687 replies to this topic

[Martino]

is the searching done during the night?

Yes, just like search room, you can search dead player.

[Electric Mango]

The 3 Mafia members are: Chaoshawk, Theophilos, and Narsis.

As we all know two of us were attacked Day 1, limiting the number of suspects to the 4 other persons who were also in the room when we were attacked, Those people are Chaoshawk, 19theSpecOps, Theophilos, and AKCPLUTO.

Last night a bunch of us ganged up to kill Chaoshawk and were attacked by mafia who dropped a chandelier causing damage to everyone in the room save 1. Among the injured were 2 of the suspected 4 from night 1, leaving Theopholis as the only uninjured suspect and most likely mafia. Narsis is the 3rd mafia. This one is a no brainer. Mafia start the game with a more intimate knowledge of items and it's not a long leap of imagination to figure Narsis is the one who dropped the chandelier on everyone in the room.



Day 1

Entrance: Kaziocore, Nerau, Narsis

Main Lobby: Chaoshawk, Persephone, 19theSpecOps

Kitchen: Curufinwe, Theophilos, AKCPLUTO

Bed Room: ccabal86, KevinH, Kasabian

[Electric Mango]

Also last night I searched the kitchen but did not find anything although I was given the impression that I overlooked something. I also noticed Nerau looking around the room as well.

If anyone has med packs they should be used on the bleeding victims 1st as they will continue to lose life if left untreated. I don't know if I would use one on Kevin or not. Martino called him good as dead and I don't know if he could be saved or not.

The room in which we should do the next kill should be the lobby again. I feel that if we target another suspect in another room than we will leave ourselves open to another mass attack. My thought is that the lobby trap has already been used and would be the safest place to target the next scum.

[19thSpecOps]

So your saying, what I think your saying is to attack narsis? Just because the chandelier didnt hurt him? Eh. I need more proof but im not gonna do anything considering im already searching chaos body to confirm if he really was mafia or not... although evidence suggest that he is. Also Im guessing ya picked theo because he hasnt talked much or?

[Kaziocore]

Map position:
Entrance(Dark): Kaziocore,

Main Lobby(Light): Chaoshawk(Curufinwe,Ccabal86(KevinH),AKCPLUTO,19theSpecOps), Narsis

Kitchen(Dark): Nerau, Electric Mango

Bed Room(Dark): Kasabian, Theophilos

I searched again in the entrance and found nothing
but I was told that there's still something here.

So what's the next plan of action?
If what you're planning EM is to lynch Narsis next,
someone (maybe two as a scum could volunteer) has to search CH's body.

[Kaziocore]

Well there are three possibilities...
(1) CH set off the trap before getting killed
(2) Someone other than CH set off the trap from the main lobby
(3) The trap was set off from another room

What I'm saying is that it may not seem to be so obvious
that Narsis could be the one who set off the trap.

[19thSpecOps]

I searched again in the entrance and found nothing
but I was told that there's still something here.

So what's the next plan of action?
If what you're planning EM is to lynch Narsis next,
someone (maybe two as a scum could volunteer) has to search CH's body.

Im already searching his body. Whilst I am also bleeding in the process.

[Electric Mango]

Also Im guessing ya picked theo because he hasnt talked much?

Day 1

Entrance: Kaziocore, Nerau, Narsis

Main Lobby: Chaoshawk, Persephone, 19theSpecOps

Kitchen: Curufinwe, Theophilos, AKCPLUTO

Bed Room: ccabal86, KevinH, Kasabian


I picked Theo because Curufinwe was attacked N1. Only Theo or AKC could have done it. AKC was injured by the chandelier. I deduced that AKC was not scum because of that leaving Theo as the mafia.


Narsis has to be the other mafia because he was the only one not injured meaning he must have been the one who cut the rope holding the chandelier up. Everyone else was injured so who else could it have been?

[Curufinwe]

Pretty much the same story as the rest, went to attack CH, got hit by that stupid chandelier

learnt that CH pushed a button which caused the chandelier to fall, a rich wealthy guy clubbed KevinH, and I am bleeding, stupid glass shard

From the fact that he pushed the button, it seems that he was indeed scum. Don't know if anyone wants to confirm this at all?
Who is our rich wealthy guy

[ccabal86]

Allright, time for me to reveal some info i got this night.

