860 replies to this topic

[Imran Ehsan]

Vote: Imran Ehsan

 

I just get a vibe that he is scum. Samus seemed to have it out for him by claiming he was a scum for the majority of D1 and Samus is the one who ended up getting killed.

 

Again, first game but that's how I'm looking at it.

 

Yeah if I was scum I would kill the only person who was vocal about me being scum (btw it was D1 and no one knew anything so all posts on D1 are fluff). That would be very smart of me </sarcasm>. In fact I see it as a scum tactic to try to get me lynched early. A pretty nooby one I might add, which brings me to..

 

 

Vote: Imran Ehsan

 

I just get a vibe that he is scum. Samus seemed to have it out for him by claiming he was a scum for the majority of D1 and Samus is the one who ended up getting killed.

 

Again, first game but that's how I'm looking at it.

 

i agree with him , he is just running around and accusing everyone .

 

VOTE: Imran

 

 

Holy moly..that was a quick bandwagon!

 

D1 was all fluff posts. But you are quick to jump on the bandwagon.

 

Noob scum detected.

 

Vote: Avater

[Ali bin Turban]

 

Vote: Imran Ehsan

 

I just get a vibe that he is scum. Samus seemed to have it out for him by claiming he was a scum for the majority of D1 and Samus is the one who ended up getting killed.

 

Again, first game but that's how I'm looking at it.

 

i agree with him , he is just running around and accusing everyone .

 

VOTE: Imran

 

Who exactly are those "everyone"?

From what I remember that was only Samus ( which was obviously done to tease him) and you (because you were inactive). I'm also under impression that you were influenced by Samus in those rare moments of your postings. Aren't you blindly following him and taking his words to serious?

[Ali bin Turban]

Vote: Imran Ehsan

 

I just get a vibe that he is scum. Samus seemed to have it out for him by claiming he was a scum for the majority of D1 and Samus is the one who ended up getting killed.

 

Again, first game but that's how I'm looking at it.

Yeah that was pretty obvious wasn't it? Well, that's why it's most probably not true.

There are just 4 maybe 5 bad guys around and if they get involved in such quarrels and vengeance kills we'd pick them off one by one in a matter of days and win the game.

 

Just imagine, what if the bad guys noticed the same thing you did and chose to kill Samus to paint Imran as a scum? In that case you'd get outsmarted and lynch innocent guy.

 

Did Samus show any evidence or made any explanation as of why did he believe Imran was a scum? I didn't see anything like that. They were just teasing each other (as far as I remember Samus even didn't vote on Imran).

[Ali bin Turban]

 

 

Umbrella is the name of alliance.
 
So Master Samus already dead any one got any leads? the only ppl looking scum to me are Kevin H,because of his spam posts and Kaziocore because of her low post count.

I got nothing . Those two you mention feel like scums to me too (especially Kazio). But lets see if someone has any lead.

 

Can you elaborate?
 
--- --- --- --- ---
 

 

Unvote: Lyner
 
D1 is really hard because I don't know what to do and there are a lot of fluff posts everywhere lol
 
After reading the whole thread, I have a slight town read on Imran and Lyner for some reason :V
 
KevinH is being KevinH (making a lot of fluff votes and always no lynching on D1) so as much as I want to lynch KevinH for sometimes being anti-town, I guess it's too early for that.
 
In conclusion, I have no idea what to do

Would you be so kind and write some more about your "town reads"? While probably most of us will agree Imran's posts gave townie vibe so far, I didn't noticed anything similar for Lyner. As a matter of fact I don't think he's said anything that would add to the conversation and I'm really curious why did you mention him...also considering you've voted for him.

