Lachiton

What scum have you hunted though? Oh yeah SBG based on "get rekt" comment which is a convenient way of bussing the other scum. You also started the wagon on SM and your defense was why a scum would go hard on someone who may turn out town. Now you're accusing me of going hard at Robert and say it is a scum move? Yes I was wrong as a town I am not sure who scum is. I can only guess. As for going back to D1 defense, damn right I will go there. I did post that out as soon as I can because I needed to give a signal to fellow town that I am town. If I was not 100% sure of the PM thing I would not have posted it. No scum would have gambled so early in the game. And Medved did confirm that he sent out that PM so there's that. And isn't the same 'he copied it from wiki' argument done by TW, a known scum? I would give you one thing, you played one hell of a game. No amount of credit is enough for how successfully you manipulated us. So well done. WP as I said before trust your instincts. Your instincts were quite right before, hopefully you can understand the game played by brewers.

Damn that's a great wall of China kinda post. Would take me forever to read the whole thing. I read the last part and your wiki argument doesn't hold good for a supposed scum to try on Day 1 and his 2ND ever post without any pressure to do so and if my assumption doesn't hold true scum team loses a player before the game even starts to pick up. Also Kevin put me in his shortlist because he somehow missed my post but he believed me the instance he saw the post. Yes you did remind him to take a look at my post but it was all done to gain my trust. That is why I stuck by you this whole game. You even tried last time to get me the gun as you feel I had believed in you so I would naturally shoot WP. WP trust your instincts this time as well. I know I had not believed your instincts before but in hindsight you were right all along. You got TW and suspected brewers as well before. IIRC you once said there's an active and a inactive scum after TW died. Come to think of it you were right, SBG was the inactive scum and brewers active one.

You know I had believed in brewers throughout this game. Everytime I thought is he the scum that is fooling us all but I brushed aside those thoughts. Well there's very little reason to doubt him, he is hyper active and posts well. He was also the one of first ones to believe my role PM thingy and defended me when TW was trying to downplay that as a convenient quote from wiki. Irony is in the last days he is using TW's argument to paint me as scum. I know now what he did previously was to gain my trust as scum realized I may last the distance in this game. Because he gained my trust, I ignored a very obvious clue now in how he started SBG's wagon in the first place. He needed to buss him to gain town's trust and as they have day talk, SBG's get rekt comment on dead TW was the cue for brewers to jump on his case. SBG too didn't seem to defend himself well, odd thing from such an experienced player which I thought as being him being so inactive and hence lost interest in the game. But it was their plan all along. Then brewers went hard at SM too to further cement his town cred, taking the cue where I went hard at Robert and trying to paint himself as an innocent town who made a mistake. That's why he voted for me and wanted the gun in my hand so that I make the mistake of shooting you instead of him and scum wins the game. His argument for voting me was odd as well, which I just explained in my previous post. My intention of posting that role PM thing was simple, to alert fellow town I am town so don't waste your shot as there's no investigative roles and difficult to confirm town or scum by anybody. As there's no lynches so having vote as your weapon was an odd thing to mention in the PM. So I thought I will put that out as though those words shouldn't have been there, it was still there. Medved then confirmed he did send out that in the PM though he didn't confirm he sent it to me or not. Now if Medved had removed that part when he sent the town PMs, and as a scum I would have still tried that trick I would be up for shoot the very moment as town would have called my bluff. It was too huge of a risk for any scum to take and that too in the first stage of Day 1 when there's no need and trying such plan could have backfired easily. Think about all of this before you take your decision.

That would be hell of a coincidence.

You know I deserve an ass kicking from rest of town for getting you to constantly manipulate me by gaining my trust and kicking me to the curb at the very last moment. Very very well played. Tbf I was being fooled by you all along. Especially how you bussed SBG. Damn come to think of it WP and SM were right all along when they were suspecting you of being scum. But I stuck to your defense and got played. I am afraid that WP has already made up his mind of shooting me but if he goes back and looks carefully the way you started the wagon on SBG and then at the last moment you completely changed your stance against me and voted me so that the gun falls in my hand and probably will shoot WP and you win the game. WP this is crunch moment for you so you need to sit back and think about the whole situation for a second. I did carefully put out my role PM and Medved of all people confirmed that he sent those exact words. So if I am scum how on earth I can be 100% sure that Medved will send that PM? Did I have a premonition that Medved will send that exact PM, even if it's supposed to be there in the wiki? I am on my phone so can't quote all the relevant posts but take a good look at the post by brewers where he voted for me. He said SBG "confirming" me about the role PM is supposedly enough proof that I am scum. Tell me a supposed scum ie me is taking a huge risk by trying to be oversmart in my 2nd ever post and posting something only town would know and my scum partner "confirms" without any clue himself so if I get busted, 2 scum members are already dead by Day 2 itself? What kind of planning will that be? Devious plan comes usually later in the game just like how brewers did with SBG. All I am saying WP analyse the whole game and take a decision.

Hopefully this does truly end the game.

