926 replies to this topic

[Mazuurek]

(i see you rhizo)

VOTE: 1cecream because rhizo

[legoboyvdlp]

I'm torn between 1ceCream and iSoc.

On one hand, 1ceCream on day 1 seemed to push for a lynch while staying on a ''safe'' option for a scum, no-lynch? Or was it the other way round?

On the other hand, iSoc looks more suspicious.

But Rhizo, who we know was a town PR was more suspicious of 1ceCream.

 

Suggestions, I'm currently un-decided?

[Finster Baby]

UNVOTE

While "doing nothing" isn't necessary indicative of townieness, it throws enough into the works to cause pause.

[The Warrior]

Vote Count

 

iSocialism (3): Ali bin Turban, legoboyvdlp, D34THBR1NG3R

1ceCream (2): KevinH, Mazuurek

D34THBR1NG3R (1): iSocialism

Preston (1): Wolfpacks

Ali bin Turban (0):

Finster Baby (0):

KevinH (0):

legoboyvdlp (0):

Mazuurek (0):

Samus (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Wolfpacks (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Finster Baby, 1ceCream, iSocialism, Preston, Samus, Sister Midnight

 

With 12 alive it takes 6 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is 12:00pm CST on Tuesday, September 6th.

[Wolfpacks]

Now I don't know if it's just me but yeah Rhizo did mention 1ceCream, but he also mentioned Preston probably being scum with COD because of their wagon on me after I said what I said, now if he was so certain that 1ceCream was the one to go for I'm sure he would have used his last action on taking him out, but he didn't, he took out COD instead which stands to reason his other suspicion was Preston, now I'm not saying 1ceCream isn't a suspect nor Isocialism, but Rhizo looked long and hard at them and decided COD was the one to take out and I'm pretty sure Preston would have been next on that list.

[KevinH]

• Mandarijn (Professor McGonagall) a Hogwarts Watcher was knocked out on night 1.
• Rafay (George Weasley) a normal Hogwarts Student has been knocked out on day 2.
• Lyner (Madam Pomfrey) a Hogwarts Doctor has been knocked out on night 2.
• Canik (Gregory Goyle) a 1-Shot Mafia Strongman has been knocked out on day 3.
• Rhizoctonia (Professor Gilderoy Lockhart) a Hogwarts Jack of all Trades was knocked out on night 3.
• Chaplain of Death (Draco Malfoy) a mafia 3-Shot Role Cop was knocked out on night 3.

Everyone killed has had a role except Rafay. I'm beginning to think that my "didn't do anything" results are more likely mafia goon/ninja than vanilla townie.

[legoboyvdlp]

Who was it then?

Anyway, unvote
Vote 1ceCream

I'm decided, unless PR give town result for him I'll stick to him

[Preston]

So Kevin named his N3 result as iSocialism, with another "Did nothing" result. It falls to iSocialism to confirm this, though at this point I would be somewhat surprised if he claimed Kevin was lying.

"Did Nothing" could easily mean any of the following - Vanilla Townie, Mafia Ninja, Mafia Goon or Godfather (not doing the night's kill), or any other role not actively being used. This uncertainty applies to the three people Kevin has investigated - SM, myself, and iSocialism. This is where a normal cop would be needed to try and distinguish those results - I hope we still have one this game.

As Kevin points out we have seen only one vanilla townie proven thus far, but I am not sure how much that means for this game because it seems to have been weighted towards killing roles thus far. We no-lynched D1 and lynched a 'known' scum D3; Rafay's on D2 was the only lynch with an unknown result. The scum also had a role cop, so aside from getting lucky on Mandarijn for N1 their kill of Lyner on N2 could have been informed by CoD - and N3 Rhizo had outed himself so that was another guaranteed role.

Kevin's result doesn't change the rationale for suspecting iSocialism much, but between him and 1ceCream I can see rationales to test both. I would like to at least see 1ceCream post before pushing that wagon to completion however; we wanted to hear from Samus too, and now we've at least heard SOMETHING after TW prodded him.

For the time being consider me intending to vote 1ceCream, but withholding my vote until they have at least had a chance to post in their own defense.

-Preston

[1ceCream]

Ok.

 

I have my RC waiting if my wagon goes further. 

 

@Lego: I pushed for a lynch while staying on NL because I was waiting if anyone looked scummy. 

[legoboyvdlp]

1ceCream, you are already past the lynch limit.
RC now.

Witholding a RC when you are on the wagon is extremely scummy imo
By the way, you should try and graduate

[1ceCream]

I'm fucking trying to graduate but I can't get 4k NS to save my life 

 

My Role: Justin Finch-Fletchley, a Hogwarts VT.

[D34THBR1NG3R]

1ceCream I don't get why you waited at first... mind explaining?

[1ceCream]

@Death I'm a noob. First game EVER. 

[D34THBR1NG3R]

@Death I'm a noob. First game EVER. 

Lego played that last game and was scum... I'm too sus of you now

 

Unvote

Vote 1ceCream

[Wolfpacks]

I'm fucking trying to graduate but I can't get 4k NS to save my life

My Role: Justin Finch-Fletchley, a Hogwarts VT.

I've sent you a message 1ceCream

Not mafia related

[Samus]

Hi guys, sorry situation hasn't changed, i've asked TW to replace me

 

 

Still fingering Samus. SAMs has temporarily been put on my scummiest list because of his recent post. I look forward to seeing what he has to say.

 

 

May I just note here.

 

What exactly was scummy about what I had to say? You never explained it at all?

 

I never mentioned anything about the current state of the game, only about the state of my activity, i'm curious what you deciphered from that or is that just a random accusation with no basis?

 

Also even with my activity issues I was still more active with more posts than the majority of current players.

 

Probably be my last post here, but i'd suggest you guys look at the string of SM's posts. They haven't really been pro pro town imo.

[The Warrior]

Samus has been replaced by King Hitler effective immediately.

[legoboyvdlp]

I believe D34TH's vote may be the end of 1ceCream, or did I count wrong?

[Mazuurek]

Then we should make the most out of the time we still have, I just hope we still have a cop alive.

[Sister Midnight]

Hi guys, sorry situation hasn't changed, i've asked TW to replace me
 
 

Still fingering Samus. SAMs has temporarily been put on my scummiest list because of his recent post. I look forward to seeing what he has to say.

 
 
May I just note here.
 
What exactly was scummy about what I had to say? You never explained it at all?
 
I never mentioned anything about the current state of the game, only about the state of my activity, i'm curious what you deciphered from that or is that just a random accusation with no basis?
 
Also even with my activity issues I was still more active with more posts than the majority of current players.
 
Probably be my last post here, but i'd suggest you guys look at the string of SM's posts. They haven't really been pro pro town imo.

Clarification, I meant that if Samus posted more, or if he bowed out (which would suck, and does suck, no offense to King) I would stop being suspicious.