Imran Ehsan

Exactly something a scum will do. It was clear from the beginning of the game that the best way to find the scum, specially as we have an insane cop amongst is, is to post night investigations and look for inconsistencies. But you want to blend in with the crowd so you wanted to see what the strategy of the town will be before making your move. Hence, your inquiry as to what path the town is going to take. In any case, I will get lynched as both me and karl both have 2 votes each and I reaches the half majority first. So either d3mon has to witch his vote or Rafay has to vote for karl before deadline to get the scum before he gets a chance to make a night kill.

Well thats pretty nice analysis. I think its clear what should be done. Except karl should be lynched and not me. vote xx karl xx

Whoa..hold up there. this is pretty interesting that you came up with a Town claim on kevinh several hours after I had already posted my investigation. It seems to me like the scum would wait until everyone has posted their investigations and then make a case and make up a claim to get a lynch. I havent had time to do an analysis of the results yet but from what I gather through a quick glance, from your analysis, it seems you are equally as likely to be scum as me. Except that you had chance and time to think up your strategy. I will post again when I get a chance to go through the permutations, but putting it up here now so hopefully people will not be jumping on a quick lynch by following the scum.

Yay..nice to be back in the game after so long. May I see that this is an interesting setup. As for the game, I am not too experienced but I also agree we should all post our night investigations and look for inconsistencies. My investigation target: KevinH. I got town.

*signs up* :big_boss:

Good point ccabal. Psychopath looks very likely in this game. And since MOD is looking for a replacement I will go with the no lynch option on Day 1 too. Unvote: JohnGato Vote: No Lynch

I don't see what we gain by not lynching on Day 1. It didn't work out that well even in the last game. We just went into Day 2 with no info and had to make a random lynch anyway. With a large pool of players we have more leeway even if we lynch a townie..so I am voting for a lynch. Who to lynch? JohnGato. He is the only one who has not posted yet and an inactive townie is useless even if he is a power role. :suicidebastard: Vote: JohnGato

I wouldnt be surprised if there is a scum doc or a scum doc too.

Yeah with 16 people in this game it will be doubly hard to pin down the scum Hope there are some cool new roles though.

mayo

Meh...in hind sight we should have lynched Rafay first and then ABD. At least I was right that eva999 is not a confirmed townie. KevinH and Rafay voting for each other should have made it clear. Ahh well, well done scummy guys... edit: actually killing Rafay earlier would not have worked anyway since he had ccabal seduced from early on anyway.

I dont get it. So the scum won even with 2 townies surviving? Assuming he killed one in the night.

Onwards to the next day vote: rafay

Also I am not sure why AbigDeer's role was not posted. I assume he was scum because the scene description says the dragon wanted to kill townies, but to confirm.... To MOD: What was the role of Danidoun the Dragon?

Feels good to be right for a change... I think we all know who to go for next. Rafay tried his level best to save his scummy partner but failed. I wonder what the special power of the dragon was though. Not very clear on what it meant when the wizard came back to life to kill it.

I still say we go for ABigDeer. But having been wrong the last 2 Days, I will join with whoever xx karl xx decides for as he is the only confirmed townie apart from ccabal.

Ok first we need to make sure you really are who you are. You say you have read ccabal's role pm. I read the pm too as we both received it together. The princess is described in the first line as _____ and _____. What are the words? So assuming you get those right, we have 3 confirmed townies. Now, the scum candidates: KevinH: Interesting character here. Rafay voted to lynch him on Day 2. If Rafay is scummy why would he vote to lynch him? KevinH also voted to lynch Rafay on Day 3. They seems to be voting for each other. Either, one is inncocent or both are scum and they are intentionally doing it to throw townies off. ABigDeer: Has not voted at all since voting to lynch Nerau. He looks like a confirmed scum to me. Rafay: The only reason he has escaped being lynched so far is because people have been thinking he is drawing too much attention to be scum. Unless he is really the scum and once he saw he got off the hook from being lynched he just continued with his style of play. eva999: OK this is where it is interesting. Are we sure he is not scum? He did save me from being lynched the previous day but he would also know RoT was innocent (if eva is scum). If he is not scum, then assuming that there are 3 scums in the game, its KevinH, ABigDeer and Rafay. Why would KevinH and Rafay vote for each other if both are scum?? Maybe there's 2 scum in the game, which would mean either KevinH or Rafay are also innocent. My point is we should go for the confirmed scum lynch today. And to me it looks like ABigDeer.

If there is a cop, please role claim. I hope you have at least confirmed that either ccabal and me and townies or identified one of the scum. If there are no cops in the game...well doubtful anyone will believe us. If there's 3 scum, then this is the end game..will be tight but if all townies vote together we may take down the scum.

The couple of games I played in so far were Closed setup. So I would like to try out the other version. Voted.

We did ask for an extension and for the Cop / other townie roles to come forward. I even posted earlier that l would entertain other options apart from RoT if theories are brought forward. But no one came forward and no theories were posted. In that scenario RoT was the only option left.

Yeah Rafay did vote for EM. But it came after the deadline. RoT did not..but he didn't have to...the half majority was reached without his vote anyway. And it is doubtful Rafay is scum..simply because he is playing so badly. He is just a temperamental and whimsical voter which is almost as bad for the townies as it is good for the real scum. So really it was a win win situation for the scum. Townies were voting for either EM or Rafay..both townies. so they just had to sit back and watch..exactly what RoT did.

So ever wonder why I did not vote to lynch Narau on Day 2 when everyone was bandwagoning to get him lynched? If I remember correctly I voted pretty early for a no lynch option before the lynch was sealed. If I were a scum I would have stayed silent or joined the lynching party. Against that we have you who have been voting to lynch every townie in sight from day 2. Switching votes and counter accusing as a scum anyone who suspects you. KevinH vote is interesting though. In any case, since no cop seems to be coming forth I will stick by my suspicions of RoT as I have stated earlier. Vote: Reign of Terror

Yes there is a little more to our roles then just to ability to talk. There was also a very good reason on why ccabal came out of the closet so early. However, revealing that part of our role will just be handing out ourselves to the scum so I don't believe we will be revealing it. If I get lynched (as the scum are pushing to do so) you will get to know it anyway.

Pretty sure that the scum are pushing for a lynch right now.

I am confirming ccabal's role claim. Also would like an extension since I am pretty sure that another townie lynch this day will be a sure win for the scum.