Ok: what if Kasabian is simply not telling the truth, lol. Why should we belive him? Also about "ramping up post counts"...Uni is back, I have less time/energy/will to post after hard days and more after relatively easy ones. I wouldn't draw such bold conclusions based on activity periods, as the reason for those can be strongly RL-based.

 

But fine, let's go with the theory that Kasabian and molestargazer are townie (I highly doubt it, but w/e). These are the remaining combos:

 

- Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Alasdair = 44

- Chaoshawk + Kaziocore + Nerau = 43

 

There is one common name there: Chaoshawk

 

So why not vote for him then? If we do, we have a bigger chance of catching a scum.

Also

 

[bUnvote][/b]

Fail

 

Unvote

I was also kind of wondering why everyone's believing Kasa. And also mod gave him "permission" to post that... so is it really from the role pm, or paraphrasing, or is Kasa somehow special by all intents and purposes?

 

It does seem kind of likely though.

Ok: what if Kasabian is simply not telling the truth, lol. Why should we belive him? Also about "ramping up post counts"...Uni is back, I have less time/energy/will to post after hard days and more after relatively easy ones. I wouldn't draw such bold conclusions based on activity periods, as the reason for those can be strongly RL-based.But fine, let's go with the theory that Kasabian and molestargazer are townie (I highly doubt it, but w/e). These are the remaining combos:- Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Alasdair = 44- Chaoshawk + Kaziocore + Nerau = 43There is one common name there: ChaoshawkSo why not vote for him then? If we do, we have a bigger chance of catching a scum.

 

Why not believe Kasa is the doc?

The ramping up post counts is what has already happened when there was a discussion about mid-day update.

Those people chose to post to get as many posts in prior to the mid-day count.

Chaoshawk is a possible candidate for a lynch...I need more time to disect all the posts.

 

 

I was also kind of wondering why everyone's believing Kasa. And also mod gave him "permission" to post that... so is it really from the role pm, or paraphrasing, or is Kasa somehow special by all intents and purposes? It does seem kind of likely though.

 

 

Again...why not believe Kasa is the doc?

I see no counter claim to prove otherwise.

Well played Kasabian but your squad does not specialize in medicine but mine does. It was a good way to pull attention off yourself and push a lynch towards myself and the dismemberment of my squad. The post counts per thread are not exact as in the way the moderator will count all of them worthy of being relevant to the posts so they will vary with accuracy and not be precise. I know for certain now Kasabian is mafia.

Well played Kasabian but your squad does not specialize in medicine but mine does. It was a good way to pull attention off yourself and push a lynch towards myself and the dismemberment of my squad. The post counts per thread are not exact as in the way the moderator will count all of them worthy of being relevant to the posts so they will vary with accuracy and not be precise. I know for certain now Kasabian is mafia.

 

Then tell me what % on the battlefield is needed for the town to win.

Then tell me what % on the battlefield is needed for the town to win.

 

Can he even do that without being modkilled?

I'm not sure if I can but I'll be vague and say its more than 89%

I'm not sure if I can but I'll be vague and say its more than 89%

 

ALRIGHT DOC!!!

 

Unvote

Vote: Kasabian

 

 

Since Kasa is mafia...mole should be mafia.

 

 

 

Im not a scum but i'll have to ask, does this mean you wanted to lynch mole? a townie? come on dude what's with you? are you really trying to help us scum hunt or not?

 

Here Kasa is professing his innocence and that mole is townie.

I suspected mole as mafia on D1 so I don't understand why he would assume I would think mole should be townie.

 

Going over his posts...he hints that he protected KevinH.

So I don't see how he can absolutely say for certain mole is a townie.

 

Kasabian, I don't want to put you at L-1 and risk a quicklynch. However, you are currently at L-2.I'd like a roleclaim, please.

 

Here mole asks for Kasa to roleclaim as doc (which forces the real doc to roleclaim).

But now Chaoshawk has counterclaimed (something he didn't necessarily need to do if he was mafia since he wasn't on the chopping block yet).

It was a last resort it seems for Kasabian to save himself and out the true doc. KevinH proved very valuable this game and it appears they targeted him or no killed.

 

Since CD and KevinH were confirmed townies I knew mole was mafia and tried to keep out of his spotlight and the enmity between him and CD.

 

It would be very scummy of him to kill CD with the little feud and tension between the two. I'd figure the third(assuming its three mafia and no third party or is the third party) one is either Martino or Alasdair and leaning towards the latter since he hasn't been very helpful.

It was a last resort it seems for Kasabian to save himself and out the true doc. KevinH proved very valuable this game and it appears they targeted him or no killed.

 

Since CD and KevinH were confirmed townies I knew mole was mafia and tried to keep out of his spotlight and the enmity between him and CD.

 

It would be very scummy of him to kill CD with the little feud and tension between the two. I'd figure the third(assuming its three mafia and no third party or is the third party) one is either Martino or Alasdair and leaning towards the latter since he hasn't been very helpful.

 

 

Your sacrifice will not be in vain as we will be able to lynch a mafia.

I would also choose Alasdair before Martino.

 

Townies

CD (most posts)

KevinH (2nd most posts)

Chaoshawk (rolelclaimed doc)

 

Who I strongly think are townies

Kaziocore (wanted mid-day update asap)

Martino (wanted mid-day update asap)

ccabal86 (he changed his vote...if he were mafia then mole should be mafia but the math doesn't add up...so by default = townie).

