That’s a good enough reason

 

Vote medved

 

 

Sheeping. lol. 

 

 

 

Sheep indeed lol. D1 is just a random voting fest, I've posted enough to not get mod killed which is my goal for D1. If you want to kill a townie this early in the game then go ahead, but it would be a terrible start to the game. I still stand on my belief that random voting accomplishes nothing, at best you might get lucky and hit scum but most of the time you just kill townies.

If you believe that then why did you "sheep" right after I voted Kvrest for inactivity and then keep your vote on him. If you think d1 lynching is pointless, why try to form a wagon? You are contradicting yourself...

So now you unvote, but only after being called out for trying to form a wagon?

 

You had plenty of time to unvote before now... And it feels like the only reason you are doing so is to try to defend yourself and take suspicion off you...

 

If you believe that then why did you "sheep" right after I voted Kvrest for inactivity and then keep your vote on him. If you think d1 lynching is pointless, why try to form a wagon? You are contradicting yourself...

 

 

Because i haven't looked at the thread since i last voted tbh, i've unvote now (my last post merged with the one i made before you). I'm not trying to form a wagon against Kverst, the difference between mine and his situation is that i've already posted enough for D1. At the time he had only made 1 post, which would have gotten him lynched. 

What's different about me Wolfpacks??

What's different about me Wolfpacks??

Your more active now

 

I thought you wanted a d1 lynch? Considering we have no idea about PRs or whether we have another scum faction or SK, wagon analysis might be best lead to go off on d2, unless cop or tracker, if they exist, tastes success.

Cons of a d1 lynch is we hit cop/tracker forcing an early rc.

Worst case if we might hit a cop, they could RC and hope there is a doctor or some protective role.

 

Again we dont know what roles exists so I'd rather not depend on such roles even existing.

Agreed.

 

In the meantime iSoc has been too quiet to my liking.

Vote: iSoc

 

Just a reminder...

 

 

All live players must make a minimum of 3 posts in the game thread per game day. Any player who does not meet the 3 post minimum on a given day will be subject to being mod-killed unless a legitimate reason for the lack of posting is communicated privately to the game mod. (In the event that something comes up that will prevent you from playing actively, please alert the mod so that a potential replacement can be found.) If multiple players have not met the post minimum on a given day, the player with the fewest overall posts will be mod-killed.

 

 

 

Deadline is tuesday, and both isoc and kevin are short right now so hopefully they are able to post more so we dont have a mod kill.... unless either of you are scum, then please dont post again

I approve this message.

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

 

 

I thought you wanted a d1 lynch? Considering we have no idea about PRs or whether we have another scum faction or SK, wagon analysis might be best lead to go off on d2, unless cop or tracker, if they exist, tastes success.

Cons of a d1 lynch is we hit cop/tracker forcing an early rc.

Worst case if we might hit a cop, they could RC and hope there is a doctor or some protective role.

 

Again we dont know what roles exists so I'd rather not depend on such roles even existing.

Agreed.

 

In the meantime iSoc has been too quiet to my liking.

Vote: iSoc

 

this is a good point.  iSoc has been posting a fair amount in the other game and nothing here... 

Isoc isn't usually that active.....

 

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

 

 

This is the stupidest reasoning I have ever heard. Just because I agree doesn't mean anything. I haven't voted for kvrest or kevin. My vote sits firmly on CM. If you think I am wagoning you are sadly mistaken and should reread my actions so far. Plus brewers and I are inseparable. You would know that if you were an active council member.   

things seem to be getting too personal.  Calm down...lol. 

things seem to be getting too personal.  Calm down...lol. 

 

You're right. I'm very sorry SeaBee.

It's Day 1 and nobody knows nuthin'.

 

No-lynch for the win (for the town). 

 

 

Plus brewers and I are inseparable.

 

scum confirmed lol

 

 

It's Day 1 and nobody knows nuthin'.

 

No-lynch for the win (for the town). 

no one knows nothing and if we no lynch, we won't know anything D2 either

 

 

 

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

 

This is the stupidest reasoning I have ever heard. Just because I agree doesn't mean anything. I haven't voted for kvrest or kevin. My vote sits firmly on CM. If you think I am wagoning you are sadly mistaken and should reread my actions so far. Plus brewers and I are inseparable. You would know that if you were an active council member.

What is your reason for voting for me then? Other than just because Brewers is? Either you are a noob scum trying to bus a townie early or just new in mafia and just are acting scummy (the same goes for kverst)

 

 

 

 

It's Day 1 and nobody knows nuthin'.

 

No-lynch for the win (for the town). 

 

no one knows nothing and if we no lynch, we won't know anything D2 either

 

Ah the eternal battle. To lynch or not to lynch, that is the question...

 

Lynching today is random. We might get scum, we might get town. There are more town than scum, therefore we are more likely to lynch town. But if it looks like we are going to lynch scum, their scum buddies may try to prevent the suspect, which would give town info in our scum hunt.

 

If we don’t lynch peeps with investigative powers will investigate, and perhaps lead us away from bad lynch, or help us find scum.

 

HOWEVER there is one thing that tips the balance ever so slightly: SBG is ALMOST always scum when I play. And so I my vote shall stand.

 

I am curious how others think through the Day 1 lynch question.

 

 

 

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

This is the stupidest reasoning I have ever heard. Just because I agree doesn't mean anything. I haven't voted for kvrest or kevin. My vote sits firmly on CM. If you think I am wagoning you are sadly mistaken and should reread my actions so far. Plus brewers and I are inseparable. You would know that if you were an active council member.

What is your reason for voting for me then? Other than just because Brewers is? Either you are a noob scum trying to bus a townie early or just new in mafia and just are acting scummy (the same goes for kverst)

 

You hadn't posted in a while, then out of the blue showed up to vote me. Your only other posts early on were before everyone started voting people up. And what you have just posted sounds more like just an attack on me and Nadarr just for being new and possibly being onto something. 

