761 replies to this topic

[CanucksDynasty]

Unvote.
Vote: Herodez

Now that's a prod.

Hey hey now...
It's not D2 and you don't have 5 votes on you.


VOTE COUNT
KevinH (3): Narsis, CanucksDynasty, Herodez
ccabal86 (2): Nerau, Electric Mango
Herodez (2): d3mon, KevinH
d3mon (1): ccabal86
Electric Mango (1): TerrorChrist
TerrorChrist (1): CaoCao

No Lynch (0):

Not Voting (1): Preston

With 11 Alive, 6 is needed to lynch.

Edited by molestargazer, 09 April 2011 - 10:53 AM.

[d3mon]

KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1..

[Emmanuel]

KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1..

[Electric Mango]

I'd rather replace an inactive vs voting them off. I remember there being some people on the waiting list.

[Preston]

CD took care of the prod, so at minimum Herodez has a day or two to respond.

I'd rather replace an inactive vs voting them off. I remember there being some people on the waiting list.

I dont see anyone on the waiting list on the front page; it WOULD be shown there, wouldnt it?

d3mon thew out the "KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1!", but that actually made me suspect d3mon more for the accusation in that statement. By the votes, KevinH was the only one even considering no-lynch... and while deviations from norms can be significant, right now KevinH has the most votes - if people are arguing to lynch SOMEONE, I'm guessing he doesnt want to be the one. Regarding the initial bandwagon on KevinH, I'd thought he had gotten up to 5 votes during the initial bandwagon but reading back it only looks like he hit 4 - I still think at least one of those had to have been scum, but have no specific suspicion yet.

Depending on how/when/if Herodez returns, I may end up voting d3mon.

-Preston

[CanucksDynasty]

CD took care of the prod, so at minimum Herodez has a day or two to respond.


I dont see anyone on the waiting list on the front page; it WOULD be shown there, wouldnt it?

d3mon thew out the "KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1!", but that actually made me suspect d3mon more for the accusation in that statement. By the votes, KevinH was the only one even considering no-lynch... and while deviations from norms can be significant, right now KevinH has the most votes - if people are arguing to lynch SOMEONE, I'm guessing he doesnt want to be the one. Regarding the initial bandwagon on KevinH, I'd thought he had gotten up to 5 votes during the initial bandwagon but reading back it only looks like he hit 4 - I still think at least one of those had to have been scum, but have no specific suspicion yet.

Depending on how/when/if Herodez returns, I may end up voting d3mon.

-Preston

Kaziocore and AKCPLUTO has posted for replacement in the sign-up thread.

[Preston]

Kaziocore and AKCPLUTO has posted for replacement in the sign-up thread.

In that case replacement IS possible then - that changes the picture, there's less reason to vote for herodez now. I had been thinking that there were no replacements available this game, and if herodez got modkilled it would be giving scum a free advantage - by lynching someone already inactive we'd avoid the double jeopardy.

I am still inclined to think KevinH town due to his being bandwagoned that early, hence his vote would have a greater chance of not being cast as anti-town... but now I'm leaning more towards lynching d3mon today.

We're almost putting too much thought into this day 1 lynch, but it's giving us a lot of useful information on who is attacking whom.

And I'm still waiting to hear Narsis' scenario information for his three picks - where is he?

-Preston

[Nerau]

Its usually not this excitng on D1

I would prefer to inactives down first simply b/c it increase activity and if a scum kill if luck but more about participation

also i moved to early on my idea

though i want to try it later i believe it is to early right now for me to tell in the middle of all the randomize

[Electric Mango]

I'm almost sure what Narsis will say but I want to hear it from him Ist.

[Electric Mango]

I still don't have any scum vibes from anyone yet although if I had to vote, I would vote for the 3 most vanilla acting people, whoever they are. That is why I tend to believe Kevin, demon, and TC are townies. They have been the 3 most "provacitive" players so far. It's really hard to tell who's who on day 1 though. I'm better in the later stages and can't figure it all out on D1 like Narsis.

[TerrorChrist]

CD took care of the prod, so at minimum Herodez has a day or two to respond.


I dont see anyone on the waiting list on the front page; it WOULD be shown there, wouldnt it?

There were 2 or 3 replacements in the signup thread

d3mon thew out the "KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1!", but that actually made me suspect d3mon more for the accusation in that statement.
By the votes, KevinH was the only one even considering no-lynch... and while deviations from norms can be significant, right now KevinH has the most votes - if people are arguing to lynch SOMEONE, I'm guessing he doesnt want to be the one. Regarding the initial bandwagon on KevinH, I'd thought he had gotten up to 5 votes during the initial bandwagon but reading back it only looks like he hit 4 - I still think at least one of those had to have been scum, but have no specific suspicion yet.

