1065 replies to this topic

[Kaziocore]

so, you want to lynch him for that?? huuuuuh??

Nooooooo.... I'm saying that this

If AoD is pro town, we should save him. But on one condition. That next day, he should reveal what power role he has or what information he has that will help the town (if cop or whatnot and who he investigated). If he doesn't, we lynch him.

may not happen because he might get nked...

[CanucksDynasty]

long weekend with stat holiday.
48 hr absence notice.

since AOD has stated a power role...I will unvote for now...
this doesn't necessarily convince me.
you could still be a scum hoping to stay alive.

Unvote: AOD

CD.

[angel of doom]

since i'm most likely going to be nk'd i gotta say the ppl i suspect the most are Kaziocore and Falzis. i'm not the cop in this game but those are the ones i'm been getting the most vibes from

[molestargazer]

well i'm going to pull a kevinH here, reread my posts and figure it out

And that was exactly the reason why KevinH kept his secret 'til the grave.
Tell us, for christ's sake.

[angel of doom]

fine if you really must know i'm the doc. i mean why do you think i was so worried about a weak doc? i was trying to keep my own skin safe

[molestargazer]

No you're not.
Unvote
Vote: Angel of Doom

[Kaziocore]

Is that vote for emphasis or something because you already voted him?

[molestargazer]

For emphasis more than anything else. And as a kind of just in case.

[molestargazer]

MOD: REQUEST DEADLINE EXTENSION OF A FEW DAYS.
It's in a few days, we could use the extra time. People need to check in and give their opinions on AoD's claim and the case on him.

Time for a Post-by-post on AoD, as promised.

• Post 1. Nothing to see here.
• Post 2. Casts a random vote on KevinH, and Post 3 corrects the bolding. Nothing to see here either.
• Post 4. Switches vote to Falzis without any reason at all.
• Post 5. Fluff.
• Post 6. Asks for a vote count.
• Post 7. Responds to a post by junk with one-line saying it's "kinda hard" to "game" (Scumhunt) on D1.
• Post 8. Says that a "john doe" doesn't necessarily need to die.
• Post 9. Throws doubt on whether CV can use the 'new' excuse and for how long.
  
  We've reached Page 4 - and really, there's no real content that AoD has given. He's not put across any thoughts of who he thinks is scum, and has just chipped in with odd notes. This could even be classed as trying to stay 'under the radar'.
  
• Post 10. Finally puts some suspicion on and FoSes Kaziocore, for an earlier OMGUS. He says he isn't unvoting from Falzis because 'something seems off' - there's still been no reasons given for this continuing vote, and I don't like that.
• Post 11. Asks why Falzis is defending Kaziocore. This could have been a reason for his vote, if it had happened before AoD puts the vote on. It's a valid point, but I wonder about the timing of the vote.
• Post 12. Kinda fluffy, agrees with a point that people shouldn't stick up for others in case they slip. Not much to see here.
• Post 13. Agrees that KevinH voting is strange. All the content in these past few posts is really agreeing with other people, and not placing a proper or solid opinion. AoD's vote is still on Falzis here. There's nothing been done at all, and that's scummy.
• Post 14. More of the same. Agreeing that KevinH looks scummy, but still doesn't do anything about it.
  Post 15. Fluff. Asks for a vote count.
• Post 16. Fluff. Asks what WIFOM is.
  
• Post 17. The only real opinion-giving post I've seen from AoD in the whole game so far. He makes his vote for KevinH using the setup as a reason - I dislike this, for reasons already given.
• Post 18. Accuses CV of bandwagoning, and asks for a vote count. Not much to see here either.

I've reached the end of Page 10. I'm finding AoD's lack of real contribution really quite scummy. I don't like his reasonings for voting KevinH, and the rest of his posts are very weak in the amount of force given in the opinions, with a lot of fluff posts.
He's had a vote on Falzis for 8 pages without giving any reasonings for it, and without contributing or changing his vote to people who made the scummy posts he mentioned.

If you ask me, so far in this read, AoD looks very much like tentative scum.

[angel of doom]

No you're not.
Unvote
Vote: Angel of Doom

so why is it that you think i'm lying?

also while i'm on it, you were pushing damn hard for kevinH's role and now me, and when i do say my role you call me a lair. it is counter productive.

and again while i'm at it, if i'm lynched and i do turn out to be protown are you willing to be lynched yourself?

[molestargazer]

so why is it that you think i'm lying?

also while i'm on it, you were pushing damn hard for kevinH's role and now me, and when i do say my role you call me a lair. it is counter productive.

There's a reason I asked for your role. It certainly influenced my opinion.
Up 'til now, I think you're quite scummy. This plus the fact it's amazingly unlikely we try and lynch 2 pro-town powerroles in 2 days makes me think that you're trying to save your own skin with a PR claim.

and again while i'm at it, if i'm lynched and i do turn out to be protown are you willing to be lynched yourself?

Yes.
At first, KevinH's lynch was just for the sake of a D1 lynch - as time grew by, he became more and more scummy.
Today, I honestly think you're scum, and will be happy to take the blame if you're not.

[angel of doom]

so your saying that it's impossible for the town to potentially lynch 2 power roles in 2 days?

[angel of doom]

also your post by post analysis seem oddly like your post by post analysis of kevinH in post #144

[molestargazer]

so your saying that it's impossible for the town to potentially lynch 2 power roles in 2 days?

No. I'm saying it's very unlikely, and makes me more likely to think you're lying about your PR.

also your post by post analysis seem oddly like your post by post analysis of kevinH in post #144

Well, yeah, that's kinda the point, it's a post-by-post analysis of you.
What's so similar about it and why is this a problem?

[angel of doom]

the problem with it is that your post by post contributed to getting KevinH lynched, and if you think i am lying about having a PR then why push for me to reveal my role if your just going to call me a liar?

[molestargazer]

Whether or not I called you out on lying depended on what you claimed.

You contributed to getting KevinH lynched. Everyone who voted on that wagon contributed to the lynch. You can't call me out on that.
Also, if you bothered to actually READ the PBP on KevinH, you may have noticed that I ended with a gut feeling that KevinH was town at the time - I voted only because we need a lynch. Only AFTER the PBP did KevinH really start acting scummy.

[angel of doom]

i'd like to hear everyone else's take on this, particularly Kaziocore who i've seen lurking but not posting

[molestargazer]

i'd like to hear everyone else's take on this, particularly Kaziocore who i've seen lurking but not posting

Sounds good to me. I'll finish off the PBP either this afternoon or tomorrow - hopefully we can get that extension I asked for. (MOD: Hint hint)

[Kaziocore]

i'd like to hear everyone else's take on this, particularly Kaziocore who i've seen lurking but not posting

Because I have nothing yet to post.

Since AOD has said that he has a power role and I'm not really sure if he's lying, I guess I'll stick with EM now.

And I also saw EM and Theo lurking but not posting.

[junkahoolik]

seems odd for the doc to role claim d2 with just 3 votes on him... i mean, sure he will probably survive the lynch, but who will protect him during the night??

Unvote