502 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

I investigated Jazzy but he got killed.

[MWilson]

I was given the role at the start of this day. I haven't yet been able to investigate anyone. I've previously laid out my reasons for suspecting Kevin, Kverst, Rafay, +unknown which turned out to be robert. Now we have a second unknown. I believe Kevin is a zombie in the same horde as robert and sold him up the river to establish more credibility. Whether we vote Rafay or Kverst isn't important. What is important is that whichever of those two is lynched the vig should target the other. I'll investigate a third of yet unnamed player tonight and publish my results in the morning. If Kevin investigates me and declares me guilty then we'll have identified 2 more zombies for tomorrow unless I investigate a not guilty player tonight. Based on the fact that I was a VT yesterday and became a cop today, it stands to reason that we may also have 2 doctors in town. If that's the case, whoever became a doctor after the start of the game should protect me and the original should protect Kevin. It's not clear yet whether Kevin is a zombie or cop yet and the fact he apparently investigated Jazzy instead of me buys him another day of remaining under suspicion but without enough evidence for a lynch.

[Rafay]

I was given the role at the start of this day. I haven't yet been able to investigate anyone. I've previously laid out my reasons for suspecting Kevin, Kverst, Rafay, +unknown which turned out to be robert. Now we have a second unknown. I believe Kevin is a zombie in the same horde as robert and sold him up the river to establish more credibility. Whether we vote Rafay or Kverst isn't important. What is important is that whichever of those two is lynched the vig should target the other. I'll investigate a third of yet unnamed player tonight and publish my results in the morning. If Kevin investigates me and declares me guilty then we'll have identified 2 more zombies for tomorrow unless I investigate a not guilty player tonight. Based on the fact that I was a VT yesterday and became a cop today, it stands to reason that we may also have 2 doctors in town. If that's the case, whoever became a doctor after the start of the game should protect me and the original should protect Kevin. It's not clear yet whether Kevin is a zombie or cop yet and the fact he apparently investigated Jazzy instead of me buys him another day of remaining under suspicion but without enough evidence for a lynch.

 

But what makes you special?? Why shouldn't anyone lynch or vote or night kill you???

 

The only thing I can say about you becoming is that maybe Kevin was converted during the night so you became a cop.

[MWilson]

 

I was given the role at the start of this day. I haven't yet been able to investigate anyone. I've previously laid out my reasons for suspecting Kevin, Kverst, Rafay, +unknown which turned out to be robert. Now we have a second unknown. I believe Kevin is a zombie in the same horde as robert and sold him up the river to establish more credibility. Whether we vote Rafay or Kverst isn't important. What is important is that whichever of those two is lynched the vig should target the other. I'll investigate a third of yet unnamed player tonight and publish my results in the morning. If Kevin investigates me and declares me guilty then we'll have identified 2 more zombies for tomorrow unless I investigate a not guilty player tonight. Based on the fact that I was a VT yesterday and became a cop today, it stands to reason that we may also have 2 doctors in town. If that's the case, whoever became a doctor after the start of the game should protect me and the original should protect Kevin. It's not clear yet whether Kevin is a zombie or cop yet and the fact he apparently investigated Jazzy instead of me buys him another day of remaining under suspicion but without enough evidence for a lynch.

 

But what makes you special?? Why shouldn't anyone lynch or vote or night kill you???

 

The only thing I can say about you becoming is that maybe Kevin was converted during the night so you became a cop.

 

They absolutely can, I'm just saying they shouldn't. If they do they'll just kill a townie and cop or best case scenario the doc doesn't protect me, I get infected and vig killed in the same night.

[Rafay]

They absolutely can, I'm just saying they shouldn't. If they do they'll just kill a townie and cop or best case scenario the doc doesn't protect me, I get infected and vig killed in the same night.

 

So why go after me and Kevin? Your theory's main point s that Kevin; a zombie betrayed Robert. So you should go after Kevin first and then me. Isn't Kevin more dangerous than me?  

[Kverst]

I feel like people ignored my post about Wilson's initial claims. I assume I am being FOSed because I was at the end of the wagon.