Depending on how/when/if Herodez returns, I may end up voting d3mon.

-Preston

I agree. D3mon is based on his earlier bandwagoning and throwing around of accusations also my suspect. My suspicion of him has now grown to a point where, if my vote would tip the balance, I would shift my vote to him. However, EM continues to spout accussations to me based on...nothing...so for now, my vote remains.

[KevinH]

Unvote.

If nobody joins me in a no-lynch vote, does it really matter if I vote no-lynch or not?

I'd rather have a replacement player than a lynch.

[KevinH]

If a tree falls in a forest and there is nobody there to hear, does it make a noise?

If I place the only vote and nobody follows, did I really vote?

[ccabal86]

The history books shall remember your vote!

Anyway, what's up with Narsis?

[Electric Mango]

You can't mess with tradition though. Think of the children Kevin!

Seriously though, you should still vote just to let your official stance be clear.

[Narsis]

The history books shall remember your vote!

Anyway, what's up with Narsis?

i had probably the worst headache in the history of headaches yesterday. here's hoping it doesn't come back today and i'll actually be able to get my thoughts down in a communicative manner.

[ccabal86]

Ouch that sucks Hope you feel better now!

[d3mon]

CD took care of the prod, so at minimum Herodez has a day or two to respond. I dont see anyone on the waiting list on the front page; it WOULD be shown there, wouldnt it?d3mon thew out the "KevinH deciding to lynch someone on D1!", but that actually made me suspect d3mon more for the accusation in that statement. By the votes, KevinH was the only one even considering no-lynch... and while deviations from norms can be significant, right now KevinH has the most votes - if people are arguing to lynch SOMEONE, I'm guessing he doesnt want to be the one. Regarding the initial bandwagon on KevinH, I'd thought he had gotten up to 5 votes during the initial bandwagon but reading back it only looks like he hit 4 - I still think at least one of those had to have been scum, but have no specific suspicion yet. Depending on how/when/if Herodez returns, I may end up voting d3mon. -Preston

It seems that I am in a tight spot. No matter what I say, I am sure it can be taken as a proof that I am Mafia.
Still, I would like to state that I never joined the bandwagon against KevinH.

There were 2 or 3 replacements in the signup threadI agree. D3mon is based on his earlier bandwagoning and throwing around of accusations also my suspect. My suspicion of him has now grown to a point where, if my vote would tip the balance, I would shift my vote to him. However, EM continues to spout accussations to me based on...nothing...so for now, my vote remains.

TC, I have not bandwagoned. So far, I have only voted for Herodez and my only serious accusation has been against you. Voting KevinH would have been bandwagoning and I didn't do that because a quick lynch never benefits the town.

All,

I would like to add that my role PM indicates that I am character from the previous round. Also, as a part of OP, mole indicated that another character from last round (Grandfather Tony) is in this round.
All this made me think that it is improabable (not impossible) that mole would have only two similar roles/characters. TC's indication that he was cleaning/mopping fueled my paranoia and made me suspicious that perhaps more than one mafia member has come back from the dead. Moreover, TC seems to be happy to lay low or join a bandwagon (he accused me after most others had stated their opinion about me).

Unvote
Vote:TerrorChrist

[TerrorChrist]

my only serious accusation has been against you.

An unfounded accusation, for that.

I would like to add that my role PM indicates that I am character from the previous round. Also, as a part of OP, mole indicated that another character from last round (Grandfather Tony) is in this round.
All this made me think that it is improabable (not impossible) that mole would have only two similar roles/characters. TC's indication that he was cleaning/mopping fueled my paranoia and made me suspicious that perhaps more than one mafia member has come back from the dead. Moreover, TC seems to be happy to lay low or join a bandwagon (he accused me after most others had stated their opinion about me).

Wrong. I already hinted at you before others, but at that time, I was at work, so couldn't scroll back to find the name belonging with the posts I was thinking about.

Unvote
Vote:TerrorChrist

Now this is getting hilarious

[d3mon]

TC, lets go through your posts that were made after I made the accusation and weren't gameplay related questions

I got to say, the argument by D3mon that this is part two, and hence it would be likely that roles are (partially) similar sounds plausible.Too bad I didn't read part 1 :sAnyhow, my list of suspects is rising.

^ I don't see any accusations here.

I suspect all those who've been arguing and accusing others of being scum, without any clear reasoning behind it, are scum. Electric_Mango is one of them. The other, I would have to scroll back for, but being at work, I might not make it unnoticed

^You accused EM, one of my posts accusing you being scum is right above this post. So I doubt if you were thinking about me. Scrolling problem.. hm..

*points at page 2*

again.. laying low