1091 replies to this topic

[Lachiton]

Or as Rhizo said Brewers is probably SK. My point is brewers is staying away from scum hunting, which is not his usual gameplay. Maybe he is not finding the game interesting as lego too complained about the same. Not sure why though, I find the setup of this game interesting and extremely challenging. All I am seeing his posts here are kinda "off" if I must put it that way, along with his implied RC which can be either stupid if he is town or extremely ballsy if he is scum/SK. I am not convinced he is town but if the majority feels that way then I hope I am wrong as with the RC move, brewers has at least prolonged his longevity in this game.

[KevinH]

"Young fool. It was I who bridged your minds. I stoked my apprentice's conflicted soul. I knew he was not strong enough to hide it from you, and you were not wise enough to resist the bait! Now, you will give me Skywalker, and I will kill you with the cruelest stroke." -Supreme Leader Snoke
 
Vote count:

Imran Ehsan (4): SeaBeeGipson, Legoboyvdlp, Brewersalliance, Lord MK,
Chaplain of Death (3): Samus, Canik, Imran Ehsan,
Brewersalliance (3): Yehom, Lachiton, Kitkat16,
Samus (1): Chaplain of Death,  
Kitkat16 (1): Robert2424, 
Canik (0):
Legoboyvdlp (0):
Rafay (0):
LordSunday (0):
Jazzy95 (0):
SeaBeeGipson (0):
Lord MK (0):
iSocialism (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Lachiton (0):
Sister Midnight (0):
Rhizoctonia (0):  
Yehom (0):

No Lynch (0): 

Not voting: Jazzy95, Rhizoctonia, iSocialism, Rafay, Sister Midnight, LordSunday,

 

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, or 5 at deadline.
Deadline is Monday, January 29 at 12:00 noon EST (11.5 hours from this post)

[Canik]

Well only.. just 7 hours I think until deadline.  Seems like we won't get to see if Samus is right or wrong on CoD today and Imran seems very scummy to me with his premature claim and advertising he's a strong power role and being like "Darn you guys! Now I'll probably be killed!".. yeah, if you're really town you probably would be after advertising it that much. I don't buy it, I think Luke Skywalker was a safe name he was given. So..

​Unvote CoD

​Vote Imran



​
​

[Rhizoctonia]

Or as Rhizo said Brewers is probably SK. My point is brewers is staying away from scum hunting, which is not his usual gameplay. Maybe he is not finding the game interesting as lego too complained about the same. Not sure why though, I find the setup of this game interesting and extremely challenging. All I am seeing his posts here are kinda "off" if I must put it that way, along with his implied RC which can be either stupid if he is town or extremely ballsy if he is scum/SK. I am not convinced he is town but if the majority feels that way then I hope I am wrong as with the RC move, brewers has at least prolonged his longevity in this game.

In my opinion the only thing Brewers could be is a SK if he's lying. I can't see a scum or werewolf coming out with an early RC like that. Mainly because I don't think they'd put themselves out there so early when it's only D2 when there's no suspicion, as well as the fake claim is on point in regards to a good one to RC. To me, the only thing that makes sense if he's lying is Kevin gave him a fake RC to make, the basically opposite role of his role the SK, the one immuned.

I'm back and forth as my gut is telling me just stupid choice of him to RC, but also didn't look at his claim as possibly a fake RC for a SK, I was looking at the possibility of him being a scum/werewolf and fake RC which I don't see a member of either doing so D2.

The problem is a SK can easily look to confuse everyone. If there is a SK, he could choose to not kill now for a few nights and everyone think it was some other role that caused 3 deaths and think there's no SK. Then look to start killing again when lower numbers.

I don't believe I've played many games with Brewers so not sure how he plays or his playstyle to compare how he's playing now.

The one benefit I would say with lynching Brewers is that with his partial RC, he's basically made himself a VT. If his only power is immunity to SK, SK won't target him anyway since he already ruined that, so if we Lynch wrong we're only risking lynching basically a VT and not a more important role. If we're wrong and he is retired Marine, we verify pretty much there's a SK. Also if he isn't lying, then I go back to suspicion that Yehom or Lach could be SK being on the Lynch early of pushing the Lynch of the one role they can't kill at night.

