1277 replies to this topic

[Shahenshah]

Mandarijn is an interesting choice, why would scum target him?

 

 

 

 

I can think of two reasons:

 

1. They may have found out his role (Is it possible?, It seems there is a possibility there can be same roles among both teams, so perhaps they deduced?)

2. They knew he was focused on tW, so killing Mand, they'd be hoping that a kneejerk wagon forms on tW and thus, they can sit back and let the townies lynch another one without having to bother and TBH, that kinda did happen as Perez jumped right on. 

 

 

-

EDIT: 1000 replies!

[Shahenshah]

Also, I would like iSoc and Finster to chip in (Is Finster active?)

[Yehom]

Mandarijn is an interesting choice, why would scum target him?

 

 

Also it seems like there are multiples of the same roles that need more clarification:

 

I'd start with Yehom, are you a doctor?

I already stated that I'm a bodyguard

[ccabal86]

Could someone who has time make a summary of all the roleclaims together, as well as those who remained silent up to this point? It would help immensely helpful, but I could do it on Saturday latest and it'd be great to get a reading earlier.

[Shahenshah]

Its weekend so I am not home. But to simplify summary for whoever is going to make the list

Lyner - No role claim
Shah - No role claim
EM - No role claim

I believe everyone else has claimed a role.

[Yehom]

I might have missed something but I can't remember that you role claimed Sha

[Shahenshah]

I might have missed something but I can't remember that you role claimed Sha

You're correct and I mentioned the same earlier.

[Yehom]

My bad I keep referring to you as Sha so it's weird to see your mentioning yourself als Shah, caught me off guard

 

You have yet to bring information yourself to the table, have yet to provide any reason as to why that is and as far as I've seen you also havo no intent on making clear what your role is. Yet you have been making little accusations to some people, but nothing too big, bandwagoning from time to time. It's almost sneaky at some points just nodding your head to things that have been said, or either demanding information to a subject without contributing much yourself. Please tell me why that is

[Shahenshah]

My bad I keep referring to you as Sha so it's weird to see your mentioning yourself als Shah, caught me off guard
 
You have yet to bring information yourself to the table, have yet to provide any reason as to why that is and as far as I've seen you also havo no intent on making clear what your role is. Yet you have been making little accusations to some people, but nothing too big, bandwagoning from time to time. It's almost sneaky at some points just nodding your head to things that have been said, or either demanding information to a subject without contributing much yourself. Please tell me why that is

You are absolutely incorrect and I'll post the details on those tommorow or later today, as I mentioned earlier, its weekend. Not home ATM.

[KevinH]

Q: Have you tried the gluten-free wookiee treats?
A: I heard they are a little Chewy.



Vote Count

The Warrior (1): Perez,
Perez (1): Imran Ehsan,
Electric Mango (0):
iSocialism (0):
Yehom (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
ccabal86 (0):
Shahenshah (0): 
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, iSocialism, Lyner, The Warrior, Shahenshah, Finster Baby, ccabal86, Yehom,

 
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Sunday, March 6, at 21:00 EST.

[Perez]

 

With all honesty, I will kick this new day by voting for TW.  He is definitely a scum, he knew Mand was slowly forming a wagon against him so he decided with his scummy friends to take him out.

 

EM is also scum, he said he was going make extensive anylisis to help own but nothing happened. 

 

Imram, is a scum, I have a good hunch. 

 

VOTE THE WARRIOR 

Wtf just happened? Can mafia kill two people in one night?

And it seems they can also protect.   Imran Ehsan was protected twice and watched once (in addition to you).  So yeah, Im a watcher.  There is no point, imo, hiding my role. 

 

Which means some townie defended him and a scum.  Town dont pretect Imram, he is definately scum!!!  

 

 

oh wow...this is so desperate that it isnt even funny.

 

1. You are claiming to be a Watcher while there is already another guy who has claimed Watcher in this game. So you will be the 2nd Watcher in this game. The only role which is repeated amongst townies.

 

2. You are claiming I am scum because two, not one, but two people protected me? And that those who protected me are scum too? How does that even make sense. Why would the scum want to protect me?

