261 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

Of interest is the MafiaWiki page on Normal Game
 
This game was never advertised as adhering to "Normal", but the definition of Normal includes "The game must contain at least one Vanilla Townie"

 

iSocialism might have been the one Vanilla Townie.

[Velocity]

Of interest is the MafiaWiki page on Normal Game

This game was never advertised as adhering to "Normal", but the definition of Normal includes "The game must contain at least one Vanilla Townie"

iSocialism might have been the one Vanilla Townie.

“At least”

[KevinH]

might have been the one

 

Two of the three lost townies had roles.
Since a distinction was made to have a goon cop vs a regular cop, I'd guess that the mafia have both goons and roles.

[The Warrior]

Alright, after spending a good deal of time considering voting for either Velocity or Robert, I’ve settled on Robert. Velocity probably has a better case against him but he is also at least contributing. I’d rather keep him alive today and hope that someone can verify his role claim tonight. Robert on the other hand, is contributing nothing and has bafflingly voted for the only known townie in the game to “set a precedent”..? I was hoping Robert would have been able to pop on by now to address that but it doesn’t seem likely. That also makes me question whether he’d be available when needed later on if he’s town.

I’m not saying that I believe Velocity is town right now either btw. I would rather have someone actively participating than not though.

For now,

Vote: Robert

[Velocity]

Alright, after spending a good deal of time considering voting for either Velocity or Robert, I’ve settled on Robert. Velocity probably has a better case against him but he is also at least contributing. I’d rather keep him alive today and hope that someone can verify his role claim tonight. Robert on the other hand, is contributing nothing and has bafflingly voted for the only known townie in the game to “set a precedent”..? I was hoping Robert would have been able to pop on by now to address that but it doesn’t seem likely. That also makes me question whether he’d be available when needed later on if he’s town.

I’m not saying that I believe Velocity is town right now either btw. I would rather have someone actively participating than not though.

For now,

Vote: Robert

On accounts of this, and what I said yesterday about me voting Robert if he didn’t show up, which he didn’t, I am also going to vote for him. Considering the pros and cons of it, yes there’s a chance he has a good power role, but there’s also the chance he’s one of our scum, and a townie with a good power role gone inactive isn’t helpful.

Vote: Robert

[brewersalliance]

Vote Count 3.2

 

Colonel Medved (0) 

KevinH (0)

Lord Mk (1) SeaBee,Gipson

Rafay (0)

Robert2424 (4) Rafay, Wolfpacks, The Warrior, Velocity

SeaBaeGipson (0)

The Warrior (0)

Velocity (3) KevinH, Lord MK, Colonel Medved

Wolfpacks (0)

 

IN DANGER OF MOD KILL: Robert2424-1 Post

 

Not Voting:  Robert2424, 

 

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.  Deadline is 5/11/19 at 4 PM

[The Warrior]

Deadline is in 45 minutes. Does anyone else have any thoughts before the day ends?

[Velocity]

Deadline is in 45 minutes. Does anyone else have any thoughts before the day ends?

Nope, and day should be over now

[brewersalliance]

Final Vote Count 

 

Colonel Medved (0) 

KevinH (0)

Lord Mk (1) SeaBee,Gipson

Rafay (0)

Robert2424 (4) Rafay, Wolfpacks, The Warrior, Velocity

SeaBaeGipson (0)

The Warrior (0)

Velocity (3) KevinH, Lord MK, Colonel Medved

Wolfpacks (0)

 

IN DANGER OF MOD KILL: Robert2424-1 Post

 

Not Voting:  Robert2424, 

 

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.  Deadline is 5/11/19 at 4 PM

 

Walder Frey was enjoying the bloodshed.  Every time he saw a Stark die, he would laugh.  Dead Starks here, dead Starks there. Served them right for always thinking they were better than the Frey’s.  He took a sip of his wine and scanned the hall. Standing in the corner, Walder spotted Robin Flint. A chunk of wood fell off the ceiling and crushed Robin Flint.

