894 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

Vote Count

Finster Baby (3): Tony Maurice, Dontavian, Brewersalliance,
Brewersalliance (1): Finster Baby,
Rafay (1): captainjf,
Ferastical (0):
Captainjf (0):
Kaziocore (0):
Chaplain of death (0):
Dontavian (0):
Lyner (0):
Tony Maurice (0):
Velocity (0):
Wolfpacks (0):
 
No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Kaziocore, Velocity, Wolfpacks, Chaplain of death, Lyner, Rafay, Ferastical,  
 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is Monday, February 8 at 12:00 EST
 

[Chaplain of death]

 

Before we hammer down on Finster there should be a N3 alignment cop, please claim some results N3 alignment cop. If they don't claim they are most likely the scum rather than finster and are hiding because they would be the next to be lynched if Finster comes up town.

That's a good point. Tho they also could be dead
But yeah it's more likely that if they don't come forward they are scum but it is a possibility they are dead.

 

 

That's fair, had forgotten we have no info on the roles of the players who are dead.

In that case I feel like we still vote on Finster, but I find it a bit odd that he would out one of his partners so early in the day after he had just survived the day before. Perhaps he was just trying to get ahead of it in case the wagon just piled on again like I did but hard to say.

[Tony Maurice]

What was finster’s claim again?

 

@Finster did u get results? Might convince  me to remove my vote.

[Chaplain of death]

What was finster’s claim again?

 

@Finster did u get results? Might convince  me to remove my vote.

 

His role only gives him 1 result. it was N2 alignment cop. However both N2 and N3 alignment cops also got a ninja ability, and we have a claimed watcher (iirc) who was watching the N1 kill target and didn't see anybody.

[Tony Maurice]

 

What was finster’s claim again?

 

@Finster did u get results? Might convince  me to remove my vote.

 

His role only gives him 1 result. it was N2 alignment cop. However both N2 and N3 alignment cops also got a ninja ability, and we have a claimed watcher (iirc) who was watching the N1 kill target and didn't see anybody.

 

It’s a voyeur who can watch someone and sees what actions have been used on somebody.

 

that’s me.

 

well finster was role blocked last night. Not sure why that would be a good choice but enlighten me if it was.

[brewersalliance]

well finster was role blocked last night. Not sure why that would be a good choice but enlighten me if it was.

 

if someone thought he could be scum they would RB him so he could not do the kill. 

[Ferastical]

I read Tony and brewers to be good bois

 

I trust this wagon

 

Vote -> Finster Baby

[brewersalliance]

In that case I feel like we still vote on Finster, but I find it a bit odd that he would out one of his partners so early in the day after he had just survived the day before. Perhaps he was just trying to get ahead of it in case the wagon just piled on again like I did but hard to say.

 

 

it was extremely likely everyone would vote torres again tho.  torres survived the day because of the rules, no half majority lynch.  he still had like 7 votes the previous day

I read Tony and brewers to be good bois

 

 

 

good boi doggo meme

[Ferastical]

 

In that case I feel like we still vote on Finster, but I find it a bit odd that he would out one of his partners so early in the day after he had just survived the day before. Perhaps he was just trying to get ahead of it in case the wagon just piled on again like I did but hard to say.

 

 

it was extremely likely everyone would vote torres again tho.  torres survived the day because of the rules, no half majority lynch.  he still had like 7 votes the previous day

I read Tony and brewers to be good bois

 

 

 

good boi doggo meme

 

 

aw yes puppers   

 

I have this feeling that the N3 vig might me scum-aligned, which is why no one has claimed the murder hit on either MK or TW

 

A scummy vig and a corrupted cop, next thing you know we're gonna have a whole western serial in production. You never know, might earn us some money for that forum upgrade   

[Finster Baby]

alright so this game died.

 

while rafay feels like he could very well be scum, the 50/50 chance on finster is just too high and too good not to take.  i dont think his actions have leaned town or scum, and i think its very plausible he would bus torres to try to be 'confirmed' as town

 

plus no new info seems to be coming out today

 

vote finster

 

edit: X20 -KevinH

Like I said, if I wind up dead, you better look long and hard at brewers being scum.  He has done nothing but advocate my lynching since I revealed my role and outed Torres as scum.

