572 replies to this topic

[Rafay]

Is Shah a very experienced player? Any interpersonal conflicts with anyone playing?

 

Not really. I think its his 3rd game.....

 

 

I'm not sure you're the tracker Mr. Imran. And neither are you. 

[Mandarijn]

What are you basing that on Rafay, just a hunch? Why would he make such a claim if he's scum though? He would be lynched tomorrow...

[d3mon]

I have to say that Imran seems to have hit the nail on the head. I would love to see what Rhizo has to say before voting because I hate bandwagons and this one is probably going to become one pretty quickly.

 

The game suddenly got a lot interesting...

 

@Rafay, why do you think that Imran is not a tracker?

[Imran Ehsan]

 

Is Shah a very experienced player? Any interpersonal conflicts with anyone playing?

 

Not really. I think its his 3rd game.....

 

 

I'm not sure you're the tracker Mr. Imran. And neither are you. 

 

 

I am pretty sure that I know that I am the tracker. You may not be sure but you will be when we lynch Rhizo today.

[Sister Midnight]

Imran, if you actually are the tracker, then by claiming the role you are committing suicide right now,  the mafia will need to kill the tracker, right?   Why would you do that?  if you're a mobster, then you could be leading us to lynch an innocent man and then you can kill him next person.  But then again, if you're a mobster and you finger someone who is innocent then everyone will know you're guilty tomorrow.  Unless I'm missing something?

 

I would love to hear from Rhizo.  Sucks because I think Rhizo is kind of hot.

[Mandarijn]

Imran, if you actually are the tracker, then by claiming the role you are committing suicide right now,  the mafia will need to kill the tracker, right?   Why would you do that?  if you're a mobster, then you could be leading us to lynch an innocent man and then you can kill him next person.  But then again, if you're a mobster and you finger someone who is innocent then everyone will know you're guilty tomorrow.  Unless I'm missing something?

 

I would love to hear from Rhizo.  Sucks because I think Rhizo is kind of hot.

A tracker isn't a very powerful role (he just got lucky, if he didn't follow Rhizo, but someone else. He wouldn't know anything ), I think Imran is willing to take the risk of possibly getting lynched. (The doc can always protect him if needed) This will mean if we have another cop, he will certainly live another day...

 

So I'm pretty certain Imran is not scum and is telling the truth.

 

But Rhizo is reading the topic, so let's see.

[d3mon]

Imran, if you actually are the tracker, then by claiming the role you are committing suicide right now,  the mafia will need to kill the tracker, right?   Why would you do that?  if you're a mobster, then you could be leading us to lynch an innocent man and then you can kill him next person.  But then again, if you're a mobster and you finger someone who is innocent then everyone will know you're guilty tomorrow.  Unless I'm missing something?

 

I would love to hear from Rhizo.  Sucks because I think Rhizo is kind of hot.

 

I wouldn't call it suicide, its quite possible that the game has a doctor and he would be protected. Also, if he was scum, he would never try to lead a lynch on day 2. He would be lynched the next day and since there are usually 3 townies per scum, it would actually benefit us.

I saw Rhizo reading the thread and he didn't post. Time to wrap this one up.

 

Vote:Rhizo

[Rhizoctonia]

lol of reading a thread at times and not posting is a sign, you need to rethink. I've read like I always do via my phone...ill get to this complete bogus claim of Imran when I'm at computer

[Chaplain of death]

well?

Based on the "fight downtown" and the fact that Imran claims that Rhizo is scum, that means hes either an SK or mafia. I'd say that whichever scum faction he ISN'T from, probably targeted someone who either was protected by a doctor, or had some kind of night kill immunity (likely one shot). 

[Chaplain of death]

There are 3 votes on Rhizo right now. It takes 7.

 

I will vote for him once we hear from him or once we run low on time. My only concern is that if Imran is a scum "cop" and found that Rhizo is a powerful enough role to sacrifice himself to take out (like a vigilante or doc or something of that nature.)

[Chaplain of death]

Day two will end Monday night. 

 

So we have roughly 2 days. I'd say if Rhizo doesn't respond by tomorrow evening, that he is likely just hoping to ride the day out without us reaching a majority, and that we should lynch his ass.

 

Rhizo if you have a claim to make, I suggest you make it in the next 24 hours, otherwise prepare to die scum!

[Rhizoctonia]

So now that I'm at a computer, I'll look to fix Imran's claim.

 

You're right, I didn't answer your question.  Neither has anyone else to this point either.  I didn't answer your question because I felt it could be your way of finding out who may have information if you're scum.  Could easily be a way to find out who may have knowledge to make sure to either target them in a lynch or kill them at night if they didn't want to roleclaim.  There was no reason me to present that I did an action on Shah when my action wouldn't be of any help.  No further information was gained with the ability I used on Shah that isn't known already from what the Mod said, so there was no reason for me to admit I did and make scum weary of me, nor have my town role get out.

