Welcome to the IRON Gaming Channel! Tonight we have a special treat as Narsis hosts what he(and we considering our poor ratings as of late) hopes is the next big game show! He calls it Guess Who Mafia.

 

Ever played that board game Guess Who? The one where players pick a person from the deck and then try to guess who the other player has by asking yes/no questions about them. What about mafia? The game of persuasion, logic, and good old fashioned murder mystery. Well whether you have or haven't now is your chance to watch these 5 players duke it out in a twisted combination of the two! Who will win? Let's find out!

 

Players still in the game:

 

2. Kaziocore

3. Nerau

5. CanucksDynasty

 

Players out of the game:

Theophilos, TOWNIE, lynched Day One.

KevinH, TOWNIE, killed Night One.

 

Revealed Information:

 

1. KevinH:

 

Hair Colour: Black

Eye Colour: Brown

Sex: Female

Skin Colour: Dark

Accessories: Glasses

 

2. Kaziocore:

 

Hair Colour:

Eye Colour:

Sex:

Skin Colour:

Accessories:

 

3. Nerau:

 

Hair Colour: Black

Eye Colour: Brown

Sex: Female

Skin Colour: Dark

Accessories: Necklace

 

4. Theophilos:

 

Hair Colour: Black

Eye Colour: Green

Sex: Female

Skin Colour: Light

Accessories: Glasses

 

5. CanucksDynasty:

 

Hair Colour: Brown

Eye Colour: Brown

Sex: Male

Skin Colour: Dark

Accessories: Necklace

 

6. The Mafia:

 

Hair Colour:

Eye Colour:

Sex:

Skin Colour:

Accessories:

 

 

The Rules

 

1. Days will last a week; nights will last 48 hours.

 

2. At deadline the player with the most votes dies. If there is a tie the first player to get to that number of votes is lynched. Should no one have been voted, a player will be lynched at random.

 

3. During the day the town(as a whole) may also ask the mod a single yes/no question about the mafia. This question must be related to the revealed information section. (Examples: Is the mafia's hair brown? Is the mafia a guy? etc. Examples of what not to ask: Is CD the mafia? Is KevinH not the mafia?) It must be asked in bold.

 

4. There are only two options for each category(hair: brown/black, eyes: brown/green, sex: guy/girl, skin: dark/light, accessories: glasses/necklace).

 

6. Upon death a persons info will be fully revealed. Additionally, one of the living players at the start of each day will be revealed in full.

 

5. Everything else should already be known to you guys since you've all played mafia before and I'm not about to throw out any major surprises. If you have any questions feel free to ask.

Edited July 18, 201016 yr by molestargazer

MOD: "Does the mafia have (brown hair and a necklace) or (black hair and glasses)?"

 

No.

 

 

Also i'm leaving tomorrow on a week-long trip. i'll send mole everything so hopefully he can take over. if not...then i guess the day will be extended till i get back.

CanucksDynasty is 100% townie!

 

(I suppose he could be a vigilante but that would be too over-the-top)

 

Now we have to lynch purposefully rather than get a random lynch.

I am thinking Kaziocore has been helpful to the town with the multiple-part question idea.

Therefore my vote will be either for Nerau or Theophilos.

Between them, I am undecided.

Therefore the mafia will have either...

Hair Colour: Brown

Accessories: Glasses

OR

Hair Colour: Black

Accessories: Necklace

 

The result was actually good because I don't need to persuade you guys to not vote CD...

So right now my vote is between Theo and Nerau.

Both didn't contribute much so it's hard to choose between them.

 

Anyway,

MOD: Can the day end on Saturday instead of Thursday so at least night will fall on the weekend where I assume people are busy?

CanucksDynasty is 100% townie!

 

(I suppose he could be a vigilante but that would be too over-the-top)

 

Now we have to lynch purposefully rather than get a random lynch.

I am thinking Kaziocore has been helpful to the town with the multiple-part question idea.

Therefore my vote will be either for Nerau or Theophilos.

Between them, I am undecided.

 

Not quite, since the above answer Narsis gave absolves me of being mafia as well

I counted the times the two posted and I got this...

