864 replies to this topic

[Wolfpacks]

Right lets just get 1 little item corrected, i didnt role claim but was outed by my own neighbour, the other thing bought up was could one of us be scum, that was something i was curious about, with MK having a PR that leaves me and LS, i have no role to claim, just a vanilla my power is in my vote. So its now for youvto decide whats what.

[LordSunday]

Right lets just get 1 little item corrected, i didnt role claim but was outed by my own neighbour, the other thing bought up was could one of us be scum, that was something i was curious about, with MK having a PR that leaves me and LS, i have no role to claim, just a vanilla my power is in my vote. So its now for youvto decide whats what.

 

Ok once again I think I'm being confused with FS.

[Rhizoctonia]

As I already stated, I guarantee one of neighbors is scum. It's who to pick, but SLMK outing him and the two others at least gives us 3 possible targets to hit.

[Wolfpacks]

Sorry misstype i mean FS

Forgot this as well

VOTE FS108

[iSocialism]

I'm thinking one of the three will be scum. Out of those three WP seems the more likely scum to me right now. time is needed for those two to speak up though. I'm also waiting to see how those three will vote.
Well that was a lot of talking in the time it took me to type. Let's wait for FS

[Sister Midnight]

I'm also waiting to see how those three will vote.

Big time!

[Yehom]

As I already stated, I guarantee one of neighbors is scum. It's who to pick, but SLMK outing him and the two others at least gives us 3 possible targets to hit.

Can't agree more

[Wolfpacks]

I'm thinking one of the three will be scum. Out of those three WP seems the more likely scum to me right now. time is needed for those two to speak up though. I'm also waiting to see how those three will vote.
Well that was a lot of talking in the time it took me to type. Let's wait for FS

someone trying to get me lynch much 

[Wolfpacks]

As I already stated, I guarantee one of neighbors is scum. It's who to pick, but SLMK outing him and the two others at least gives us 3 possible targets to hit.

 how exactly can you guarantee one of us is Scum unless you already know who the scum is, which means you either have a power role or you are Scum   

[The Warrior]

"I don't believe it! I don't believe it! Oh, Ron, how wonderful! A prefect! That's everyone in the family!"

"What are Fred and I, next-door neighbours?"

 

Vote Count

Chaplain of Death (2): KevinH, Lyner

FS108 (1): Wolfpacks

iSocialism (1): SeaBeeGipson

Lyner (1): FS108

Supreme Leader MK (1): Chaplain of Death

Finster Baby (0):

KevinH (0):

King Cankles (0):

Kitkat16 (0):

LordSunday (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Wolfpacks (0):

Yehom (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: Finster Baby, iSocialism, KevinH, King Cankles, Kitkat16, LordSunday, Rhizoctonia, Sister Midnight, Supreme Leader MK, Wolfpacks, Yehom

 

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is 1:00pm CST on Wednesday, May 31st.

                   

[LordSunday]

"I don't believe it! I don't believe it! Oh, Ron, how wonderful! A prefect! That's everyone in the family!" "What are Fred and I, next-door neighbours?"

 

Lmao I love the subtle humor there TW

 

 

 

I'm also waiting to see how those three will vote.

 

I'm waiting for this as well. We should keep in mind however we only have ~23 hours until deadline.

[Lyner]

I don't like last minute vote scramblings, so let me start this with my gut feeling:

 

Vote: SLMK

 

 

Wolfpack's panicking seems natural, or does it? Anyway, why do you vote for FS?

[Wolfpacks]

Panicking when did i do that lol, i voted for FS because i know im not scum and i guess i believe MK

[Rhizoctonia]

 

As I already stated, I guarantee one of neighbors is scum. It's who to pick, but SLMK outing him and the two others at least gives us 3 possible targets to hit.

 how exactly can you guarantee one of us is Scum unless you already know who the scum is, which means you either have a power role or you are Scum   

 

 

 

Because it would be absolutely stupid of a game to have 3 people, all town, be neighbors and allowed to talk.  3 people, all knowing they're town would greatly minimize the possible scum.  It only makes sense that TW would have one of the neighbors as scum, to not only have the others believe they're town, but also discuss with them when they can talk on trying to get them to push a lynch on someone, since no one else can see the conversation and if the other neighbors think the 1 scum is town then they maybe easily persuaded. 

 

Hell, look up the role on mafiascum, it even says under game advice:

 

If you are one of three Neighbors, chances are reasonable that one of the other Neighbors is scum.

 

 

The mere fact you're trying to doubt what quite frankly is obvious is very concerning.  There's 1 between you 3....and you have now went up to #1 suspect of them.

Vote:  Wolfpacks

[Chaplain of death]

I don't see why having neighbors exclude you from being a scum

But that explain FS's defenses, tho

 

I doesn't, as has been explained before I could do so. =p

 

From. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Neighbor

""Use and Power
Neighbors are essentially unconfirmed Masons where the moderator honestly acknowledges no expectation of one Neighbor having the same alignment as any other Neighbor. In an ideal world, the alignment of any Neighbor would be as random as the alignment of the player itself. In practice - and especially in Themed games - Neighbor is seen as an excuse to mix scum Neighbors where they would have been called bastard for doing so with a Masonry. The name for this excuse was originally coined by PokerFace

To that end, the real power of Neighbors comes from their ability to speak to each other. Scum players, particularly those that do not like playing as scum, will not be able to maintain a pro-Town appearance for very long if engaged in dialogue like if they were a Mason. Thus, in the hands of skilled players a Neighborhood can function either as a Masonry (if both players are town) or a directed Cop investigation (if one is not town). In the hands of unskilled players, Neighbors are virtually useless.