 

So for point 1, I would say it is highly unlikely that the town will have two guys with the same role. Two Watchers? One of them is a scum Watcher I am positive. So either you or ccabal is scum. I am betting its you.

 

For point 2, I am not even sure what your point is. You are saying I am scum based on a "hunch" while those who protected me are also scum? Thats a reach. So in one shot you want to cast suspicion on me who has been trying to scum hunt from Day 1 and at the same time cast suspicion on the potential protective roles of the town.

 

Vote: Perez

 

Too many inconsistencies in your post. You have been lurking all through the last 3 days. And suddenly you appear conveniently on D4 to role claim and claim you have identified scum on a "hunch". You really think people will fall for this.

 

I used my action on TW last night. He is a 2-shot Commuter.

 

 

1) Theres another role role repeated in this game. Which is to protect, and imo, that ability is more valuable than the watcher.  Which means the odds are higher that  one of them has to be scum.

 

2) I said one of them.... BECAUSE, you are valuable asset to them. What a dumb question is that? That raises suspicion even higher.

 

You fail bub, lets see what other excuse you make. 

[Imran Ehsan]

There was no way I would have known that no other Role Cops existed in the game if I was was in fact a scum role cop. For all i knew anyone of Mandarijn, you, lyner, EM or Shah could be a role cop. If i was scum there is no way I would have made that claim just to get Rafay lynched. He would have been lynched any waymost probably with or without my role claim. So your accusations hold no water.

 

What I find extremely suspicious is Mandarijn getting killed at night, a player who was himself looking pretty suspicious, and you coming out guns blazing on TW right as day starts. It seems all too scripted to me. The scum wants another good townie lynch so they will try to set up the most easy guy to be lynched. So the scum kills manadarijn, who had not claimed any role, over some more valuable kills. And conveniently you come out on D4 accusing (and voting) for TW and me on the very weird reasoning that I was protected by 2 players (?) How does that even make sense? I think you could not be sure whether I investigated TW at night or not so the accusation on me.

 

I am still unclear on ccabal's role on this though. They seem to be confirming each other so I am still not sure if they are working together or whether Perez's scum team knew somehow ccabal targetted me at night as well. I would need to go back and look at R2V's previous posts to see if I can dig out something suspicious.

By the way, whats everyones thoughts on the 2 kills? Was that a Vig action or somehow the scum pulled  out 2 kills?

2) I said one of them.... BECAUSE, you are valuable asset to them. What a dumb question is that? That raises suspicion even higher.

 

and yes this. We have seen no Vig kills at night. Why would scum try to protect me when there has been 0 Vig actions before this night. Unless you guys have a Vig in your team and somehow assumed that argument will make sense. Yeah you knew there is a Vig but the townies did not. You are contradicting yourself the more you post.

pss: What were your actions the previous nights? You have made no reveals regarding your previous nights actions. Only going with your scripted story. Lets hear what you claimed to do on the first 2 nights,

[ccabal86]

MOD: Could we get an extension to the deadline?

[KevinH]

MOD: Could we get an extension to the deadline?

 

Deadline is Sunday, March 6, at 21:00 EST.

 

I think 9 more days should be enough time for discussion. Will you be gone on March 6 or something?

[Shahenshah]

My bad I keep referring to you as Sha so it's weird to see your mentioning yourself als Shah, caught me off guard

You have yet to bring information yourself to the table, have yet to provide any reason as to why that is and as far as I've seen you also havo no intent on making clear what your role is. Yet you have been making little accusations to some people, but nothing too big, bandwagoning from time to time. It's almost sneaky at some points just nodding your head to things that have been said, or either demanding information to a subject without contributing much yourself. Please tell me why that is

Ok, so I just stepped out of watching deadpool and have a few minutes to kill and I had an epiphany.

- You know if you were truly a townie, you wouldn't want townies to go around role claiming at this stage. Anyone smart enough can deduce things down to a certain point. IMO you and scum team are just trying to pinpoint the doctor for the night kill. That's a real real scummie move. You guys are trying to see who is the doc, myself or Lyner
Or maybe EM. If I make a role claim, then you guys will have pretty much everything pinned down.

I'm sorry but you'll have to take chances with your night kill mate, I'm not going to blurt it out for you.