 

There was no reason, immediately upon day 3, to bus Torres.  None of the scum had been outed.  The full contingent was still in play. 

 

I gain NOTHING by bussing anyone.  I expect to be dead at some point regardless.

 

But if I wind up dead, Brewers should be absolutely the next to die by the town. 

[brewersalliance]

 

alright so this game died.

 

while rafay feels like he could very well be scum, the 50/50 chance on finster is just too high and too good not to take.  i dont think his actions have leaned town or scum, and i think its very plausible he would bus torres to try to be 'confirmed' as town

 

plus no new info seems to be coming out today

 

vote finster

 

edit: X20 -KevinH

Like I said, if I wind up dead, you better look long and hard at brewers being scum.  He has done nothing but advocate my lynching since I revealed my role and outed Torres as scum.

 

There was no reason, immediately upon day 3, to bus Torres.  None of the scum had been outed.  The full contingent was still in play. 

 

I gain NOTHING by bussing anyone.  I expect to be dead at some point regardless.

 

But if I wind up dead, Brewers should be absolutely the next to die by the town. 

 

you keep taking all the credit for "outing" torres for being scum but you really didint.  torres had 7 of the 8 votes needed and only didnt get lynched because the vote to lynch him came after deadline and Kevin did not count it.  

 

He should have been lynched on day 2 but people were not active enough around deadline.  so it makes perfect sense he would be lynched the next day, so as a member of scum, bussing him would be the smart play.  you gain what you are trying to do:  claim you are "confirmed town" for "outing" torres as scum, even tho torres was good as dead regardless of your claim.  

 

again there is a 50% chance you are scum since we know one of the two cops is scum, and bussing someone who did get over the number of votes to be lynched but they were not counted since they came after deadline makes perfect sense for a scum player to do.  

 

you constantly trying to claim you "outed" torres and were the reason for his lynch is a 10000% exaggeration of what happened and feels like you are trying wayyyyy to hard to take the credit for the lynch of a scum player that you really made zero impact on his lynch.  this makes me feel like its far more likely that you are the scum cop.  

[brewersalliance]

now yes, there is a 50% chance you are town, however, the constant misrepresentation that you are the reason torres was lynched is making me more confident that you are the scum cop

@finster, are you honestly going to tell me if any other player had a 50% chance of being scum, you wouldnt think lynching them is the right call?

[captainjf]

I wish I had something useful to contribute. I am caught in this whirlwind of claims and arguments. Is Finster Scum? I'm not convinced (50% chance regardless). Is there a better option? Right now, I'm really not sure. I'm not really leaning towards anyone in particular right now (although my vote is for Rafay).

 

I feel like it is really easy for folks to be manipulated this game as the scum can have what are usual town rules. I'm trying to keep my distance.

[Dontavian]

What was finster’s claim again?
 
@Finster did u get results? Might convince  me to remove my vote.

 
His role only gives him 1 result. it was N2 alignment cop. However both N2 and N3 alignment cops also got a ninja ability, and we have a claimed watcher (iirc) who was watching the N1 kill target and didn't see anybody.

It’s a voyeur who can watch someone and sees what actions have been used on somebody.
 
that’s me.
 
well finster was role blocked last night. Not sure why that would be a good choice but enlighten me if it was.

In addition to voyeur, there’s potentially:

• Jack of All Trades (Doctor, Jailkeeper, Voyeur) n1, n2, n3
• Voyeur n1, n2, n3, n4 1x Strongman

What did you see happen last night exactly?

Anyone spend the night in jail and want to share?

[Finster Baby]

 

 

alright so this game died.

 

while rafay feels like he could very well be scum, the 50/50 chance on finster is just too high and too good not to take.  i dont think his actions have leaned town or scum, and i think its very plausible he would bus torres to try to be 'confirmed' as town

 

plus no new info seems to be coming out today

 

vote finster

 

edit: X20 -KevinH

Like I said, if I wind up dead, you better look long and hard at brewers being scum.  He has done nothing but advocate my lynching since I revealed my role and outed Torres as scum.

