If Myrrdin can't play, who will be his replacement?
Also Samus is alive D2, what type of sorcery is this? Hagrid gave his life to protect him.
+1 King Hitler
Why would the scum target CoD?
At least Samus didn't buy it in night 1. Felt bad for him last game. 
+1 Finster
Welcome to Day 2, Samus!
Vote: Mazuurek
His post count is 1 for the whole game.
Townie points to Sister Midnight for the good humor!
+1 KevinH
If Samus aurvives till day 2, he must then be scum.
I vote Samus
Since editing is taboo, I must say that the above fact seems to be by unspoken tradition 
well, nevermind, it merged the posts.
+2 legoboy - this is outright scum behaviour imo. What type of justification? lol
King Hitler - awarded Townie of the Year by IRON Times 3 years running.
Finster Baby - I'm leaning towards townie. There isn't much information on D2 and Finister seems to be trying to at least find something
Myrrdin Emrys - I'd like to wait to see the verdict on if he's replaced or not before we get some judgement here.
iSocialism - seems more active than past games. Might be a new play style. I doubt he'd get more active as scum as his usual Turtley strategy seems to do good for him.
legoboyvdlp - about mid way here. New player so mistakes are expected but at the beginning he got really defensive when SM joke voted for him. Keep an eye on this.
Lyner - can't really make a judgement yet.
KevinH - obvious scum for stealing my name. On a real note, kind of half and half. Doesn't seem to post anything with weight, just sort of floats around in my opinion. May be trying to avoid suspicion, but I haven't played with him enough to know if it's his playstyle or not.
Wolfpacks - new player if im correct (I've never played with him.) Hasn't made too many mistakes which is coming off kind of surprising.
Samus - Alive d2? Obvious scum.
Ali bin Turban - seems to be trying to help town
Sister Midnight - has just quoted HP in my opinion. Also was on the no lynch vote (one of the 5 is possibly scum, and yes I'm on the wagon too.) I feel SM is coming off the most scum-like out of the new players.
Rafay - playing like Rafay does, not much to go off of.
Rhizoctonia - I think his unfamiliarity with HP references is making him somewhat back off from being super active like usual. Townie feel with what little he's posted so far.
Mazuurek - can't really make an opinion on him yet.
Vote: Sister Midnight
Reasons above. Like I stated, scum team probably has a new player on it. SM just attracts me the most at the current time as a possible scum.
+2 King Hitler (mentioning me surviving n1 again)
Also 'hidden defense' of his scum buddy KevinH. Goes to claim he is scum in jest and then turns it around with 'uncertainty', easy mind trick there.
Also 'hidden defense' of his other buddy Finsterbaby. He's leaning towards him being townie because on D2 there's not much info available. Doesn't use the same arguement for anyone else, but the same argument applies to everyone else. You make this too easy.
Another low suspect here is ABT & Rhizo as he does the same thing, but they are very low/neutral on my radar so far.
@ABT, KH -- indeed, this is no joke.
It seems by tradition that Samus is ALWAYS killed on day 1 if he joins in as town, so if he survived, he must be scum.
Of course, I am new, but on the other hand, I have seem several references to this tradition, and it makes sense.
+3 again with the 'samus is still alive' scum tactic.
Unvote
Hi Preston
And good evening to you as well Finster.
---
So a bit of activity today, good - seems to be following four main threads.
1. KevinH's List - another analysis list, and I'm a little amused he gave me the same rating as himself. Gryffindor indeed?
It doesn't stop me from watching him of course, but more notably he lays out a list of his current suspects: Lego, Samus, iSoc, Lyner, Rafay, mazuurek.
Kevin also accurately noted that I am riding on Myrrdin's legacy. He was an active poster apparently and not trying to hide, though skimming day 1 I can't get into his head on some bits either, particularly his unvoting prior to the day's end. He had voted for CoD before the day ended, along with Lego - and CoD was killed on night 1. Speculation, but I wonder if that kill was intended to shift suspicion onto Lego and Myrrdin as the two who had votes there?
