1065 replies to this topic

[Electric Mango]

I think that I have more votes than anyone right now so I'd like nothing more than to find someone else to start taking some heat but I really doubt that it's AoD. Mole did a very good analysis of AoD's posts but I don't get any scum tells from it. I tend to believe AoD's role claim about being the doc and here's why. Most games do have a doc role, AoD knows this as he has played many games before. If AoD role claimed he was the doc, the chances of the real doc calling him out would be too big of a risk to take if indeed AoD was scum.

While I like Mole's aggressiveness I think he's barking up the wrong tree and could be leading the town to our 2nd wrong lynch.

[angel of doom]

reason i claimed at the time was because i had the majority and according to Narsis time was almost up

[molestargazer]

Time is almost up, hence why I asked for an extension.

[Narsis]

If you guys can keep the activity going then i don't see a problem with a weeklong extension.

Deadline is now Sept. 15.

Also, votecount to come when i get some free time.

[Sir Jesus]

I think that I have more votes than anyone right now so I'd like nothing more than to find someone else to start taking some heat but I really doubt that it's AoD. Mole did a very good analysis of AoD's posts but I don't get any scum tells from it. I tend to believe AoD's role claim about being the doc and here's why. Most games do have a doc role, AoD knows this as he has played many games before. If AoD role claimed he was the doc, the chances of the real doc calling him out would be too big of a risk to take if indeed AoD was scum.

While I like Mole's aggressiveness I think he's barking up the wrong tree and could be leading the town to our 2nd wrong lynch.

With this post, I am now sure you are scum.

I'm getting good vibes from AoD, and I don't think we should lynch another possible power-role on D2.

I really believe AoD is a pro-town powerrole. Even if I wasn't sure, it would just seem illogical to lynch him based on the fact that the probability of a scum fake roleclaiming at 3 votes is unbelievably low (haven't ever seen it myself).

EM also knows that AoD is pro-town, but for a different reason: he is scum and knows his fellow scum-mates. EM is also not stupid. The last time a possible power-role presented themself, he jumped on them and successfully secured the kill. However, it was at a heavy cost: suspicion was cast heavily on him due to this action. Now that the opportunity has presented itself again, he taking the opposite road and is defending him.

Based on these actions, I have without a doubt determined that EM is scum and AoD is pro-town (doc).

I will bet these facts on my life. If EM is lynched and turns up anything but scum, I IMPLORE that you lynch me the next day!

Mole: I know you feel strongly about your analysis, but I feel even more secure of the scumminess of EM. I ask that you PLEASE change your vote to EM.

AoD: If you are really the doc, I ask that you protect me. I have a strong feeling that I will be scum target #1 with the lynch of one of their own.

[CanucksDynasty]

@Sir Jesus - I have considered what you said about EM. Since I had suspected both of them...I will cast my vote on him as well.

Vote: Electric Mango

[junkahoolik]

reason i claimed at the time was because i had the majority and according to Narsis time was almost up

i don't think you had the half majority needed for a lynch and there was still enough time... i don't really know what to believe now...

[Electric Mango]

Can we get a vote count. I don't want to be lynched until we use all the time available. I can't believe I have this many votes as I have done nothing wrong. All of SJ's accusations about me are ridiculous.

[Narsis]

The "Mod Knows All" VC

Carl Vincent - 1 (angel of doom)
angel of doom - 1 (molestargazer)
Electric Mango - 4 (CanucksDynsasty, Sir Jesus, Kaziocore, Falzis)

Not voting - 4 (Theophilos, Electric Mango, Carl Vincent, junkahoolik)

Also, working on a replacement for Carl Vincent.

[junkahoolik]

ya know, something seems off about AoD's claim. it bothered me since he did it. in short, i don't believe him.

vote AoD

[Falzis]

Unvote

I also don't believe AoD's role claim. He didn't have a half-majority vote before deadline lynch. He had 3 votes. That's not a half majority (it's 4 out of 7, 7 out of 12 is the majority lynch). Plus, if he is the doc, it's incredulous to role claim since he will surely be NKed since who would protect him. Unless he can protect himself, which I doubt, right?

