286 replies to this topic

[SeaBeeGipson]

So I'm getting the gist of today is just a fight between Brewers and Kevin it seems. Rafay role claiming this early is interesting, but want to add just because someone was found not doing an action doesnt mean he isnt scum. Scum could have a PR doing the kills while Kevin is a goon. Just a thought, and I dont think we should sell someone as confirmed townie so far.

Also as far as D1 lynch, my argument has been the information we gather comes into better use in later days, not D2. Specifically when we have counter role claims, fake claims, usually coming into D3+, itll help us figure what's the truth. Least in theory since we never lynch.

[brewersalliance]

So I'm getting the gist of today is just a fight between Brewers and Kevin it seems.

 

 

just to clarify I have no feeling either way on kevin being scum or town.  but we need to lynch someone and have nothing to go off so i picked kevin for always voting no lynch lol

 

if we get a better candidate i will switch for sure

[Rafay]

Angela Martin, a Dunder Mifflin Accountant (Tracker).

 

You already know my action

[brewersalliance]

its a believable claim.  either TW gave rafay a fake name or hes scum.

 

If rafay was scum i dont see him faking a RC this early for no reason, it would bring to much attention to him, but you never know.   for now i tend to believe it, even tho i dont know why he did it lol

[KevinH]

 

Brewersalliance (2): KevinH, Colonel Medved

KevinH (3): Brewersalliance, Lord MK, iSocialism

...
With 10 players alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline will be at 1:00pm CN Server time on Thursday, June 13th.

 

 

What's wrong with a role-claim to save a townie?

Double FoS: Brewersalliance

[brewersalliance]

 

 

 

Brewersalliance (2): KevinH, Colonel Medved

KevinH (3): Brewersalliance, Lord MK, iSocialism

...
With 10 players alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline will be at 1:00pm CN Server time on Thursday, June 13th.

 

What's wrong with a role-claim to save a townie?

Double FoS: Brewersalliance

 

it doesnt save you tho.  just because he saw you do nothing does not mean you arent scum.  it means absolutely nothing either way.  you could be a townie or a scum that did not do any action. thats all it means

we gain nothing from it.  all we know is you most likely did not kill WP (unless you are a ninja)

[Rafay]

What's wrong with a role-claim to save a townie?

 

Though if Kevin flips town I'm gunnin for brewers. If he's mafia then I've shot myself. 

[The Warrior]

Vote Count

 

Brewersalliance (2): KevinH, Colonel Medved

Colonel Medved (0):

Eogrim (0):

iSocialism (0):

KevinH (3): Brewersalliance, Lord MK, iSocialism

Lord MK (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Velocity (0):

 

 

No Lynch (1): Eogrim

 

Not Voting: Rafay, Rhizoctonia, SeaBeeGipson, Velocity

 

With 10 players alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 1:00pm CN Server time on Thursday, June 13th.

 

Currently in line to be mod-killed:

[KevinH]

"Got it a week after we started dating"

 

I'm due to be lynched in 2 days.

Only scum would want that.

[Lord MK]

Unvote.
As i said i would.

Post Count

KevinH 20
brewersalliance 20
Rafay 13
Lord MK 10
iSocialism 10
Rhizoctonia 9
Eogrim 8
Colonel Medved 7
SeaBeeGipson 6
Velocity 6

Not Voting: Rafay, Rhizoctonia, SeaBeeGipson, Velocity

Considering both of these.

Vote: Velocity

[KevinH]

^  means post count, not vote count.

 

Thank you for unvoting.  A scum could have conveniently gone "inactive" for another day and then be "surprised" when I got lynched.

 

Speaking of which, where are Brewersalliance and iSocialism?

[SeaBeeGipson]

So there looks like the only wagons are Brewers and Kevin.

While I'm not sure on either, I dont believe 2 no lynches works in our favor. With Rafays results on Kevin, Kevin could still be scum, but theres also a plausible chance hes town. Rafay could also be fake claiming or scum himself with a tracker role.
As for Brewers, it's an odds game. This risk seems more validated to me as there isnt any results defending the possibility he may be town or scum.

Vote: Brewers

Note I encourage everyone to place a vote even if it's for no lynch rather than sitting on the no vote list

[Rafay]

I hope I'm right.

 

Vote: Velocity.

[Eogrim]

it doesnt save you tho.  just because he saw you do nothing does not mean you arent scum.  it means absolutely nothing either way.  you could be a townie or a scum that did not do any action. thats all it means

we gain nothing from it.  all we know is you most likely did not kill WP (unless you are a ninja)

 

So far, the only RC we got is Rafay, who says he targeted Kevin N1. As long we don't have any other claims out in the open this is as close to evidence we got.

