1065 replies to this topic

[Kaziocore]

falzis, it wasn't a case of letting AoD live. it was one of trying to find the summoner first. and the explications weren't to say that "here is how things are" they were more of "this is why i played like i played".
anyway, i doubt that kevin was a summoner or a summoned being since his color is green in the dead people list and he has written to his right "pro town". so either there are 2 summoners and one is pro town or there is just 1 summoner. if there are 2 summoners and one is protown, he'd be at a severe disadvantage with both the town players and the other summoner and his minions after his tail. so i doubt that very much. i also think that SJ has info on falzis since he seemed to defend him on d3 and d4. i would very much like to hear what he has to say. also, if he is so sure that falzis isn't scum, i'll move my vote to theo's replacement. i find it dubious that he asked to be replaced at around the same time when EM got lynched. could it be that he lost his nk ability with EM's loss and considered it a lost cause??

unvote

vote: crazyemolad

can't the other summoner be pro-town?

[junkahoolik]

can't the other summoner be pro-town?

doubtful with the amount of power roles we have around here that have not been contested.


but, truth is that i'm starting to smell a rotten fish in here the more i think of this game. let's call him a SJ short for Sharky junior
i don't understand one thing about him: he claims to be a seer and he roleclaims. but, he then votes for the lynch of the roleclaimed doc. why?? one answer could be that he thought there was another doctor. but, he then exposes the townie doctor first thing during this day thus proving that he didn't think that. so why did he vote for the doc last night?? wasn't he afraid he'd get NK'd??

what do you know that we don't?? and also, do you mean to say that there is a pro town cop also that is receiving information?? and, considering the amount of protection you are granting falzis, is he the cop?? cause i really don't buy that... it would mean a insane amount of power roles pro town that way...

Oh Doctor Protect Me

Gahhh ..... I hate doing this .......

I have special powers that let me look into your souls. I am not a cop, nor am I physically able to move well.

I have looked into EM's soul, and what I have seen is DANGEROUS.

I felt him killing. I knew he had slain someone that night, but didn't know until the morning with the rest of you.

and lookie what i found...

unvote

[junkahoolik]

hmm... i'll post more after someone else does some posting

[junkahoolik]

if i killed the game, does that make me the sole winner of this edition??

anyway, can i get some prods here??

[Narsis]

i believe that the lack of activity would be due to Thanksgiving(at least that'd be why up here in Canada).

but yes i can drop some prods...

[CanucksDynasty]

Mmmmm...turkey turkey.


Interesting post Junk. I'll give it some thought. But I wanna hear from some of the others first about your idea on SJ.

[Falzis]

I floated the same idea as much when I FoSed SJ way back in early D4. IF he is scum he's definitely not on the same side of EM or the controller. Two scum factions or self-aligneds?

[CanucksDynasty]

If SJ is not townie...then I think he might be "self-aligned".

The thing I don't get is why SJ doesn't want to share his findings on N2?
Both Mole and SJ (doc and seer) roleclaimed.
If mafia were to target anybody it would be them.
So why the reluctance to share the info on N2????
That info would help the town (by removing a suspect).

He said he didn't want mafia to have another target but why in the world would mafia want to target someone else???

I'm very tempted to vote for SJ.

[junkahoolik]

well, since it seems like i like exposing possible situations, let me throw this this in also... i think there is a pro town summoner and i think he is kazio. he has been alluding that there is one since all throughout d4. so kazio, if you are a summoner, what do you control??

[angel of doom]

vote:SJ

i want to hear about what you got on night 2, now is not the time to be holding back info

as you can probably tell i'm mole's replacement

[CanucksDynasty]

vote:SJ

i want to hear about what you got on night 2, now is not the time to be holding back info

as you can probably tell i'm mole's replacement

I thought I was crazy for a moment.

[junkahoolik]

weren't you... dead or something??

anyway, welcome back!!

[angel of doom]

necromancy FTW! sad thing is i cant win so i'm just filling the void oh well

[angel of doom]

1 summoner:???
2 docs: me(self aligned/controlled, and mole/me pro town)
1 seer: SJ
1 vig: Kevin H
1 demon:EM(self aligned/controlled)
1 townie: Martino

thats 7 roles so far plus an unknown amount of scum/town/summoner out of the remaining 5 roles

[Sir Jesus]

If SJ is not townie...then I think he might be "self-aligned".

The thing I don't get is why SJ doesn't want to share his findings on N2?
Both Mole and SJ (doc and seer) roleclaimed.
If mafia were to target anybody it would be them.
So why the reluctance to share the info on N2????
That info would help the town (by removing a suspect).

He said he didn't want mafia to have another target but why in the world would mafia want to target someone else???

I'm very tempted to vote for SJ.

For two simple reasons I will not release this information:
- Weakens the town in the long run, we want to keep pro-town identities hidden (if this person is hidden)
- There is no reason to release the information, the person is not in danger of being lynched. Nor have they dropped any breadcrumbs for me or others to pick up on.


There is little to no benefit for naming this person or their ability.


However, the mafia would freakin' LOVE to know this person's identity.......

vote: Canucksdynasty

[angel of doom]

wrong it does since it narrows our potential suspect list by 1 person

[junkahoolik]

Falzis - ?? falzis has pointed out that it was obvious that mole was doc. i'd have expected the doc dead if he was scum. but, there is the possibility tha the maf lost their nk'ing ability so...

crazyemolad - ?? though theo left the game at a dubious time. also, crazy never did anything except bandwaggon. no reasons said no nothing... he looks dubious if you ask me.

molestargazer - i think this guy right here is the doc. he roleclaimed very subtly and before it was needed. he also counterclaimed to AoD's doc claim just not 100% explicitly.

junkahoolik - that be me

CanucksDynasty - i'm pretty sure this guy right here is a townie.

Sir Jesus - i don't know what to think of him. i had to ask him explicitly D4 what the name of his role was. he never said anything except that he wasn't the cop before that. afraid he would get counterclaimed maybe?? he also showed no fear of getting nk'd during N3. would have expected a investigative role to really know he is the one who will be targeted first and to be a lot more defensive.

Aquinas - i think he is a townie

Kaziocore - ?? though he has been always going on about there being a pro town summoner. i'd like to hear more from him.


also, what's the basis for your vote on CD, SJ??

[Kaziocore]

Wait a minute why is AoD here again?

[Falzis]

Unvote

I'll leave junk alone for now because I think CD and SJ would be the choices for my vote. One wants the information, one wants to keep it hidden. Both have reasons to do so. Hmm

[Kaziocore]

oh okay he's mole's replacement