 

IN DANGER OF MOD KILL: Robert2424-1 Post

 

 

Robert2424, Robin Flint, a Vanilla Townie was mod killed D3

 

It is now N3.  Deadline for all actions is 5/13/19 at 4pm CN time

[brewersalliance]

Who else could I kill?  Lothar wondered… Starks were dead everywhere he looked.  Blood ran thick on the floor. The screams echoed in the halls.  Wait! Robb has a direwolf! The wolf needs to die!

 

“You there,” Lothar yelled at some soldiers. ‘Go outside and kill the wolf before it breaks out!”

 

A group of soldiers ran outside to where Gray Wind was kept.  Lothar smiled. The young wolf would die soon, but first his dire wolf would fall.  Just as he pondered that thought, a sharp pain erupted in his back. Another jolt from a knife struck him.  Lothar never felt the third blade…

 

Wolfpacks, Gray Wind, a Vanilla Townie died n3

Lord MK, Lothar Frey, a mafia Jack of all Trades died n3

 

It is now day 4

 

Colonel Medved (0) 

KevinH (0)

Rafay (0)

SeaBaeGipson (0)

The Warrior (0)

Velocity (0)

 

Not voting:  Colonel Medved, KevinH, Rafay, SeaBeeeGipson, The Warrior, Velocity

 

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.  Deadline is 5/19 at 11am CN time

[Velocity]

Who else could I kill? Lothar wondered… Starks were dead everywhere he looked. Blood ran thick on the floor. The screams echoed in the halls. Wait! Robb has a direwolf! The wolf needs to die!

“You there,” Lothar yelled at some soldiers. ‘Go outside and kill the wolf before it breaks out!”

A group of soldiers ran outside to where Gray Wind was kept. Lothar smiled. The young wolf would die soon, but first his dire wolf would fall. Just as he pondered that thought, a sharp pain erupted in his back. Another jolt from a knife struck him. Lothar never felt the third blade…

Wolfpacks, Gray Wind, a Vanilla Townie died n3
Lord MK, Lothar Frey, a mafia Jack of all Trades died n3

It is now day 4

Colonel Medved (0)

KevinH (0)

Rafay (0)

SeaBaeGipson (0)

The Warrior (0)

Velocity (0)

Not voting: Colonel Medved, KevinH, Rafay, SeaBeeeGipson, The Warrior, Velocity

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline. Deadline is 5/19 at 11am CN time

As far as I am concerned, this proves two things.

One, this is not role madness, there wouldn’t be this many townies if it was. I know i am one, so there wouldn’t be this many.

Two, the flavor text does matter to the game, as I’ve said.

Anyone with a power role, whatever ones are left, got anything for the rest of the town?

[SeaBeeGipson]

MK turned out to be scum.
I'm willing to bet Velocity is a VT based on the amount of VTs present and MK being on his wagon. Willing to bet another scum was in that wagon as well. The question is whether it was CM or Kevin.

[Rafay]

Well Velocity definitely gets townie points for sure. There was definitely a mafia on the Robert wagon for sure and it ain't me.

[Wolfpacks]

Wtf pfft

[Velocity]

MK turned out to be scum.
I'm willing to bet Velocity is a VT based on the amount of VTs present and MK being on his wagon. Willing to bet another scum was in that wagon as well. The question is whether it was CM or Kevin.

My thoughts exactly. I’m debating which of those two might be it, though as of now I’m less inclined to believe... i don’t know. Kevin was already voting me and MK jumped on, if I was lynched and flipped town like I know I am, it would put at least two of the scum in a bad position, and if Kevin is town and MK was scum, it still works the same way because scum wouldn’t want to put more than one of them on me for when I flipped town. So it could work either way.
CM has been more or less in the background, i don’t have much to say about him because he wasn’t really contributing to the whole situation with me almost being lynched, which almost leads me to believe he’s town because he didn’t try to build the case against me even further, thought that also could work in reverse and he’s scum trying to hide.

Whoever Rafay’s mother is cannot die on this night or be lynched, that would bring it to 2-3 town, and unless the vig gets lucky scum will win after their night kill, which means for the town we have Rafays mother (assuming VT), Rafay (unborn child), me (Robb Stark), and either a vig or SK, of which an SK would be terrible news for the town.

