We don't have to have a mislynch.

 

Also, I don't know how it would help the vig. Any lynch wagon wouldn't have me or Kevin on it, weather we are town or scum. We  known too well as no lynchers on day one. 

while some are firmly on the lynch day 1 every game stance....

 

Yeah, we absolutely don't have to have one. I really don't have a stance on ml/nl on D1, kinda just depends on how things play out, I suppose.

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

vote SBG

 

because every game SM plays with SBG, SBG is scum

 

 

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

vote SBG

 

because every game SM plays with SBG, SBG is scum

Sm is not here.

 

 

 

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

vote SBG

 

because every game SM plays with SBG, SBG is scum

Sm is not here.

Boom. Get rekt.

 

Also is Kevin advocating for a D1 lynch?

 

 

 

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

vote SBG

 

because every game SM plays with SBG, SBG is scum

Sm is not here.

Vote SM for not being here

 

 

 

 

Welcome to the game killer.

 

Vote: Col Med

 

You dare give me such a role that you gave me? You shall pay.

vote SBG

 

because every game SM plays with SBG, SBG is scum

Sm is not here.

Boom. Get rekt.

 

Also is Kevin advocating for a D1 lynch?

Vote kevinH for wanting a D1 lunch. That had to mean he is scum

These quote chains are going to drive me wild

Oh hello new person

 

Unvotw

vote campinkiller

Also is Kevin advocating for a D1 lynch?

 

Yes.

 

There is no cop so we won't know anything more on Day 2 than we do on Day 1. We have to lynch and get lucky.

I would love nothing more to have Kevin be lynch day one because he wants to lynch day one. Though, he has a point, our votes are our best weapons.

 

However, Kevin what happens when we accidentally lynch the backup role on day one?

These quote chains are going to drive me wild

Jessica Alba drives me wild

Oh hello new person

 

Unvotw

vote campinkiller

Damn beat me too it

 

Vote KevinH

 

Because he isn't no lynching

If we assume it follows the pre setup, 12 players, 3 scum?, Witch would make 9 town. If we mislynch today, we can only mislynch one more before a mislynch causes mafia victory. If we don't Lynch today, it won't be until day 4. Honestly no lynching gives the best shot, also odds wise. Course this is worse case scenario and if I'm correct on number of scum.

 

I might be in the minority for no lynch, but I believe it'll help us most odds wise.

alright constant voting an unvoting over

 

sorry medved.  if you mod kill me id understand

 

anyways

 

im never a fan of no lynch.  the only thing that bugs me is if we kill the jailer, scum will get an extra power role.  the odds of that happening are only 8.3% though, so I dont think that should be a huge factor with this lynch.

 

Id be okay with either lynching the most inactive townie, or anyone who has a history of negativly impacting the game from the towns perspective-as best case we get scum, worst case we get a townie who really doesnt help us win.
 

obviously if someone does something super scummy, id be down to change my opinion on who to vote for.

 

  KevinH suggesting we actually lynch is one of two things.  Scum kevin saying we should lynch cause we dont have a cop, and this means I am town because as scum this would be suicide for me

 

Or

 

Town Kevin realizing no lynch does not help town as we have no investigative roles

 

 

Good luck, town. And pray that the goat will help us win

 

 

Fear not. I'll help us win like always. Yet you gotta not vote for me.

 

Yes Kevin advocating for a D1 lynch does sound strange but I guess I agree.

 

Vote: TW

 

For bringing up past game events and trying to influence people negatively against the best hope of the town. Thats classic mafia strategy.

Any reasonable person knows that town lying to town is bad.

Vote Count

 

brewersalliance (1): Lachiton

Robert2424 (0): 

Lachiton (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0): 

KevinH (1): Wolfpacks

Wolfpacks (0): 

The Warrior (1): Rafay

Rafay (2): Robert2424, The Warrior

CampinKiller (1): brewersalliance

Lord MK (0): 

iSocialism (0): 

Velocity (0): 

 

Not Voting:  SeaBeeGipson, KevinH, CampinKiller, Lord MK, iSocialism, Velocity

 

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is December 3rd and 2:00pm CST

Any reasonable person knows that town lying to town is bad.