Vote: Angel of Doom

[Falzis]

Carl Vincent - 2 (angel of doom, junkahoolik)
angel of doom - 3 (CanucksDynasty, Falzis, molestargazer)
Electric Mango - 2 (Sir Jesus, Kaziocore)

Not voting - 3 (Theophilos, Electric Mango, Carl Vincent)

The VC before AoD hinted at a power role. 3 votes. Too early.

[Sir Jesus]

Can we get a vote count. I don't want to be lynched until we use all the time available. I can't believe I have this many votes as I have done nothing wrong. All of SJ's accusations about me are ridiculous.

Nothing wrong? I personally am saddened by KevinH's loss, which you initiated...

Falzis, I really hope you see the truth in my logic before we lynch the wrong person again.

[Falzis]

Sorry I'm going with AoD on this one. It seems like an attempt to lure out a counter PR claim from the real doc. His role claim was premature to say the least.

[Kaziocore]

Unvote

I also don't believe AoD's role claim. He didn't have a half-majority vote before deadline lynch. He had 3 votes. That's not a half majority (it's 4 out of 7, 7 out of 12 is the majority lynch). Plus, if he is the doc, it's incredulous to role claim since he will surely be NKed since who would protect him. Unless he can protect himself, which I doubt, right?

Vote: Angel of Doom

Your right. This sounds really fishy. I'll have to rethink my vote for EM.

[angel of doom]

so what is the half majority then? cause unless i'm wrong we got kevinH with 4 votes before his lynch and i was going off narsis claim that the day was almost up before the extension. but if you wanna lynch me then go ahead. just remember the first 4 ppl will be under the most scrutiny after i'm dead and my role is relieved. also i can protect myself if i so choose btw so that argument is a moot point

[Sir Jesus]

so what is the half majority then? cause unless i'm wrong we got kevinH with 4 votes before his lynch and i was going off narsis claim that the day was almost up before the extension. but if you wanna lynch me then go ahead. just remember the first 4 ppl will be under the most scrutiny after i'm dead and my role is relieved. also i can protect myself if i so choose btw so that argument is a moot point

Not only this, but EM's public defense of AoD will be heralded as pro-town and he slips under everyone's radar.

[angel of doom]

TBH i still have my doubts about EM being scum, however i have a overwhelming feeling about falzis and Kaziocore

[Electric Mango]

Nothing wrong? I personally am saddened by KevinH's loss, which you initiated...

My vote was just a random vote. Go back and read all the posts again, it was Mole and Martino that were responsible for his death and got everyone to vote for KevinH, not me.

[molestargazer]

Despite what EM has said, I still strongly believe that AoD is scum and should be our lynch for today. I haven't even finished the PBP. Yet he did very little to contribute to the game during D1 and was very quick to make a fake PR claim during D2 when it was completely unnecessary, as someone has pointed out.

Other candidates for today's lynch - well, the main one is EM. I'm not really feeling the EM case right now. This, admittedly, could be due to my pushing for AoD's lynch, but reading Sir Jesus' original vote-post on EM, I really can't see much worth pointing out. His lesser contribution than in other games was prewarned by EM himself, and so is a nulltell in terms of his alignment. Sir Jesus really didn't give EM much of a chance to respond before jumping to a vote. @EM - Why did you ask the question about Carl Vincent that Sir Jesus pointed out here?

Cases are getting stronger as time in the game goes by. I feel that Sir Jesus' case on EM is a little reaching. Whilst I will be the first to admit the case I have presented for AoD's lynch isn't watertight, I still feel that he's really worth a lynch.

To those who voted EM - are there other reasons for his lynch other than those Sir Jesus pointed out in his original post? If so, could you please link me to them?

TBH i still have my doubts about EM being scum, however i have a overwhelming feeling about falzis and Kaziocore

Overwhelming? Is this just gut or do you have any compelling evidence? You just seem to be casting accusations around without anything to back them up.

My vote was just a random vote. Go back and read all the posts again, it was Mole and Martino that were responsible for his death and got everyone to vote for KevinH, not me.

Responsibility that I will accept. I will accept that I played a major part in KevinH's death, and don't particularly regret it either. He was scummy as hell, and if he had survived I would just be on his back again today. At least this way we can move on.

as I've stated, I will probably finish the AoD PBP today.