So far I have no scummy vibes from SBG or TW, but I don’t think it would be so simple as CM and Kevin being the last two scum.

[Colonel Medved]

Looks like we got a scum finally. At least things are turning around!

 

 

 

MK turned out to be scum.
I'm willing to bet Velocity is a VT based on the amount of VTs present and MK being on his wagon. Willing to bet another scum was in that wagon as well. The question is whether it was CM or Kevin.

My thoughts exactly. I’m debating which of those two might be it, though as of now I’m less inclined to believe... i don’t know. Kevin was already voting me and MK jumped on, if I was lynched and flipped town like I know I am, it would put at least two of the scum in a bad position, and if Kevin is town and MK was scum, it still works the same way because scum wouldn’t want to put more than one of them on me for when I flipped town. So it could work either way.
CM has been more or less in the background, i don’t have much to say about him because he wasn’t really contributing to the whole situation with me almost being lynched, which almost leads me to believe he’s town because he didn’t try to build the case against me even further, thought that also could work in reverse and he’s scum trying to hide.

Whoever Rafay’s mother is cannot die on this night or be lynched, that would bring it to 2-3 town, and unless the vig gets lucky scum will win after their night kill, which means for the town we have Rafays mother (assuming VT), Rafay (unborn child), me (Robb Stark), and either a vig or SK, of which an SK would be terrible news for the town.

So far I have no scummy vibes from SBG or TW, but I don’t think it would be so simple as CM and Kevin being the last two scum.

 

 

I made my points when voting for you, which at the time made the best sense to me out of the options we had for lynch. I wouldn't say I've been in the background, i was pretty open with possibilities yesterday from you hyping the RC to be bigger, and the PGO possibility. If i really wanted to sit in the background, i would have only posted the necessary times to not get lynched then stay quiet. I wish we had post counts, so i could see how active i was yesterday but i felt i was around most of the day if anything.

 

Other than that, i do admit that MK flipping scum does give townie points. But i wouldn't say it guarantees you as town. As i mentioned yesterday, scum vote for scum all the time. MK could have been hiding in a wagon against scum to give himself townie points as well if you were lynched and flipped scum. I suppose the same could be accused of me. I'm the only person who knows i'm town, but that's just how the game works.

[KevinH]

Townie-Point-Analysis ^TM
 
Day 1
Named Townie +∞

Rafay

 
Day 2
Not voting = -1

Colonel Medved, SeaBeeGipson, The Warrior, Velocity, 

Not getting hammered when one more vote needed = -1

Velocity

 
Day 3
Voting to lynch Robert, now known to be town = -1

Rafay, The Warrior, Velocity

 

Totals:

+∞ Rafay
0 KevinH
-1 Colonel Medved
-1 SeaBeeGipson
-2 The Warrior
-3 Velocity

 

Velocity is still my #1 suspect

[SeaBeeGipson]

Townie-Point-Analysis ^TM
 
Day 1
Named Townie +∞

Rafay

 
Day 2
Not voting = -1

Colonel Medved, SeaBeeGipson, The Warrior, Velocity, 

Not getting hammered when one more vote needed = -1

Velocity

 
Day 3
Voting to lynch Robert, now known to be town = -1

Rafay, The Warrior, Velocity

 

Totals:

+∞ Rafay
0 KevinH
-1 Colonel Medved
-1 SeaBeeGipson
-2 The Warrior
-3 Velocity

 
Velocity is still my #1 suspect

And how many points would you award yourself for visiting Wolfpacks last night?

[KevinH]

And how many points would you award yourself for visiting Wolfpacks last night?

 

None, because that didn't happen.

[SeaBeeGipson]

And how many points would you award yourself for visiting Wolfpacks last night?

 
None, because that didn't happen.

Interesting because as Talisa Stark, a Town Watcher. I watched Wolfpacks last night and behold, you also visited him on the night he died. So again, how many points would you award yourself for visiting Wolfpacks?