Nerau: 6

Theo: 8

 

Also when you look at the dates of the posts,

Nerau disappeared after posting on July 10.

He then only posted three days after (July 13, lurking perhaps?)

Theo on the other hand was only absent at the beginning of the game.

 

Also I felt Nerau was only agreeing to things and not adding much to the discussion.

 

So right now I'll have to vote Nerau:

Vote: Nerau

Not quite, since the above answer Narsis gave absolves me of being mafia as well

 

And we would just believe you?

Naturally, for whom would you trust but a fellow townie - me.

I counted the times the two posted and I got this...

Nerau: 6

Theo: 8

 

Also when you look at the dates of the posts,

Nerau disappeared after posting on July 10.

He then only posted three days after (July 13, lurking perhaps?)

Theo on the other hand was only absent at the beginning of the game.

 

Also I felt Nerau was only agreeing to things and not adding much to the discussion.

 

So right now I'll have to vote Nerau:

Vote: Nerau

 

Tough choice since neither really contributed much.

I have more of a scummy feel for Theo though.

 

I asked him if he was OK with KevinH suggestion and he said very much so.

But then proceeded to suggest hair+eyes combo.

If it was OK ... then why bother to make a suggestion of hair +eyes combo???

 

He also posted that weird combo list of not mafia.

And he used primary hair + eyes on his list (saying there may be a hint in the mod rules.)

 

Also...how does MOD answer absolves Theo?

No reasonable explanation given.

 

Vote: Theophilos

I'm betting that mafia will look like this...

 

Hair Colour: Brown

Eye Colour: Brown

Sex: Female

Skin Colour: Light

Accessories: Glasses

 

 

Ouch Narsis, next time try prodding without a pitchfork

 

Anyway, the combination question sounds good.

 

We might also make an assumption, that (a) Narsis gave a clue to how mafia looks with the initial description or (B ) that he gave no such clue.

 

If he didn't than mafia is surely not:

 

brown/brown/male/dark/necklace

brown/brown/male/dark/glasses

brown/brown/male/light/necklace

brown/brown/male/light/glasses

brown/brown/female/dark/necklace

brown/brown/female/dark/glasses

brown/brown/female/light/necklace

brown/brown/female/light/necklace

 

There is a catch tough, I'm assuming that the two primary variations clues wise are hair and eyes.

 

I still don't see how he thought MOD gave a clue.

I didn't understand what how if mod didn't give a clue then...mafia is surely not (see list)...

List didn't include glasses...maybe a mistake on Theo's part.

 

Very much so.

 

My suggestion would be, "brown hair/green eyes or black hair/brown eyes"

 

This is when I asked if KevinH suggested question was acceptable.

He agreed but then proceeded to provide his own suggestion.

 

Nope only a feeling, those two characteristics are also the two I'm most likely to remember in RL when I meet someone or such. I'm betting on the fact that Narsis might have approached it the same way ... than again if he is more in to details, than I'm likely wrong.

 

Trying to defend his assumption of hair + eyes.

Betting that Narsis would approach it the same way.

I don't buy that.

 

CD I already agreed to you asking the q, somewhere above ...

 

Looked but couldn't find where he agreed to allow me to make the decision of what to ask the mod.

It was first suggested by KevinH, followed by Kazio, and then Nerau.

Then I asked the question.

 

 

Not quite, since the above answer Narsis gave absolves me of being mafia as well

 

MOD answer doesn't absolves him...(other than Theo claiming townie).

CanucksDynasty is 100% townie!

 

(I suppose he could be a vigilante but that would be too over-the-top)

 

Now we have to lynch purposefully rather than get a random lynch.

I am thinking Kaziocore has been helpful to the town with the multiple-part question idea.

Therefore my vote will be either for Nerau or Theophilos.

Between them, I am undecided.

 

 

I hope it's between them and you're not mafia.

Cuz if you are mafia...then well played.

Nerau could be mafia lurking...(I don't know enough of his gameplay to make that judgement).

And didn't really help contributing much.

 

 

this should be interesting to play to say the least

 

The 2nd to post ... not much here.

