894 replies to this topic

[CanucksDynasty]

Is it 6 to lynch or is it 7 to lynch?

[Theophilos]

Yeah I'm usually on-line at this our ... need to check Alpha and Stuff.
That said I voted for EM, 'cause I already FoSed him ... and I though it a perfect opportunity to get one member of the scum club out of the way.

[Theophilos]

I think 6 'cause there's 10 of us left, that's a majority ...

[Narsis]

oh now this is interesting and at the same time absolutely perfect! this is the kind of thing i was watching for. now to wait to see if EM is scum or town...

if EM is scum, then my eyes immediately go to Falzis. SJ as well would be one to look at.

if EM is town, then KevinH, CD, and Martino would be my suspects.

just saying so if i die you know who to look at.

[Aquinas]

Please quote exactly where I said I wanted the doc to role claim. I'd love to see it.
...
I always find it ironic that people who put themselves out there the most to try to help the town win always seem to draw the fire, while others who hardly contribute (Sir Jesus and others) get a free pass.

You're right, poor choice of words on my part. I meant to convey that your choice to begin this discussion was in some way a validation of the choice for the doctor to roleclaim. That I think was weird, as I discussed.

Sir Jesus has no free pass in my book. In fact I have a few suspicions about him. However, if he is scum and if you are scum I'll lynch you first to help squelch the scum influence over the townies.

With Theo's vote on EM, if EM turns out scum, it would mean that amongst SJ, Nerau-Narsis, and I, two are scum. I don't think anyone here would say even one of them is scum assuming you think I am the other scum.

I believe that your basis for this is voting records. I doubt a smart scum team would always vote together. If your defense between you and Electric Mango is that although you have similar voting records you are not a team, this assumption that scum teams are not reflected in voting patterns would be inconsistent.

oh now this is interesting and at the same time absolutely perfect! this is the kind of thing i was watching for. now to wait to see if EM is scum or town...

if EM is scum, then my eyes immediately go to Falzis. SJ as well would be one to look at.

if EM is town, then KevinH, CD, and Martino would be my suspects.

just saying so if i die you know who to look at. tongue.gif

Left out again.

[Narsis]

that's because i think you are a townie Aquinas...i only gave my scum suspects.

[Falzis]

I believe that your basis for this is voting records. I doubt a smart scum team would always vote together. If your defense between you and Electric Mango is that although you have similar voting records you are not a team, this assumption that scum teams are not reflected in voting patterns would be inconsistent.

You're forgetting that the case will be different if EM is scum since it would be illogical for scum to vote for fellow scum. Lol that was the point, if EM is scum, no scum could have voted for EM especially if they could have just tied the vote or tilted it towards Kevin. Right?

That's why, I will be shocked to find out if EM is scum. Since that would mean SJ and Narsis are scum.

[Narsis]

actually, my point of view would be you and sj but meh. keep in mind that kaziocore could be scum as well...

[Sir Jesus]

Grrrr..... I have the worst timing when it comes to mafia.

Let's hope to God that we made the right decision, or there will be rough times ahead.

[Kaziocore]

actually, my point of view would be you and sj but meh. keep in mind that kaziocore could be scum as well...

What? You are saying that if EM is scum I could still be scum? If I'm scum why would I vote for my fellow teammate or something and I'm not in danger of lynching on Day 3.

[Falzis]

actually, my point of view would be you and sj but meh. keep in mind that kaziocore could be scum as well...

I really doubt EM would turn up scum. But hey even if he is, and people lynch me the next day because they think I'm scum, it's all good since town can afford to mislynch the next day if scum is lynched today.

If EM is scum:

Day 4 - 6 townies, 2 scum (vote for either me, SJ or Narsis)
Day 5 - 5 townies, 1/2 scum (if correct lynch / if not from above pool of suspects)
Day 6 - 4 townies, 0/1 scum (if correct lynch / if not from above pool of suspects)
Day 7 - town wins!

If EM is not scum:

Day 4 - 5 townies, 3 scum (must be correct lynch or lose on next day - 50% chance since six voted for EM, 3/6 are scum)
Day 5 - 3/4 townies, 2/3 scum (if 3-3, town loses, if 4-2, must be correct lynch or lose on next day)
Day 6 - 2/3 townies, 1/2 scum (if 2-2, town loses, if 3-1, must be correct lynch or lose on next day)

I wonder where mole is. I'm itching to know EM's alignment.

[CanucksDynasty]

I think Rule #8 applies...so no more talking.

[molestargazer]

Oh, damn, damn, damn.

Apologies for my absense. I've been away for a few days, and forgot about this game's deadline.

