597 replies to this topic

[Sister Midnight]

No I was wondering why it was such a big deal to Robert.

I don't see why I should have to name claim. I explained why I unvoted yesterday after his name because I believed him because of my role. Cause I'm a dragon. Is there a 3rd, I have no idea. But assuming the lore revolves around the 3 dragons, I'm willing to bet there probably is. This could be an Avenue Scum try to Fake RC with. Meaning claiming one of the remaining 2 dragons. Scum probally has limited options for fake names. I'm putting a Danger upon scum for not claiming. If for some reason there is only just 2 dragons, Idk if they would be willing to try to fake claim. It be a 50-50 shot, but if that was there only option, I imagine they'd take it. I'd rather have a chance to catch scum with my role then not. Scum should be looking for a fake claim, unless Brewers gave them some. My objective is to make it very hard for scum. 
 
I may very well claim before the day is over, If I believe it'll help the town. 

I must have misunderstood your earlier post. I thought you said you’re Drogon.

[LordSunday]

What perplexes me now is after that long winded post about forcing scum to take a shot in the dark... I don't think they'd be stupid enough (especially now) to try and claim the name of a dragon when as it's been stated; likely all 3 dragons are in play. That means most likely no matter which name is claimed there would most likely be a counter claim of the same name (assuming again scum is that stupid to try).

 

Jazzy and Nadarr are both still very quiet, and as the day continues that's going to draw more of my focus

 

@Mod could we get a vote count and post count of those below the req amount for the day? Please

[brewersalliance]

I'll get another vote count tomorrow. We got another foot + of snow and it's gonna be -60 out the next few days so I've been cleaning snow again all day

[Rhizoctonia]

No I was wondering why it was such a big deal to Robert.

If this is what you and Rhizo were referring to then that makes sense.

Yea, I don't think you originally got what I was saying with my comment.

My point was why it was a big deal for Robert to withhold it. I don't see the real big deal to admit what dragon name he was.

[Robert2424]

Its more over the only thing going on. 

 

VOTE JAZZY

 

Where are you?

[Jazzy95]

I'm alive, lots of things dumped on me lately but I'll reread what's already been said. I know someone brought up my lynch of MK. I gave my reason and would've started the wagon had KevinH not beat me to it.

[Robert2424]

One down, 

 

Unvote

Vote Nadarr

 

Where you go now?

[Rhizoctonia]

What perplexes me now is after that long winded post about forcing scum to take a shot in the dark... I don't think they'd be stupid enough (especially now) to try and claim the name of a dragon when as it's been stated; likely all 3 dragons are in play. That means most likely no matter which name is claimed there would most likely be a counter claim of the same name (assuming again scum is that stupid to try).

 

Jazzy and Nadarr are both still very quiet, and as the day continues that's going to draw more of my focus

 

@Mod could we get a vote count and post count of those below the req amount for the day? Please

 

 

^precisely

 

There's literally a huge cast of GoT, you literally have tons of options to fake claim as, and less risky ones.  Let alone, I'm not sold on this idea that scum weren't given a alternate name to RC as, as some have claimed.  There's been very few games that are based off a story/book/etc that involve characters that scum are not given another name to claim.  Could it happen, sure, as outside of scum no one knows and each game can be different then the others, but statistically it's very unlikely if based on most Mafia games on here.  I surely agree that when someone RC's that they should provide their name, for off chance that they didn't get one thus forcing scum to possibly pick an alternate name that could actually be the same as someone else, but it's not necessarily a make or break with finding scum if they did get a fake RC.  I know if I was scum, given that one Dragon name was already claimed, I surely wouldn't go the route of picking another Dragon name due to fear all 3 names are likely used if 1 was.

[The Warrior]

In addition to the character names/roles that we've already been given in this game and how they each have interacted with the GoT lore:

 

Another reason that I tend to believe that fake claims may not have been given in this game is because Brewers is writing flavor text for game updates but in this game they are not directly associated with the particular action of the day/night. This is different from the last game in that regard.

 

And for what it's worth, I didn't give scum fake name claims in all of the Harry Potter games.

[Rhizoctonia]

In addition to the character names/roles that we've already been given in this game and how they each have interacted with the GoT lore:

 

Another reason that I tend to believe that fake claims may not have been given in this game is because Brewers is writing flavor text for game updates but in this game they are not directly associated with the particular action of the day/night. This is different from the last game in that regard.

 

And for what it's worth, I didn't give scum fake name claims in all of the Harry Potter games.

