340 replies to this topic

[Commander Shepard]

Perhaps Rafay shouldn't be included, iSocialism and Pretzimus the Great are probably the best two candidates.

Does anyone know/think something to suggest that iSocialism is not an arsonist? 

[KevinH]

Vote Count:

iSocialism (1): Rafay
Rafay (1): iSocialism
Pretzimus the Great (1): Commander Shepard
Robert2424 (0):
Commander Shepard (0):
Electric Mango (0):
No lynch (0):

 
Not voting: Robert2424, Electric Mango, Pretzimus the Great
 
Tree Stumps:

Road2Victory, Duderonomy 

 
Dead Arsonist:

Lyner

 
With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.
Deadline is 17:00 EDT Sunday, November 1.

Note: I didn't spell it out in the rules, but am adding it now:
"If a day reaches the deadline without a lynch, the player with the most votes over a half-majority will be lynched. In the event of a tie, the first player to the most votes will be lynched."

[Rafay]

EM what makes you think that I'm scum?

 

Unless you're scum.... I mean you've been trying to stay away from personally taking out some1 but trying to change the discussion from one point to another.

[Duderonomy]

CS isn't very active, but when he is...

[Commander Shepard]

EM what makes you think that I'm scum?
 
Unless you're scum.... I mean you've been trying to stay away from personally taking out some1 but trying to change the discussion from one point to another.

 
I thought you might have being an arsonist but you worked well in getting Lyner lynched. 
It takes time for me to think about all this data lying around. You being an arsonist is just as likely as EM being an arsonist imo. If you decided to lynch your partner it would have being risky with 1 arsonist left. It really wouldn't make sense for an arsonist to play such high stakes. Some things you did weren't very tree like but it is easy to judge other trees actions. 
 
People Who I think are trees: Rafay, Robert2424, Commander Shepard, Electric Mango 
People Who I think could be the last Arsonist: iSocialism, Pretzimus the Great
 
Personally I would vote Pretzimus if it was just me deciding who to lynch. 
 

The fact that no one else is counter claiming fire fighter is all the proof i need.
 
Robert is also townie or the biggest mafia d-bag ever. He pretty much admitted abondoning this game and has not voted the last two days because he is not qualified. He has not read the thread but at least is man enough to admit that and is not voting because he does not want to screw thi gs up for the town. So he's a townie. If he's an arsonist then that is a scumbag move and Robert does not strike me as that kind of player.
 
That leaves Rafay, ISoc, and Pretzimus, who is also i active. I am going to give him the benefit of the doubt as well. To me it is down to just two, Rafay and ISocialism.

I disagree about Preztimus. I disagree about Rafay as well. If you dismiss Pretz so easily you really shouldn't convict Rafay when he paved the way for lynching Lyner from what I read anyway. 

I dismissed iSocialism a little bit too fast but it seems that iSocialism is the person everyone wants to lynch today. 

If it's between Pretz and Rafay (ignoring iSocialism) then I think Pretz most probable to be the arsonist.

[Pretzimus the Great]

Well if it helps with anything, I am not the firefighter but I am also not arsonist. It will strike some as suspicious that I have only just now decided to post after being voted. I read all of the posts but don't post anything because quite frankly I don't know what to say. But if you want to waste what is potentially the last day of voting on me, well go ahead because you will just find out that I'm a tree.

[iSocialism]

Well if it helps with anything, I am not the firefighter but I am also not arsonist. It will strike some as suspicious that I have only just now decided to post after being voted. I read all of the posts but don't post anything because quite frankly I don't know what to say. But if you want to waste what is potentially the last day of voting on me, well go ahead because you will just find out that I'm a tree.

fluff, and I will tell you why newbie. No one is every going to claim to be scum, besides this one game when someone thought it was "good" logic to oust his fellow scum members. Besides that incident. CS already claimed FF role, so not being a FF is easy for anyone to say. Telling people who you are/claim to be after one vote on you is pretty weak. Not knowing what to say is how the game mostly go, so don't worry. Telling people that they are wasting their vote by voting for you, is a red flag. But you are new and a lot of new people do that, however. They do that when they are scum as well.

 

There is not much evidence for Pretz, for him to be either.