 

There was no reason, immediately upon day 3, to bus Torres.  None of the scum had been outed.  The full contingent was still in play. 

 

I gain NOTHING by bussing anyone.  I expect to be dead at some point regardless.

 

But if I wind up dead, Brewers should be absolutely the next to die by the town. 

 

you keep taking all the credit for "outing" torres for being scum but you really didint.  torres had 7 of the 8 votes needed and only didnt get lynched because the vote to lynch him came after deadline and Kevin did not count it.  

 

He should have been lynched on day 2 but people were not active enough around deadline.  so it makes perfect sense he would be lynched the next day, so as a member of scum, bussing him would be the smart play.  you gain what you are trying to do:  claim you are "confirmed town" for "outing" torres as scum, even tho torres was good as dead regardless of your claim.  

 

again there is a 50% chance you are scum since we know one of the two cops is scum, and bussing someone who did get over the number of votes to be lynched but they were not counted since they came after deadline makes perfect sense for a scum player to do.  

 

you constantly trying to claim you "outed" torres and were the reason for his lynch is a 10000% exaggeration of what happened and feels like you are trying wayyyyy to hard to take the credit for the lynch of a scum player that you really made zero impact on his lynch.  this makes me feel like its far more likely that you are the scum cop.  

 

You had no idea that Torres was scum.  There was a wagon that failed D2, but nobody knew for certain that he was scum until I investigated and reported to the town that fact.  It confirmed that he was indeed scum and that lynching him was the correct play.  Do you honestly think that if I were the scum cop I'd out my own teammate?  

 

Why would any scum bus a partner first thing on day 3?  That play makes zero sense to anyone else but you.  Maybe you planned on bussing him when he was at L-1 and you're pissed that he was caught.

 

Or you're trying to take some heat off you because you're still clinging to this "I never get lynched" thing you had going?

 

If I hadn't reported my findings you'd have spent 2 weeks vacillating back and forth over him, me, or some other target du jure, and there's no guarantee you would have settled on Torres and you'd have likely killed another townie.  

 

I'm not buying your innocence one iota.  You're attempting to portray me as scum when I've done exactly nothing scummy.  

 

As I said previously.  Go ahead and lynch me.  You'll only be speeding up the demise of the town.  They've killed 4 of us and we've only lynched one of them.  But you ahead and continue to concentrate on yet another townie instead of hunting true scum and you'll only hasten the demise of the town after 3 are killed (me and 2 more in the night) after today.

[KevinH]

Vote Count

Finster Baby (4): Tony Maurice, Dontavian, Brewersalliance, Ferastical,
Brewersalliance (1): Finster Baby,
Rafay (1): captainjf,
Ferastical (0):
Captainjf (0):
Kaziocore (0):
Chaplain of death (0):
Dontavian (0):
Lyner (0):
Tony Maurice (0):
Velocity (0):
Wolfpacks (0):
 
No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Kaziocore, Velocity, Wolfpacks, Chaplain of death, Lyner, Rafay,  
 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is Monday, February 8 at 12:00 EST
 

[brewersalliance]

Why would any scum bus a partner first thing on day 3?  That play makes zero sense to anyone else but you.  Maybe you planned on bussing him when he was at L-1 and you're pissed that he was caught.

 

 

lol how many lies/misinformation can you push? 

also @ finster you have ignored my question a couple times so I am going to ask it again...

 

@finster, are you honestly going to tell me if any other player had a 50% chance of being scum, you wouldnt think lynching them is the right call?

[brewersalliance]

Maybe you planned on bussing him when he was at L-1 and you're pissed that he was caught.

 

also for the record, i voted for torres first on Jan 4th, 11 days before the deadline lol so yeah, try again with your lies lol 

[Finster Baby]

also @ finster you have ignored my question a couple times so I am going to ask it again...
 
 

@finster, are you honestly going to tell me if any other player had a 50% chance of being scum, you wouldnt think lynching them is the right call?

EVERY player has a 50% chance of being scum. You do, I do, everyone. You seem to have latched onto the fact that since theres a probability that there is 1 cop who is scum, that I *HAVE* to be that player. You're wrong. But that's never stopped you before.

[Wolfpacks]

It seems like we are going round in circles