687 replies to this topic

[Theophilos]

Almost forgot >_<

At this point Narsis probably can't out his partner for a simple reason. His scum partner is dead, ie Chaos was killed by townies. Would Narsis now to confirm his partner, he'd hang him self with it, thus the reluctance, thus the guilt.

[ccabal86]

About the N1 actions by my self and AKC. The game started with us setting the trap for scum (which makes it certain that Mafia didn't know about it imo. Which made imo Curu at least a bit suspicious, given we had no good leads one way or the other. Having considered the options with AKC, we decided to search and attack. Me being the attacker as I started the game with a weapon as every proper vigilante would.

How would a trap like that lure mafia more than your average townie? It was basically a box with a button on it....

He isn't he is claiming a role he can't possibly have.

So you're saying that a knife wasn't part of the trap you've set and thus Curu couldn't have gotten it from there?

[Narsis]

How would a trap like that lure mafia more than your average townie? It was basically a box with a button on it....




So you're saying that a knife wasn't part of the trap you've set and thus Curu couldn't have gotten it from there?

i agree. the box is something that if the vigs placed it works against their wincon. it has a much higher chance of hurting a townie then hurting mafia as mafia are more likely to be cautious. however if scum placed it then of course it would work towards their wincon as they need to kill everyone that isn't mafia.

[AKCPLUTO]

Narsis, let's focus on the key issue. If you are vig, who is your partner?

[Theophilos]

How would a trap like that lure mafia more than your average townie? It was basically a box with a button on it....

So you're saying that a knife wasn't part of the trap you've set and thus Curu couldn't have gotten it from there?

The box was preset by the Mod, with the vigilantes being the ones that made it to aid them, thus having the advance notice of it. As far as it's attracting goes ... at that point anyone could have pushed the button save for the vigilantes since we knew in advance what was in it. Why such a random set up? That's a question that only our Mod can answer.

No I'm saying Narsis is claiming a role he can't possibly have, since there are only two vigilantes, AKC and I.

[ccabal86]

I almost forgot: We haven't discussed a key issue. Why did you whack KevinH?

You said, as a vig, you were given info indicating that he was scum. What was this info?

[AKCPLUTO]

CC, you're talking to Narsis, right?

Wow, we're probably driving Narsis batty at this point! LOL!

[ccabal86]

Yeah, sorry I should have clarified. Yes, I am asking Narsis

[19thSpecOps]

Ah well scum could post here doing something but in reality they are doing something else I guess thats why they are worried but then again who is coming to narsis defense... no one. But then again it could be convient that hes not having anyone defend him because of the others but then the point of him not getting hurt last night is odd and strange. So as far as lynching him goes, Ill confirm tonight with choas while yall go after narsis, frankly i have no problem considering edvidence suggests that hes mafia or scum. Either way we shall find out tonight right?

[Theophilos]

i agree. the box is something that if the vigs placed it works against their wincon. it has a much higher chance of hurting a townie then hurting mafia as mafia are more likely to be cautious. however if scum placed it then of course it would work towards their wincon as they need to kill everyone that isn't mafia.

Not really, as you are neglecting the fact that the box was preset and we as vigilantes were only told we set it up and what it contains.

And your' theory doesn't work naturally, as the knife is re-usable and can well be used by a townie. The chances of scum pressing it were just as high, albeit for the fact that scum would have likely pushed the button at night. Why Curu pushed the button so recklessly, is for him alone to answer

[AKCPLUTO]

Curiosity killed the cat!

[Narsis]

Narsis, let's focus on the key issue. If you are vig, who is your partner?

scum wanting to out another vig eh?

[19thSpecOps]

Curiosity killed the cat!

But Satisfaction brought it back!!

[Curufinwe]

Curu is Curu, I pushed the button because we were all to busy umming and ahhing about it.
I am a man of action...

[Narsis]

I almost forgot: We haven't discussed a key issue. Why did you whack KevinH?

You said, as a vig, you were given info indicating that he was scum. What was this info?

combination of the items the vigs started with plus wanting to generate some discussion/reactions.

[ccabal86]

Ok, then Theo and AKC, but what was the logic behind going after Curu on night 1? If I was in your stead, I would have surely waited a night before hurting someone, after all you were only guessing at that time too.

[19thSpecOps]

Curu is Curu, I pushed the button because we were all to busy umming and ahhing about it.
I am a man of action...

I was gonna push the button too xD. lol but anyway ya got a knife from it obviously.

[Narsis]

Ok, then Theo and AKC, but what was the logic behind going after Curu on night 1? If I was in your stead, I would have surely waited a night before hurting someone, after all you were only guessing at that time too.

this. especially when the town so kindly asked the vigs not to attack night 1 to avoid muddying up the results.

[19thSpecOps]

this. especially when the town so kindly asked the vigs not to attack night 1 to avoid muddying up the results.

Who asked for this? on what page?

[Narsis]

Ah well scum could post here doing something but in reality they are doing something else I guess thats why they are worried but then again who is coming to narsis defense... no one. But then again it could be convient that hes not having anyone defend him because of the others but then the point of him not getting hurt last night is odd and strange. So as far as lynching him goes, Ill confirm tonight with choas while yall go after narsis, frankly i have no problem considering edvidence suggests that hes mafia or scum. Either way we shall find out tonight right?

to the best of my knowledge searching a body only reveals the items they had not their alignment. hence why i'm trying so hard to point to AKC/Theo being scum. if i die, you will indeed find a bat in my possession...but that doesnt mean i'm mafia. after all Theo who is claiming to be a vig also has a bat...