 

 

 

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

This is the stupidest reasoning I have ever heard. Just because I agree doesn't mean anything. I haven't voted for kvrest or kevin. My vote sits firmly on CM. If you think I am wagoning you are sadly mistaken and should reread my actions so far. Plus brewers and I are inseparable. You would know that if you were an active council member.

What is your reason for voting for me then? Other than just because Brewers is? Either you are a noob scum trying to bus a townie early or just new in mafia and just are acting scummy (the same goes for kverst)

 

You hadn't posted in a while, then out of the blue showed up to vote me. Your only other posts early on were before everyone started voting people up. And what you have just posted sounds more like just an attack on me and Nadarr just for being new and possibly being onto something. 

 

 

 

@CM I have always played aggressively when it comes to Mafia (I play with my friends). I also think very similarly to the way brewers does. I know this because I have read through multiple games in the Forum to get a feel for everyone's play style. That is why I agree with brewers a lot. I like his logic, but at the same time I take everything he says with a grain of salt because he can smooth talk his way through a lot and I have read a couple games where I suspected he was scum early on but no one else caught it and they died because of that. As much as I don't want to be D1 lynch since this is my first game with yall, I will not apologize for my play style. If that makes you think I am scum so be it, but I am not and it would be a bad start to the game.

 

 

 

 

Inb4 Brewers post another opinion you agree with.

 

How many times have you piggy backed off brewers so far?

 

FoS: Nadaar

This is the stupidest reasoning I have ever heard. Just because I agree doesn't mean anything. I haven't voted for kvrest or kevin. My vote sits firmly on CM. If you think I am wagoning you are sadly mistaken and should reread my actions so far. Plus brewers and I are inseparable. You would know that if you were an active council member.

What is your reason for voting for me then? Other than just because Brewers is? Either you are a noob scum trying to bus a townie early or just new in mafia and just are acting scummy (the same goes for kverst)

 

You hadn't posted in a while, then out of the blue showed up to vote me. Your only other posts early on were before everyone started voting people up. And what you have just posted sounds more like just an attack on me and Nadarr just for being new and possibly being onto something. 

 

 

 

@CM I have always played aggressively when it comes to Mafia (I play with my friends). I also think very similarly to the way brewers does. I know this because I have read through multiple games in the Forum to get a feel for everyone's play style. That is why I agree with brewers a lot. I like his logic, but at the same time I take everything he says with a grain of salt because he can smooth talk his way through a lot and I have read a couple games where I suspected he was scum early on but no one else caught it and they died because of that. As much as I don't want to be D1 lynch since this is my first game with yall, I will not apologize for my play style. If that makes you think I am scum so be it, but I am not and it would be a bad start to the game.

 

 

I'm not asking you to apologize for anything Nadarr, i was just asking if there was a reason behind your vote on me outside of brewers also voting. Is there one other than that? 

 

And to Kverst; i'm not attacking you or Nadarr, just airing my concerns and theories. I voted for you simply because you had 1 post at the time, which would have gotten you lynched due to the activity rule. I have posted enough to not get mod killed, and have been sitting in the background mainly because D1 has no substance so there is no real reason to post. I've also been modding my mafia game as well 

 

 

He jumped on Kvrest right after I voted for Kvrest for activity, perhaps he was trying to form a quick wagon on him, which basically happened as MK also quickly voted for Kvrest as well...

 

This reasoning made a lot of sense to me which is why I voted for you. Since it is D1, we have to look at every action and explanation to try and find something to vote against. While you might very well be town, I don't want a D1 no-lynch so my vote will remain until I feel you are less scummy, or a better option presents yourself. I am not 100% sure about you so if a wagon does begin to form around you I will reconsider my vote because I don't want to lynch someone based on too little, but I also don't want my vote to go to waste. 

 

He jumped on Kvrest right after I voted for Kvrest for activity, perhaps he was trying to form a quick wagon on him, which basically happened as MK also quickly voted for Kvrest as well...

 

This reasoning made a lot of sense to me which is why I voted for you. Since it is D1, we have to look at every action and explanation to try and find something to vote against. While you might very well be town, I don't want a D1 no-lynch so my vote will remain until I feel you are less scummy, or a better option presents yourself. I am not 100% sure about you so if a wagon does begin to form around you I will reconsider my vote because I don't want to lynch someone based on too little, but I also don't want my vote to go to waste. 

 

 

I've already explained my reasoning on the vote on Kverst twice, including in my last post. And i would consider there already being a wagon on me, since i am one vote away from lynch lol

Can we get an updated vote count?

 

 

Your more active now

 

Haven't you been playing the last 5-6 games???

On Day 2, someone will know somethin'.

 

(assuming there are some investigative roles, which is a pretty good assumption)

Vote Count

 

Brewersalliance (0):

CampinKiller (0):

Colonel Medved (2): Brewersalliance, Nadarr

iSocialism (1):  Lachiton

KevinH (1): Rafay

Kverst (1): Lord MK

Lachiton (0):

Lord MK (0):

Nadarr (0):

Rafay (0):

Robert2424 (0):

SeaBeeGipson (2): Sister Midnight, Robert2424

Sister Midnight (1): SeaBeeGipson

Wolfpacks (0):

 

No Lynch (3): Wolfpacks, KevinH, Kverst

 

Not Voting: CampinKiller, Colonel MedVed, iSocialism

 

With 14 players alive it take 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 3:00pm CN Server time on Tuesday, December 18th.

 

Currently in line to be mod-killed: iSocialism (2 posts on day 1)

You are right CM. I thought Brewers had unvoted. I'm not sure so...

 

Unvote