761 replies to this topic

[Preston]

Thanks for responding AKC. It doesnt really add anything more... but it at least states your views.

I'm on the fence still. Both AKC and CD have good reasons to vote for them.

I want to hear other peoples' reactions to this discussion - we cant let anyone get a free pass by staying quiet.

In particular, TC: As our only proven townie, what do you think between AKC and CD?

-Preston

VOTE COUNT
CanucksDynasty (1): AKCPLUTO
AKCPLUTO (1): CanucksDynasty
Electric Mango (1): TerrorChrist

Not Voting (4): Preston, ccabal86, Electric Mango, reign of terror

With 7 Alive, 4 is needed to lynch.

Edited by molestargazer, 13 May 2011 - 12:32 PM.

[TerrorChrist]

At this point, I would rest my case insofar as CD's voting record speaks for itself, whereas I am a simple and innocent townie who has made a legit role claim that has yet to be undermined. Furthermore, CD's veteran slyness should be kept in consideration insofar as he knows how to pull a few fast ones, which is exactly what he has done throughout the game with the aforementioned votes. With that, I am not sure what else I can or should say. As such, as I said and will say again, I am innocent until proven guilty and so, I invoke my right to remain silent.

I would say that you claiming a role which is similar in many aspects to the one I have claimed is quite a legit undermining of your roleclaim...
[/color]

[TerrorChrist]

At this point, I would rest my case insofar as CD's voting record speaks for itself, whereas I am a simple and innocent townie who has made a legit role claim that has yet to be undermined. Furthermore, CD's veteran slyness should be kept in consideration insofar as he knows how to pull a few fast ones, which is exactly what he has done throughout the game with the aforementioned votes. With that, I am not sure what else I can or should say. As such, as I said and will say again, I am innocent until proven guilty and so, I invoke my right to remain silent.

I would say that you claiming a role which is similar in many aspects to the one I have claimed is quite a legit undermining of your roleclaim...
[/color]

[AKCPLUTO]

TC, in which case, I wouldn't put it past Mole for putting two roles that are this similar in a game like this?

[TerrorChrist]

I have no idea what you just said. What is "putting it past Mole"

[Electric Mango]

Mole is Molestargazer, the IRON legend who is running this game.

[reign of terror]

I still think that AKC and CD might be both townies. That leaves Preston, EM, and ccabal86 to be the mafia. Just an idea I am throwing out there!

[CanucksDynasty]

I still think that AKC and CD might be both townies. That leaves Preston, EM, and ccabal86 to be the mafia. Just an idea I am throwing out there!

Impossible that AKC and myself can both be townies. Just 3 mafia votes and the game would be over. It's been a couple of days already and neither of us has been lynched. So what the means is that ACK is mafia or I am mafia. It's ACK that is mafia.

And it's been almost a full day with a vote on EM by TC (a known townie). If it's not game over soon...then I have to believe that EM is mafia.

[ccabal86]

I still think that AKC and CD might be both townies. That leaves Preston, EM, and ccabal86 to be the mafia. Just an idea I am throwing out there!

I'm 100% sure that is not the case, because I'm a townie

Anyway it all seems to boil down to CD or AKC, with possibly EM as a possible second mafia member? Since we haven't learned that much in the past few days I think what everyone should do now is put a FoS on the person you'd vote for if you had to vote RIGHT NOW. Maybe that will spark some discussion.

FoS: CanucksDynasty

[ccabal86]

Addendum: Oh yeah, please state your reasons for the FoS if you haven't already. If you already voted, then no need to FoS obviously.

[reign of terror]

FOS-Preston

If CD and ccabal aren't lying, and AKC is lying that would leave AKC, Preston, and EM to be scum. Also Preston has not been challenged at all this entire game. Preston also voted for d3mon and then backed off quickly after d3mon roleclaimed as the security guard. Seems like something a scum would do because he doesn't want to have a deciding vote on one of the town's leading roles.

[CanucksDynasty]

FOS-Preston

If CD and ccabal aren't lying, and AKC is lying that would leave AKC, Preston, and EM to be scum. Also Preston has not been challenged at all this entire game. Preston also voted for d3mon and then backed off quickly after d3mon roleclaimed as the security guard. Seems like something a scum would do because he doesn't want to have a deciding vote on one of the town's leading roles.

That is a possible combo.

It's clear that mafia combos are not...
CD+ACK
CD+cc
TC+EM

Known fact that TC is townie. If he guessed correctly on EM then we should not see a lynch (provided the remaining 2 townies do not vote). It's risky to wait but it's been a day and no lynch so far. If EM is not lynched...it confirms that he is mafia (cuz TC is townie and we assume 3 mafia in this game).

[CanucksDynasty]

Isn't it about time everyone to roleclaim? We're facing a LYLO.

So far...
ACK - Cowardly Lifeguard
CD - vanilla townie
Rot - vanilla townie
TC - ex lifeguard

[reign of terror]

Does anyone want a list of the votes and unvotes so far in this game? I was making one for myself, but if anyone else wants it I will post it here.

[CanucksDynasty]

@rot - sure...more info can't hurt.

@Pres - what are your thoughts on TC vote on EM?

[reign of terror]

Day 1

April 1st
Narsis votes KevinH
CD votes KevinH
Herodez votes KevinH
ccabal86 votes d3mon
d3mon votes Herodez
TC votes EM
CaoCao votes KevinH
Nerau votes ccabal86

April 2nd
EM votes ccabal86
CaoCao unvotes

April 4th
KevinH votes No-Lynch

April 6th
CaoCao votes TC

April 7th
KevinH unvotes then votes Herodez

April 8th
KevinH unvotes
d3mon unvotes then votes TC
CD unvotes then votes d3mon
KevinH votes No-Lynch

April 10th
Preston votes d3mon

April 11th
TC unvotes then votes d3mon
Preston unvotes

April 13th
CaoCao unvotes then votes d3mon
KevinH unvotes then votes CD
Preston votes d3mon

April 14th
Preston unvotes

[TerrorChrist]

Mole is Molestargazer, the IRON legend who is running this game.

That was actually the only bit that I DID understand

[reign of terror]

Day 2

April 25th
EM votes CaoCao

April 26th
CD votes CaoCao
ccabal86 votes CD
Preston votes CaoCao

April 29th
KevinH votes CaoCao
RoT votes AKC
RoT unvotes then votes CaoCao
Preston unvotes
RoT unvotes

May 1st
AKC votes CD

May 2nd
TC votes CaoCao

May 4th
RoT votes CaoCao
Preston votes CaoCao

Day 3
May 8th
AKC votes CD
CD votes AKC

May 9th
CD unvotes

May 10th
TC votes EM

May 11th
CD votes AKC

[CanucksDynasty]

Online right now...
Ccabal+rot+CD+TC
Means this is not a mafia combo.

[ccabal86]

Isn't it about time everyone to roleclaim? We're facing a LYLO.

So far...
ACK - Cowardly Lifeguard
CD - vanilla townie
Rot - vanilla townie
TC - ex lifeguard

All right, I guess that makes sense, it is LYLO after all. But even if we miss here we may have a (however slim) chance of living another day...

I'm a Restroom Attendant. I can "lock" people in the restroom for a night, preventing any action by that player to be carried out. The player I lock in, can't be nightkilled either. It's also unused - I was saving it for a LYLO situation as a last straw.