Imran Ehsan
IRON President
-
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Imran Ehsan
-
Welcome back!
-
-
I know this is your first game and all but everything isnt about you. All your posts are about yourself while you have only 1 vote. Theres one guy with 5 votes and another with 2 votes. You should try to add something productive to the town by actively trying to find ppl who may be scum and your thoughts on who may be scum.
-
Canik voted at the last minute or 30 mins before deadline. He was in no danger of being lynched then. He could have easily not voted and let the game go to another night with another lynch. But he didnt and hammered the vote. So his claim that he hammered FB to save himself is false. ^ ...go to another night with no lynch i meant.
-
Interesting...... So you are saying Finster used his first night action on kevin and found him town. And then on the second night he checked out SBG and found him scum? Meh I just realized that you guys play mafia differently. I'm used to PR's using their powers before D1 starts. In my scenario it's possible for Finster to use his powers twice already, but here he could have only once because he was lynched before he could use it a second time. It still doesn't explain to me why Finster would act like he did on D2 That or you are trying to set up SBG up for a mislynch later. anyway if you turn up scum then it will clear SBG.
-
-
-
I agree with your statement that we should let FB speak from the dead, but not your deduction. So lets hear what FB said. Relevant parts highlighted. From the above it is pretty clear that he used his first action on you (kevinh) and found you town. He also indicated he had one more action left. So what do we get from the above two posts. 1. He investigated kevin and found him town. 2. He was not able to id any scum with his first action. 3. He made the humongous mistake of revealing he has a very powerful action and that he should be allowed to live another day to use it. 4. Who can potentially claim something like that? Doc? Tracker? Follower? Roleblocker? Nope. None has actions that are strong enough to give concrete information to town by use of only one night. It could have only been a cop who could make that claim. This reveal was a huge mistake by FB. 4. Scum picked up on that reveal and knew very well he cannot be allowed to live another night and reveal his results. He would have been targetted for kill at night, I am 100 % sure. 5. But they saw an opportunity early. They saw he already had 2 votes on him and time is running out. They decided to take out the cop when they had the chance and not take the risk of the cop being protected at night. So they decided to go for the kill immediately. From above we can deduce Canik has 80% chance of being scum, Yehom has 70% chance of being scum and both Yehom Canik has a high probability of both being scum. We lynch Canik today and Yehom tomoroow. I can guarantee you town will lynch at least 1 scum amongst those 2. Vote: Canik
-
-
welcome back
-
-
If you want to make the game interesting, vote to lynch, dont vote No Lynch. That makes it boring and pointless to play the game. Canik was in my shortlist but the same could be said of CoD. I just gave CoD the benefit of doubt that he was busy RL. However, robert was in my short list and his behavior has been scummy. So I would rather lynch robert. But an inactive will do also, they kill games. If ppl dont want to lynch robert this early in the game, i understand as he has been active. but he hasnt done anything yet to really explain his scummy behavior imo. But we need to lynch today, if not robert, then an inactive. We got no info from d1 and n1 and if d2 goes no lynch again, we will be in the same position again on d3, with probably 1 less townie.
-
OK going back to my vote on Robert. I found his following post pretty scumworthy: Basically he is just sitting on the fence while saying he doesnt mind in d34th gets lynched. If he wanted No Lynch on d1 he should have voted NL like some others did. But he is not, while saying he doesnt like lynches on d1. Now lets look at another of his posts: Again he is saying he like D1 NL but indicating that d34th should be lynched for his inactivity. In other words, he wants d34th to be lynched but would not vote for it himself. This is classic scum behavior where they dont want to be on the lynch wagon of a townie but wants other townies to lynch a townie. If he is scum, he knows d3th will turn up town on lynch and then he will push to put suspicion on the ones who lynched a townie. His style of play so far has also been subtly trying to put suspicion on others while not taking the lead himself. When he saw Rhizos arguments against kevin, he took no sides but posted: Basically he is keeping the option open whether to push for a kevin lynch if he sees some players being swayed by rhizo's arguments. Most of his posts are neither here nor there, classic sitting on the fence. Thats a pretty strong scum tell, because scum dont want to take the lead in lynching others but will try to manipulate townies to suspect each other and subtly push to lynch a townie.
-
Agreed with kevin. It is doubtful all 3 scum were on the d3th wagon. I would say there was probably 1. So my shortlist of susects for this day are: Not Voting: Canik, Chaplain of Death, D34THBR1NG3R, Rhizoctonia, Robert2424 That was before d34th was replaced. Amongst the above, lets take out d34th. Rhizo explained his position on why he is not voting d34th so lets take him out as well. That leaves Canik, CoD and Robert. CoD mentioned he was busy with RL. So lets give him the benefit of the doubt as well. That leaves Canik or Robert. I havent had time yet to go through all their posts but there was one post by Robert that I noticed was very scumworthy. I will explain more in detail once I have a chance to go through all their posts again. But for now: Vote: Robert2424
-
-
Gonna backup kevin here. In previous games normally there were replacements on standby or those who signed up for a game were at least active in game. In this case, this game took almost a month to start up and d34th has been inactive in-game for over 3 weeks. Its pretty safe to say this has never happened before in previous games (i.e. there was always a chance that someone who had signed up for the game would probably show up later, bc they were active at least in-game). So, kevin going against his normal style of play for this game is absolutely justified. And I dont think he would have started playing differently if he was scum, but tha remains to be seen. In any case Lynching is always good. I dont believe in relying on the cop to give townies info to lynch scum. I like analysisng voting trends when someone gets lynched. And I am already getting some interesting vibes from some people due to this lynch wagon. @kitkat - is this the first game you are playing?
-
-
-
Masked. Welcome.
-
-
Done. Welcome back.
-
He is already masked. What problem is he having? He forgot his password?
-
Welcome back!
-
Masked. Welcome.
-
/in