Narsis did NOT drop the chandalier, but he IS mafia. I saw him hit KevinH over the head with a baseball bat. If he didn't drop the chandalier, someone else must have. The only question that remains is whether the chandalier can be remotely triggered from an other room.

Our next lynch candidate however, HAS to be Narsis.

[Curufinwe]

CH dropped the chandelier, as said above.

[Narsis]

Allright, time for me to reveal some info i got this night.

Narsis did NOT drop the chandalier, but he IS mafia. I saw him hit KevinH over the head with a baseball bat. If he didn't drop the chandalier, someone else must have. The only question that remains is whether the chandalier can be remotely triggered from an other room.

Our next lynch candidate however, HAS to be Narsis.

assuming i did attack Kevin...how could you have seen that unless you didnt attack CH. and why wouldn't you attack CH? and if you did attack CH...then how could you have seen me hypothetically attack Kevin?

some other interesting points:

I was one of three people who attacked chaoshawk.

how could you know how many people attack CH?

The 3 Mafia members are: Chaoshawk, Theophilos, and Narsis.

As we all know two of us were attacked Day 1, limiting the number of suspects to the 4 other persons who were also in the room when we were attacked, Those people are Chaoshawk, 19theSpecOps, Theophilos, and AKCPLUTO.

Last night a bunch of us ganged up to kill Chaoshawk and were attacked by mafia who dropped a chandelier causing damage to everyone in the room save 1. Among the injured were 2 of the suspected 4 from night 1, leaving Theopholis as the only uninjured suspect and most likely mafia. Narsis is the 3rd mafia. This one is a no brainer. Mafia start the game with a more intimate knowledge of items and it's not a long leap of imagination to figure Narsis is the one who dropped the chandelier on everyone in the room.



Day 1

Entrance: Kaziocore, Nerau, Narsis

Main Lobby: Chaoshawk, Persephone, 19theSpecOps

Kitchen: Curufinwe, Theophilos, AKCPLUTO

Bed Room: ccabal86, KevinH, Kasabian

or CH dropped it because he figured he was going to die anyway?


another thing to consider: Curu was attacked night 1, however you were also attacked night 1 and night 2. AKC, CH, SpecOps are the only three people to have been in two of the rooms on both nights where someone attacked someone else. additionally, they were all three in the room when the chandelier dropped.

also:

CH dropped the chandelier, as said above.

[ccabal86]

assuming i did attack Kevin...how could you have seen that unless you didnt attack CH. and why wouldn't you attack CH? and if you did attack CH...then how could you have seen me hypothetically attack Kevin?

I'll let Martino answer this.

MOD:Is it possible to witness an other player's action while performing an action of your own (an action that is not "Watch X")

Also, I saw at least 2 other players besides me (one dressed as a zebra and a cop) charge CH.

[Electric Mango]

Narsis is lying is my 1st impression.

[Electric Mango]

Narsis is lying is my 1st impression.

[Kaziocore]

Well from here...

- Attack Y: Attack player Y. You can either use your bare hands to attack or use a weapon you have found/were given at the beginning of the game. Attacking has a high chance of being detected by other players.

this makes me think that people inside the room can detect if someone was attacked (note that the light is also turned on)
but from the posts in this game, you only get info of the costume of the attacker

[Narsis]

Well from here...



this makes me think that people inside the room can detect if someone was attacked (note that the light is also turned on)
but from the posts in this game, you only get info of the costume of the attacker

which is exactly why i'm wondering how ccabal could have hypothetically seen me.

@EM: lying about what EM?

[19thSpecOps]

Interesting turn of events. Tis true about theo. Considering ack was hurt last night. As for narsis something is fishy...but im searching the body of ch tonight for the record.

[Martino]

I'll let Martino answer this.

MOD:Is it possible to witness an other player's action while performing an action of your own (an action that is not "Watch X")

Also, I saw at least 2 other players besides me (one dressed as a zebra and a cop) charge CH.

- Watch Y: Watch player Y. This greatly increases the chance that you will observe their night action.


So yeah, you can detect actions while performing your own actions, but the chances are not nearly as good as when you are watching someone.

[ccabal86]

Well from here...



this makes me think that people inside the room can detect if someone was attacked (note that the light is also turned on)
but from the posts in this game, you only get info of the costume of the attacker

Which is why I was very pleasently surprized that I saw actual player names this time.