Players:

 

1. 
   
2. brewersalliance, Shrimp Soup (Vanilla Town) was found boiled from N1
   
3. Lachiton (Velocity), Shrimp Creole (Mafia Tracker) was lynched on D6
   
4. KevinH, Coconut Shrimp (Town Cop) was found BBQ'd from N2
   
5. SeaBeeGipson, Pineapple Shrimp (Vanilla Town) was mod killed on D3
   
6. Robert2424, Shrimp Stew (Vanilla Town) was found Cooked from N3
   
7. The Warrior, Shrimp Salad (Vanilla Town) survived!
   
8. Kverst, Shrimp Kabob (Mafia Godfather) was mod killed on D4
   
9. Kitkat16, Shrimp & Potatoes (Vanilla Town) was lynched on D5
   
10. Sister Midnight, Pepper Shrimp (Town Cop) was found BBQ'd from N4
    
11. Rafay, Shrimp Gumbo (Mafia Goon) was lynched on D2
    
12. Wolfpacks, Lemon Shrimp (Vanilla Town) survived!
    
13. LordSunday, Mummy Shrimp (Mafia Traitor) was lynched on D4
    
14. Rhizoctonia (Jazzy95), Shrimp Sandwich (Non-Consecutive Town Tracker) was found eaten from N5
    

 

 

Setup:

 

• 
  
• This game is a closed setup, no information will be disclosed. 
  

 

Rules:

 

• 
  
• During the day phase each player may speak and vote in-thread.
  
• If a player receives the majority of the available votes during the day, they are lynched.
  
• At deadline, a player with half-majority will be lynched.
  
• After the day, the game goes to night.
  
• The game thread is closed during the night. Only mafia may speak to each other at night.
  
• All active roles may submit actions via PM at night.
  
• You play to win, game throwing will not be tolerated.
  
• You are not allowed to discuss this game outside of the game thread unless I have given you means to (a quicktopic) or the game is over.
  
• Offensive comments, Slandering, or slurs will not be tolerated. One warning will be issued for the first offense, and the next offense gets you forced-replaced
  
• All dead players can no longer participate in the game.
  
• Do not quote any private communications in this thread, which includes role pms. You may paraphrase. 
  
• Do not use cryptography, invisible text, tiny text, or the like.
  
• Mass role-claiming is not allowed, but you may reveal your role if you have something interesting to share.
  
• Breaking one of these rules may, at my discretion, result in a modkill. If you are modkilled, you will become a Neutral Survivor, and thus automatically lose. Modkilling may or may not end the game day.
  
• Do not edit or delete your posts in this thread. If there is a problem with a post, such as incorrect formatting, ask me to fix it for you.
  
• You must remain active to be in this game. If you do not post at least 3 times a game day, you may be force-replaced.
  
• Rules may be added or subject to change.
  

Vote Count

 

Lachiton (0):

KevinH (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Robert2424 (1): SeaBeeGipson

The Warrior (0):

Kverst (0):

Kitkat16 (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Rafay (1): KevinH

Wolfpacks (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

LordSunday (0):

 

 

Not Voting: Lachiton, Robert2424, The Warrior, Kverst, Kitkat16, Sister Midnight, Rafay, Wolfpacks, Rhizoctonia, LordSunday

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Feburary 3rd at 5:00pm CN

I know we don't have much to go on, but frankly, I don't think that voting no lynch even 1-2 votes away from ending the day early on day 1 is a big deal, let alone 3-4. I think keeping the day going on day 1 is overrated anyway.

It may be true for D1 but it's generally good practice not to end the day early if you're town. It is also applicable if we are certain we have got scum for sure but still shouldn't rush votes. So last 2 votes are always crucial and town has to be careful.

 

Question to you, if instead of no lynch brewers got lynched, who we now know was town, and the day ended early, would your feelings in this matter change?

 

I know we don't have much to go on, but frankly, I don't think that voting no lynch even 1-2 votes away from ending the day early on day 1 is a big deal, let alone 3-4. I think keeping the day going on day 1 is overrated anyway.

It may be true for D1 but it's generally good practice not to end the day early if you're town. It is also applicable if we are certain we have got scum for sure but still shouldn't rush votes. So last 2 votes are always crucial and town has to be careful.

 

Question to you, if instead of no lynch brewers got lynched, who we now know was town, and the day ended early, would your feelings in this matter change?

 

 

Sure. But the voting wasn't going that way. 

 

I know we don't have much to go on, but frankly, I don't think that voting no lynch even 1-2 votes away from ending the day early on day 1 is a big deal, let alone 3-4. I think keeping the day going on day 1 is overrated anyway.

It may be true for D1 but it's generally good practice not to end the day early if you're town. It is also applicable if we are certain we have got scum for sure but still shouldn't rush votes. So last 2 votes are always crucial and town has to be careful.

 

Question to you, if instead of no lynch brewers got lynched, who we now know was town, and the day ended early, would your feelings in this matter change?

Given that Brewers was actually not scum, wouldn't you also say it's better the day ended sooner then allow a mislynch of Brewers?

What exactly am I lying about??

