516 replies to this topic

[lilweirdward]

I'm just explaining my train of thought, not defending Rafay. Not sure how that warrants this kind of overblown response. Did I hit the mark?

It's interesting that you bring up "bussing", since you did put the 4th vote on Robert but didn't vote Donta.

Fun fact: Everyone who voted for Robert also voted for Dontavian, except LWW.


Vote: LWW

An overblown response? I said it was suspicious of you to avoid addressing Rafay's multiple scum tells twice, but then you double (triple?) down on that and take it a step further and actually vote for me, and I'm the one being overblown?

I don't feel like explaining myself about why I didn't vote to lynch a guy who'd just replaced in, when I had been voting for their predecessor for literally posting 3 times the whole game. If you wanna believe that that was bussing but not what Rafay did, then no explanation I could ever give would be good enough.

I was just at 2 votes, jeez.
One was Lww who is auto disqualified and the other is WP who is still not dead.

So i wasn't a lynch target then, limey.
Stop twisting stuff.

I would vote for MK because he seems to have it in for me, but I don't want it to look like a OMGUS vote

But I'm holding out for a while longer

Lol, my advice would be to not say you're waiting to vote for someone until it's not so obviously an OMGUS vote. Do you have any thoughts on anything except MK's petty jabs at you?

[Wolfpacks]

That holding bit wasn't actually concerning MK lol

No well none that I'm ready to put into words yet.

[The Warrior]

You're completely ignoring the whole "bussing your scum partner" angle, and I'm not sure if it's deliberate or not, but it feels suspicious. Plus this whole "Rafay can't be the bad guy, he voted for scum!" act, coupled with leaning on the scales yesterday to get Tony lynched instead of the person with the next highest votes (conveniently also Rafay again) really feels scummy. It mostly only makes sense if Rafay flips scum, so I'm keeping my vote where it's at since my whole theory about this game so far breaks down if he's somehow town. If it works out the way I think it will though, I think we may have found our two remaining scum.

I'm just explaining my train of thought, not defending Rafay. Not sure how that warrants this kind of overblown response. Did I hit the mark?

It's interesting that you bring up "bussing", since you did put the 4th vote on Robert but didn't vote Donta.

Fun fact: Everyone who voted for Robert also voted for Dontavian, except LWW.


Vote: LWW

This is an interesting point. Could have been a bussing attempt initially since Robert was unlikely to be helpful and then hoping an active Dontavian wouldn’t be lynched since he was more likely to be helpful.

[lilweirdward]

This is mind numbingly frustrating, but Lyner is a way better player than he sometimes gets credit for, so I shouldn't be surprised people are buying his analysis so easily.

I'm gonna take the Tony approach here, just lynch me and you'll see. There's still a chance or two left as long as whoever is the EC doesn't give the elector to Lyner, and when I flip town just like Tony did, you'll see that the same two people who pushed to get both of us lynched are the actual mafia. I can't believe I'm saying this, but give elector to MK, he at least seems to have some sense, and I have a hard time believing he's scum (although if he is then he's done brilliantly to let us all eat ourselves alive). Ideally we could not do this whole rigamarole and just lynch Rafay, but clearly my approach is not working so hopefully a townie gets elector and we can still save this tomorrow.

[Lyner]

Would be great if the rest of town can chime in

[Wolfpacks]

I don't think lynching LWW would be the right way to go here, my initial opinion was wrong as I found out about Tony and I thought they was together as scum and I was wrong there so that makes me feel that LWW is Town.

[Lord MK]

Tick tock.

Deadline is approaching.


Rafay seems awfully quiet after the accusations.
Normally whenever you accuse him, he goes full Kratos.
Which makes me even more suspicious that he is indeed scum

[Rafay]

OK so before anyone does anything stupid. I am going to RC.

 

I'm the College. I selected TW and Lord MK as his back up last night.

 

Why?

 

Cuz TW did an amazing job.

[The Warrior]

Just so we’re clear: Is anyone countering Rafay’s claim that he is the Electoral College?

Also,

@Brewers - Can the Electoral College only be given to a town player?

[lilweirdward]

...interesting. Good question TW, but I'd imagine it has to be town-aligned since otherwise the game would essentially be unwinnable for town. The example role PM was town aligned too.

If no one counter claims then I'll unvote, obviously. This kind of ruins my entire theory lol.

[Lord MK]

Vote Count

Rafay (2): MK, Lww
Lww (3): Kevin, Rafay, Lyner
Kevin
Tw
Mk
lyner
Torres
WP

So we killing Lww?
So wp and Torres, we going to get any thoughts from you?

If no one comes forward to counter rafay
I want to put in my nomination for Torres to be lynched for his zero contribution policy.

[lilweirdward]

Would very much prefer not to die now. Mislynching obviously doesn't help and it won't even prove anything if Rafay was town the whole time anyway. I didn't have a backup theory though lol so idk who to target instead.

Oh dang I totally forgot Torres was even still in this game lol. Where you at buddy?

[Lord MK]

First

RIP Finster

And uh....Tony was town

This was his last post. And only post on d4.
So he's inactive and also doing the stating the obvious scum tell.

[brewersalliance]

Torres will be mod killed tomorrow if he doesn't post

The EC is always town and cannot be scum

[Lord MK]

Bring back the Baby.
We will replace each and every one until the baby no longer gets night killed.

[lilweirdward]

Lynch the first Finster that survives a night. I like it. I support that plan.

[Rafay]

The EC is always town and cannot be scum

 

I didnt want to do it. But I had to before a grievous mistake was made.....  

[The Warrior]

If no one counters Rafay then he is confirmed town and should not be voted for. Please chime in if you haven’t yet.

@Torres - Any thoughts to share?
Deadline is 9am CST tomorrow. We need to figure out what we want to do.

[Rafay]

Bring back the Baby. We will replace each and every one until the baby no longer gets night killed.

 

Why do you want me lynched so bad??

 

His first post if he rejoins will be a vote against me.

[lilweirdward]

First

RIP Finster

And uh....Tony was town

This was his last post. And only post on d4.
So he's inactive and also doing the stating the obvious scum tell.

Thinking about this again, it did seem really weird at the time. It's also suspicious that he didn't engage once during the whole me/Rafay/Lyner drama. Not sure if brewers is actually replacing him with deadline so close, but the play so far is scummy enough to warrant a vote anyway.

Vote: Torres

Bring back the Baby. We will replace each and every one until the baby no longer gets night killed.

Why do you want me lynched so bad??

His first post if he rejoins will be a vote against me.

If he tries to lynch you without anyone countering your EC claim then I'll happily help you kill him one more time