 

Unknown

Nerau

Alasdair

 

Mafia

Kasabian - fake roleclaimed doc

molestargazer - my D1 suspect and Kasa defended him (see my previous post)

Ok, so a day consists of 10 RL days, right? That means the "day" will end on Sep 12. I suggest we request a battlefield update on Sep 10. Untill then the 3 people who has been the most active in this thread so far keep up with the game-relavant posting, an all other people should keep their posting to a minimum.Then from the battlefield update we can get an idea regarding our active posters' alignment.

 

 

may i ask why?imo i believe activity is a must and controlling someones activity just to determine the mafia is silly, even though a strategy like that could accomphlish somethinga better plan? i would have to think on that one

 

 

I agree with you nerau, activity is a requirement for everyone. not because a person has the higher count of post it make this person instantly a townie, we have to be careful with that because there may be some scummies trying to fool usI agree with making an strategy to hunt the scum.I'd disagree with you,i think killing straight away in day 1 isnt a good idea sometimes because you don't really have to much evidence to accuse someone, although if before the 12 we have cornered a scum , then he have to be lynched.PS: Mmm, how can we be sure he really is a townie with this short-notice

 

 

Nerau shoots down CC suggestion of keeping the top 3 posters isolated.

Kasa agrees with him.

 

Maybe this shows a connection between the two?

So back to scum hunting. There are/were some interesting things going on, so I'm not going to meddle too much at this point. But I will bring forth a new lynch target.

vote Nerau

 

is this because of my actions or just because i end up in one of Kevin's combinations

 

and it seems a new twist has been placed on with the claims of our docs

 

Which is telling the truth?

 

I am in more inclinded to believe Chaos simply for the facts present and knowledge of the town's requirements

 

Nerau shoots down CC suggestion of keeping the top 3 posters isolated.

Kasa agrees with him.

 

Maybe this shows a connection between the two?

 

no i was stating how activity shouldn't have been controlled or limited just for the sake of scum hunting

Great you change your mind, you did it well, you wont regret for that change, believe me.

 

I don't know if the question above was for all, but im stepping in and say, i would go again for the options of kaziocore, CH or Nerau, i would go with lynching either Kazio or CH (botw higher post count from the 3 of them)

 

I also suggest an update before the deadline, what will be gained with that? easy more information that will lead to the real scums ,therefore, there won't be any townie dead.

 

 

I doubt Kasa would finger his scum-mates...so I'm thinking that kaziocore and Nerau are townies.

 

Townies

CD (most posts)

KevinH (2nd most posts)

Chaoshawk (rolelclaimed doc)

 

Who I strongly think are townies

Kaziocore (wanted mid-day update asap)

Martino (wanted mid-day update asap)

ccabal86 (he changed his vote...if he were mafia then mole should be mafia but the math doesn't add up...so by default = townie).

Nerau (kasa fingered him as a possible mafia...so therefore he's probably townie).

 

Mafia

Kasabian - fake roleclaimed doc

molestargazer - my D1 suspect and Kasa defended him (see my previous post)

Alasdair - by process of elimination...he's most likely mafia.

That reasoning sounds pretty good to me.

 

The question is: who do we go for? I'm inclined to go for molestargazer as he has the most posts out of the 3.

That actually isn't a bad idea but it won't matter what order as they do not have the advantage in post percentage anyways. It definitely would make sense to get rid of their most active poster.

The current vote count looks like this (I think)...

 

Kasabian (2) - ChaosHawk, CanucksDynasty

No Lynch (1) - Kasabian

molestargazer (1) - KevinH

Nerau (1) - Martino

 

Not voting (5) - molestargazer, Nerau, Alasdair, Kaziocore, ccabal86

 

 

 

I'm OK with voting for either mole or Kasa.

Vote: molestargazer

 

I think we should go for the most active suspect, just to ensure we gain as much ground as possible.

Ok: what if Kasabian is simply not telling the truth, lol. Why should we belive him?

 

I am 99.9% sure it's truth.

Way, way more than enough to not hunt him for today at least.

EBWOP:

I posted that before I saw recent updates. I'm a fool. Hang on, let me read.

Here mole asks for Kasa to roleclaim as doc (which forces the real doc to roleclaim).

Jesus, please, PLEASE do not make me reveal why I said that.

 

Vote: Kasabian

 

Well, this seems simple enough. If he's scum, it's good. If he's doc, we kill Chaos tomorrow.

EBWOP: The "Jesus, please" statement applies to my 99.9% post as well. Just so you know.

 

Also - quadruple post ho!

Vote: molestargazerI think we should go for the most active suspect, just to ensure we gain as much ground as possible.

 

We probably have a cop...so he should investigate mole (just to be sure).

 

Jesus, please, PLEASE do not make me reveal why I said that.Vote: KasabianWell, this seems simple enough. If he's scum, it's good. If he's doc, we kill Chaos tomorrow.

 

That is my plan.

You can explain yourself the next day...as I am sure you will.

Im writing true my blackberry and i wont quote anything because i can't just got back from work from 6am to 2am i was today, i found whatever you choose is fine, i would't mind sacrifice for the townies when i know for sure he screwed himself by counterclaiming something he's not you fooled everyone but not me.

 

And btw what i told narsis was if the hint i left was ok to be put it without getting mod-killed that is all since this is the first timw im doc i didn't knew how to do it.

 

Ps: i expected that move from everyone but not from you mole come on!