 

 

True point, i think I do remember being a scum in one of those and not being given one.  Well then my statement is not as factual as I thought, just seems like most times I've played scum I usually was.  

[Sister Midnight]

I would be a little surprised if Brewers gave fake names for role claiming. Did he do it with the last GoT game? It seems very un-Brewsky-as-GRRM for him to give fake roll clams.

[Rhizoctonia]

I would be a little surprised if Brewers gave fake names for role claiming. Did he do it with the last GoT game? It seems very un-Brewsky-as-GRRM for him to give fake roll clams.

 

 

Yes he did give me a fake RC name as SK (I never needed to use)

[Sister Midnight]

I would be a little surprised if Brewers gave fake names for role claiming. Did he do it with the last GoT game? It seems very un-Brewsky-as-GRRM for him to give fake roll clams.

 
 
Yes he did give me a fake RC name as SK (I never needed to use)

In that case idk wtf.

[Yehom]

Vote: Robert

 

You're stalling and distracting. Either you give us something to off of or hold your tongue forever 

[Nadarr]

Dude, I have been gone for a day. Chill out a little. I really don't have much more to add at the moment. We are still talking about Robert's role claim which seems like something stupid to be arguing over. He didn't fully claim, but is it honestly that big a deal. Even if I agree with TW and his assumptions of possible characters does it still matter? If Robert is a dragon, which one doesn't mean anything; he would still be town no matter which one he is.

[Robert2424]

Vote: Robert

 

You're stalling and distracting. Either you give us something to off of or hold your tongue forever 

I'm making conversation, all your votes do is role digging. "Lets vote for him to say his name". Exactly what it looks like. 

[brewersalliance]

Vote Count 4.01

Colonel Medved (0) 

iSocialism (0) 

Jazzy (0)

LordSunday (0)

Nadarr (1) Robert2424

Rhizoctonia (0)

Robert2424 (2)  Colonel Medved, Yehom

Sister Midnight (0)

The Warrior (0) 

Yehom (0)

 

Not Voting :  iSocialism, Jazzy, LordSunday, Nadarr,Rhizoctonia,  Sister Midnight, The Warrior, 

 

 

Currently in Danger of a mod kill:  iSocialism, 1 post

 

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch or 3 at deadline.  Deadline is Friday, Feb 1 at 10:00 am CN time.

[Robert2424]

UNVOTE

As you can see, by the vote count literally nothing is going on.

[Robert2424]

So it seems up to me to make a lagament push as no one else is willing to to do anything.

If we where to go off wagons alone, I'd could go after TW however I think there is a better way to go after that later. Yehom has been more of a bully, and while I suspect him, he's actions could be justified. Jazzy and naderr are too quiet that's for sure. I want to also hear CM current scum reads and why he's only been in the background thus far. I imagine 1 person being scum on kvest wagon. Leaving Lord Sunday and Rhizo as my canadites.

Rhizo at first suspected TW but voted with TW today. @Rhizo has your view changed at all? Any other scum reads? Did you expect the kvestlynch to go through or would you have unvoted if you were in time?

Lord Sunday dose seem to be trying to be helpful but as I'm posting from my phone I'm away from my notes. What are your scum reads?
Also Jazzy, I saw you reading the thread. Any more thoughts?

[The Warrior]

I hate to keep bringing up iSoc's name because as of now I believe that he returned as a member of the town. However, that is precisely why I want to hear more from iSoc. Other than myself, iSoc is the only other person I have any certainty about at the moment. Do you have any ideas?

 

 

So it seems up to me to make a lagament push as no one else is willing to to do anything.

If we where to go off wagons alone, I'd could go after TW however I think there is a better way to go after that later. Yehom has been more of a bully, and while I suspect him, he's actions could be justified. Jazzy and naderr are too quiet that's for sure. I want to also hear CM current scum reads and why he's only been in the background thus far. I imagine 1 person being scum on kvest wagon. Leaving Lord Sunday and Rhizo as my canadites.

Rhizo at first suspected TW but voted with TW today. @Rhizo has your view changed at all? Any other scum reads? Did you expect the kvestlynch to go through or would you have unvoted if you were in time?

Lord Sunday dose seem to be trying to be helpful but as I'm posting from my phone I'm away from my notes. What are your scum reads?
Also Jazzy, I saw you reading the thread. Any more thoughts?

You could certainly go after me for my shitty voting record so far and I wouldn't fault you for doing so. The problem is that I just haven't had a good read yet in this game. However, I have been contributing in other ways and I am nearly positive that everything I have been saying about character names matter. Is it going to help us find scum for sure? Maybe not but it could.