The Warrior

That's pretty much Rafay's MO. Stays silent until he gets a vote or two, shows up and calls the voter a name, OMGUS votes, and then disappears. Not saying he can't be scum of course because he very well could be. We're just at a point where we only have a couple chances left to lynch correctly and will need to start agreeing on who to lynch. I'm obviously being framed! Mind you, it's subtle, but still - it would take an experienced player to come up with a scheme so cruel, so I suggest looking into mafia players with some seniority! And in addition, someone who might have motivation to kill LWW, Torres, and finally ghaws in order to get me framed! Just take a moment to think about this, alright? Only a fool would go forward with killing ghaws, but if you consider me such a fool, then most probably nothing I say will make you chance your mind. After all, there's this big case built against me, so why shouldn't you vote? Truth be told (literally haha), if there's any ounce of trust left for me in you, I want you to hold on to that, as I assure you, I'm working solely for the good of this town, and nothing else. I ain't pointing any fingers because... I'm pretty much clueless as to how I should proceed. This is murky waters, and I'm not a great swimmer. Being framed is obviously a possibility. If you believe you're being framed do you care to venture a theory about who is crafting that strategy?

The Covenant is invading and KevinH is worried about his fantasy football team getting trashed..

As expected Wolfpacks was a VT unfortunately and ghaws was killed at night. Yesterday's final vote: Brewers made an interesting argument in favor of lynching Ferastical yesterday. It's interesting that ghaws was killed at night since he was the only other to vote for Ferastical (granted it was before Brewers made his long argument against him). ghaws did say though that he believed Ferastical to be scum unless there was a convincing reason not to think so. This isn't necessarily condemning of Ferastical but could be scum trying to eliminate potential opposition that they think could be locked onto one of their own. It's worth monitoring. We're down to 7 town vs 3 mafia now so we have 2 mislynches left if we don't hit scum today or tomorrow. I'm also interested in hearing from the people who voted for someone other than Wolfpacks, Lord MK, or Ferastical yesterday. Lord MK cast the only vote for Lyner and Finster cast the only vote for Rafay. @Lord MK - Can you explain your reasoning again for voting Lyner when it looked like there was little chance he'd be lynched? @Finster - Can you explain your reasoning again for voting Rafay when it looked like there was little chance he'd be lynched?

Up to 13 players now.

10 so far. Keep em coming!

To be fair the odds of him being a Vig were pretty low to begin with.

Sounds good. Thanks.

Good afternoon all, The Harry Potter saga returns for my next game: [TW-13] Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince! You won't want to miss all the action in the penultimate game in this series! Sign up now! Players: 1) Dontavian 2) Wolfpacks 3) KevinH 4) Tony Maurice 5) Rafay 6) lilweirdward 7) Torres951 8) Brewersalliance 9) Finster Baby 10) Lyner 11) Ferastical 12) Lord MK 13) Ali bin Turban 14) Robert2424 15) Velocity 16) Nadarr 17) Kaziocore 18) Chaplain of Death

I voted for captainjf for 2 reasons: 1) I think he's new to mafia here. I almost always welcome new players to the game with a welcome vote on day 1. 2) He hasn't posted yet. Yes I'm not as active as I used to be either but he hasn't posted at all. If he shows up and starts posting I will most likely remove my vote from him. I'm working on this. Trying to be more active since work is slowing down for me. @Velocity - Can you please prod captainjf again if you haven't recently?

I'm assuming that Wolfpacks will indeed turn up as a VT unfortunately since deadline is passed and he knows that we can't change the vote anyway and he still maintains his towniness. We'll see for sure but I'm assuming that will be the case..

I saw what you did there. wait he is in this game? has he even posted? @velocity can u ping him and if he doesnt post can u line up a replacement? i dont think TW has shown up yet either... if they dont show up close to deadline are u gonna look at replacing them or will they both be mod killed? also would u do both a lynch and a mod kill? or would a lynch stop the mod kill from happening? Throwin' non-post shade at me without even knowing that I've posted. Come on man. Vote: captainjf Welcome to mafia. Also, where you at?

