346 replies to this topic

[d3mon]

Well i have no clue on who could be Mafia. All i've seen are people making, what i think are, their usual day 1 claims or just random accusing with no evidence. What do we need to get the ball rolling?

Well.. accusing someone of being scum usually gets the ball rolling.

KevinH, why are you against the extension?

Are you impatient to get the night kill ??
or just happy to see that town has kinda agreed on No-lynch?

[CanucksDynasty]

After leading the lynch on the cop (security guard) in the last game...I'm starting to rethink my lynch on D1 policy. That lynch was a huge blow against the town.

We have 11 players with presumably 3 mafia.

If we did 2 consecutive no lynch, we would have 3 nights to gather info and 1 chance to get mafia before LYLO (worst case scenario and assuming only 1 nightkill).

D1 No Lynch - 8/3
N1 mafia kill - 7/3
D2 No Lynch - 7/3
N2 mafia kill - 6/3
D3 Lynch - 5/3
N3 mafia kill - 4/3
D4 LYLO

If we lynched on D1...we get 2 chances to lynch mafia and 2 nights to gather info.

D1 Lynch - 7/3
N1 mafia kill - 6/3
D2 Lynch - 5/3
N2 mafia kill - 4/3
D3 LYLO

Hmmmm

[FightingOkra]

Well then, I think Angel is Mafia. Reason: Gut feeling! will wait for his response to make a decision.

[FightingOkra]

After leading the lynch on the cop (security guard) in the last game...I'm starting to rethink my lynch on D1 policy. That lynch was a huge blow against the town.

We have 11 players with presumably 3 mafia.

If we did 2 consecutive no lynch, we would have 3 nights to gather info and 1 chance to get mafia before LYLO (worst case scenario and assuming only 1 nightkill).

D1 No Lynch - 8/3
N1 mafia kill - 7/3
D2 No Lynch - 7/3
N2 mafia kill - 6/3
D3 Lynch - 5/3
N3 mafia kill - 4/3
D4 LYLO

If we lynched on D1...we get 2 chances to lynch mafia and 2 nights to gather info.

D1 Lynch - 7/3
N1 mafia kill - 6/3
D2 Lynch - 5/3
N2 mafia kill - 4/3
D3 LYLO

Hmmmm

So that means you think we should no-lynch? I don't think a mafia player would recomend a no-lynch.

[CanucksDynasty]

Undecided at this point.

I think if everyone votes between 2 lynch candidates...then voting patterns can be established. If not everyone votes...then the importance of voting patterns are lessened.

Seeing the inactivity that generally is associated with D1...I'm leaning towards a no-lynch.

[CanucksDynasty]

BTW I will be away on vacation between July 12th - 17th with limited access to the internet.

[d3mon]

After leading the lynch on the cop (security guard) in the last game...I'm starting to rethink my lynch on D1 policy. That lynch was a huge blow against the town.

We have 11 players with presumably 3 mafia.

If we did 2 consecutive no lynch, we would have 3 nights to gather info and 1 chance to get mafia before LYLO (worst case scenario and assuming only 1 nightkill).

D1 No Lynch - 8/3
N1 mafia kill - 7/3
D2 No Lynch - 7/3
N2 mafia kill - 6/3
D3 Lynch - 5/3
N3 mafia kill - 4/3
D4 LYLO

If we lynched on D1...we get 2 chances to lynch mafia and 2 nights to gather info.

D1 Lynch - 7/3
N1 mafia kill - 6/3
D2 Lynch - 5/3
N2 mafia kill - 4/3
D3 LYLO

Hmmmm

CD advocating no-lynch..
I am not against it but I am a little surprised.

*adds CD to the list of suspects*

[FightingOkra]

Why would you suspect him for thinking about a no-lynch?

[CanucksDynasty]

Why would you suspect him for thinking about a no-lynch?

Because generally I have been in favour of lynching on D1. So it is out of character for me to advocate a no lynch. So a deviation from the norm should make people wary of me.

But I would say...
If every is compelled to vote...I would be for a lynch. If everyone has votes strewn about...maybe a no lynch may be the best course of action.

[FightingOkra]

Well I haven't seen any reasons to suspect anyone at this point.