Official vote count and lynch scene to come shortly.

[molestargazer]

VOTE COUNT
KevinH (4): Falzis, Sir Jesus, Narsis, Electric Mango
Electric Mango (6): Martino, Aquinas, Kaziocore, KevinH, CanucksDynasty, Theophilos

Not Voting (0)

With 10 alive, 6 is needed to lynch.

The noose strung up in the middle of the cafeteria was about to get its second usage during the chaos of the hospital. Opinions change throughout the day, but as night falls, the tide turns very quickly to be against Electric Mango.
The lights are switched on as Electric Mango is dragged to the noose. The rickety chair is kicked out from under his feet, and his thrashing body creates a grisly spectacle for the inmates.

After one last twitch, EM falls still. Some notes in his pocket revealed that Electric Mango was, in fact, perfectly sane - and part of the plot to kill all in the Hospital.

Electric Mango, MAFIA GOON, has been lynched.
IT IS NOW NIGHT 3.
NIGHT ACTIONS TO ME BY MONDAY EVENING, THE 27TH JULY. (I won't go away this time, honest!)

[molestargazer]

Day breaks.

You all gather round in the canteen, around the noose, and a quick count reveals that someone else is missing.
You find CanucksDynasty in his cell. The red marks around his neck confirm he's been strangled to death - and a quick search of his cell provides no clear information that he was out to kill anyone.

CanucksDynasty, TOWNIE, has been killed.

It is now DAY 4.
Deadline is the 10TH AUGUST.

[Kaziocore]

Now that EM was found to be scum now I'm pretty sure that Falzis is scum!

VOTE: Falzis

[Falzis]

Well you'll be dead wrong! If anything, I was a victim of EM's manipulations. He hitched on everything that I did, supported everything that I said, and cozied up to me with his posts where he says he thinks I'm townie. And now I'm scum by poisonous association.

My defense on D3 against lynching sojourner still applies here. But more over, I've always put my head farther out than EM who conveniently played my second fiddle, trying to play townie but was actually not.

Like Martino and others have said, it would be too obvious for scum to have played it that way. If you want to look at subtle alliances, look at Sir Jesus' direction. SJ and EM were the first ones to state outright that they thought I was a townie, they were the people who supported me every step of the way. Now you can interpret it as that we are a three-some scum and I suppose many will lynch me with greater belief because of that but once I die you'll see I wasn't in league with them.

Lastly, I think Nerau-Narsis is the 3rd scum if one of the scum didn't hide by voting for EM (which could be Theophilos or still even KevinH once they saw the snowballing consensus against EM) because according to mole's lynch story on D2, only two scum were in the story and I think if there are 3 scum, the reason why only 2 were included because one of them was inactive (Nerau).

I won't be voting to support my cause to prove my innocence. Even if you vote for me, we can still afford a mislynch today.

Vote: No Lynch

[CanucksDynasty]

Boo...only got one day of gaming in.
Go town!!

[Narsis]

Falzis! taht is a very bad move! a very bad move.

we have 8 alive: two mafia(assuming) and 6 townies. imo a mislynch of a townie would be better then a no lynch. you yourself were against a no lynch earlier so why the sudden change of heart? if you are so sure that i'm scum then why not vote me?

imo the following are townies:

Martino and Aquinas. they voted for EM early and had more then enough of a chance to change their votes as the wagon picked up speed. i dont think it would have been hard to come up with some excuse to vote against Kevin.

as for scum...:

don't neglect to look to Theophilos as scum. althoguh he placed the hammer vote, it was CD who placed the real hammer. even if Theophilos voted against Kevin, Em would have died. also, although Falzis could be scum, if i remember correctly it was EM following Falzis for most of the game. i would suggest someone do a reread to confirm that since i can't.

on a side note: i'll be V/LA for 5 days(mole forgot to mention that it seems).

I still have it on the sticky note on my desktop.
It was to be included in the first votecount.

Edited by molestargazer, 27 July 2009 - 04:37 PM.

[KevinH]

EM was killed early as a townie in the last two games. He is due to be scum.

I knew it! Always go with your first thought. (just kidding)

Hypothesis: Electric Mango and Falzis are scum. The 3rd scum that was needed to lynch the townie on day 1 was an inactive player at the time.

It's as good a theory as any.

It's still as good a theory as any.

KevinH (4): Falzis, Sir Jesus, Narsis, Electric Mango
Electric Mango (6): Martino, Aquinas, Kaziocore, KevinH, CanucksDynasty, Theophilos[color="orange"]

Those that voted for Electric Mango are more prone to be townie; those that didn't are more prone to be scum.