^^^^ That's a good point. Also along with that do we have any sort of penalty for not voting at all.

what I have looked at has shown me that you appear to have made less effort hunting scum than WP or Brewsky. I get the point about brewers but WP made more effort than me in hunting scum? Plzzz!! IIRC I did vote for someone every time except I think Day 1, even if they turned out town, WP has mostly stayed away from voting. He did vote for TW but at the very end of the day with not much hope of forming wagon. Also Robert took a gamble while shooting TW and not because of WP but mostly I guess because TW jumped on Robert's wagon as soon as I started it. So that's why I have refused to give much credit to WP for that because voting late in the day, especially because you were getting the heat for not voting at all, and with a flimsy reason like gut feeling shouldn't earn you much praise. And since when just voting for scum with no wagon forming mind you, automatically makes you town?Look back at my posts from my spat with Robert till my vote on SBG and tell me I didnt try to scum hunt. Even a known scum TW took advantage of my spat with Robert and jumped on his wagon at the first opportunity he got. Scum will always look to take advantage of such scenarios and TW being an experienced player knew how to side with one or the other and he did exactly that. I told town once and I will suit again, when you look to sniff out diabolical plans you always miss the most obvious clues. I am your best chance to win as scum has no chance of winning without me getting the gun and hope I shoot the wrong person. As for my vote I guess I am clear on this Vote: WP

Not sure if you seriously believe this statement. We don't have any investigative roles here, so no both of you just voted on hunch as only scum can be sure of alignment. I will give brewers more credit for actually helping start a wagon on SBG and you got town points for casting the 2nd vote, I was on his wagon as well in case you have forgotten. I don't really give you much credit for TW as iirc it was the only time you actually made your suspicions of him public and you voted late and hence wagon never took off. Not much convincing argument from you either against him and neither did you try to rally others to vote for him. But still you deserve some credit for being the lone vote on TW. But just voting for scum doesn't automatically qualify you as town as scum do try to create distance so if one is caught, the other can't be traced through him. Look at all my posts and point out to me where I acted scummy or deliberately tried to misguide town. Shooting me does equal to losing the game as with me present we can still win if we r down to 2 town and have to shoot scum to win.

I accept your challenge. Can I have The Warrior as my champion?Well since you agree to this, I guess I can take a chance on that.Vote: Rafay If people are voting for Rafay do we keep him from hammering so that he can go through this whole trial by combat and check out how brewers handles it? I know it's not a recommended approach as we can't analyse wagon but since it's Day1 we can check it out. A trial by combat will only happen if someone does not reach the half majority for a lynch, which for today's purpose is 4 votesOh damn! I assumed Rafay was at 2 votes before I voted for him. My bad. Unvote

I accept your challenge. Can I have The Warrior as my champion? Well since you agree to this, I guess I can take a chance on that. Vote: Rafay If people are voting for Rafay do we keep him from hammering so that he can go through this whole trial by combat and check out how brewers handles it? I know it's not a recommended approach as we can't analyse wagon but since it's Day1 we can check it out.

Rafay doesn't take much time to make his decision, does he? Well I hope this is really it for town as I strongly feel SM is our last scum. In case she is not, which is slim. then it's probably WP but I would be surprised if that happens.

Vote: SM I do think she is our last scum but if she does turn up town then it must be WP. Brewers is 99% town, acc to me. Putting aside that rare 1% chance he is fooling us by sacrificing his partner, though it will be still dumb move

Nominating Rafay for trial by combat can be an interesting choice, then you leave him to his own fate and luck. If he survives he can add one more feather in his illustrious mafia cap and have another reason to pat himself on the back:p

So it means the player with the most votes will his/her fate be decided by a roll of dice? What happens if another player is tied with most votes, both may die or live?

Vote: No Lynch . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Any more open slots? I m in then

So Rafay can be the tie breaker @Rafay, here's your opportunity, you can make a difference here. You have not voted the entire game but by voting you can help Robert find the last scum. Robert is doing the right thing imo by just reading through the arguments and counter arguments of other players and not jumping in with his thought atm. He will take the final decision so it's the job of rest of the town to find him the best possible and logical choice(s)

I am town so let's not overcomplicate this. Stop all your conspiracy theories lol

If brewers is scum then it would be a very stupid play to sacrifice his only remaining partner, knowing fully well that as long as the gun bearer doesn't shoot me or anyone at all then scum has no chance of wininng. With 5 town and 1 scum, town's not losing this. Even if next 3 shots get 3 gun bearers killed and the ratio is 2:1, assuming I am alive and not the gun-bearer, that will mean we will have 2 confirmed townies and the gun-bearer will know whom to shoot. So it is extremely unlikely that brewers will leave it to the last gun bearer to doubt my innocence so that he can manipulate him/her to shoot me and win it for scum. Remember as long as gun-bearer is active and I am not shot, 1 scum cant win this. So keeping this in mind, I do think brewers is town. Coming on to WP, he has been suspecting me and brewers for a while now. He has eased up on me but still suspect brewers, at least that is consistent of him. He was the lone vote on TW and was the 2nd one on SBG so that earn him townie points in my eyes. So that leaves Rafay and SM. Rafay doesn't vote at all so that's a problem even though he has been throwing accusations at both WP and SM. SM looks to be playing safe with never fully committing to her suspicions unless someone else has already went ahead and formed the charge, in which case she would likely join in. Not necessarily scum tell but scum also tends to hesitate so as to not draw unnecesary attention. At this point it can be either Rafay and SM, with SM my likely choice at this point. And even she is town, she is active and participates so we can try to scum hunt again the next day. Robert may die if he shoots SM and she turns out town but with 2 successful shots already under his belt, town is in excellent shape and won't lose unless makes some drastic mistakes. This is interesting though. It may be Seabee just being Seabee but he did the same with TW which got brewers on his back and this may be a last ditch attempt to save SM, as who would trust a known scum. So placing my vote for now Vote: SM

Ok fair enough!

We have 1 scum left likely so cant lose as long as I am not shot Also SBG as scum in every game SM plays is not true. Both of them were town in the Last Jedi mafia.

Yeah my bad. Medved didn't count your vote so I missed that.

Both Rafay and you stayed out. WP did vote for both TW and SBG. Did you vote for TW though? I know you voted for Robert and he turned out town. So to be fair I am dropping WP from my suspect's list for now. Brewers was never on it. So currently there's both of you on the radar. Ok correction you did vote for him. So only Rafay stayed out.

One more scum and we are done. We are in excellent shape and we can't lose now as long as I am not the gunbearer