 

... Warrior and Kevin supported the notion of ending the day early.

 

^ That's the lie.

 

I prefer to have more data points to analyze activity so I do not support ending the day early.

 

 

Why do you want them to tell how much they weigh

You know what he meant.

Oh sorry my sense of humour bypass is obviously not working properly.

 

The Majority of the time I always vote no lynch day one, even is day one is always up in the air it should never end early.

 

 

I prefer to have more data points to analyze activity so I do not support ending the day early.

 

 

But you did vote "No-Lynch" and did not hold off your vote until the deadline neared. So thats why I believe you too are partially responsible.

Why exactly does robert have seabee's vote on him?

13 The Warrior
9 Sister Midnight
8 LordSunday
7 Kitkat16
7 Kverst
6 Rafay
6 Lachiton
5 Robert2424
4 Wolfpacks
4 KevinH
3 SeaBeeGipson
2 Rhizoctonia


Low numbers for a Day 2 when Day 1 ends early.

Vote: Rhizoctonia.

 

Start talking please.

The problem is they killed off the most talkative of us, at least we had someone to work off of.

The problem is they killed off the most talkative of us, at least we had someone to work off of.

I’m guessing that is part of why he’s dead, I’m calling it the Samus factor. If you are a good enough player scum wants you dead ASAP. It also is part of what makes it suspicious if certain players are still alive on day 3. After Brewsky’s stellar performance in recent games he is starting to fall prey to the Samus Factor.

 

What do we have to go on? So far no one with a power role is sharing much. The day ended early by accident and Rafay is implying that KevinH and TW are suspect because they were pushed to end the day early on the no lynch wagon. I see no evidence of this. Kev is always in favor of a no lynch and advocates for it. But I don’t see how either of them pushed anything. Is this the Samus Factor at work?

I highly doubt anyone with a power role this early into the game will say outright what information they have, then again crazier things have happened

13 The Warrior

9 Sister Midnight

8 LordSunday

7 Kitkat16

7 Kverst

6 Rafay

6 Lachiton

5 Robert2424

4 Wolfpacks

4 KevinH

3 SeaBeeGipson

2 Rhizoctonia

 

 

Low numbers for a Day 2 when Day 1 ends early.

These numbers are pretty crappy. Obviously there hasn't been much going on but we need more than this from everyone, myself included. So @Kevin, other than just posting the numbers, what thoughts do you have?

 

I have a feeling that we might be looking at a game where we won't be counting much on town power roles. We all need to talk more.

Here's a list from which to start discussion.

Most likely to be scum: Rafay

• Voted for me, a townie, and then lies about The Warrior and me.

KevinH (1): Rafay

 
Second most likely to be scum: SeaBeeGipson, Lachiton, LordSunday

• Voted for Brewersalliance, now a known townie

brewersalliance (2): SeaBeeGipson, Lachiton, LordSunday

 
Third most likely to be scum: Rhizoctonia

• Voted for something besides a no lynch

The Warrior (1): Rhizoctonia

 

Most likely to be town: Sister Midnight, Kitkat16, KevinH, The Warrior, Wolfpacks, Robert2424, Kverst,

• Voted for No-lynch, which was the townie thing to do.

No Lynch: Kitkat16, KevinH, The Warrior, Wolfpacks, Robert2424, Kverst, Sister Midnight

Here's a list from which to start discussion.

 

Most likely to be scum: Rafay

• Voted for me, a townie, and then lies about The Warrior and me.

KevinH (1): Rafay

 

Second most likely to be scum: SeaBeeGipson, Lachiton, LordSunday

• Voted for Brewersalliance, now a known townie

brewersalliance (2): SeaBeeGipson, Lachiton, LordSunday

 

Third most likely to be scum: Rhizoctonia

• Voted for something besides a no lynch

The Warrior (1): Rhizoctonia

 

Most likely to be town: Sister Midnight, Kitkat16, KevinH, The Warrior, Wolfpacks, Robert2424, Kverst,

• Voted for No-lynch, which was the townie thing to do.

No Lynch: Kitkat16, KevinH, The Warrior, Wolfpacks, Robert2424, Kverst, Sister Midnight

 

 

I literally came in the game as a replacement and jokingly put a vote, next day it was posted the person I replaced was not actually replaced anymore, so at that point I didn't know if I was still playing, then day ended.

Also

 

Vote Rafay

I got admit I am getting a scum feel from Rafay, but ill hold my vote for now,

 

I thought it was decide a day before that LS and Rhizo where both playing,

 

 

I literally came in the game as a replacement and jokingly put a vote, next day it was posted the person I replaced was not actually replaced anymore, so at that point I didn't know if I was still playing, then day ended. Also   Vote Rafay

 

Care to explain?

 

This your third post and you come charging out of the gates at me.

 

Also, TW and Kev are both Veteran players. People will follow their decisions more easily. That's why when they voted to end the day early others thought it was the better thing to do. 

... when they voted to end the day early

 

"If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it." -misattributed to many

 

I literally came in the game as a replacement and jokingly put a vote, next day it was posted the person I replaced was not actually replaced anymore, so at that point I didn't know if I was still playing, then day ended. Also   Vote Rafay

 

Care to explain?

