303 replies to this topic

[Electric Mango]

Kevin, I let my wife read that and she thinks you're hilarious. Please keep more like these coming, I'm thinking about one day composing your all time greatest hits. I'm almost thinking about changing my vote to your crony just to keep you around for more posts like these. I'm not very good at poems as you can tell by my first attempt at a haiku since grade school. That being said, I would like to put forth one more attempt of poetic verse. After all, we most likely be lynching Kevin today and I thought it would be nice if we honored him with poetry.

Roses are red
Violets are blue
I suck at poems
Let's lynch Kevin

[KevinH]

The Case Against Electric Mango (and Kaziocore)

Exhibit 1 - The Day 1 Vote

No Lynch - KevinH, Reign of Terror, Imran Ehsan, d3mon
Kevin H - ccabal86
Sir Crocodile - Kaziocore
Imran Ehsan - BeeBs, SirCrocodile, KF2001
d3mon - EM

Not Voting - ABigDeer

Optimal townie strategy was not to lynch. Kaziocore and Electric Mango voted otherwise.

Exhibit 2 - The Day 2 Order of Voting

KF2001, vanilla townie, was lynched. Votes in order: ccabal86, Electric Mango, Reign of Terror, Kaziocore, Imran Ehsan, KevinH

The town had to pick somebody to lynch, but votes #2 and #4 came from Electric Mango and Kaziocore, assuring specifically that another townie was killed.

Exhibit 3 - Outing the Cop

tl;dr
cop role claims and town kicks ass

This plan got the cop killed and has no confirmed townies for the rest of us to trust. Earlier, I thought the masons might be telling the truth and that 2 of the other 3 players might be the scum. However, now that I have 2 votes on me and no others have joined the bandwagon, I suspect that the votes on me are from the two remaining scum.

Granted, the scum might possibly be SirCrocodile and another that doesn't want to appear too eager to lynch me, but I think there is a stronger case that the masons are not whom they claim to be.

[Electric Mango]

Day 1: I voted for a probable scum.
Day 2: I voted for the same person you hammer voted.
Day 3: RoT role claims along with Kaziocore and me and it leads to the lynch of a scum.

Meanwhile, you have been playing against your historical playing style and being an all around suspicious character. This whole game you talked about following the cop and when the cop role claims you want to vote no lynch. If we would have listened to you, the odds would now be shifted further in the mafia's favor and our cop would still be dead. Admit it Kevin, admit that you are scum, admit it and the truth shall set you free.

[KevinH]

Day 1: I didn't vote for a townie and followed the best course of action.
Day 2: I agreed with the majority that someone had to be lynched and added my vote only after the candidate was chosen (influenced by our "Masons").
Day 3: Given what we knew for sure at the time, a no lynch was the best course of action.

Given what we know now, lynching me is the worst course of action. If I get lynched and another townie is night-killed, it will be 2-2 and the scum will win.

If the masons truly are masons, they should not be trying to lynch a townie like me. It's all a "he said, she said" game at his point'; I don't believe what they said.

[Kaziocore]

Optimal townie strategy was not to lynch. Kaziocore and Electric Mango voted otherwise.[/indent]

This is just your opinion and your playing style and probably WIFOM.

[Kaziocore]

Imagine if you would ...

ACT II

The Scene: The Scum Lair
The Time: The latest last night
The Characters: Kaziocore (K) and Electric Mango (EM)

EM: This is sweet! They believed the mason story and the cop actually role-claimed.
K: Too bad he had already fingered BeeBs, but our lynch of a scum lends credibility to our townie claim.
EM: After we night-kill the cop, there will be six players left. We only need one townie to join us against one of the others.
K: Yup, a half-majority at deadline will do it.
EM: Let's go after KevinH. It will be easier to turn one of the others against him than the other way around.
K: Agreed. I'll send in the night-kill...

(fade to black)

Everything is possible but you have to ask yourself
whether this is very plausible or probable to happen.

For example, I could also invent possible scenarios
where Imran Ehsan is scum with his partner SirCrocodile
who is conveniently inactive but it's less plausible than
you and d3mon being scum as you actively defended
BeeBs and tried to lynch the cop.

Your scenario would have been a little bit plausible
if BeeBs, EM, and me are in danger of getting lynched
but as you can see, SirCrocodile was more likely to
be a target without our intervention.

[d3mon]

While, I think that the writing is on the wall that I am going to be the next one to be lynched, I do agree with EM and Kazio that KevinH has not been acting like his usual self.. for what little this might be worth

Vote:KevinH

Also, imho SirCroc is the last scum, so I am hopeful that town will win despite lynching me..

[KevinH]

I'm getting that feeling that I'm going to have to say "well played" to the EM and the scum

Well played.

[Imran Ehsan]

I am not entirely convinced but with d3mon's vote it does not matter any longer.

Vote: KevinH

[Nerau]

as that is majority

KevinH a mafia rolelblocker has been lynched

SC has been mod killed

Game is over

Town wins

[Imran Ehsan]

excellent game everyone. So was there a 3rd mafia? was it SirCroc? and whats a roleblocker?

[KF2001]

I think a roleblocker is someone who can block player actions.

Ex. Roleblocker targets cop. Cop action does nothing.

Correct me if I'm wrong.

[reign of terror]

Yay, my roleclaim gamble payed off. One of the first games I've played that the town won.

[d3mon]

Well played EM, Kazio and RoT.. I would have tagged along you guys on day 3 but a voice inside me kept saying that EM is scum and is trying something crazy (RoT's guess didn't help )

Tough luck KevinH, it must have been tough playing with only two active scum...

[KevinH]

I try to play the same regardless.

Everything I said could have been true.

Nevertheless, it was fun. My wife was entertained as much as EM's.

[KevinH]

And yes, SirCrocodile was the third scum. It's hard to say whether his inactivity lost it for the scum side. If the other townies were going to go along with EM's plan, it was was a losing battle.

[ccabal86]

Yay, my death was avenged! Well played town

What was SirCroc's role?

[Electric Mango]

That was a fun game everyone, you can definitely count me in for the next game as well. The mafia were up against pretty tough odds to start considering we had a cop, doc, and 2 masons. The town almost got a lucky break in the beginning when we were so close to lynching SC.

[Kaziocore]

We won hahahah

[Imran Ehsan]

And yes, SirCrocodile was the third scum. It's hard to say whether his inactivity lost it for the scum side. If the other townies were going to go along with EM's plan, it was was a losing battle.

HA! I knew it. Thats why when I voted him for lynching on Day 1 all hell broke loose. Beebs started arguing about why I am mafia and KevinH went, "no, no, no lynch!"