446 replies to this topic

[Commander Shepard]

No one truly knows if they're going to lynched or not when when they're voted upon with my vote.

I would pile on the pressure by helping to send them to L-1, if everyone else doesn't intend to no lynch then I wouldn't bother holding my vote back from lynching someone.

[KevinH]

It's interesting to see who votes whom, but the reality is that nobody knows nothing' (except scum)

[Kaziocore]

Votecount 1.02

Alternate_Tree (1) - Euclid of Alexandria
Chaplain of death (1) - Nerau
Commander Shepard (0) -
d3mon (0) -
DarkIceDragon (1) - Commander Shepard
Euclid of Alexandria (1) - Lyner
Imran Ehsan (1) - Alternate_Tree
iSocialism (1) - killgor
KevinH (2) - Imran Ehsan, iSocialism
killgor (0) -
Lyner (1) - Chaplain of death
Nerau (1) - d3mon
reign of terror (1) - KevinH

Not Voting (2) - DarkIceDragon, reign of terror

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
KevinH is the current wagon leader at L-5
Deadline is Tuesday, June 18th, 2013 @ 03:06 EDT

I'm still looking for reign of terror's replacement. Please message your friends to join

[KevinH]

1-Shot Cop
2-Shot Vigilante
Jailkeeper
Tracker
Innocent Child

 

We've got 3 of these roles.  The cop, jailkeeper, and tracker will get information in the night.  It would be bad to force them to roleclaim early.

 

Which of the poisons did the scum pick?

[Imran Ehsan]

 

1-Shot Cop
2-Shot Vigilante
Jailkeeper
Tracker
Innocent Child

 

We've got 3 of these roles.  The cop, jailkeeper, and tracker will get information in the night.  It would be bad to force them to roleclaim early.

 

Which of the poisons did the scum pick?

 

 

I have been wondering the same thing. My best guess will be they picked Innocent child, Vigilante and 1-shot cop. Why?

 

innocent child - no power really and with 10 townies its unlikely the ic will be picked to lynch and even then just missing one mislynch on a townie is not that important.

 

vigilante: he has a higher probability of picking off townies in the early nights. vig mis-killing helps the scum.

 

1-shot cop: this is a close one but I think they will go for this role. the cop has only 1-shot of identifying just one of the scum. its unlikely the cop will want to use this ability early which gives the scum more time to kill off the cop.

 

as opposed to:

 

jailkeeper: this is a pretty strong role and works almost as well as the cop and he has no handicap 1-shot or 2-shot ability

 

tracker - no handicap on his abilities and he has a better chance of identifying the scum as he can track a scum who sends in a kill.

[Alternate_Tree]

can't they have multiple of the same roles though?  In that case they might have more innocent childs and less night abilities

[KevinH]

can't they have multiple of the same roles though?  In that case they might have more innocent childs and less night abilities

 

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Pick_Your_Poison (referenced in post #3) shows 0 or 1 of each of the power roles, so I don't think we'll have multiples in this game.

[Alternate_Tree]

Alright, thanks for the clarification.  I'd agree with Imran about what roles are more likely than others

[killgor]

i tend to agree with the power roles you laid out. the tracker and jailkeeper are the best things we've got going for cops since most of the town power roles will not be using their abilities each night.

[Euclid of Alexandria]

I agree with the role speculations but it seems irrelevant. We'll find out the roles when they are claimed or when there are two night kills. Before that I don't see how it would affect our play.

[KevinH]

Ok then, what shall we talk about?

[Euclid of Alexandria]

We could talk about how we are going to actually get someone lynched. It's not gonna be easy to have 7 of us agree on someone.

[KevinH]

It's not going to be easy because

• nobody knows nothing'
• the odds favor lynching a townie
• we're risking a lynch of a townie power role
• the scum won't lynch themselves

[Euclid of Alexandria]

It's not going to be easy because

• nobody knows nothing'
• the odds favor lynching a townie
• we're risking a lynch of a townie power role
• the scum won't lynch themselves

2. That's always gonna be the case.
3. That's gonna be the case until we lost all three.
1. & 4. By lynching someone we get info from the voting records so we at least know something tomorrow.

To be honest I don't care that much who we lynch as long as we lynch someone. Ideally we should have two competing wagons towards the end of the day.

[Euclid of Alexandria]

Okay, I'm gonna move my vote just so we have another wagon of two.

Vote: Nerau

[Commander Shepard]

Unvote:

Vote: Nerau

[d3mon]

Hm.. this is rather interesting. A couple of quick votes on Nerau..

 

/me takes notes

[Chaplain of death]

Killgor's votes are seeming pretty fluffy again.....

 

Unvote

 

Vote Killgor

[Commander Shepard]

Hm.. this is rather interesting. A couple of quick votes on Nerau..

 

/me takes notes

You can take them to the bank afterwards and cash them out.

[Commander Shepard]

If I was to pick someone to lynch based on nothing but gut and being curious, it would be KevinH.

Turn the stone over and see what happens.