 

Well the truth is I though he was town for saying this

Welp this setup is similar to Kevin's last game
 
 
Also checking in

But then I forgot that The Warrior wrote this on the first page

Only the following roles may exist in this game:

Vanilla Townie, Bodyguard, Commuter, Sane
Cop, Role Cop, Vanilla Cop, Flavor Cop, Doctor, Friendly Neighbor,
Follower, Gunsmith, Innocent Child, Jack of All Trades, Jailkeeper,
Mafia Goon, Mafia Encryptor, Mafia Godfather, Mafia Ninja, Mafia
Strongman, Mafia Traitor, Mason, Miller, Motion Detector, Neapolitan,
Neighbor, Neighborizer, Nurse, Roleblocker, Rolestopper, Serial Killer,
Tracker, Universal Backup, Vigilante, Voyeur, Watcher

The following modifiers may also exist in this game:

Ascetic, Backup (with or without primary
role present), Bulletproof, Enabler (with or without primary role
present), Even/Odd Night, Macho, Neighbor, Non-Consecutive Night, Weak,
X-Shot

 

So yeah lol
 

I'm really curious why did you mention him

Because you don't just mention the people you suspect as scum in this game?
Everyone should share who they think is town or scum no matter how strong or weak the reads.

 

...also considering you've voted for him.

It's a random vote bruh

It's a thing on D1

I guess I have a strong townread on King Hitler

^ Added after seeing King Hitler's post

 

I've explained it in a second post (you've quoted) why you feel scummy to me. While I agree sharing thoughts on townie/scum is essential, doing it without any explanation is causing confusion and thus is scummy by nature.

 

So if you have any ideas/readings please try to explain them, because your opinion is not that important, your reasoning is (no offense, I hope you get what I mean).

I see lurking Shah didn't have anything to add to the conversation. That's a shame, considering he's such a talkative guy normally . Just the same like on the first day (when he didn't say much, apart from repeating arguments given by Mandarijn and Imran).

[Ali bin Turban]

 

 

Feel sorry for samoos getting killed so early in 2 consecutive games..lol

 

Duh. The mafia try to take out the most analytical and active players first.

 

 

 

Kaziocore (1): Samus

 

 

And look here. Perhaps the biggest lurker and possible connection to Samus' death.......

 

This post has scum written all over it.

 

I don't know how good Samus his analytical skills are, but as far as I know he got killed early last game and was scum in the one he won. Clearly Imran would be the 1st to go if they wanted to kill the most analytical player. Or Ali, but he's still inexperienced.

 

Then your 2nd sentence, you've always stated that you're against lynching inactives (and lurkers I think as well). Yet, now you're dropping hints on Kazio for a (probably) lul vote on Samus.

 

Very suspicious if you ask me...

 

I'd normally agree with you...but then I've skimmed a few games and somewhat agree with Kazio (though he's on my list for possible lynch targets should we not get anything solid on day 2)

I got nothing from last night, sort of

I hate to repeat Kazio, but I'm also curious what happened .

[Mandarijn]

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

[Ali bin Turban]

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

We need to replace Roq, not to ping him.

[Avater]

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 

[Ali bin Turban]

 

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 

 

For fun you say? My apologies for taking you as a Samus follower then, because you really sound like newbie scum getting scared of unwanted attention.

 

Vote: Avater

 

I'd like to hear if other folks got any night findings, but if there's nothing solid there I'm keeping my vote on you.

[Rafay]

Then your 2nd sentence, you've always stated that you're against lynching inactives (and lurkers I think as well). Yet, now you're dropping hints on Kazio for a (probably) lul vote on Samus.

 

I'm not lynching Kaz for being inactive but he's been quiet and Samus died and the vote and the....well trying to make headway out of last night. 

[KevinH]

It's Day 2 and Kaziocore is alive.  
 
He must be on the scum's side.
 

[Imran Ehsan]

 

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 

 

 

Fun votes ended on Day 1. Any votes and accusations from D2 onwards will be taken seriously and it will be assumed you are bandwagoning if you provide no valid reason.

[Lyner]

It's Day 2 and Kaziocore is alive.  
 
He must be on the scum's side.
 

 

Seconded

[Rhizoctonia]

 

 

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 

 

 

Fun votes ended on Day 1. Any votes and accusations from D2 onwards will be taken seriously and it will be assumed you are bandwagoning if you provide no valid reason.

 

 

 

Seriously?  I'll make sure to take note of every time you throw out baseless accusations or votes with no valid reason.  So far you had D1, basing it off posts, and now D2 2 people "Bandwagoning."  Both are soft reasons for accusing.  No one has wanted to come forward with information, so this is where we're at.  Lyner seems to be the only one to come out that he might have something, though only "sort of."  I'm curious what it is, but also rather him not expose his role this early unless the information is helpful or useful.  

