687 replies to this topic

[19thSpecOps]

so you saw him attack when it was dark but not when it was light. it just seems to me that if he had attacked the second night you would have seen it. which makes me think a second person attacked Perse/EM.

Unless the mod left it out by accident? could that be it? considering this is a new game.. Could it be the lights were switched on after it happened?

If not these issues then who else was in the room besides me and em and chaos? because i wasn't paying atten. to any other extra person here. Cept chaos.

[19thSpecOps]

Unless the mod left it out by accident? could that be it? considering this is a new game.. Could it be the lights were switched on after it happened?

If not these issues then who else was in the room besides me and em and chaos? because i wasn't paying atten. to any other extra person here. Cept chaos.

Nvm the lights were off.. they never went on according to what happened, so it appears that I only saw a mage attack him but not him attacking em. because the room was so dark I couldnt see anything else. Unlike by sheer happenstance that i was lucky to see him stab em the first night in the darkness.

[Narsis]

Nvm the lights were off.. they never went on according to what happened, so it appears that I only saw a mage attack him but not him attacking em. because the room was so dark I couldnt see anything else. Unlike by sheer happenstance that i was lucky to see him stab em the first night in the darkness.

i thought Kazio said he switched the lights back on in the main lobby?

[19thSpecOps]

i thought Kazio said he switched the lights back on in the main lobby?

He did but I guess they didnt come on fast enough. Because it was still dark when I saw a mage attack chaos.

[Kaziocore]

We won't really know the whole truth.
It could be that the lights were on when you watched (increases chance but not necessarily 100%)
or it could be that the lights turning on would only benefit us the next day.

[KevinH]

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

[Narsis]

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

but how can you know that?

unless you know something we dont...

[Kaziocore]

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

So you're saying it's better to search or watch than to kill a suspect mafia right now?

[Kaziocore]

The people who are not following CH could do that...

[KevinH]

I don't have special information.
I found a med kit and then used it successfully.
I think the town will have a better chance of winning if we take that approach (most of us, anyway).

[Curufinwe]

I go back to the is there not enough of us to lynch two people tonight?

[ccabal86]

I go back to the is there not enough of us to lynch two people tonight?

That wouldn't benefit the town, as we would surely kill a townie. This way we have a ~50% chance of catching the mafia first, and save the townie

[Curufinwe]

True, but as was stated before, a very logical arguement was placed against the two that could be lynched.

[ccabal86]

I suggest we do this one by one. It will probably take at least 2 nights to lynch even one of them.

[Kasabian]

The people who are not following CH could do that...

Sorry for not being to much around, RL have been hard ,

So, let me get this straight, how much ppl are required to lynch somebody in this case CH?

Because i'll have to agree with kevinh, we should also search or watch for anything else, i.e a med kit, so if we just need x ppl to lynch somebody, the others can do the search, since almost everyone are following CH, i'll do the search hoping to find a med kit.

So, correct me if im wrong with any of the above comments.

[ccabal86]

Actually, we don't really know how much damage an unarmed individual can inflict, but I suspect it has to be 1 or 2 at most

[KevinH]

I go back to the is there not enough of us to lynch two people tonight?

I suggest we do this one by one. It will probably take at least 2 nights to lynch even one of them.

Absolutely one by one.
Assuming one townie and one scum, killing both at once would guarantee a townie death.
Killing one by one gives a 50% chance that the scum would be killed first and a townie death is avoided.

[Curufinwe]

Ok then, just throwing the idea out there.

[Kaziocore]

Actually, we don't really know how much damage an unarmed individual can inflict, but I suspect it has to be 1 or 2 at most

CH has 7 hp left.
I am assuming that there's a vig following him so that leaves 4 hp left...

[19thSpecOps]

CH has 7 hp left.
I am assuming that there's a vig following him so that leaves 4 hp left...

and theres three people in the lobby plus me right? or?