300 replies to this topic

[brewersalliance]

My FoS on Kevin still stands btw

hopefully someone has some solid intel on something tho

[Lord MK]

Doctor found dead

[Velocity]

My FoS on Kevin still stands btw

hopefully someone has some solid intel on something tho

Whoever bothered to target Robert knows something, apparently. We’re down a or the doctor, so that sucks for us right out the gate. It was Apollo though, he was always my least favorite 😛

[brewersalliance]

 

My FoS on Kevin still stands btw

hopefully someone has some solid intel on something tho

Whoever bothered to target Robert knows something, apparently. We’re down a or the doctor, so that sucks for us right out the gate. It was Apollo though, he was always my least favorite

 

or they just got lucky

 

I am guessing this is a role madness game, as gods typically have powers, so whomever they targeted was probably more likely than not a PR

[Rafay]

Did they just not hit you or are you one of them?

 

I'm willing to bet on the 2nd part. 

[brewersalliance]

 

Did they just not hit you or are you one of them?

 

I'm willing to bet on the 2nd part. 

 

lol how much do you want to bet on that?

ill give you 10/1 odds too

(10/1 since there are 10 players not you so 10 potential roles for me )

[Rafay]

lol how much do you want to bet on that? ill give you 10/1 odds too (10/1 since there are 10 players not you so 10 potential roles for me )

 

Pretty confident w/ myself since I would've killed you had I been the scum.

 

Robert's death was a lucky shot. Mafia had day talk maybe they could've figured something out.

[brewersalliance]

 

lol how much do you want to bet on that? ill give you 10/1 odds too (10/1 since there are 10 players not you so 10 potential roles for me )

 

Pretty confident w/ myself since I would've killed you had I been the scum.

 

Robert's death was a lucky shot. Mafia had day talk maybe they could've figured something out.

 

FoS on Rafay

 

Thats exactly what scum would say, especially when they are suggesting the reason I survived n1 was I am scum lol

[KevinH]

I absolutely hate the reasoning of "you're alive so you must be scum".

 

That said, I'll take the 10:1 payout when the odds are really lower than that because I'm pretty sure there are multiple scum in the game. 

[brewersalliance]

So what are you gonna wager then? Lol

[Colonel Medved]

*clears throat, getting ready for my Sister Midnight Impression*

 

OH NO, NOT ROBERT!!!

 

*the crowd cheers, and i take a bow*

 

In all seriousness though, that sucks. Can i get a doctor to revive the doctor please

 

OMG I'm alive!!!

 

Looks like the scum have taken pitty on you, we shall see how long it lasts lmao

 

I absolutely hate the reasoning of "you're alive so you must be scum".

 

 

Agreed, this early in the game just makes it sound even more stupid. Maybe when its down to the last couple, would that actually have any substance.

[Canik]

Only the good die young ;(

(because the rest are scum, get it? xD)

I am guessing this is a role madness game, as gods typically have powers, so whomever they targeted was probably more likely than not a PR

Yeah I'm pretty sure it is. And as there was no night yet, scum couldn't have known for sure. Unless they had some daytime D1 investigation but that'd be some bs. No way Jazzy gave them that ability.

[KevinH]

So what are you gonna wager then? Lol

 

I never bet against the house.

 

You know if you are scum or not.  I don't.

[Kverst]

Just a word of caution: If Brewers is mafia, this whole "don't lynch brewers/kill him n1" would be a huge advantage to them, especially as I feel we are leaning towards being cautious of all accusers of brewers in the future. I feel like regular things that would get most people called out wouldn't be able to be brought up against brewers just due to the "don't lynch brewers" attitude.

 

That being said, Brewers shouldn't be automatically FOSed for being alive...

[SeaBeeGipson]

Agreed.

Voting brewers or anyone just for being them is kind of bogus. Vote based on actions or evidence of that game not every game.

Anyway, I'm going to say scum most likely got lucky with a doctor hit rather than believing they have some OP daytime investigation role. Even in a role madness game that would be killer. Good news, if its role madness then we most likely have some helpful roles despite losing a doctor. Problem is we should be wary of role claiming now because we wont have anyone to protect us, unless a nurse exists.

[Rafay]

We definitely have a cop and a vig if this is role madness. But they won't out themselves for no substantial gain.

[The Warrior]

Just a word of caution: If Brewers is mafia, this whole "don't lynch brewers/kill him n1" would be a huge advantage to them, especially as I feel we are leaning towards being cautious of all accusers of brewers in the future. I feel like regular things that would get most people called out wouldn't be able to be brought up against brewers just due to the "don't lynch brewers" attitude.

 

That being said, Brewers shouldn't be automatically FOSed for being alive...

You should never base a decision to lynch or not lynch someone on previous games. Using past grudges (or even some past habits to a certain extent) as the basis of your decision making in a given game does the town a disservice. Anyone can be scum or town in any given game and play styles can change. Saying "OMG Brewers is alive on day 2 or 4 or 5, he must be scum" is a terrible argument. The same argument has been made about Kevin, Me, Imran, and Samus, and probably a dozen other people over the years. There are just too many factors in any given game that can change. Every person should be treated as suspicious by all other players until something can be proven.

 

Current Post Count:

 

brewersalliance 19 Jazzy95 11 The Warrior 11 Lord MK 9 KevinH 7 Rafay 7 Canik 7 Velocity 6 Colonel Medved 6 SeaBeeGipson 5 Nadarr 3 Kverst 3 Robert2424 3

 

Both Kverst and Nadarr still only have 3 posts. Kverst had forum problems though and has at least posted once so far today. Nadarr has not.

 

@Nadarr - Do you have any thoughts on anything?

[Nadarr]

Sorry. I am not getting any of my updates....
I really think this automatically FOS brewers is insane. He is a smart player and a better liar but he is also super helpful for the town. I think we should leave him be for the time being. I know I dont have the most activity, and I am going to attempt to be better about checking daily.

[Canik]

My FoS on Kevin still stands btw

hopefully someone has some solid intel on something tho

 

The Kevin thing where he asked if we are Olympians or Townies, I don't think is great evidence but it is one of the more interesting things we have to go on.

@Kevin - you want to elaborate on that some more, or add any comment about that? 

[Kverst]

I don't think the Olympian or Townie thing is that important...But I agree we have nothing to go off of.