 

I was initially the SECOND vote on Robert. I unvoted, but it was far after my unvoting would have affected the lynch at all (There were 8 votes total on Robert when I unvoted). I then replaced my vote. Why should I be FOSed this adamantly for this?

[Colonel Medved]

I don't think the "Kevin betrayed Robert" theory is very possible. What would he gain from that? Selling out a teammate for credibility sounds very short term and puts you in the spotlight. I'm leaning more towards Kevin being cop.

It's unfortunate that his investigation didn't pan out, but at least we have another potential cop in play (if MWilson is telling the truth).

[Wolfpacks]

I investigated Jazzy but he got killed.

thats very convenient but tbh you did say you would investigate either Jazz or Mwilson

 

 

I was given the role at the start of this day. I haven't yet been able to investigate anyone. I've previously laid out my reasons for suspecting Kevin, Kverst, Rafay, +unknown which turned out to be robert. Now we have a second unknown. I believe Kevin is a zombie in the same horde as robert and sold him up the river to establish more credibility. Whether we vote Rafay or Kverst isn't important. What is important is that whichever of those two is lynched the vig should target the other. I'll investigate a third of yet unnamed player tonight and publish my results in the morning. If Kevin investigates me and declares me guilty then we'll have identified 2 more zombies for tomorrow unless I investigate a not guilty player tonight. Based on the fact that I was a VT yesterday and became a cop today, it stands to reason that we may also have 2 doctors in town. If that's the case, whoever became a doctor after the start of the game should protect me and the original should protect Kevin. It's not clear yet whether Kevin is a zombie or cop yet and the fact he apparently investigated Jazzy instead of me buys him another day of remaining under suspicion but without enough evidence for a lynch.

 

But what makes you special?? Why shouldn't anyone lynch or vote or night kill you???

 

The only thing I can say about you becoming is that maybe Kevin was converted during the night so you became a cop.

 

i gotta admit when i posted earlier in this day i had the same idea, im pretty sure if a role player gets infected another town takes his place, Kevin did play his hand early and the Zombies knew he was a cop

[Nadarr]

I believe Kevin is a zombie now due to his RC yesterday. However, I am confused why we are focusing Kvrest? This doesnt make any sense.

[KevinH]

Tonight, I will investigate one of:

• Wolfpacks
• MWilson

I would again plead that the doctor protect me and that the vig not kill one of the two that I might investigate.

[Wolfpacks]

Tonight, I will investigate one of:

• Wolfpacks
• MWilson

I would again plead that the doctor protect me and that the vig not kill one of the two that I might investigate.

This still isn't going to help us who to lynch, we are still looking for 3 zombies and your still playing a hunch that one of us two are zombies, but not really pushing anyone else, it's either you are a cop or your trying to give yourself a couple of days grace to keep suspicion off of you and making the doc use his power when someone else could use it
I'm still uncertain which is which although im leaning more to the latter.

[KevinH]

Here's what we have.

First we have a close vote of a zombie (Robert) vs a townie (Pengui). While there are legitimate reasons why a townie might have voted for Pengui, the zombies had extra incentive to protect one of their own.

 

PenguiNation (6): Robert2424, Rhizoctonia, Colonel Medved, Wolfpacks, MWilson, Jazzy95

Robert2424 (6): SeaBeeGipson, Rafay, KevinH, Nadarr, Kverst, Velocity

Velocity (1): FrigidInferno

Not Voting: PenguiNation

 

 
 

Then we have the vote after I investigated Robert and found him guilty.

 

KevinH (4): Robert2424, MWilson, Wolfpacks, Jazzy95

Robert2424 (9): KevinH, Rafay, Colonel Medved, Nadarr, SeaBeeGipson, Kverst, Rhizoctonia, FrigidInferno, Velocity

Robert2424, a Zombie, has been lynched on day 4.

 

 

What can I say?

There are 2 players alive that did not vote for the now-known zombie; they make the short list for me.

 

In fact, 

Vote: Wolfpacks

 

We need to lynch somebody and based on the little that we have, this is the best option.

