scum etc.? why is it different from CD asking me earlier who i suspected? in all these cases we are giving mafia information on who to kill/not to kill in order to frame someone else etc. so why post suspects anyway?

Well, normally when someone posts that he suspects someone, he is going to give a reasoning as well. We can then judge the reasoning the next day and determine if we are going to follow it. In this case, however, people were randomly throwing out names of who they would suspect more. I don't think that is useful to the town and I could see how it would help the mafia. That is why I thought it to be a bad idea.

[Falzis]

Publishing a suspects list is good for the town if accompanied with sound reasoning. Random suspicions is not good. So it's ok if someone says who they suspect in their room only if they have a good reason to suspect that person.

I'm feeling good in my room as I don't have any reason to suspect Narsis or KevinH that much, although I'm putting Narsis more on the sure townie list for the same reasons as CD's.

[KevinH]

It's a stretch, in my opinion, to have "sound" reasoning for a suspect on day 1.
Sure, a pro-town strategy suggestion makes somebody less suspicious, but mafia know that and would make the same suggestion.

[Falzis]

I didn't say people would or should have sound reasoning on D1 already. I'm just saying if anyone wants to post a suspect list, there should be at least some reasoning behind the suspicion. And yes I agree with what you said KevinH on the last part too.

[Narsis]

Well, normally when someone posts that he suspects someone, he is going to give a reasoning as well. We can then judge the reasoning the next day and determine if we are going to follow it. In this case, however, people were randomly throwing out names of who they would suspect more. I don't think that is useful to the town and I could see how it would help the mafia. That is why I thought it to be a bad idea.

precisely the answer i was looking for.

[Electric Mango]

I'm pretty sure we'll be lynching by the end of the day so stay active.

[Aquinas]

I'm pretty sure we'll be lynching by the end of the day so stay active.

Yep, I'm back after a busy weekend and all caught up.

I figure we can all take part in an examination of the survivors in the killing room after the fact. If you are really concerned about someone, its never terribad to tell us what you think of course but, when the pool of suspects per room gets so shallow things change. In the end though, the scum are taking a risk killing weather or not the victim has tipped them off. They are going down in two turns no matter what with a 50% chance of going down that next day. If they are going to kill I don't think the opinion of the victim prior to is going to be a huge break for them.

[junkahoolik]

it will no be a huge break tomorrow, but it may prove to be one in the days after this. though now that i said this too, ignore my suggestion altogether.

[CanucksDynasty]

it will no be a huge break tomorrow, but it may prove to be one in the days after this. though now that i said this too, ignore my suggestion altogether.

No worries.
I didn't think it to be such a bad suggestion anyways.

With that...I believe Martino is to vote for crazyemolad to wrap D1 up.

Or MOD could just end the day since it's already DEADLINE day.

[molestargazer]

I figured I'd give you guys a bit of time.
You've got about two hours.

[Martino]

I think we may as well end the day now.

vote crazyemolad

As a reminder to everyone:

Room 1 = Sir Jesus, Firkked, junkahoolic
Room 4 = Electric Mango, AoD/SinKon, Kaziocore
Room 7 = Falzis, Narsis, KevinH
Room 8 = CanucksDynasty, Aquinas, Martino

MOVE: Room 8

[Narsis]

MOVE: Room7

let's get this show on the road!

btw mole: did you foresee the plan that the town has come up with with the room assignments?

No comment on that one. That answer could very much influence plans or lack thereof.

Edited by molestargazer, 16 November 2009 - 07:19 PM.

[Falzis]

MOVE: Room 7

good question Narsis and good answer mole!

Why thank you.
It was a nice try, Narsis. But only that.

Edited by molestargazer, 16 November 2009 - 07:56 PM.

[molestargazer]

VOTE COUNT
crazyemolad (7): Falzis, Narsis, Sir Jesus, Kaziocore, KevinH, SinKon, Martino
SinKon (4): CanucksDynasty, Electric Mango, Aquinas, Firkked
Falzis (1): Junkahoolik

Not Voting (1): crazyemolad

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Near the end of the day, crazyemolad grows oddly quiet. Neither the prodding of the players nor of the aircraft's turbulence could turn him away from his quiet, solemn-looking thoughts. The passengers threw him the occasional glance as they discussed where they would spend the night. Eventually, the players started to turn against the quiet man. When he said not a word to defend himself, the players started to round on him. What if it was a clever ruse? They had to do something, right?
In the end it was Narsis, whom in the lack of a weapon, took a small glass bottle of spirits and smashed it over crazyemolad's head. The lynch mob turned on the hapless passenger, punching and kicking in their spite, whilst the remaining passengers held back, a little nervously, over what their fellow passengers had been turned into.

A search of the man's body revealed nothing untoward.
Now all the passengers had to do was to decide where to spend the night.

crazyemolad, TOWNIE, has been lynched.
It is now DUSK. Players have 48 hours from now to post in which room they will spend the night.
(Players who have posted their movements post-hammer will have them counted)

[CanucksDynasty]

MOVE: Room 8


Big surprise that crazyemolad was a townie
/sarcasm/

[Narsis]

Why thank you.
It was a nice try, Narsis. But only that.

was worth a try.

[Narsis]

also:

Room 1 = Sir Jesus, Firkked, junkahoolic
Room 4 = Electric Mango, AoD/SinKon, Kaziocore
Room 7 = Falzis, Narsis, KevinH
Room 8 = CanucksDynasty, Aquinas, Martino

bold have chosen their room(the correct room).

[Electric Mango]

MOVE: Room 4


I hope I get a good night sleep