2. iSoc and Ali arguing about iSoc's earlier statement regarding scum on the no-lynch vote. Either they're good at acting, or Ali is just that argumentative, or these two don't like each other and aren't on the same team. It's drawing a lot of attention to the pair of them, and feels like Ali doesn't want to let iSoc go.
3. Lego tossed a FoS on KevinH with minimal explanation, after previously focusing on Samus?
4. Votes/FoS being directed at Rafay and Mazuurek, the current minimums in vote count (if you exclude myself due to late joining or add in Myrrdin's posts to my count).
Before going further, I decided to do a post count only since Day 2 started, to see how that looked without the spamminess of Day 1:
Ali bin Turban 7
Finster Baby 8
iSocialism 6
KevinH 9
King Hitler 6
legoboyvdlp 3
Lyner 1
Preston 2 (counting this one)
Rhizoctonia 2
Sister Midnight 6
Wolfpacks 3
Samus 0
Rafay 0
Mazuurek 0
So the subject of lurkers vs low post count vs inactives... the easy targets that can't (or are not) defend themselves. I'm always a little leery when this line of attack is used, because similar to the day 1 no lynch it is a "blameless" targeting - one where if the vote happens and a townie is lynched, everyone on that wagon can say it was sheer numbers and how can you question the statistics? My personal thought is that if someone is REALLY scum, then they have a power role of their own and that makes the game more exciting - i.e. scum are less likely to be truly inactive barring outside life issues, so lynching inactives is better-than-even odds to kill town instead of scum. If they're really dead weight we can try to get another replacement for future days.
With that said, I also want to distinguish between "Lurker" and "inactive" - the first is scummier than the second. Both Mazurrek and Rafay (and Samus, and Lyner until today) have not posted on day 2, but have they been observed to be reading this thread without posting, by ANYONE? If so, then yes there is more info that they are lurking and it's on the word of the one who says they saw them reading without posting.
The other question is when they last did anything else on the forums - to proactively answer this part myself, Rafay's last post in the forums was on June 17th; Mazuurek's was yesterday, June 27th; Lyner's only day 2 post was to say he's having a hard week (explanation for inactivity), today June 28th; Samus has been active elsewhere on the forums, last post today June 28th.
So with all that said - unless someone can specify they have seen someone actively reading this thread (list on the bottom) but not posting, Samus and Mazuurek both hit the "active on forums but not posting here" criteria moreso than Rafay and Lyner. So are they lurking, or just not paying attention here - do they NOT have a role so they are bored with the game and less attentive, or are they trying not to make waves? Some pressure might help - and to spread out the votes so a wagon doesn't form, I am going to vote for the other active-but-not-here-and-no-day2-posts player.
Vote: Samus
Come rejoin the conversation to remove your inactivity/lurking and I'll remove the vote.
As a relevant side question, would those who have played with him more recently consider Samus enough of a veteran that he would have been a better N1 target than CoD? Ignoring what seems to be a running joke about him, anyway...
-Preston
Preston's analysis here looks really genuine, so I believe you to be townie. You raise some good points, but you're voting for the wrong person.
Samus should be coming around. I don't believe there is a need to vote for him to make him show up. My main concern is for the people who were post happy on d1, and now won't even post. D2 is hard to analyze, and I know that not much talking can be done. So my list goes like this, using TW post count
Wolfpacks 19 fluff posting, and voting out of the blue
Finster Baby 19 Helpful
Sister Midnight 19 active
Myrrdin Emrys 17- MIA
KevinH 16 Helpful
Ali bin Turban 16 - " argumentative"
King Hitler 14 Helpful
legoboyvdlp 10 active enough for a newbie
Samus 9 needs to become active
iSocialism 7 - myself
Rhizoctonia 6 active enough
Lyner 6 excued
Chaplain of death 5 DEAD
Rafay 2 - inactive
Preston 1 - Helpful
Mazuurek 1 - MIAish
Vote Wolfpack
also was in the NL wagon.
I will say though, I think that there is probably 4 scums all together, and with my thinking of around 1 in the NL wagon that would be a 1-5 chance of hitting scum. Outside the wagon would leave us 3 scums or a 3-9 chance of hitting scum. I came to this conclusion mostly by a gut feeling, back had a little "evidence" to back it up.
I will be leaving this afternoon and won't be back until the 4th.