[Sister Midnight]

 

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.
 
Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...
 
I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 
 

 
Fun votes ended on Day 1. Any votes and accusations from D2 onwards will be taken seriously and it will be assumed you are bandwagoning if you provide no valid reason.

That's a little disconcerting because what if I agree with what someone has said, but have nothing new to add to it? If someone convinces me with their brilliant reasoning and I vote that means I'm bandwagoning?

Right now we have very little evidence of anything or on anyone. I don't feel like I can make a educated guess about anything and I'm not fond of wild ass guessing.

[Imran Ehsan]

Seriously? I'll make sure to take note of every time you throw out baseless accusations or votes with no valid reason. 

 

Where did I throw out baseless accusations? Are you still sore about me catching you lying and getting you lynched in the other game? Because I dont see any "baseless accusations" being thrown about by me in this game.

 

So far you had D1, basing it off posts, and now D2 2 people "Bandwagoning." Both are soft reasons for accusing.

 

I have no clue what you are trying to say here.

That's a little disconcerting because what if I agree with what someone has said, but have nothing new to add to it? If someone convinces me with their brilliant reasoning and I vote that means I'm bandwagoning?

 

Voting for someone "just for fun" is bandwagoning. Providing no reason or no reason other then.."yeah I agree with him" is bandwagoning. No one said you cant do it. You can provide whatever reason you want for your vote. But I will also call you out for doing it because thats a pretty good indicator of scumminess.

[Shahenshah]

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.
 
Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...
 
I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

We need to replace Roq, not to ping him.

Why the former and not the later? Just curious, generally we try and ping first and then replace if ping doesn't pongs.

[The Warrior]

Roq has been pinged. If he cannot continue actively, he will be replaced.

[Ali bin Turban]

 

Why the former and not the later? Just curious, generally we try and ping first and then replace if ping doesn't pongs.

 

This game is about talking with others, not just about stopping by every few days to cast a vote. It would be be great for Roq to stay with us because he's intelligent guy and surely would make discussions more interesting...but that would require him to devote some time and for now it seems he can't afford that.

 

Apart from the metagame, do you have anything to add on things that are happening right now / had happened last night ?

[Ali bin Turban]

 

 

 

Can we ping Roq? As he seems to have forgotten about this game... Although he has been on the forum on the 28th and if he's scum, I can see him advocating to kill Samus as well. But meh, he just needs to post more.

 

Also Avater has hardly post anything and now he's pretty quick on the lynch wagon. It could be just him being new to the game (as we've seen last game as well ). But it is pretty suspicious Avater...

 

I also have nothing (usefull) to share from N1. (I'm still leaving that in the middle )

Yeah u r right i am just a noob trying to figure out this game , i voted Imran just for fun 

 

 

Fun votes ended on Day 1. Any votes and accusations from D2 onwards will be taken seriously and it will be assumed you are bandwagoning if you provide no valid reason.

 

 

 

Seriously?  I'll make sure to take note of every time you throw out baseless accusations or votes with no valid reason.  So far you had D1, basing it off posts, and now D2 2 people "Bandwagoning."  Both are soft reasons for accusing.  No one has wanted to come forward with information, so this is where we're at.  Lyner seems to be the only one to come out that he might have something, though only "sort of."  I'm curious what it is, but also rather him not expose his role this early unless the information is helpful or useful.  

 

What are those baseless accusations (please don't quote D1, because many people did that and it has no importance)?

 

So far at D2 we got:

 

1. KHitler jumping the gun - which seems like overzealous, inexperienced townie action to me and he gets noting to prove his choice (apart from D1 bickering).

2. Avater comes in and supports KH with accusations.

3. Imran hits Avater back with his suspicions.

4. It turns out Avater is not accusing Imran for real, but just for fun.

5. Imran's not buying his explanation.

6. You came in and attack Imran.

 

Why do you have problem with Imran, yet a guy that's claims to "vote on D2 just for fun" is no concern for you? How far you think we'll get with a jester crew confusing rest of the town with their "fun voting"?