 

I didn't want to have to role claim this early, but since I seem to have been on the hot seat thanks to Imran I guess I will have to.  I am Red Star a town JOAT.  I suspected early on that D3mon was possibly a scum, and Shah seemed to defend him so I was interested in seeing if they were working together.  I also know Shah has played Mafia many times now, and someone who pushes people to play, so I wanted to know early on if he was scum or not.   I'm not sure how much D3mon plays mafia, but knew how involved Shah seems to be, so out of the 2, I picked the one I feared most if scum.

[Mandarijn]

@Rhizo: What ability of the JOAT did you use on Shah then? Did you get any result?

 

@Robert2424 In this fictional scenario what would Imran get as a result if he's a tracker:

Rhizo checks on (let's assume investigates) Shah

Ninja (Mafia) kills Shah

Imran tracks Shah

[Mandarijn]

I've done some reading about this Red X character: http://teentitans.wikia.com/wiki/Red_X

And it seems he isn't really a bad character.

 

@ROBERT, does the Mafia only have bad character's names?

 

Meh, they could both be telling the truth, but I don't know.

[Chaplain of death]

So now that I'm at a computer, I'll look to fix Imran's claim.

 

You're right, I didn't answer your question.  Neither has anyone else to this point either.  I didn't answer your question because I felt it could be your way of finding out who may have information if you're scum.  Could easily be a way to find out who may have knowledge to make sure to either target them in a lynch or kill them at night if they didn't want to roleclaim.  There was no reason me to present that I did an action on Shah when my action wouldn't be of any help.  No further information was gained with the ability I used on Shah that isn't known already from what the Mod said, so there was no reason for me to admit I did and make scum weary of me, nor have my town role get out.

 

I didn't want to have to role claim this early, but since I seem to have been on the hot seat thanks to Imran I guess I will have to.  I am Red Star a town JOAT.  I suspected early on that D3mon was possibly a scum, and Shah seemed to defend him so I was interested in seeing if they were working together.  I also know Shah has played Mafia many times now, and someone who pushes people to play, so I wanted to know early on if he was scum or not.   I'm not sure how much D3mon plays mafia, but knew how involved Shah seems to be, so out of the 2, I picked the one I feared most if scum.

 

Problem here. Imran found evidence of Red X and you claim to be Red Star, and your only evidence of your role is information that is already public. Also does not address the red residue.

 

vote: Rhizo

[Rhizoctonia]

 

So now that I'm at a computer, I'll look to fix Imran's claim.

 

You're right, I didn't answer your question.  Neither has anyone else to this point either.  I didn't answer your question because I felt it could be your way of finding out who may have information if you're scum.  Could easily be a way to find out who may have knowledge to make sure to either target them in a lynch or kill them at night if they didn't want to roleclaim.  There was no reason me to present that I did an action on Shah when my action wouldn't be of any help.  No further information was gained with the ability I used on Shah that isn't known already from what the Mod said, so there was no reason for me to admit I did and make scum weary of me, nor have my town role get out.

 

I didn't want to have to role claim this early, but since I seem to have been on the hot seat thanks to Imran I guess I will have to.  I am Red Star a town JOAT.  I suspected early on that D3mon was possibly a scum, and Shah seemed to defend him so I was interested in seeing if they were working together.  I also know Shah has played Mafia many times now, and someone who pushes people to play, so I wanted to know early on if he was scum or not.   I'm not sure how much D3mon plays mafia, but knew how involved Shah seems to be, so out of the 2, I picked the one I feared most if scum.

 

Problem here. Imran found evidence of Red X and you claim to be Red Star, and your only evidence of your role is information that is already public. Also does not address the red residue.

 

vote: Rhizo

 

 

 

Imran did not find evidence of Red X, the only information regarding the Red X was from the Mod explaining how Shah was killed.  The only thing Imran found was red residue from supposedly following me.  Which could be from Red-X who obviously killed Shah, or residue from my character, Red Star who can change into a energy form composed of Red shimmering Plasma.

[Chaplain of death]

You're correct. I meant that Shah was killed by Red X, and there was red residue found from tracking you. Nothing of Red Stars character leaves behind residue. 

[Rhizoctonia]

I don't know why Mod put red residue, but he didn't specify what the residue was.  If it was blood, I'd assume he'd specify it.  Red-X character as far as I can read doesn't leave a red residue, and Imran didn't see me kill him like he suspects.  It could just as easily been residue with changing into red plasma form, or if he tracked me to where Shah was, it could of been blood from Red-x killing him.  You're lynching me off of Imran simply tracking me that I met with Shah

[Rhizoctonia]

@Rhizo: What ability of the JOAT did you use on Shah then? Did you get any result?

 

@Robert2424 In this fictional scenario what would Imran get as a result if he's a tracker:

Rhizo checks on (let's assume investigates) Shah

Ninja (Mafia) kills Shah

Imran tracks Shah

 

 

Cop, and what Robert already said, that he was not what I expected, but was town

[Imran Ehsan]

Lol...I don't buy any of it. I am on my phone now but if you want I can do a line by line analysis of your lies.
Later on I meant