The post count analysis by iSoc shows alot of info here, Wolfpacks active on D1, then ghost D2? Suspected scum here or maybe more the SK. An SK can't collaborate with any partners, so imo they are most likely the ones who are going to try and confuse everyone with their replies and activity.
Now that I mention that, Preston's seems more SK'ish. He hasn't really shown any form of collaboration with anyone, which means possibly working alone.
my head it swims with noises and voices, I can't understand the words that's being used it swirls and swirls like the dust and sand of the desert, what does deflection really mean, who is deflecting from what or whom, no wait it is starting to clear I can make out a letter, no wait I now see a name can it be true, it couldn't be over and over again the name appears. That's it I see it now.
Wow Fluff means randomness who knew
Unvote Maz
Vote Finster
This is scummy, Finster voted for you, so you revenge vote with no basis?
Evident scum here.
So guys if I don't survive this night, here is my analysis.
There are 3 or 4 scum members. 1 SK.
High on my scum list are (in order):
legoboyvdlp
King Hitler
Wolfpacks
KevinH
Even though I think legoboy is more scum than King Hitler, i'm keeping my vote for King Hitler because he's more experienced with his words in this game.
But legoboy I see right through you.
I wasn't going to play this game after I decided I was quitting from this game permanently, but I had a plan on how I could change things and it's something I was going to test out now, which the scum above have all proven to me.
Also guys my rationale behind the people above being scum are the ones that are mentioning me surviving N1 is that if you think about it, they obviously knew they weren't going to kill me on N1 (as they did the killing). They can use this fact to their ability to sway votes in their favour, the first thing majority of those scum mentioned (above) on DAY 2 was that I was still alive and because of that I must be scum - this is 'new' information in a way, because it's now a discussion that can be started. Also my inactivity didn't really help.
Also note how many people mentioned 'Samus survived night 1 bla bla', go back and ready, guarantee you not anymore than 4 players? those numbers sound abit familiar.. How many scum might there be hmm?? I'll let you think about that.
Also I wouldn't be coming in here to defend myself on the last day if I were scum lol, surely my scum partners would be doing that for me or would have prodded me to get in here and do that much earlier.
I'll go over the thread again and pick out some other things I notice shortly.
Convince town to lynch Samus, then kill another townie at night. gg
anyway my vote still remains on King Hitler
Convince town to lynch Samus, then kill another townie at night. gg


Root Admin
Ex-Kilo CO, Ex-Bounty Director, Ex-Mentor, Ex-Admissions Admin Ex-Deputy Headmaster of Academy, Ex-Recruitment Staff, Ex-SWAG Personell, Ex-Academy Staff, Ex-Trade Post Director, Ex-Deputy Trade Post Director, Ex- Foxtrot Master Sergeant, Ex-Award Panel Deputy Director, Ex-Award Panel Staff, Ex-Trade Post Staff, Ex- Delta Executive Officer, Ex-Express Delivery
00:48 Fernando[IRON] � I will refer to you as Supreme Overlord Guru Samus
Only I have the baptismal power.
Samus because of your dedicated service to IRON; your high casualty count and aid given your fellow IRONers. I hear by baptize ye in Fire and blood. You rise as IRON!
You may now wear proudly in your Sig "I have been Baptized in Fire and Blood and emerged as IRON."
18:28 %FinsterBaby[IRON] • I'm only afraid of Master Samus.
18:28 %FinsterBaby[IRON] • All powerful root admin
18:29 @onbekende • wussie
18:29 %FinsterBaby[IRON] • he can make you disappear. I've seen it
MVP(Mod’s Choice)= Master Samus; I think Master Samus played amazingly for a guy who claims it was his second only mafia game. He never led the town on him and that’s why he deserves this award. He was impressive in manipulating the town that led to the ultimate mafia victory.
Player of Mafia; Master Samus/emudevelopment (shared); I think both were instrumental in the town’s defeat. Both were manipulative and deceptive. They clearly came out as pro-town and looked like de-facto town leaders. They led the lynch wagon w/o anyone uncovering their true motives.
Samus, you should be proud that you've helped make an environment where people feel safe enough to share their experiences.