Vote: No Lynch

[FightingOkra]

Forgot to explain my reason. I would rather not vote wrong and would also rather get this thing moving. I will change my vote if something changes.

[d3mon]

Why would you suspect him for thinking about a no-lynch?

Well.. he has always been a "lynch on the first day benefits town guy".
In the last round he led the bandwagon against someone claiming to be a security guard (on the first day), because "no-lynch" is not good for the town. Now, he might be trying to ensure that the same mistake is not repeated. But, this is not what he usually does and I find it a little suspicious.

[CanucksDynasty]

Well.. he has always been a "lynch on the first day benefits town guy".
In the last round he led the bandwagon against someone claiming to be a security guard (on the first day), because "no-lynch" is not good for the town. Now, he might be trying to ensure that the same mistake is not repeated. But, this is not what he usually does and I find it a little suspicious.

Yeah...it's called learning from your mistakes.

[ccabal86]

Well, things are a bit different now than it was last game. In TMCWPTI #2 the day 1 linchee was an active player, and here we're talking about lynching an inactive (btw, how many are left?). Inactives hurt town simply by existing. Mafia can plan their tactics with the inactives in mind (like we did last game).

[AngelCruzdelaSant]

I would like you all to know that BeeBs deleted. Just letting y'all know.

[CanucksDynasty]

Well, things are a bit different now than it was last game. In TMCWPTI #2 the day 1 linchee was an active player, and here we're talking about lynching an inactive (btw, how many are left?). Inactives hurt town simply by existing. Mafia can plan their tactics with the inactives in mind (like we did last game).

I guess the benefit of lynching inactives is getting rid of dead weight and removes all doubt what role (townie/mafia) they are.

[Kaziocore]

After leading the lynch on the cop (security guard) in the last game...I'm starting to rethink my lynch on D1 policy. That lynch was a huge blow against the town.

We have 11 players with presumably 3 mafia.

If we did 2 consecutive no lynch, we would have 3 nights to gather info and 1 chance to get mafia before LYLO (worst case scenario and assuming only 1 nightkill).

D1 No Lynch - 8/3
N1 mafia kill - 7/3
D2 No Lynch - 7/3
N2 mafia kill - 6/3
D3 Lynch - 5/3
N3 mafia kill - 4/3
D4 LYLO

If we lynched on D1...we get 2 chances to lynch mafia and 2 nights to gather info.

D1 Lynch - 7/3
N1 mafia kill - 6/3
D2 Lynch - 5/3
N2 mafia kill - 4/3
D3 LYLO

Hmmmm

I think something is wrong with CD right now advocating for a no lynch

If you look at it, the first one sounds better because the cop has 3 nights to gather info
than the second one but the problem is...
1) If the mafia killed the cop, we are better off on the second option
as at least we have a info from the previous days because of voting.
The days could be as silent as today if all just agreed on the first option
2) On the first option, the mafia has all the control on who to kill therefore who will
live on day 4 like let's say the second option where we have the option to
kill the inactive people where at least the cop could investigate only the
active people. The mafia will only let the inactive people live on the first option.

[Kaziocore]

So FOS: CD
so you'll know I have my eyes on you

And a Vote: Tracker
for being inactive.

[Kaziocore]

And something is wrong with Preston as
I miss his very long posts.
His last visit was on July 3.

[Tracker]

Tracker twiddled his thumbs a little as he felt the boredom setting in. Even though many people were braving the rain and leaving the cover the establishment provided, more seemed to duck in and take their place. It was curious, but only for so long. As his mind started to wander, his eyes caught a glimpse of the cappuccino machine. It was beckoning to him with its smell wafting through the air, tempting him with promises of years past. No! He couldn't go back, he had to stay distracted. It was that moment that he was brought back to reality once again by hearing his name.

"I vote for Tracker for being inactive!" Wait, what? He wasn't even a part of their little group and they were complaining for him not automatically participating? "Now see here, I'm fine with you playing your... whatever here, but I think that you're being a little overzealous in your expectations! I just got here and I'm attempting to learn the rules of this game or whatever you call it! So please show some patience for the non-initiated!" With that, Tracker sat back down and with a small satisfied smirk pulled out a box of Cheez-Its from his groceries and started to munch.

Don't make me go from a no-lynch to a revenge vote.