Weighing the risk reward. Imran still hasn't replied either. At this point my vote is Imran, Brewers, or KitKat. Imran for the supicion that has been brought his way, brewers because I believe there's a possibility he's the SK and if we're wrong we still are only lynching someone who made themselves a VT instead a more important role and we gain information from his Lynch, and Kikat because he's jumped around on the RC guys and thought Lego was fake RC for which I do think Lego's was a real RC.

[Robert2424]

I'd rather not have a no Lynch day 2.

VOTE IMRAN

[Rhizoctonia]

This sucks because I been waiting for Imrans response as he said he"d reveal what he could over 24 hours ago if it looked like he would be killed. It's now 32 hours from that reply, and no response and 3 1/2 hours before deadline.

Fuck it,

Vote: Brewers

It's a safe choice as the worst if we mislynch we only kill basically a VT because he already pretty much ruined his role. Think there's a possibility he's the SK, using his fake RC role to look town by telling us there's a SK, but also making everyone think its not him. Still think it could just be a poor choice RC by a town, but see the benefit of information we gain from his Lynch and the possibility that is there he is the SK
This sucks because I been waiting for Imrans response as he said he"d reveal what he could over 24 hours ago if it looked like he would be killed. It's now 32 hours from that reply, and no response and 3 1/2 hours before deadline.

Fuck it,

Vote: Brewers

It's a safe choice as the worst if we mislynch we only kill basically a VT because he already pretty much ruined his role. Think there's a possibility he's the SK, using his fake RC role to look town by telling us there's a SK, but also making everyone think its not him. Still think it could just be a poor choice RC by a town, but see the benefit of information we gain from his Lynch and the possibility that is there he is the SK
Sorry looks like it double posted my phone reply.

[legoboyvdlp]

Unvote

Vote Brewers

 

definitely not doing another no lynch, so if there is any need I'll go back to Imran

[brewersalliance]

This sucks because I been waiting for Imrans response as he said he"d reveal what he could over 24 hours ago if it looked like he would be killed. It's now 32 hours from that reply, and no response and 3 1/2 hours before deadline.

Fuck it,

Vote: Brewers

It's a safe choice as the worst if we mislynch we only kill basically a VT because he already pretty much ruined his role. Think there's a possibility he's the SK, using his fake RC role to look town by telling us there's a SK, but also making everyone think its not him. Still think it could just be a poor choice RC by a town, but see the benefit of information we gain from his Lynch and the possibility that is there he is the SK
This sucks because I been waiting for Imrans response as he said he"d reveal what he could over 24 hours ago if it looked like he would be killed. It's now 32 hours from that reply, and no response and 3 1/2 hours before deadline.

Fuck it,

Vote: Brewers

It's a safe choice as the worst if we mislynch we only kill basically a VT because he already pretty much ruined his role. Think there's a possibility he's the SK, using his fake RC role to look town by telling us there's a SK, but also making everyone think its not him. Still think it could just be a poor choice RC by a town, but see the benefit of information we gain from his Lynch and the possibility that is there he is the SK
Sorry looks like it double posted my phone reply.

nah, im not the SK, it was just a poor choice on my part.  if i was actually the sk i wouldnt have done something like that which could draw attention to myself.   but what lahciton said before pretty much sums it up.  im just for some reason not able to hold an interest in this game.  i honestly have no idea why, as I am a huge star wars nerd.   maybe thats kind of why I lack interest in this game, cause deep down i was kind of irritated i didnt get a dark side role, as I am all about the dark side and it just became kind of hard for me to care, idk.  

 

but yeah no, im not the sk.  im town but like you said its a safe lynch.  unfortunately, youre not gonna get the SK, but you arent really gonna get a power role either, since im basically a slightly more powerful vt.  plus with my lack of interest, I haven't been doing much scum hunting, so lynching me would not be that bad of a thing for the town versus accidentally lynching a town power role, or someone who is more committed to scum hunting

[legoboyvdlp]

Unvote 

Vote: Imran

[brewersalliance]

Also if he isn't lying, then I go back to suspicion that Yehom or Lach could be SK being on the Lynch early of pushing the Lynch of the one role they can't kill at night.

