1469 replies to this topic

[CanucksDynasty]

oh, the first strategy i layed out implies the cop roleclaiming. the 2nd does not.

What was your 2nd strategy?

VOTE COUNT
Junkahoolik (1): Firkked

Not Voting (12): Narsis, Junkahoolik, Electric Mango, KevinH, Sir Jesus, crazyemolad, Falzis, Kaziocore, Aquinas, Martino, CanucksDynasty, angel of doom

Edited by molestargazer, 27 October 2009 - 07:28 PM.

[junkahoolik]

you actually quoted it...

if we use the 4 separate rooms for spreading and forget about the rest, sure, we will lose the leads, but then the list of possible targets would be shrunk down to 2 people one of which would be scum the other probably townie. also, scum would probably not move in a 2 man compartment and perform a nk there since then they would paint a sure target on their back. i'd say we go for a lynch today and use the later strategy.

[CanucksDynasty]

you actually quoted it...

Sorry...I thought that was part of the cop roleclaim strategy.

So basically you are also saying we should move into 4 separate rooms that are not adjacent to each other.
And you are in favour of lynching on D1.

[Narsis]

what second strategy?

if we choose your scenario...then we will find one mafia via the cop. however, if we don't and follow the original idea, we could easily find all the mafia via the cop. sure we might find none, but i'll take a chance at 3 or 4 and risk getting nothing then get a guaranteed 1.

basically: cop role claiming is a bad idea unless necessary.

[Narsis]

EBWOP: what is up with people posting while i type!

[junkahoolik]

what second strategy?

if we choose your scenario...then we will find one mafia via the cop. however, if we don't and follow the original idea, we could easily find all the mafia via the cop. sure we might find none, but i'll take a chance at 3 or 4 and risk getting nothing then get a guaranteed 1.

basically: cop role claiming is a bad idea unless necessary.

depends on the fact that the cop may have to roleclaim to convince others to vote scum off. then the cop is again just good for 1 time. though if this happens, the doc can protect him. but, given the limited number of people that can be in a room, the identity of the doc could be easier than normal found out and both cop and doc could die soon.

[junkahoolik]

EBWOP: what is up with people posting while i type!

you're not the only one

[Narsis]

depends on the fact that the cop may have to roleclaim to convince others to vote scum off. then the cop is again just good for 1 time. though if this happens, the doc can protect him. but, given the limited number of people that can be in a room, the identity of the doc could be easier than normal found out and both cop and doc could die soon.

1 time. but the cop could very easily have found more then 1 mafia and at the very least some townies.

[CanucksDynasty]

1 time. but the cop could very easily have found more then 1 mafia and at the very least some townies.

My sentiments exactly.

[Firkked]

depends on the fact that the cop may have to roleclaim to convince others to vote scum off. then the cop is again just good for 1 time. though if this happens, the doc can protect him. but, given the limited number of people that can be in a room, the identity of the doc could be easier than normal found out and both cop and doc could die soon.

Game mechanic rules don't state a limit on the number of people in any room at night.

[Narsis]

Game mechanic rules don't state a limit on the number of people in any room at night.

but we can enforce an unofficial limit.

[CanucksDynasty]

If we are in agreement with the described plan of 4 separate non-adjacent rooms...

Perhaps we should sort out the seating arrangements (I just did this by the numbering system)...

Room 2
1. Narsis
2. Junkahoolik
3. Electric Mango

Room 3
4. KevinH
5. Firkked
6. Sir Jesus

Room 6
7. crazyemolad
8. angel of doom
9. Falzis

Room 9
10. Kaziocore
11. Aquinas
12. CanucksDynasty
13. Martino

Although this removes choice...it removes it for everyone.
It's possible that 2 mafia may end up in one room.
Whereas if mafia had a choice...they would probably want to spread out and not be clustered in one room.

What do you think?

[Narsis]

bad idea imo. i think we should let people choose which of the 4 sections they go to, of course limiting them by the max for each section. this allows us to watch and see who is going where and with who. is it a late choice? what motives would they have for going in that section? particularly, if someone dies in that section and they live does this make them any more suspect?

essentially we are giving up some information.

[CanucksDynasty]

bad idea imo. i think we should let people choose which of the 4 sections they go to, of course limiting them by the max for each section. this allows us to watch and see who is going where and with who. is it a late choice? what motives would they have for going in that section? particularly, if someone dies in that section and they live does this make them any more suspect?

essentially we are giving up some information.

That's fine...it was just a thought.
Wondering where is everyone?

Right now...I'm getting good townie vibes from you Narsis.

So for my purposes....

Townies
CD (me obviously)
Narsis (suggested 4 separate room idea)

[Firkked]

Technically the day portion has 3 weeks and a 72 hour prod rule. If someone hasn't checked in by Wednesday we may get replacements starting Sunday.

Otherwise I'd say people are busy, I'd worry if it were Friday and it stayed this quiet.

[junkahoolik]

That's fine...it was just a thought.
Wondering where is everyone?

Right now...I'm getting good townie vibes from you Narsis.

So for my purposes....

Townies
CD (me obviously)
Narsis (suggested 4 separate room idea)

i agree with narsis. unless you luckily included all 3 scum in the same room, i think it won't matter that much as they will just kill someone they have easy access to.

[junkahoolik]

though on d2, some shuffling of the peps in the nk area will have to occur.

[junkahoolik]

i just thought of something. if tomorrow we lynch one of the people that was in the room and he turns out to be townie, expect the exposed scum to do the next NK. if he has the choice at least...

[Narsis]

not really...like i said let people choose.

[junkahoolik]

not really...like i said let people choose.

reasoning??