If Robert is indeed at L-1, we should be really careful to not hammer him until he at least has a chance to come and say something. We won't get many chances to mislynch before losing, so we need to be careful about making this lynch a foregone conclusion.

 

@mod have you prodded Robert yet?

If Robert is indeed at L-1, we should be really careful to not hammer him until he at least has a chance to come and say something. We won't get many chances to mislynch before losing, so we need to be careful about making this lynch a foregone conclusion.

 

@mod have you prodded Robert yet?

Hence why I didn't vote.  No need to end the day early.

 

 

I have slight trust for Kevin because what he did D1, which involved Wolfpacks, who we now know is scum. Let's analyze: at first, Kevin voted No Lynch. After some time, Wolfpacks joined in. What does Kevin do? Change his vote from No Lynch to Wolfpacks, kept that vote for the whole game. Tell me if that would seem logical to you if you were scum. So either he's an SK or a townie.

That's actually quite interesting, but at that point Rafay already has 5 votes. Changing vote to WP is a safe bussing if Kevin is scum

If KevinH is a scum, there wasn't any real risk involved in voting on WP. There were already like 5 votes on Tony and 3 on Rafay. Nobody cared for WP.

So placing D1 lul vote on your scum buddy that is in no danger of getting lynched is nothing exceptional.

 

Obviously he could be a town, but this act is really no indication of his allegiance.

 

 

This.

 

 

Vote Count

 

Robert2424 (5): Abt, Tony, Lilywad, cod, Dontavian ❤️

KevinH (2): brewers, limey

Ali Bin Turban (2): Kevin, Ferastical

Tony Maurice (0):

Chaplain of Death (0):

Brewersalliance (0):

Lyner (0):

lilweirdward (0):

Dontavian (0):

Ferastical (0):

Finster Baby (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not voting: Baby, Robert

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Saturday, November 14 at 0000 UTC.

 

.

Roberto has been prodded, hasn't responded.

 

 

Also, slight rule edit

The Cop will return a result clearly indicating the alignment of their target, if they are successful.

(Town, Mafia, Sk)

.

 

I have a list of potential replacements lined up.

I'm asking them if they are ready to jump in for Roberto.

And replacement also depends on whether Robert responds before then.

But it's still iffy.

And besides he's way below the required post count.

But will wait till this midnight UTC to make a decision.

To the group:

 

I can end the day now with my vote or we can wait.   Let me know.

If we wait until 0000UTC and Mod finds someone to take Roberts role, who do we shift the vote to? If he doesn’t find a replacement, then Rob get MKilled anyway

I'm OK with ending the day early.

 

It's sort of like a lynch-mod-kill.

I actually would like to wait a bit in case there is ever a chance that Robert will show up to say something... also now that I think about it, who would want to be a replacement in a game if they'll get lynched during the same day they join? Just seems so sad, lol 

Usually a mod will reset the vote count if someone subs in for an inactive player, although idk if MK would do that or not.

 

What is the deadline? If there is still plenty of time then I'd rather wait for a replacement. No point in potentially losing another day in this game.

I am for ending this day early as it gives us some certainty about robert’s role and what actually happened today,

I actually would like to wait a bit in case there is ever a chance that Robert will show up to say something... also now that I think about it, who would want to be a replacement in a game if they'll get lynched during the same day they join? Just seems so sad, lol

Well there's Velocity for one.

Robert has been replaced by Velocity, due to failure to respond to prod.

All votes for Robert have been reset in accordance with that.

 

Deadline has been extended by 24 hours from the initial deadline.

 

Vote Count

 

KevinH (2): brewers, limey

Ali Bin Turban (2): Kevin, Ferastical

Velocity (0):

Tony Maurice (0):

Chaplain of Death (0):

Brewersalliance (0):

Lyner (0):

lilweirdward (0):

Dontavian (0):

Ferastical (0):

Finster Baby (0):

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not voting: Baby, Velocity, Abt, Tony, Lilywad, cod, Dontavian ❤️

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Sunday, November 15 at 0000 UTC.

Vote count was reset, and deadline was extended, that’s good.

 

 

I can say that I am town. Among other things, though, I need to catch up on the game thread so I can post some of my thoughts. Maybe after I’ve had my morning coffee..

