1469 replies to this topic

[Falzis]

junk's post seem off lately but if i had to compare him to sinkon on D1, i'm much more inclined to vote for sinkon seems reviewing things it really looks like sinkon was all over the place plus the different post style he has now on D2 which appears more controlled. i don't know if it's because of activity (whether he's busy iRL lately) but it doesn't fit with his overzealous attitude to participate on D1.

junk is close to getting my vote (especially after narsis' inquisition) but right now, i'll still stick with my original vote.

i wanna hear CD's thoughts. he has been aggressive but lately is missing in action. maybe still full from thanksgiving

[Falzis]

EBWOP: I just remembered junkahoolik doesn't like to be called junk. sorry junka! >.<

[KevinH]

@ those who didnt vote for junkahoolik: could you go through your reasoning for not voting him.

He doesn't seem like scum to me. (He could, of course, be doing a good job as scum appearing to be townie)

[Electric Mango]

I didn't vote for junkahoolic because I thought KevinH had the most anit town posts out of anyone. I explained them all in my previous posts but a quick recap will follow:

KevinH proposed 2 less than optimal strategies.

The first was with room assignments - his was better than random room assignments but it was less than optimal and would give the scum more targets.

The second was with the cop and some townies dropping hints stratety. His theory would make it easier for the mafia to zero in on the cop.

Also he said I OMGUS'd him. When I questioned him on it he said it was a joke. Maybe it was but there was no indication at the time that he was joking. I would expect a joke to be obvious or end with a

[Falzis]

I have a different reading of KevinH. I don't think he's scum.

[junkahoolik]

narsis, i answered the question already. i'd say martino and firkked. though i'm not exactly sure here... you also started asking questions with a black or white answer attached to them and kazio also voted for me then went afk probably after i can't say i heard from him a lot. correct me if i'm wrong but this is the last day right??

[Electric Mango]

Yep, this is the last day.

Also to let everyone know, my U key on my personal pc is broken so if you notice spelling errors it's because I'm at home playing. I don't want anyone to know that I can't spell.

[KevinH]

Also he said I OMGUS'd him.

No.
I said I could vote for you because you voted for me.
That's me OMGUSing you, not vice versa.

I addressed this before but to refresh your memory:
...
More clarification on the OMGUS:

In the context of answering the question of who could be mafia, I was answering that I could think EM is mafia because he voted for me, not that he was responding to something I said about him.

OMGUS? I was asked whom I thought was scum and I was trying to respond that Electric Mango must be scum because he had voted for me. Yet again I have to explain my attempts at humor.

Attempting to mislead, perhaps?

[KevinH]

Attempting to mislead, perhaps?

I forgot the .

[CanucksDynasty]

i wanna hear CD's thoughts. he has been aggressive but lately is missing in action. maybe still full from thanksgiving

Away for work...so was not online as much.

Both junkahoolic and SinKon were on my radar so it doesn't matter to me which of them gets lynch.

[junkahoolik]

it kind'a irk's me that i'll be lynched without a shred of a case really... that and the fact that i haven't even asked to roleclaim since, who knows, i might be the cop or something from what everyone except 1 person should know... well, 2 if you count mole

well, anyway, no need to bother people, i'm a simple townie...

[junkahoolik]

junk's post seem off lately but if i had to compare him to sinkon on D1, i'm much more inclined to vote for sinkon seems reviewing things it really looks like sinkon was all over the place plus the different post style he has now on D2 which appears more controlled. i don't know if it's because of activity (whether he's busy iRL lately) but it doesn't fit with his overzealous attitude to participate on D1.

junk is close to getting my vote (especially after narsis' inquisition) but right now, i'll still stick with my original vote.

i wanna hear CD's thoughts. he has been aggressive but lately is missing in action. maybe still full from thanksgiving

how do my posts seem a bit off??

[Martino]

it kind'a irk's me that i'll be lynched without a shred of a case really... that and the fact that i haven't even asked to roleclaim since, who knows, i might be the cop or something from what everyone except 1 person should know... well, 2 if you count mole

well, anyway, no need to bother people, i'm a simple townie...

It's not our job to demand a roleclaim. If you have a valuable role and are about to get lynched, you should have enough sense to roleclaim yourself. Anyway, I presented my case against you in the post I made my vote. You responded that you still thought that a No lynch and follow the cop today was the best strategy. So I had no reason to unvote you. It also didn't help that you then voted for Falzis without believing that lynching is the best strategy. If you do not believe it is in the town's best interest to lynch, voting seems to indicate that you do not care about the town's best interests.

[KevinH]

thought that a No lynch and follow the cop today was the best strategy.

That's not much of a reason. The truth is that you want to lynch somebody and you need a candidate. This is consisent with the strong anti-no-lynch stance.

Probability favors junkahoolik being a townie and the town will be worse off when he is lynched.

[junkahoolik]

i pretty much said all i have to say. bring on the lynch i guess...

[Narsis]

it kind'a irk's me that i'll be lynched without a shred of a case really... that and the fact that i haven't even asked to roleclaim since, who knows, i might be the cop or something from what everyone except 1 person should know... well, 2 if you count mole

well, anyway, no need to bother people, i'm a simple townie...

as Martino said, you havent done anything to convince us that not lynching you is best. you support a no lynch stance, so obviously you arent going to give a case against someone else. and considering that the majority of people believe a no lynch stance is detrimental...spouting that as a reason not to lynch you doesnt exactly work.

so yes there might not be a huge case against you...but you have done nothing to refute it.

@KevinH probability favours the lynchee always being townie. the only time it would favour them being mafia is when mafia outnumber the town...at which point they've won anyway.

[junkahoolik]

well narsis, i haven't really heard any case against me that is based on anything remotely solid. can someone please state at least a coherent accusation?? not one of your black/white statements i mean (cause that really wasn't a question, i feel you were trying to sell me as incongruent). and from what i see, the last 2 pages are mostly me trying to not get lynched. so why do you say i did nothing to refute it??

vote narsis

for the reasons stated above.

[Narsis]

ok so now you go against your no lynch stance...why?

[Sir Jesus]

Wow, I just have no freakin' clue who could be scummy here.

I agree that we should totally stick with the original plan of separating into rooms.

If someone can present a case against someone that makes sense, I would consider voting for them. Other than that, there is just no evidence against anyone that I can point out. Since I have to vote

Vote: SinKon



The reason: I've seen him multiple times contradicting himself or lying. Example: "Sir Jesus is active...."

[Aquinas]

@ Junkahoolik: Although it might be to late anyway, I don't think flopping between a lynch and no lynch strategy is helping your case. You've been back and forth the last few pages. I'd be more able to trust you if you could stick to a stance. Seeing as we haven't had a death scene, it seems our time has not expired...we're in a gray area I think...

Vote: SinKon

The reason: I've seen him multiple times contradicting himself or lying. Example: "Sir Jesus is active...."

The same could be said about Junkahoolik. Do you think SinKon's flip flopping is worse than Junkahoolik's?