[Rhizoctonia]

I'm trying to decide if we have two cops.  If MWilson is telling the truth either Kevin got turned last night, Kevin wasn't a cop to begin with, or we have 2 cops

[Colonel Medved]

I'm trying to decide if we have two cops.  If MWilson is telling the truth either Kevin got turned last night, Kevin wasn't a cop to begin with, or we have 2 cops

 

I think since a zombie could be potentially added after each night, two cops doesn't sound to far off. As far as i'm concerned, Kevin has shown to be a cop with the Robert investigation. He could have been turned last night, but we really have nothing to go off of. MWilson could be another cop, the new cop, or just a zombie trying to kill off a PR with an easy claim.

 

Since we have to vote, and Kevin is the only person who has proven his role, i will follow him for the time being. I should be able to check the thread again before deadline, but since i'm sick and work overnights i'm better off securing my vote now.

 

Vote Wolfpacks

[Wolfpacks]

I'm trying to decide if we have two cops. If MWilson is telling the truth either Kevin got turned last night, Kevin wasn't a cop to begin with, or we have 2 cops

I think since a zombie could be potentially added after each night, two cops doesn't sound to far off. As far as i'm concerned, Kevin has shown to be a cop with the Robert investigation. He could have been turned last night, but we really have nothing to go off of. MWilson could be another cop, the new cop, or just a zombie trying to kill off a PR with an easy claim.

Since we have to vote, and Kevin is the only person who has proven his role, i will follow him for the time being. I should be able to check the thread again before deadline, but since i'm sick and work overnights i'm better off securing my vote now.

Vote Wolfpacks

When did Kevin prove his role, cant remember that happening must have missed that and wasnt you one of the first Kevin accused of being a zombie, personally I think Kevin has been turned, they already knew he was a cop and he would be the first player to be turned and MWilson probably is the new cop because of this,Kevin is a very skilled player and can easily manipulate you into voting his way, I'm Town and a vote for me will only cause town to lose another.


Vote Kevin

[Rafay]

Kevin wasn't wrong the last time. If he is, then he'll pay the price.

 

Vote: Wolfpacks.

[Nadarr]

Why are we targeting WP?

[Wolfpacks]

Kevin wasn't wrong the last time. If he is, then he'll pay the price.

Vote: Wolfpacks.

So you want to lose a town just to prove a point,

Why are we targeting WP?

Because I'm targeting Kevin and the zombies don't like that

[Nadarr]

Ah. That makes sense.

[Colonel Medved]

 

 

I'm trying to decide if we have two cops. If MWilson is telling the truth either Kevin got turned last night, Kevin wasn't a cop to begin with, or we have 2 cops

I think since a zombie could be potentially added after each night, two cops doesn't sound to far off. As far as i'm concerned, Kevin has shown to be a cop with the Robert investigation. He could have been turned last night, but we really have nothing to go off of. MWilson could be another cop, the new cop, or just a zombie trying to kill off a PR with an easy claim.

Since we have to vote, and Kevin is the only person who has proven his role, i will follow him for the time being. I should be able to check the thread again before deadline, but since i'm sick and work overnights i'm better off securing my vote now.

Vote Wolfpacks

When did Kevin prove his role, cant remember that happening must have missed that and wasnt you one of the first Kevin accused of being a zombie, personally I think Kevin has been turned, they already knew he was a cop and he would be the first player to be turned and MWilson probably is the new cop because of this,Kevin is a very skilled player and can easily manipulate you into voting his way, I'm Town and a vote for me will only cause town to lose another.


Vote Kevin

 

 

He proved his role when he investigated Robert, and he turned zombie after being lynched. It could be possible that he is a zombie now, but since no one else has shown credible evidence towards being a confirmed town (other than just a role claim), then that limits the people we can actually trust. You being zombie isn't a guaranteed thing either, he hasn't investigated you but it's all we have to go off of.

 

If you do turn town, then it will be very unfortunate. I wouldn't say it would be Kevin's fault 100%, since this is a shot in the dark since no proof has come forward, but since he started the wagon it would put him in a bad position with town next time around. We all have to vote to avoid being mod-killed, so this is my best bet for the time being.