 

The Cop is still active, with the mafia switch and SK alive they may get actions through. Doctor seems rendered useless now, since the mafia doctor switch was taken out and the SK can just turn them off every night, right? And the Vigilante is dead.

 

The rest, I need to read the game thread to see how people have been playing.

The rest, I need to read the game thread to see how people have been playing.

Welcome to the game VL. The rest is basically peeps sparring over others playing style across their entire Mafia history or trying to sift criminal intent evidence from when or how someone said something.

Vote count was reset, and deadline was extended, that’s good.

 

 

I can say that I am town. Among other things, though, I need to catch up on the game thread so I can post some of my thoughts. Maybe after I’ve had my morning coffee..

 

The Cop is still active, with the mafia switch and SK alive they may get actions through. Doctor seems rendered useless now, since the mafia doctor switch was taken out and the SK can just turn them off every night, right? And the Vigilante is dead.

 

The rest, I need to read the game thread to see how people have been playing.

Welcome!

 

Cop might or might not be useless depending on SK's choice.

Yes our Doc is practically useless rn

Vote count was reset, and deadline was extended, that’s good.

 

 

I can say that I am town. Among other things, though, I need to catch up on the game thread so I can post some of my thoughts. Maybe after I’ve had my morning coffee..

 

The Cop is still active, with the mafia switch and SK alive they may get actions through. Doctor seems rendered useless now, since the mafia doctor switch was taken out and the SK can just turn them off every night, right? And the Vigilante is dead.

 

The rest, I need to read the game thread to see how people have been playing.

Welcome!  Nice to see someone active join!

 

I think you have the general gist of what's up so far.

Thanks MK for swapping Robert out. Kind of like with Torres, I am still a little suspicious of some of the things he said during the game while he was still around, but I'm willing to give Velocity a pass to see how he acts.

 

I'm almost a little suspicious of Tony playing so seriously. Chasing down leads, making good criticisms, and not hammering someone to end the day early? Almost like he has incentive to be more serious this time around 🤔

 

The rest, I need to read the game thread to see how people have been playing.

Welcome to the game VL. The rest is basically peeps sparring over others playing style across their entire Mafia history or trying to sift criminal intent evidence from when or how someone said something.

Yeah, it does seem that way. The only notable exception to their normal play style that stands out to me is Tony, but if he was going to switch his play styles to be more serious at some point it would happen eventually that he would do it in a game. I don’t take it as a huge indication of anything, with incentive to win or not.

 

If anything, if he’s trying to become a more serious player he could see that he was some role like a VT and decided to swap in a game where him getting lynched would hurt the town excessively.

 

I haven’t finished reading through yet, as I’m still in my classes and they last for about another hour, but it does still seem to be mostly going off of play styles and who’s said what so far. Not much actual hard evidence against anyone.

Don't overlook AbT's scumtell:
 

If we assume scum would like to blend (so not go no-lynch route) and they wouldn't all jump on the Rafay's wagon, then there must be at least one among (Tony, KevinH, Robert)

 

He might be a misguided townie, but he's my top choice for scum at the moment.

 

 

I can say that I am town.

 

 We did it boys, we found the way to beat mafia. Let's all just say whether we're town or not! 

 

AbT and LWW, I've seen you both be rather active in discussion, but no votes yet. Waiting for something?

 

I can say that I am town.

We did it boys, we found the way to beat mafia. Let's all just say whether we're town or not!

 

AbT and LWW, I've seen you both be rather active in discussion, but no votes yet. Waiting for something?

Ah yes, the floor here is made of floor.

 

I figured since Robert didn’t make it clear, and played in some odd way, I would clarify that I am indeed town.

Apologies guys, but due to personal matters, my activity is going to dive. If its possible, it would be a good idea to replace me, since I wont be able to participate as before .

 

I can say that I am town.

 

 We did it boys, we found the way to beat mafia. Let's all just say whether we're town or not! 

 

AbT and LWW, I've seen you both be rather active in discussion, but no votes yet. Waiting for something?

 

 

They were both voting for Robert but their votes got reset, as did mine.

Apologies guys, but due to personal matters, my activity is going to dive. If its possible, it would be a good idea to replace me, since I wont be able to participate as before .

Sad to hear, but RL always wins. Take care of yourself