Thus, Neighbor is a fairly low-tier power role that amplifies the skill of its players. This does not mean that you can stuff a game with them - if the Neighbors deduce that they are all town, they will begin to act like Masons. Masons, to contrast, are quite powerful.

Play Advice
If you are one of three Neighbors, chances are reasonable that one of the other Neighbors is scum."

I can't find the post identifying neighbors in this game, but am I correct in thinking Wolfy, MK, and FS have role claimed as neighbors? And MK is bullet proof?

According to the above, 1 of those three is prolly scum.

FOS on all three. Of the three, MK's weak role claim makes me not want to vote for him on this day, but he's very suspicious looking ATM. And, honestly, his posts make him look scummy. On a related note, it is odd when that he demanded a vote count, posted the vote count, then complained about being "forced to do it" by "you guys." If someone volunteers to do something like a vote count, etc. in a game like this, they shouldn't whine about it and act victimized. That looks manipulative and scummy. MK, I hope you know what you are doing with your RC!

That leaves WP and FS as likely to receive my lynch vote. MK thinks we all trust WP. Why do you think that, MK? Have I missed something? (Outside mafia I'd trust Wolfy in every way, but in game is another story.)


Everything I've said just now is contingent upon my understanding of MK, FS, and WP role claiming as neighbors.

 

THANK YOU! I'm glad someone other than KevinH and I posts the actual links with what the roles do. You should always be able to tell what the roles do from the Mafiascum wiki, if the mod decides to change how a role works compared with mafiascum, they should inform the town as such.

 

Right lets just get 1 little item corrected, i didnt role claim but was outed by my own neighbour, the other thing bought up was could one of us be scum, that was something i was curious about, with MK having a PR that leaves me and LS, i have no role to claim, just a vanilla my power is in my vote. So its now for youvto decide whats what.

 

I want to point out one very major thing here. SLMK outed 2 townies. He may be one but he still roleclaimed for himself and 2 others with one of them potentially being scum. Role claiming for others is very much frowned upon in game except as the result of investigations. Be that as it may its done so with that information there are a couple possibilities.

 

1) He could be scum, and hoping for the townies in his neighbor group to save him by claiming.

2) He could be a townie, who was unaware of the high likelihood of scum being part of the neighbor group (which is a result of ignorance by not looking your own role up).

 

I say he was unaware because in his defense after he claimed he said unequivocally that neighbors are a townie faction which is false.

 

 

As I already stated, I guarantee one of neighbors is scum. It's who to pick, but SLMK outing him and the two others at least gives us 3 possible targets to hit.

 how exactly can you guarantee one of us is Scum unless you already know who the scum is, which means you either have a power role or you are Scum   

 

 

Its highly likely as if there wasn't a scum you would most likely have been Mason's, however, TW also could have used the neighbor roles just to throw the uncertainty in there. Its possible that you are all townies, but its also possible that 1 is scum (or more).

[FS108]

Right lets just get 1 little item corrected, i didnt role claim but was outed by my own neighbour, the other thing bought up was could one of us be scum, that was something i was curious about, with MK having a PR that leaves me and LS, i have no role to claim, just a vanilla my power is in my vote. So its now for youvto decide whats what.

Who knows I know all I can do is sit here and vote, so who knows all I can say we are neighbors and who knows it can be like Xenophilius Lovegood but who knows?

[FS108]

[The Warrior]

"What were you doing under our window, boy?"

"Listening to the news."

"Listening to the news! Again?"

"Well, it changes every day, you see."

 

Vote Count
 

Supreme Leader MK (2): Chaplain of Death, Lyner

Chaplain of Death (1): KevinH

FS108 (1): Wolfpacks

iSocialism (1): SeaBeeGipson

Lyner (1): FS108

Wolfpacks (1): Rhizoctonia

Finster Baby (0):

KevinH (0):

King Cankles (0):

Kitkat16 (0):

LordSunday (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Yehom (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: Finster Baby, iSocialism, KevinH, King Cankles, Kitkat16, LordSunday, Sister Midnight, Supreme Leader MK, Wolfpacks, Yehom

 

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is 1:00pm CST on Wednesday, May 31st.

[FS108]

Sorry misstype i mean FS

Forgot this as well

VOTE FS108

Also since we cant edit FOS Wolfpacks and SLMK
​Reason: I cant tell who is fibbing and who is telling the truth so far one spills the beans saying he is bullet prof which is a bold statement and for an other I don't believe aka wolfpacks because I know my role   

[Yehom]

SLMK gave us a role, FS gave us a name. Unless WP comes with something more believable, I'm inclined to believe he's scum, seeing his previous comments are a bit sketchy as well. 

 

Vote: Wolfpacks