 

 

 

also a good point, so when im lynched and flip town, look at those two for being so quick to jump on me for being potentially the sk, since I am a kill they would not be able to get at night, so they would either have to lynch me, or hope mafia kills me 

Unvote

Vote Brewers

 

definitely not doing another no lynch, so if there is any need I'll go back to Imran

 

 

Unvote 

Vote: Imran

well that was quick lol, switched back to imran off me within 8 min haha any reason why?  was my statement just that convincing?   im not complaining or anything, I just think its strange to flop back and forth so quick there 

[SeaBeeGipson]

Unvote

Vote Brewers

 

definitely not doing another no lynch, so if there is any need I'll go back to Imran

Can someone get a tally of how many times Lego has jumped votes?

To Imran: I enjoy how you keep referring to a name claim as a role claim, as if they are equivalent. 

To Rhizo: I'm lost now. Weren't you FoSing everyone who voted for Brewers just one page ago? I'm lost on what information could be gained with a Brewers lynch, that we wouldn't get elsewhere. Worst case, we lynch an overpowered VT. Best case, we hit the SK. I don't see what information outside of "FoS on those on his wagon" we'd gain, which is kind of the same spot we are in now. People have been accusing those on Lego and Brewers wagon for a decent part of the day, but it doesn't seem much has fermented there. I just don't see the huge gain on information that we don't already seem to have. Of course, if he is the SK, we could at least save another person from being NK'ed but with supposedly two mafia factions at play, he also has a chance to hit them. I don't see the benefit to fake claiming so early in the game, which might be why I'm skeptical that he would fake claim

[Sister Midnight]

I’m confused AF right now. I tend to believe Brewsky’s role claim, and it doesn’t make sense to purposely lynch a vanilla townie. To me the person who looks most scummy is Imran, I hate to vote or him, but

VOTE IMRAN

[Rhizoctonia]

Unvote
Vote Brewers

definitely not doing another no lynch, so if there is any need I'll go back to Imran

Can someone get a tally of how many times Lego has jumped votes?

To Imran: I enjoy how you keep referring to a name claim as a role claim, as if they are equivalent.

To Rhizo: I'm lost now. Weren't you FoSing everyone who voted for Brewers just one page ago? I'm lost on what information could be gained with a Brewers lynch, that we wouldn't get elsewhere. Worst case, we lynch an overpowered VT. Best case, we hit the SK. I don't see what information outside of "FoS on those on his wagon" we'd gain, which is kind of the same spot we are in now. People have been accusing those on Lego and Brewers wagon for a decent part of the day, but it doesn't seem much has fermented there. I just don't see the huge gain on information that we don't already seem to have. Of course, if he is the SK, we could at least save another person from being NK'ed but with supposedly two mafia factions at play, he also has a chance to hit them. I don't see the benefit to fake claiming so early in the game, which might be why I'm skeptical that he would fake claim

The FOS is still there depending on what Brewers comes out as. If he comes out as immuned to SK, then it would put concern that those on his wagon could be SK, wanting to Lynch him as the SK couldn't kill him at night. This of course would include me, but I see this as the best choice.


What we will possibly find out from his Lynch.

1. If he's SK we kill the SK, win win

2. He comes up retired Marine.
- We verify likely there's a SK and that's why it was a 3rd death last night, instead of a paranoid gunowner
- If we don't Lynch him, we start tomorrow still not having any idea of there is a SK, besides again believing Brewers roleclaim. If there is a SK, he could not kill tomorrow and then we sit here still debating is there one, or was the 3rd death N1 due to something else
- If wrong, we lose a glorified VT at this point. His role is useless as if he's telling the truth a SK won't target him so he basically has no power. Better that then someone with more important role and not ruined one
- If wrong, then personally I'd be suspicious of people on him, especially early on as possible SK's. They'd want him lynched. So I'd dig into Yehom/lach/kitkat, though as I stated, less suspicious of KitKat on this point as he held strong on his vote on Lego prior after Brewers RC, and didn't switch til after.

Imran, if telling the truth about a more important role leads to a bigger loss then a VT now in brewers. I also don't like many just merely followed you onto Imran without really any of their own opinion outside of saying you make good points. Though if Imran is town, him admitting he is an important role means he'll likely be killed tonight unless there's a doc to save him.