While Brewers conclusion that it doesn't prove Kevin is scum is true, it at least lessens the likelyhood.

 

I do not understand his justification for voting Kevin in spite of this.

 

FoS Brewers

FoS isoc, for voting Kevin and staying in the background

 

Unvote

 

Vote iSocialism

[Velocity]

So there looks like the only wagons are Brewers and Kevin.

While I'm not sure on either, I dont believe 2 no lynches works in our favor. With Rafays results on Kevin, Kevin could still be scum, but theres also a plausible chance hes town. Rafay could also be fake claiming or scum himself with a tracker role.
As for Brewers, it's an odds game. This risk seems more validated to me as there isnt any results defending the possibility he may be town or scum.

Vote: Brewers

Note I encourage everyone to place a vote even if it's for no lynch rather than sitting on the no vote list

I’m honestly more inclined to vote no lynch than lynch somebody but there’s no point in it at this time, so it’s either Kevin or brewer for me. I feel like weighing them evenly there’s a better case for Kevin being town just because of Rafay’s claim, although it’s not really something I can compare and have one outweigh the other yet.

I’m really not sure how I’ll vote yet, but I’ll decide when I have time to “review” what little we have to go off of, which will probably be a couple hours before deadline, due to my work schedule.

[brewersalliance]

it doesnt save you tho.  just because he saw you do nothing does not mean you arent scum.  it means absolutely nothing either way.  you could be a townie or a scum that did not do any action. thats all it means

we gain nothing from it.  all we know is you most likely did not kill WP (unless you are a ninja)

 
So far, the only RC we got is Rafay, who says he targeted Kevin N1. As long we don't have any other claims out in the open this is as close to evidence we got.
While Brewers conclusion that it doesn't prove Kevin is scum is true, it at least lessens the likelyhood.
 
I do not understand his justification for voting Kevin in spite of this.
 
FoS Brewers
FoS isoc, for voting Kevin and staying in the background
 
Unvote
 
Vote iSocialism

I think he has a point here. iSoc just kind of sat buy and jumped on the wagon that basically formed simply because I was throwing a vote our there to cause some discussion.

Unvote

Vote iSocialism

[The Warrior]

“And I knew exactly what to do. But in a much more real sense, I had no idea what to do.” - Michael

 

 

Vote Count

 

Brewersalliance (3): KevinH, Colonel Medved, SeaBeeGipson

Colonel Medved (0):

Eogrim (0):

iSocialism (2): Eogrim, Brewersalliance

KevinH (1): iSocialism

Lord MK (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Velocity (2): Lord MK, Rafay

 

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: Rhizoctonia, Velocity

 

With 10 players alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 1:00pm CN Server time on Thursday, June 13th.

 

Currently in line to be mod-killed:

[brewersalliance]

Brewersalliance (3): KevinH, Colonel Medved, SeaBeeGipson

 

 

 

 oh damn I might get lynched.  Guess I should just role claim.

 

I am Jim Halpert, an Ascetic Dunder Mifflin salesman.

 

My abilities are that I am immune from all night actions.  

 

Im sure townies all got roles saying things like Dunder Mifflin salesman/accountant/whatever the job is they do in the show so if youre town you will know im telling the truth.

 

I was hoping i wouldnt have to RC as I could have caused scum to waste their night actions on me, but now at least we know I am town and that town shouldnt target me with any actions, since they will be wasted 

[Velocity]

Brewersalliance (3): KevinH, Colonel Medved, SeaBeeGipson

oh damn I might get lynched. Guess I should just role claim.

I am Jim Halpert, an Ascetic Dunder Mifflin salesman.

My abilities are that I am immune from all night actions.

Im sure townies all got roles saying things like Dunder Mifflin salesman/accountant/whatever the job is they do in the show so if youre town you will know im telling the truth.

I was hoping i wouldnt have to RC as I could have caused scum to waste their night actions on me, but now at least we know I am town and that town shouldnt target me with any actions, since they will be wasted

I’m going to go ahead and believe this , it’s so close to deadline if he was scum this would’ve been such a risky move to play considering the only other person who could be voted to save him, iSoc.

For the sake of saving someone who may be town...

Vote: iSocialism

[Velocity]

To add on to that, the only thing I think that would be odd about his RC is the fact that he’s apparently immune to all night actions, as a regular town, would be a little bit broken if there’s no way to kill him without a lynch...
though it could make sense if there’s scum and a SK out there, which we don’t know yet.