d3mon

I am assuming that if scum has roles that have the ability to kill during the day, it is possible that town has a role that can roleblock in the day. Unfortunately, this is speculation and I have no way to confirm.

Roleblocked is definitely a possibility and it might work in our favor as it makes anyone roleblocked atm a prime suspect. Now, if I was scum, then waiting isn't doing me any favors as it gives town an extra vote and thus an increased chance of lynching a scum. If we end up seeing a late day kill, its likely that the scum/serial killer is currently inactive.

Merry Christmas everyone Back to game, I am not sure if voting someone for inactivity at this time would be appropriate. I believe most of us are pretty busy with RL atm and it can lead to inactivity. Though I would like to point out that there hasn't been a day kill so far, so there are the following possibilities 1) It was a one time thing. 2) The scum/serial killer is inactive atm.

1943

From what I read from the death note wiki it seems that Aenir had some kinda investigative role, so it seems that the scum are going after any people with investigative abilities or it might be that they put all names in a hat, picked one up and decided to get rid of it. Now, I think it would be a safe assumption that there are 3 scum but if there are 4 of them then we are getting pretty close to LYLO.

Just wondering.. how many scum does everyone think are out there?

I am a little reluctant to lynch anyone atm. We have already lost a couple of what seem like cop roles and lynching without any evidence might cost us another major power role. I agree that xarastier's playing style is different from what most of us are accostomed to but he seems more like a enthusiastic townie vs a scum to me. Vote : No lynch

I am not sure if KevinH is scum but the fact that he is alive even after making a claim that virtually paints a target on his back.. kinda makes me a little suspicious about him. I am wondering if the townies in the night talk thread can confirm if KevinH is indeed a townie? Cuz, if not then we might be playing into the hands of scum.

Hm.. are we sure that all the guys that are talking in the night talking thread are not scum?

I have been for a very long time been a proponent of no lynch on day 1 and while I did place a meaningless vote for Karl, its time to get back to business.. Vote: No Lynch

The no lynch bandwagon is oddly missing KevinH's name

This is a very interesting setup.. Just to get the game started. Vote:Karl

I m winning..

/in

Tbh, I don't care atm.. have fun

I spent most of the last game day drunk, so I haven't read what was discussed but I believe gunsmith investigation on godfather should produce a gun.. And by that logic, I can be the Godfather

According to my understanding of Gunsmith's role, any role capable of nightkilling will show up as having a gun.. So an investigation on Godfather should reveal a gun.. BTW, when you guys are done lynching me.. make sure you lynch my prime suspect.. i.e. Aenir too

A jack of all trades cannot neighbourize.

Hm.. I guess it could be read this way.. What I meant was and in your words "To trust or not to trust, that is the question." and without your trust my role was as good as wasted. A better way to say it would have been "I wished that EM could investigate and find out". Also, if you are accusing me of being scum and knowing your role before you role claimed, then I assure you that if I was scum, you would have been night killed and not neighbourized.

I agree what I am saying is highly unlikely, at the same time a mafia neighbourizer is improbable but if you had played any mafia game with EM or read the games he has played so far then you will realize that scum courting EM is suicidal.. tbh, I was hoping EM would investigate me the night I neighbourized him I haven't seen Mafia framer in action before but it is possible that unless the framer changes target, the framed individual comes up positive in any subsequent investigations or the framer was a one shot permanent frame role which was used on me after I tried to save Kazio.. Also, if you go through my actions, none of them have been anti town.. If I were scum, I would have voted for Chaplain of Death and saved Imran.. then again, a perfect record in itself is suspicious.. Now, this is just my opinion, but with the confirmed townie roles Jack of all trades, Weak Doc Vigilante, Gunsmith (and no vanilla townies).. imho, Mafia would have stronger roles than a one shot Neighbourizer...

I am neighbourizer and well.. EM can vouch for it. If I was scum, I would choose someone other than EM to neighbourize, cuz its a lot more easy to mis guide a new player vs EM.. Also, according to the discussion we had last night, he was going to investigate someone on my list of suspects. If I was scum, and was misleading him, then I had absolutely no reason to use the night kill on him.. Anyhow, with one Mafia framer dead, the only possible scenario that I could have a gun on me is another framer and well.. while that is the truth for me, its a unlikely truth for the rest of you, so I am not too hopeful.

I cannot explain why an investigation on me would reveal a gun, except perhaps there are more Mafia framers.. anyhow, best of luck town

I am still not sure about Imran, his actions indicate that he is townie but if no other evidence comes up, I am will very likely vote for Imran. Aenir, you have tried to defend Imran, I am wondering if there is a reason behind that.. AFAIK, EM can be a scum trying to deceive town, so, it would be great to know the cause behind your reasoning.. Unvote

Imho, EM's argument to lynch Kazio was pretty valid. Kazio implied that he couldn't use his ability on night 1, i.e. even if he wanted to, the game mechanics didn't allow it. Now, this conflicts with how my role is defined. Also, it seems that nobody else had a role that was blocked on day 1.. cuz he should then have come forward and indicated that such roles existed. While, hindsight is always 20/20, I still think EM made a valid argument.

There is a very big difference between my vote and yours. My vote was the third and left ample time/votes for Kazio to argue his case. While, your votes, and I am including Aenir in this, did was create a scenario where even one mistake/quick vote from a townie will lead to a lynch. Tbh, even if you are town, I have to say, it was a very bad move.