 

This your third post and you come charging out of the gates at me.

 

Also, TW and Kev are both Veteran players. People will follow their decisions more easily. That's why when they voted to end the day early others thought it was the better thing to do. 

 

On a lynch (or no lynch) that requires SEVEN to hammer, placing the first, second, or even third vote is NOT the same as actually casting the seventh hammer vote. Do the votes count the same? Sure, but I cannot control what other people do. I controlled my vote. I didn't force anyone else to vote for "no lynch" after me. That was their choice and the hammer coming so early falls squarely on the person who actually cast that final vote. In this case, Sister Midnight.

 

Since you are clearly so concerned with people who "wanted the day to end early", point out EXACTLY where your contention is noted with Sister Midnight who actually cast the final vote to end the day early. Because all I see is this:

 

 

Also guys like Warrior and Kevin supported the notion of ending the day early. We need to grill up some shrimp starting now.

 

 

Warrior and Kevin. Please weigh in.

 

 

 

Lynch all liars.   Vote: Rafay

 

What exactly am I lying about??

 

 

 

Being one of the first 3 votes for no lynch when it takes SEVEN to hammer is NOT equivalent to "supporting ending the day early".

 

So what you're saying is that the next 4 should be lynched???

 

The thing is that in mafia, if you don't want an action committed; don't vote for it. 

 

 

 

 

I prefer to have more data points to analyze activity so I do not support ending the day early.

 

 

But you did vote "No-Lynch" and did not hold off your vote until the deadline neared. So thats why I believe you too are partially responsible.

 

 

 

 

I literally came in the game as a replacement and jokingly put a vote, next day it was posted the person I replaced was not actually replaced anymore, so at that point I didn't know if I was still playing, then day ended. Also   Vote Rafay

 

Care to explain?

 

This your third post and you come charging out of the gates at me.

 

Also, TW and Kev are both Veteran players. People will follow their decisions more easily. That's why when they voted to end the day early others thought it was the better thing to do. 

 

 

How can you possibly take issue with Kevin and I about something that we DIDN'T force but don't even comment directly about or question the person who DID force the day to end early?

 

FOS Rafay

Vote Count

 

Lachiton (0):

KevinH (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Robert2424 (1): SeaBeeGipson

The Warrior (0):

Kverst (0):

Kitkat16 (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Rafay (2): KevinH, Rhizoctonia

Wolfpacks (0):

Rhizoctonia (1): Kitkat16

LordSunday (0):

 

 

Not Voting: Lachiton, Robert2424, The Warrior, Kverst, Sister Midnight, Rafay, Wolfpacks, LordSunday

 

In danger of Mod-Kill: SeaBeeGipson (Last Post 1/27), Lachiton (Last Post 1/28), Robert2424 (Last Post 1/28)

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Feburary 3rd at 5:00pm CN

Yeah Rafay's accusation of Kevin and TW is asinine. I read up the thread and couldn't find any post where either of them remotely suggested to end the day early. Voting for someone, even no lynch DOES NOT equal to trying to end the day early. It's always the responsibility of the subsequent voters to know when to place their votes.

 

It looks to me either Rafay is trying to distract away from the people who ACTUALLY ended the day early or found something about Kevin/TW which

he doesn't want to share for some reason and therefore cooked up weird charge and making a terrible job out of it.

My post asking why SeaBee voted robert kind of got brushed under the rug, but alright. 

 

Rafay's lie is a bit concerning, Rafay, would you care to explain?

My post asking why SeaBee voted robert kind of got brushed under the rug, but alright. 

 

Rafay's lie is a bit concerning, Rafay, would you care to explain?

Reasoning is we have nothing. Like we usually do when a no lynch happens.

So it's based purely off guessing. As for Rafay and TW and Kevin, the reasoning is a bit off but they're just as likely to be scum as anyone at this point lacking any evidence otherwise. FoS everyone

 

I literally came in the game as a replacement and jokingly put a vote, next day it was posted the person I replaced was not actually replaced anymore, so at that point I didn't know if I was still playing, then day ended. Also   Vote Rafay

 

Care to explain?

 

This your third post and you come charging out of the gates at me.

 

Also, TW and Kev are both Veteran players. People will follow their decisions more easily. That's why when they voted to end the day early others thought it was the better thing to do. 

 

 

 

I think I already went over this, but to rehash it.

 

I replaced Lordsunday January 25th 3ish PM.  6 hours later, Mod says LS isn't replaced anymore, thus wondering where I fell and trying to get a clear answer if I was still in game since name was listed on player list, but so was LS and I was told I replaced him.  12 hours after joining the game, D1 ended.  Not sure how I'm suppose to rack up the post count in a matter of 12 hours when I was just thrown into said game, but guess I seem to have missed the ball since you want to bring into account my post count, and Kevin wants to bring in my post count and my lulz vote as I just entered the game and had it end only hours later.

 

In terms of my vote, it's quite simple.  Kevin and TW have called out your lies thrown at them better then I can and I agree with them.  You're the best option thus far today.