The arguments about Ferastical and Wolfpacks are both interesting. I don't personally have a strong scum read on either of them. Ferastical's actions could be scummy (as pointed out by the information Brewers linked from the mafiawiki) but it could also be that he just doesn't know what to do and is just trying to follow others. Wolfpacks on the other hand isn't really acting any different than he does in any other game so it's hard to read. Deadline is in 20 minutes though and unless other people vote in the last couple minutes Wolfpacks might be our only choice since he is currently leading the vote and we need to do something. At the very least we might get some direction on what to do tomorrow by lynching one of them and seeing what their alignment ends up being. Vote: Wolfpacks

He said it to everyone. You should never lynch based off of events from previous games. It hurts the integrity of the game to do so. Additionally, stop calling people names. That has no place here. We have a war to win against an alien race now. Onward to Reach!

“Boo” [ooc]I tell Brewers he’s drunk all the time. I’m rarely wrong. [/ooc]

It is possible that a JOAT protected a Scum but that wouldn’t block a kill anyway. Scum aren’t going to kill scum.

Sorry about my absence folks. Damn rl. Also, @rafay - bad read. I was confirmed town.

Sorry again about my relative inactivity. There is all sorts of stuff going on irl for me right now. To address a few things that have been said today so far: First off, I don’t think anyone needs to actually justify why they voted for Tony. His actions warranted the votes against him. I’m not surprised he ended up being town but he also deserved the votes he got based off of in game actions. Having said that, there probably was at least one scum in there somewhere but this would also be an easy place for the majority of scum to stay away from while town kills town. Secondly, Rafay calling out the 7 people who voted for Tony and asking for justification from us all is again, ridiculous. He earned his votes. Thirdly, There is very little reason why scum wouldn’t have killed on given night with the low odds of a town JOAT catching someone in the process so it’s likely that at least one of our JOAT’s uses a protective action last night. So if that was you, you probably know who at least one more townie is today. I advise sitting on that knowledge unless absolutely necessary to save that person in line for a lynch or until we’re in a LYLO situation or something.

Vote: Tony Tony is now at L-1. Deadline is in ~5 hours. Anyone who hasn’t voted yet please keep that in mind.

@Robert - The JOAT’s actions are specifically stated in the OP.. everyone knows im VT, the vote of me is out of principle after I ended the day twice. The votes for you are because you’ve done things that are scummy. And yes that includes casting the final vote early two days in a row. The second day may not have been several days early like the first one was but did you not think about the response you got to your day 1 vote at all when you voted on day 2?

Deadline is Monday so I’m not in a hurry to vote but I’m still leaning toward Tony.

Two things stand out to me about the day 1 no lynch in particular: 1) It wasn’t just a few hours early. It was several days early. 2) It was shortly after we actually started discussing our options in more detail with regards to putting together a strategy. We still had time to discuss and it was taken away from us.

Sorry to hear that Velocity. I do know the feeling. Take care.

I am Sansa Stark and I began the game as a town Compulsive FBI Agent. My role changed on night 3 when I investigated Finster. Finster was actually Petyr Baelish (Littlefinger). Upon my investigation of him my role and alignment changed. I became a Jack-of-All-Trades member of the Serial Killer faction. I had one shot each of Governor, Cop, and Role Cop. On the day that Finster was supposed to be lynched I saved him with my Governor role. When Rafay finally role claimed we knew for certain that he was the last mafia alive because not only was his role clearly fabricated but he also claimed Finster's real character name (Littlefinger). We couldn't share that bit of information with Dontavian of course though so we made our argument against Rafay without disclosing that. Rafay made our final arguments easy for us with his role claim. I am surprised that Dontavian didn't call Rafay on his obvious lie though.

Told you Rafay was scum.

@Dontavian We also never figured out what happened on the night when there were three kills. You’re not factoring in what Lyner did that night though. He jailed me. I’m assuming you didn’t commit one of those kills. I’m assuming Lyner didn’t commit one of those kills. I couldn’t have committed one of those kills. That leaves Rafay and Finster as the only two other people who could have committed a kill. It’s not a given that Finster is town but we have a lot more actual evidence that suggests he is with multiple different types of cop investigations coming back clean against him. Rafay on the other hand only has your one investigation result clearing him (which he is basically disputing himself when he says that he commuted every night). All evidence suggests Rafay is scum. Why leave the game up to chance when you can win it for us now?