638 replies to this topic

[Kaziocore]

VOTE COUNT
Not Voting (16): ABigDeer, Alternate_Tree, Angel Cruz dela Sant, BeeBs, cam177, ccabal86, Daimos,
Electric Mango, KevinH, Nerau, OrangeRush7, Rafay, reign of terror, Xx Karl xX

With 14 Alive, 8 is needed to lynch.

[Electric Mango]

Sounds like town, mafia and serial killer to me. Also there was a doc in training so we probably have a doc as well

[cam177]

Well guess it is time to look back to day one and get a list of people who wanted JohnGato gone bad

[BeeBs]

I'm thinking this was the action of two factions also. The flavor sets it up so that the mafia are trying to make us sane again, not kill us. I'd go with a townie vigilante calling in the hit on JohnGato.

We'll have to go back and look at how that unfolded. Hopefully there is something to tease out. It was an interesting target for the scum, I'd say we didn't come through with no information, but it will take some stretching.

[KevinH]

Does "cured in the head" really mean he's dead?

(no rhyme intended)

[ccabal86]

Does "cured in the head" really mean he's dead?

(no rhyme intended)

Well, seeing as both people are listed under the same tag in the OP, I'd wager yes.

Maybe Imran can still talk? If so, he should say something.

[ABigDeer]

Neighbourizer?

[OrangeRush7]

Well that was an interesting night. The neighborizers were noted by their gender as well, so could that have some effect on the game? They may have been some form of lover roles. However, I doubt they knew about each other, as Imran was the first one to vote for JohnGato to be lynched.

In addition, I think it is likely that somebody other than the mafia ordered the attack on JohnGato. Now I just need to look back on day 1 and see if I can figure anything out.

[KevinH]

Now somebody knows something. Everybody should make suggestions so those with real knowledge can blend in.

The fact that JohnGato died does not put more suspicion on those that voted for him, in my opinion.
While it was not pro-town to lynch him, there could easily be scum that didn't vote for him that wanted to frame the voters.

Also, by being inactive, JohnGato was not really threatening the scum so it's a good possibility that he was killed by someone other than scum (I agree with OrangeRush).

[Daimos]

I thought eliminating inactive people favors us? If that is the case than why would a mafia eliminate JohnGato? This tells me there is another faction involve.

[cam177]

by reading how they died the ones trying to bring sanity could of went for Imran, so if it was a lover role that would have taken out JohnGato since the two our bound with eachother so John may have commited suicide.

[Xx Karl xX]

by reading how they died the ones trying to bring sanity could of went for Imran, so if it was a lover role that would have taken out JohnGato since the two our bound with eachother so John may have commited suicide.

I doubt that, because if they were connected in some way, don't you think they would have known about that. and I dont think Imran knew about JohnGato's role since he was the first to vote for him. So there probably is some vigilante-type role out there

[Rafay]

I still think my theory of 3 factions is correct. Thanks for the support guys. So what do we do? A question pointed at experienced members of our insane town. Has any1 ever encountered such scenario?

[Alternate_Tree]

I agree with the multiple factions, this is my first game though so I wouldn't know

[Alternate_Tree]

I agree with the multiple factions, this is my first game though so I wouldn't know

[Alternate_Tree]

sorry multiple post, internet being funky

[Electric Mango]

It's not uncommon to have a serial killer, especially in games with this many people.

[OrangeRush7]

The question is though, why would a serial killer waste his kill on an inactive? Either they knew something others didn't, or they have multishot, and will have more people to kill on following nights. I don't know... just a thought.

[KevinH]

I think it was a pro-town player that had to make a night-kill.

If somebody had to die, JohnGato the inactive was the best choice for a townie faction and the worst choice for any other faction.

However, he was going to be replaced. From a mafia perspective, one dead townie is as good as another.

[Xx Karl xX]

I think it was a pro-town player that had to make a night-kill.

If somebody had to die, JohnGato the inactive was the best choice for a townie faction and the worst choice for any other faction.

However, he was going to be replaced. From a mafia perspective, one dead townie is as good as another.

ya, i can see how it could have been a prow-town vigilante, cause any other person would have been totally random to kill, and at least this random kill was on an inactive.