[Lord MK]

Unofficial Vote count:

Imran Ehsan (7): SeaBeeGipson, Brewersalliance, Lord MK, Canik, Robert2424, Sister Midnight, legoboyvdlp
Brewersalliance (4): Yehom, Lachiton, Kitkat16, Rhizoctonia
Chaplain of Death (2): Samus, Imran Ehsan,
Samus (1): Chaplain of Death
Kitkat16 (0):
Canik (0):
Legoboyvdlp (0):
Rafay (0):
LordSunday (0):
Jazzy95 (0):
SeaBeeGipson (0):
Lord MK (0):
iSocialism (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Lachiton (0):
Sister Midnight (0):
Rhizoctonia (0):
Yehom (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Jazzy95, iSocialism, Rafay, LordSunday


With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, or 5 at deadline.
Deadline is Monday, January 29 at 12:00 noon EST


The deadline is up, Kevin is still to show up.
But either way, Imran is lynched.

Since technically it is twilight and we have till Kevin shows up, to post anything we wish to say before night.
I think if Imran is online and he has a role and he used it N1, he should share the details.
That will help the town, at least.

And you can RC in full if you can.
It won't be able to save you as the deadline is over, but you can do your bit for the town.

[Lachiton]

Lego changed his vote to Imran again so Imran is at 7 and brewers at 4.
So Imran has been lynched.

[Lord MK]

He did?

Fos: Lego

I know where my vote is at tomorrow at least.

[brewersalliance]

Lego changed his vote to Imran again so Imran is at 7 and brewers at 4.
So Imran has been lynched.

yeah he unvoted imran then voted me, then 8 min later he unvoted me and voted imran lol

 

Unofficial Vote count:

Imran Ehsan (7): SeaBeeGipson, Brewersalliance, Lord MK, Canik, Robert2424, Sister Midnight, legoboyvdlp
Brewersalliance (4): Yehom, Lachiton, Kitkat16, Rhizoctonia
Chaplain of Death (2): Samus, Imran Ehsan,
Samus (1): Chaplain of Death
Kitkat16 (0):
Canik (0):
Legoboyvdlp (0):
Rafay (0):
LordSunday (0):
Jazzy95 (0):
SeaBeeGipson (0):
Lord MK (0):
iSocialism (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Lachiton (0):
Sister Midnight (0):
Rhizoctonia (0):
Yehom (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Jazzy95, iSocialism, Rafay, LordSunday


With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, or 5 at deadline.
Deadline is Monday, January 29 at 12:00 noon EST


The deadline is up, Kevin is still to show up.
But either way, Imran is lynched.

Since technically it is twilight and we have till Kevin shows up, to post anything we wish to say before night.
I think if Imran is online and he has a role and he used it N1, he should share the details.
That will help the town, at least.

And you can RC in full if you can.
It won't be able to save you as the deadline is over, but you can do your bit for the town.

hey im not dead lol

[legoboyvdlp]

if you're talking about hammers, Robert did that

 

I'm regretting getting into this game, I have no idea what to do

[Sister Midnight]

"Young fool. It was I who bridged your minds. I stoked my apprentice's conflicted soul. I knew he was not strong enough to hide it from you, and you were not wise enough to resist the bait! Now, you will give me Skywalker, and I will kill you with the cruelest stroke." -Supreme Leader Snoke Vote count:

Imran Ehsan (4): SeaBeeGipson, Legoboyvdlp, Brewersalliance, Lord MK,Chaplain of Death (3): Samus, Canik, Imran Ehsan,Brewersalliance (3): Yehom, Lachiton, Kitkat16,Samus (1): Chaplain of Death,  Kitkat16 (1): Robert2424, Canik (0):Legoboyvdlp (0):Rafay (0):LordSunday (0):Jazzy95 (0):SeaBeeGipson (0):Lord MK (0):iSocialism (0):Robert2424 (0):Lachiton (0):Sister Midnight (0):Rhizoctonia (0):  Yehom (0):No Lynch (0): Not voting: Jazzy95, Rhizoctonia, iSocialism, Rafay, Sister Midnight, LordSunday,

 With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, or 5 at deadline.Deadline is Monday, January 29 at 12:00 noon EST (11.5 hours from this post)

Wait! What? That would be midnight, you said noon. I would have waited to vote.

[Sister Midnight]

Crap I didn’t mean to post that! Lmao