- You've been a suspect pretty much through out the game.

- I've made solid cases against people. Hell I went through 30-40 pages and listed dozens of quotes to bring my reasoning forth in the past. Just a few of my posts are bigger than your entire participation in this game. You are all free to browse through my posts and see for yourself. Yehom you're just throwing mud around hoping it sticks.

- Re bandwagon: I never jumped on bandwagon even after big evidence, I gave rusken chance to sort it out, I'm sorry he was noob and alot of townies ended up voting for him. Regarding Rafey, dude, he didn't even BOTHER to respond, only then did I vote. I posted again Rafey asking for clarification, dude, nothing came. I'm not going to apologize for noobness of some of our own players.

-in summary you're looking to pinpoint the doc and throwing absolutely baseless allegations my way.

You've also been a suspect throughout the game.

Vote: Yehom.

[ccabal86]

 

MOD: Could we get an extension to the deadline?

 

Deadline is Sunday, March 6, at 21:00 EST.

 

I think 9 more days should be enough time for discussion. Will you be gone on March 6 or something?

 

 

Ah, never mind. This is what you get when you try to play mafia at work in a hurry. I thought deadline was this Sunday...

 

EDIT: I will do some proper analysis in the weekend.

Edited by ccabal86, 26 February 2016 - 09:49 PM.

[iSocialism]

Most scum killed one guy and a x-shot killed the other. SO TW Imran says you are a 2-shot communter. Did you kill someone last night?

I think someone killed mand because he was a very pro-town player, if not the most. They could also be trying to frame TW.

Ccabal Says that Yehom, Perez ,Lyner himself visited Imran. Can someone confirmed that he visited TW? I feel like if you were a true tracker/watcher you would know.

Can Lyner also confirm that he visited Imran?

Perez what is your star character name, since you already RCed.

 

 

From peoples claims

The Warrior 2-shot commuter - can you give us a star wars name if this is true? If not could you vote fro Imran
Electric Mango - No RC
iSocialism Lor San Tekka - Neapolitan
Yehom - Body guard, can't remember the name
Perez - Watcher - no name
Imran Ehsan - Can't find the exact details.
ccabal86 - was able to watch or track. Might as well just say what you are You already gave it away.
Shahenshah - No RC
Lyner - Town consided by Samus
Finster Baby ? can't remember

 

But as you can see. Everyong hasn't pretty much RCed. but most people will agree upon at least 4 scums. So, yes someone is a liar. In all honest don't trust anyone.

[Imran Ehsan]

^ for the record my star wars name is Rey. I am a role cop.

[Shahenshah]

Most scum killed one guy and a x-shot killed the other. SO TW Imran says you are a 2-shot communter. Did you kill someone last night?

I think someone killed mand because he was a very pro-town player, if not the most. They could also be trying to frame TW.

Ccabal Says that Yehom, Perez ,Lyner himself visited Imran. Can someone confirmed that he visited TW? I feel like if you were a true tracker/watcher you would know.

Can Lyner also confirm that he visited Imran?

Perez what is your star character name, since you already RCed.

 

 

From peoples claims

The Warrior 2-shot commuter - can you give us a star wars name if this is true? If not could you vote fro Imran
Electric Mango - No RC
iSocialism Lor San Tekka - Neapolitan
Yehom - Body guard, can't remember the name
Perez - Watcher - no name
Imran Ehsan - Can't find the exact details.
ccabal86 - was able to watch or track. Might as well just say what you are You already gave it away.
Shahenshah - No RC
Lyner - Town consided by Samus
Finster Baby ? can't remember

 

But as you can see. Everyong hasn't pretty much RCed. but most people will agree upon at least 4 scums. So, yes someone is a liar. In all honest don't trust anyone.

 

As Neopolitan, did you find anything useful?

[The Warrior]

I am Finn (FN-2187), a 2-shot Commuter. I did not use my night action last night.

Killing Mandarijn seems like it was too easy of a way for the scum to frame me. Of course I would be suspected if he died. Perez immediately jumped right on that train. Clever planning by Perez and his ilk? Or did he just fall into the mafia's trap with his quick draw reaction?