The best three option for town is Pretz, Raf, or me if that floats your boat, and I see why d4 might make you think that.

[Pretzimus the Great]

 

Well if it helps with anything, I am not the firefighter but I am also not arsonist. It will strike some as suspicious that I have only just now decided to post after being voted. I read all of the posts but don't post anything because quite frankly I don't know what to say. But if you want to waste what is potentially the last day of voting on me, well go ahead because you will just find out that I'm a tree.

fluff, and I will tell you why newbie. No one is every going to claim to be scum, besides this one game when someone thought it was "good" logic to oust his fellow scum members. Besides that incident. CS already claimed FF role, so not being a FF is easy for anyone to say. Telling people who you are/claim to be after one vote on you is pretty weak. Not knowing what to say is how the game mostly go, so don't worry. Telling people that they are wasting their vote by voting for you, is a red flag. But you are new and a lot of new people do that, however. They do that when they are scum as well.

 

There is not much evidence for Pretz, for him to be either.

The best three option for town is Pretz, Raf, or me if that floats your boat, and I see why d4 might make you think that.

 

Well thanks for some pointers lol. IF I ever play again I will keep those in mind. I figured most of what I said was a big red flag but oh well. I'm not too worried if I get lynched.

[Road2Victory]

This is pivotal point, we need to get the right guy or else town can lose this one....

[KevinH]

Vote Count:

iSocialism (1): Rafay
Rafay (1): iSocialism
Pretzimus the Great (1): Commander Shepard
Robert2424 (0):
Commander Shepard (0):
Electric Mango (0):
No lynch (0):

 
Not voting: Robert2424, Electric Mango, Pretzimus the Great
 
Tree Stumps:

Road2Victory, Duderonomy 

 
Dead Arsonist:

Lyner

 
With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.
Deadline is 17:00 EDT Sunday, November 1.

[Electric Mango]

It doesn't look like Pretzimus or Robert plans on voting so it will most likely be my vote that decides our fate. All of us voting have varying opinions on who is guilty. I have already said that I am most suspicious of iSoc and Rafay so it will most likely be one of those two. I was pretty sure it was going to be Rafay but his first vote on Lyner thru me for a loop yesterday. ISoc seemed town to me but his late vote on Lyner looked suspicious so Im torn on who to vote for.

I trust Commander Shepherd and he is voting for ISoc so that is also something i have to account for. Will decide later.

[iSocialism]

CS is not voting for me.

[Road2Victory]

Hmmmm

[Electric Mango]

My bad, CS is voting for Pretzimus, My memory failed me.

[KevinH]

Vote Count:

iSocialism (1): Rafay
Rafay (1): iSocialism
Pretzimus the Great (1): Commander Shepard
Robert2424 (0):
Commander Shepard (0):
Electric Mango (0):
No lynch (0):

 
Not voting: Robert2424, Electric Mango, Pretzimus the Great
 
Tree Stumps:

Road2Victory, Duderonomy 

 
Dead Arsonist:

Lyner

 
With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.
Deadline is 17:00 EDT Sunday, November 1.

[Duderonomy]

I don't think Pretzimus or Robert2424 are going to be very active, but if EM hasn't voted by the end of today, then he is definitely the arsonist. An arsonist wouldn't vote on this day, because why risk your own lynch when you're going to win the next day lynch or not?

 

This day is a must-lynch day for trees, whereas the first two days were optional-lynch days for trees.

 

It's important to note that the decision to lynch/not lynch is situational not constant. I know it hurts to think about it, but all-lynch is not an optimal strategy for trees in every situation.  

[Road2Victory]

Let's go!!!!

[Commander Shepard]

Vote: iSocialism

[iSocialism]

Do I get an explanation of why you choose me over your other candidates.

[KevinH]

Vote Count:

iSocialism (2): Rafay, Commander Shepard
Rafay (1): iSocialism
Pretzimus the Great (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Commander Shepard (0):
Electric Mango (0):
No lynch (0):

 
Not voting: Robert2424, Electric Mango, Pretzimus the Great
 
Tree Stumps:

Road2Victory, Duderonomy 

 
Dead Arsonist:

Lyner

 
With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.
Deadline is 17:00 EDT Sunday, November 1.