1277 replies to this topic

[Samus]

tbh I don't think Lyner is scum.

 

My predictions are The Warrior, R2V & Kaz so far, I suspect there are two more but can't quite decide yet who

[Mandarijn]

I'm also going to vote for my main suspect at this moment. We'll see what happens.

 

Vote The Warrior

[Finster Baby]

Now that iSoc has satisfied my reasoning for initially voting for him....

UNVOTE: iSocialism

VOTE: The Warrior

He's been suspicious to me for a while, plus he's a good player, able to pass himself off as anything he wants. Pretty scummy, IMO.

[iSocialism]

Now that iSoc has satisfied my reasoning for initially voting for him....

UNVOTE: iSocialism

VOTE: The Warrior

He's been suspicious to me for a while, plus he's a good player, able to pass himself off as anything he wants. Pretty scummy, IMO.

and what might that be?

[Imran Ehsan]

Interesting flurry of votes on the TW. Kinda like what we saw on the iSocialism wagon. Such quick  changes of stance on the lynch target gets my spidy senses tingling....and not in a good way.

 

Can you guys explain the reason for the TW vote instead of just..."he looks scummy!"

[Mandarijn]

The reasoning for TW was already explained on pages 14-16 I think, I got this quote from Samus and I tend to agree with him:

TW seems the most scummy tbh, that timeline of events he posted seems more like a push to pose Robert as scum and get a wagon on him again.

 

Also bare in mind this is his first game of Mafia, he seems to be trying too hard to prove to be the innocent townie bystander, while actively pushing for people to be lynched.

 

First CS for his inactivity, then being part of suspected scum who lynched FF & now his persistent accusations towards Robert. Nobody in this game has flip flopped so much.

 

I see right through you scum.

 

Vote: The Warrior.

 

Also Imran, I greatly agree that D1 lynches are necessary, never thought about it like that before. But we atleast have some form of information now.

[The Warrior]

So your vote of me is predicated upon the opinion of someone who openly champions his ability to deceive the town into doing his work for him as scum, is because I voted to remove an inactive player from the game while almost everyone else agreed that removing an inactive was our best option as a town, and because I pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious, after half a dozen other people pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious? Does that about cover it? Seems more to me that the scum in this game are afraid that I might have some influence with other people and might be able to seek them out and prosecute them.

[Finster Baby]

Now that iSoc has satisfied my reasoning for initially voting for him....

UNVOTE: iSocialism

VOTE: The Warrior

He's been suspicious to me for a while, plus he's a good player, able to pass himself off as anything he wants. Pretty scummy, IMO.

and what might that be?

Mainly that you really hadn't answered the questions he posed. IMO you have to my satisfaction now, which is why I reversed my vote.

TW has also been on my radar for quite some time, for reasons elaborated on by Samus and Mandj.

Unless I see something more compelling regarding another person, this is where I stand for now.

So your vote of me is predicated upon the opinion of someone who openly champions his ability to deceive the town into doing his work for him as scum, is because I voted to remove an inactive player from the game while almost everyone else agreed that removing an inactive was our best option as a town, and because I pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious, after half a dozen other people pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious? Does that about cover it? Seems more to me that the scum in this game are afraid that I might have some influence with other people and might be able to seek them out and prosecute them.

Samoose is on my list too.

[Rusken]

While it's cute to watch people go immediately towards someone else, I have to base it on what I previously stated, and that is inactivity. With Samus posting the information, I have to go with the most inactive at this time.

 

UNVOTE

Vote: Kazio

[Road2Victory]

tbh I don't think Lyner is scum.

 

My predictions are The Warrior, R2V & Kaz so far, I suspect there are two more but can't quite decide yet who

So you think I am scum? Explain other than that I post a lot, thats an obvious reason. 

[Samus]

So your vote of me is predicated upon the opinion of someone who openly champions his ability to deceive the town into doing his work for him as scum, is because I voted to remove an inactive player from the game while almost everyone else agreed that removing an inactive was our best option as a town, and because I pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious, after half a dozen other people pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious? Does that about cover it? Seems more to me that the scum in this game are afraid that I might have some influence with other people and might be able to seek them out and prosecute them.

lol i'll ignore the part about me.