 

yes i believe so

 

in theory we could know the charatertics of mafia before the day ends

 

 

edit

 

ok i read it wrong only one question a day

 

Misread rules (kinda like I did).

 

i say lets start with the first two

 

hair/eye colour and do what kazicore is suggesting and then we know at least something going into the next day.

 

Here is where he could be scummy.

Suggesting hair/eyes combo.

But really...Kazio offered it first in his example question.

 

i believe theo is trying to limit the combinations so that we can gain the most information within a single question

 

Trying to defend Theo's list.

I can't see why he would do this if he was scum.

 

i understand what you are saying

 

and yes kevinh reasoning is acceptable

 

Agreeing to KevinH suggested question.

 

go ahead and pick the charateristic

 

its fine with me

 

Gave me the go ahead to choose the question.

I hope it's between them and you're not mafia.

Cuz if you are mafia...then well played.

 

I try to play the same whether I'm townie or not. However, this time I'm townie.

I will support the known townie in his decision.

 

Vote: Theophilos

Obviously I claimed I had Black hair and Glasses, with my answer to Kazio. So expanding anything from that is a complete fabrication.

 

Also, so what if I did give my suggestion ... agreeing to you posting a question, is supposed to bar me from giving my suggestion or what?

 

brown/brown/female/light/necklace and putting this in bold, is just that putting something in bold, given that I was listing the possibilities I made a mistake ... so?

 

Either way the votes are there, after I'm proved a townie, think about that

Obviously I claimed I had Black hair and Glasses, with my answer to Kazio. So expanding anything from that is a complete fabrication.

 

Also, so what if I did give my suggestion ... agreeing to you posting a question, is supposed to bar me from giving my suggestion or what?

 

brown/brown/female/light/necklace and putting this in bold, is just that putting something in bold, given that I was listing the possibilities I made a mistake ... so?

 

Either way the votes are there, after I'm proved a townie, think about that

 

 

The thing is...how the hell are the rest of us to know that you have black hair and glasses?

You don't even tell us that until now.

Good afternoon, folks.

Narsis has now left and I have just returned from a vacation, so I will be taking over the moderating duties.

I hear the deadline for D1 is tomorrow, hopefully i'll have got my bearings by then and know what's going on.

 

In the meantime, do continue.

Obviously you can't until you lynch me and see that I'm a townie.

Obviously you can't until you lynch me and see that I'm a townie.

 

Well...if not you then who?

You haven't voted for anyone yet.

It'll be sad if Theo was lynched without Nerau even posting

It'll be sad if Theo was lynched without Nerau even posting

 

I have seen him online today.

If I were to vote for anyone it would be KevinH.

If I were to vote for anyone it would be KevinH.

 

 

Really?

Why is that.

 

Please share your insights.

It's nothing much, but ...

 

You were excluded by MOD. That leaves pretty much four equal probabilities. I than excluded my self and Kazio. Nerau might be mafia, but I don't think he'd intentionally play in such a reserved manor if he was mafia.

 

That leaves KevinH.

ok just to explain some things

 

Nerau disappeared after posting on July 10.

He then only posted three days after (July 13, lurking perhaps?)

 

i was at work during those times and i was tried so i forgot about this

 

 

and yes i am contributing very much and i am aware of this and with possiblities out there

 

there are quite a few and believe no matter the question information would be gained which would help eliminate possiblities and therefore gain the town what it most desire

edit

 

and yes i am contributing very much and i am aware of this and with possiblities out there

 

nd yes i am not contributing very much and i am aware of this and with possiblities out there

I'm not really convinced about the scumminess of anyone, but I think the game will play out and we stand a good chance to win.

 

I know CD is a townie and I know I am a townie. That means I have a 1/3 chance of picking the right person to lynch.

 

If we mislynch, then there will only be 3 players left after a night kill. Even if there wasn't a question, I would have a 50% chance of guessing scum.

But there is a question and I will be able to deduce whether a different revealed player is scum or not; if that happens, I will definitely be able to place my vote on the scum tomorrow. Will the other townie follow my vote?

 

However, if I am revealed and shown to be townie with the question, I won't know about the remaining 2 players. It will be a 50% guess for the win. I feel lucky.