370 replies to this topic

[Kaziocore]

VOTE COUNT
No Lynch (9): d3mon, ZincoX, Rafay, Theophilos, Imran Ehsan, Electric Mango, ABigDeer, KevinH, KF2001

Not Voting (4): BeeBs, ccabal86, Nerau, reign of terror

With 13 Alive, 7 is needed to lynch.

The people of Kaardoli decided not to lynch anyone

"This is hopeless." They all mutter.
They couldn't find the king's killer

IT IS NOW NIGHT ONE.
NIGHT ACTIONS TO ME BY TUESDAY.

[Kaziocore]

The sun rises, and one by one
we see the people of Kaardoli go
out of their homes...

Farmer: No! My dear Belle. Who the hell would do such a thing?!

We see the old man had angry tears in his eyes

Farmer: First the king, now my beautiful cow. MONSTERS!

With the exception of Kaardoli's prize-winning cow,
the rest of the people seem to be alive and well to
continue their search for justice for the king.

It is now DAY 2
Deadline: Wednesday, 4th of April

Votes needed to lynch: 7

[ccabal86]

Well, this is most interesting. It seems no one was killed.

[BeeBs]

At least we can say for certain something is different about the scum in this game. However, whether it be the players or the roles we can't be certain.

[Kaziocore]

http://www.iron-command.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=34050

If KF2001 will not come back, we will need to find a replacement

[KevinH]

Holy cow!
What now?

Check Dow
Then bow

Not sow
Ask how

[Electric Mango]

It seems my hypothesis now carries a little more validity considering no one was night killed.

Here's what I believe we are up against.

Werewolf

He can turn other town folk into werewolves and when the werewolves equal or outnumber the townies, the original werewolf and all who were turned will win.

I'm guessing if we lynch the head werewolf, we win.

I would also assume that we will have some power roles at our disposal. Probably something along the lines of a doc and a cop, but with their roles tweaked for this game.

[BeeBs]

It seems my hypothesis now carries a little more validity considering no one was night killed.

Here's what I believe we are up against.

Werewolf

He can turn other town folk into werewolves and when the werewolves equal or outnumber the townies, the original werewolf and all who were turned will win.

I'm guessing if we lynch the head werewolf, we win.

I would also assume that we will have some power roles at our disposal. Probably something along the lines of a doc and a cop, but with their roles tweaked for this game.

Duh. I mean coooooooome on. This is just stupid. Of course this is what we're up against. Thanks for nothing. This post doesn't give us anything. No call to action, no solution, no nothing. If you're going to post you might as well actually post something worthwhile.

At this point I'll probably just vote for Kevin H. I'm getting tired of his stupid a$$ poems.

[Imran Ehsan]

At least we can say for certain something is different about the scum in this game. However, whether it be the players or the roles we can't be certain.

Duh. I mean coooooooome on. This is just stupid. Of course this is what we're up against.

Thats quite a turnaround from uncertain to being absolutely sure. For all I know it could have been a roleblocker or a doc who got lucky and thwarted the scum. How are you so certain that this is a werewolf?

[ccabal86]

Thats quite a turnaround from uncertain to being absolutely sure. For all I know it could have been a roleblocker or a doc who got lucky and thwarted the scum. How are you so certain that this is a werewolf?

I will have to echo this question. I still don't find the werewolf option very feasible - it's just too imbalanced, no matter how I look at it. Finding the "original" werewolf is also no simple task, especially without nightkills to give the town hints.

[BeeBs]

Thats quite a turnaround from uncertain to being absolutely sure. For all I know it could have been a roleblocker or a doc who got lucky and thwarted the scum. How are you so certain that this is a werewolf?

I will have to echo this question. I still don't find the werewolf option very feasible - it's just too imbalanced, no matter how I look at it. Finding the "original" werewolf is also no simple task, especially without nightkills to give the town hints.

Well excuse me, go ahead with your asinine over analyzation of a few of my words. You're reaching and you know it.

Look, no night kill. That means either are scum are dumb or they have some other power they are running with. Maybe they don't lose when we kill the original vampire/warewolf/monster, but they just can no longer convert and only communicate in the night phase.

Judging by the flavor of his game (and the effort put in by the mod to make it that way) I think it is an obvious assumption we are dealing with something different here. You'd be stupid not to agree. Maybe they can NK, but only on a limited basis. The details aren't certain, but I think the general idea of conversion is plain to see.

[KevinH]

Must poem or haiku
(Is word poem one syllable?)
Otherwise I die

[ABigDeer]

I'm still going to say that there is more than one scum.

[Electric Mango]

Beebs needs to calm down.

[ccabal86]

Must poem or haiku
(Is word poem one syllable?)
Otherwise I die

Really? That is interesting, and certainly a first for mafia games. Does this mean you're some sort of poet laureate?

I'm still going to say that there is more than one scum.

This. If we still don't get a night kill tonight, I'm going to find the werewolf scenario more beliaveable.

Beebs needs to calm down.

And this.

[KevinH]

poet, minstrel, bard
making things rhyme is not hard
find scum on the card

[Rafay]

Thats it no more poems/Hes trying to throw us off his back with poetry indicating he is Mafia scum.

Lynch: KevinH

[Theophilos]

Gentlemen this is the first and the last warning, if you can not (for whatever reason) show a minimum of respect for our fellow players, then you will be appropriately sanctioned.

Theophilos of Mantineia m.p.
Council Member, Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs


I have to admit, we've made little progress towards identifying possible mafia scum. I'd like to point out that all options seem to be open, including the werewolf (or a variation) one. The fact is that it is very likely that if the game was adapted to allow for a werewolf, than it's "victory conditions" and/or paths to a townie victory might just as well have been adapted to compensate for the supposed edge of the werewolf or whatever we are facing.

Not a fan of lynching Kevin either, seems to me his posts keep it interesting

[d3mon]

I hate to say it but I agree with Theo, we have made very little progress towards identifying the scum or understanding the game..

I might be grasping at straws here, but knowing Kazio's dislike towards "no lynch", it is very probable that in a game designed by him, he would make no lynch the worst possible option for the town..

Now, EM's guess of the game mechanics (werewolf!!), would support this presumption and thus I believe that he is probably right (or darn close)..

With all that said, I find BeeBs' reaction to EM's guess as something the head werewolf would say.. so here it goes

Vote: BeeBs

@KevinH

Keep em coming..

[ZincoX]

Maybe a doctor protected the person that the mafia tried to kill. I think it's possible that BeeBs is scum, but I am not sure, so I...
Vote: No lynch