 

but you seem to suggest you have some knowledge we don't have. Why don't you share that?

 

 

 

Now that iSoc has satisfied my reasoning for initially voting for him....

UNVOTE: iSocialism

VOTE: The Warrior

He's been suspicious to me for a while, plus he's a good player, able to pass himself off as anything he wants. Pretty scummy, IMO.

and what might that be?

 

Mainly that you really hadn't answered the questions he posed. IMO you have to my satisfaction now, which is why I reversed my vote.

TW has also been on my radar for quite some time, for reasons elaborated on by Samus and Mandj.

Unless I see something more compelling regarding another person, this is where I stand for now.

So your vote of me is predicated upon the opinion of someone who openly champions his ability to deceive the town into doing his work for him as scum, is because I voted to remove an inactive player from the game while almost everyone else agreed that removing an inactive was our best option as a town, and because I pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious, after half a dozen other people pointed out that Robert was acting suspicious? Does that about cover it? Seems more to me that the scum in this game are afraid that I might have some influence with other people and might be able to seek them out and prosecute them.

Samoose is on my list too.

 

everyone's on your list aren't they?

[Finster Baby]

Well, for the first couple of days, people should be ranking the probabilities of scum vs. townie.

[Samus]

imo right now, The Warrior has suggested he has a possible town power role which I perceive as a way to potentially get the current wagon off him, if he does then I will back off him and unvote, if he doesn't prove so then in my eyes you're even more scum than I initially believed.

[Imran Ehsan]

Interesting accusations against TW. I would normally put down the flip flopping on D1 as an inexperienced players actions playing the game for the first time. However, Samus has a point about him targeting Robert. Still this is his first game so we need to take that into account. I would be interested to hear more clarification from TW whether that post was trying to set up robert as a potential lynch candidate and if so, why he thinks Robert should be lynched.

 

I am also still interested to hear from the "lurkers". Kaz is inactive. I would rather we get a replacement for him that lynch him. MOD do we have any replacements available?

 

As for the others, they have been on the forum and not posting much, just "lurking". These are more suspicious to me. Going by kevin's post count, the least 5 active are:

 

Electric Mango 17

Rafay 13

Perez 13

Yehom 10

Lyner 8

Kaziocore 7 (replacement possible?)

 

These guys need to post more and weigh in on who they think are scum. I dont want the townies bickering against each other while the scums lurk around.

[Kaziocore]

Sorry guys!

 

My isp is so shit, we still have no internet connection since last week. If it's possible, please replace me. I don't know when they would fix the connection.

[Rusken]

If Kazio is replaced, then my vote will change, until then, I'm keeping my vote.

 

At least they came forward about it, but, well, you know, trust issues.

[Road2Victory]

If Kazio is replaced, then my vote will change, until then, I'm keeping my vote.

At least they came forward about it, but, well, you know, trust issues.

Same goes for me

[KevinH]

Q: Where does Princess Leia go shopping for clothing and such?
A: At the Darth Maul, of course.



Vote Count

The Warrior (3): Samus, Mandarijn, Finster Baby,
Electric Mango (2): Kaziocore, Perez,
Kaziocore (2): Road2Victory, Rusken,
Perez (1): Electric Mango,
Lyner (1): Robert2424, 
Rafay (0):
iSocialism (0):
Rusken (0): 
Mandarijn (0):
Finster Baby (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
Yehom (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Samus (0):
Road2Victory (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Imran Ehsan, The Warrior, Yehom, Lyner, Rafay, iSocialism,

 
With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Saturday, February 6, at 18:00 EST.

As mod, I won't do post counts.

I will post the vacancy, but don't have a replacement ready at the moment.

[KevinH]

Lyner is normally an active player, but also has a low posting count. However, he can't be trusted.

Lyner

 

I do not count that as a vote, if that was the intention.

[Rusken]

Wait, when did Kazio vote for Mango?