I prefer to Lynch all liars

Have I lied to the town in this game? If so, then hang me.

 

There should be definitely 9 town 3 mafia otherwise we are screwed.

 

So we can mis lynch for 3 consecutive days.

 

But with 4:1 town mafia ration we may hit 1-2 mafia out of 6 kills which may prolong the days.

 

Any reasonable person knows that town lying to town is bad.

I prefer to Lynch all liars

There are situations where lying can be beneficial tho. So just cause you lie about something doesn't mean you should be lynched no matter what. The lying TW is talking about is not one of those situations tho

Have I lied to the town in this game? If so, then hang me.

 

There should be definitely 9 town 3 mafia otherwise we are screwed.

 

So we can mis lynch for 3 consecutive days.

 

But with 4:1 town mafia ration we may hit 1-2 mafia out of 6 kills which may prolong the days.

I think TW is referring to previous games as you do have a track record of saying some things that aren't true. However in the last game I don't think it was the case, I don't think you intentionally lied about killing TW, I think you either missed my message or thought I made a mistake.

 

Now this could be TW just trying to help the town, or he could be scum trying to use our general consensus against rafay to lynch a townie and if rafay did turn up town after a lynch, no one would really hold it against TW for pushing it. So it's a safe scum play imo

I'm not saying that makes TW scum. I'm just saying even tho many townies might think a rafay lynch will benefit town, TW suggesting it does not make him town either

Rafay seems awfully defensive...

 

Any reasonable person knows that town lying to town is bad.

I prefer to Lynch all liars

 

This is a generally accepted policy in mafia and should be for good reason.

 

 

 

Any reasonable person knows that town lying to town is bad.

I prefer to Lynch all liars

There are situations where lying can be beneficial tho. So just cause you lie about something doesn't mean you should be lynched no matter what. The lying TW is talking about is not one of those situations tho

Have I lied to the town in this game? If so, then hang me.

 

There should be definitely 9 town 3 mafia otherwise we are screwed.

 

So we can mis lynch for 3 consecutive days.

 

But with 4:1 town mafia ration we may hit 1-2 mafia out of 6 kills which may prolong the days.

I think TW is referring to previous games as you do have a track record of saying some things that aren't true. However in the last game I don't think it was the case, I don't think you intentionally lied about killing TW, I think you either missed my message or thought I made a mistake.

 

Now this could be TW just trying to help the town, or he could be scum trying to use our general consensus against rafay to lynch a townie and if rafay did turn up town after a lynch, no one would really hold it against TW for pushing it. So it's a safe scum play imo

I'm not saying that makes TW scum. I'm just saying even tho many townies might think a rafay lynch will benefit town, TW suggesting it does not make him town either

Lying can be beneficial in certain situations but that doesn't make it a good policy. As a general rule of thumb "Lynch All Liars" is a good policy.

 

Yes, I am trying to help the town by making sure it's known that town lying to town is not a good policy.

 

No, I haven't seen a reason that is specific to this game to lynch Rafay yet. I was voting to raise a point.

 

Unvote

Velocity is the only player who has not posted yet btw.

 

@Velocity - Any thoughts so far?

I do think, like always, that we need to go for a lynch or at least the action of going for a lynch. There's been a lot of progress on this day which is good thing. With everyone noticing that a lunch might be imminent. Everyone is getting on the defensive side. Lots of votes flying around meaning lots of little things to look at.

 

VOTE Kevin

 

I mean advocating for a lynch on day one. I have only seen that like once before, and you were a scum. However you do go for no lynches even when you are scum.

 

 

With everyone noticing that a lunch might be imminent.

 

Really?? No one bothered to invite me.

I didn’t see that we started lol, I’m here, and like I’ve stated however many times before, unless I’m needed to or have good reason to vote I prefer to not vote. A D1 Lynch could be beneficial to us, considering we might take out a scum, but we could also potentially take out one of the important players, like the jailer, would give scum a power role, so if I’m called upon to vote I might, but for now I’m gonna avoid it, as is my policy.